Here Are the Arguments That Persuaded the 5th Circuit To Block OSHA's Vaccine Mandate for Private Employers
The appeals court said the rule, which was published on Friday, raises "grave statutory and constitutional issues."
The appeals court said the rule, which was published on Friday, raises "grave statutory and constitutional issues."
The stay may only last a very short time. But it does suggest the judges think the plaintiffs have a serious case to make against the mandate.
Several Republicans are seeking to overturn the new OSHA rule. Despite the razor-thin margins in both Houses, a repeal resolution will not get enacted.
The Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services has adopted a more stringent rule for health care providers than OSHA is imposing on large employers.
The rule just issued by OSHA has fewer legal flaws than the initial plan floated by the White House. But it's still problematic, and could set a dangerous precedent if upheld by courts.
Federal courts will have to decide whether the rule is "necessary" to protect workers from a "grave danger."
The federal standard contains some carve outs that were not part of the White House announcement, likely to help insulate rule from legal challenge. (Updated with a response to Ilya Somin.)
Plus: Children's vaccine passports in San Francisco, investors' inflation fears are on the rise, and more...
Plus: The Twin Cities will both vote on rent control ballot initiatives, New Jersey and Virginia voters will pick a new governor, and more...
Plus, speculation around Virginia's heated gubernatorial race
Plus: New York City's vaccine mandate is accidentally shrinking the city's workforce, a windowless dorm in California stokes controversy, and more...
Plus: The Reason Roundtable makes talking about taxes interesting.
Plus: In-N-Out fights San Francisco's vaccine mandate, the Vienna Tourism Board gets an OnlyFans, apes protest the DEA, and more...
Neither politician is willing to tolerate deviation from the one business policy he thinks is best.
Plus: Seattle businesses embrace private security in response to a police officer shortage, the FDA is set approve "mix and match" booster shots, and more...
Plus: Most Americans favor smaller government as the pandemic fades, consumer spending grows despite supply chain issues, and more...
While the president insists on a top-down mandate, individuals making their own choices are achieving vaccination goals.
Denmark recently lifted all COVID mandates. The U.S. should do the same.
Plus: A dangerous misunderstanding about what caused America's opioid overdose epidemic, a look at this year's Nobel Prize winners, and more...
The failure of legal challenges obscures an ongoing scientific debate.
De Blasio should honor expectations of medical privacy, not threaten government retribution for those who make choices he dislikes.
The fines for failure fall not on the unvaccinated, but the people serving them.
This is great progress, but there is even more in the vaccine pipeline.
TSA security screenings led to more driving and thus more auto deaths. Mandating vaccines on airplanes could have a similar effect.
The vaccines seem to be working well, but the FDA isn't.
Plus: the unintended consequences of mandating COVID vaccines for students
Vaccine hesitancy can, in part, be laid at the feet of experts who betrayed the public’s trust.
Overcautious health officials are living on another planet.
San Diego becomes latest school district to require teen jabs. But is it good policy?
The vaccine mandate on health care workers, ahead of the broader mandate on the rest of us, is putting America in uncharted territory.
Plus: Magical thinking about the spending bill, new rulings on mask mandates, and more...
There’s no clean way this applies to the pandemic.
Plus: Brothel raids, rapid COVID-19 testing, and more...
When you are already convinced a policy makes sense, any evidence will do.
If the government is going to approve them for everyone eventually, why wait?
The lawsuit argues the mandate leads to discrimination based on content of speech and type of speaker.
There is one positive case of COVID-19 on campus.
Plus: Internet freedom at 11-year low, charter school enrollment up 7 percent, lawyer behind abortion lawsuit speaks up, and more...
We’re on our way to having to ask for permission to go about our daily lives.
It did recommend authorizing boosters for those over age 65
Rules are for the little people.
Persuading vaccine objectors is a much better approach than imposing coercive top-down mandates.
Young males infected with COVID-19 are six times more likely to develop myocarditis than those who have been vaccinated.
Plus, how his tax hikes won't actually help anyone, either.
The presidency has always been inclined to unilateral power—and many Americans like it that way.