Gallup: 54% of Americans Think Govt is Too Powerful; Rest Too Scared to Answer

Gallup reports, "At least half of Americans since 2005 have said the federal government has too much power, whereas in the three years prior to that, Americans were more inclined to believe federal power was 'about right.'"
Welcome to the 21st century, in which a majority of Americans seem dissatisfied with the role of government. Gallup notes elsewhere that even unpopular government outfits such as the CIA, Homeland Security, and the Federal Reserve pull higher approval ratings than the IRS, of which just 27 percent of Americans have a highly favorable view. Only one of nine agencies rankes had a "net positive" score over 50 percent (the Centers for Disease Control). Read more.
So what happens when negativity toward government becomes the new normal? In The Declaration of Independents: How Libertarian Politics Can Fix What's Wrong With America, Matt Welch and I argued that widespread dissatisfaction with partisan politics (as evidenced by massive declines over the past several decades in party affiliations) would be followed by motivated people routing around politics and creating ad hoc, single-issue interest groups that would start pushing back on government power. School choice, the Tea Party, pot legalization, gay marriage, the effort to stop SOPA/PIPA - all support the idea that when the gap between the general progress in our commercial and cultural lives and the general lassitude in the areas dominated by politics (education, health care, retirement) gets too great, all hell will break loose. People get pissed and pissed people create the change they want to be (hmm, that sounds familiar), whether they're given permission by the powers that be or not.
What say you, Reason.com readers? Are we on to something? Or just on something?
Related: Newest Reason-Rupe Poll says about 20 percent of Americans qualify as libertarian based on views of economic and social issues.
Watch a video summary of the results with Emily Ekins and me.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
It looks like Romney some crazy how gained a percentage point somewhere.
You might want to see a doctor about the brain damage.
That seems a little low to me. Of course I receive no entitlements nor am I employed by the govt. so I am just a tad biased.
I am a (state) government employee and I think the government has too much power, so bias isn't everything.
Who are the 7% of the people who think the federal government doesn't have enough power?
FedGov employees?
Nannies and rent seekers.
People who think "power" means "electricity".
commies? or T O N Y?
Everyone who thinks they can't get what they want without government help.
Politicians.
Why do we keep electing from the 8%?
Because most of the other 92% just want to live their own lives?
"Anarcho"-syndicalists and collectivists
Once the government controls everything it will create anarchotopia and then whither away.
All these polls about Obama's popularity rating dropping, that government too powerful, economy stinks etc...
Yet, they still vote for people that EXPAND government; like Bloomberg.
Forgive me if it's all numb to me.
the mob is incapable rational analysis
So steadily rose under Bush originally topping out at TARP. Slight drop during first couple years of Obama then rising again to above TARP level about a year beford Obamas re election. Was that when Obamacare passed?
Looks like that 59 was the first poll taken after Obama care passed.
The about the right amount and too much lines crossed in 2005.
So I guess we could cut spending back to 2005 levels. That shouldnt be hard, right?
Can we stop acting like these polls mean anything?
Everyone thinks that the government has too much power IN CERTAIN AREAS. When you overlap the areas that the sheep believe the government needs MORE power, every aspect of society has a group of people pushing for more government control over.
A slight majority of Americans approving/disapproving something is meaningless.
If most still have a favorable opinion of the CDC, it's because they haven't been paying attention. They think obesity is a communicable disease; that's all you gotta know about how politicized their 'science' is. When the government decides criticizing the government is an anti-social disorder calling for involuntary commitment of those poor souls afflicted by the disease, it will be the CDC providing the justification.
Add me to the list - you're definitely on to something?