Wisconsin State Representative Proposes Immunity Bill For 911 Callers in Overdose Situations

One Wisconsin state representative is motivated by the first hand-experience of witnessing his daughter's near-lethal drug overdose to advocate for drug reforms. He wants to protect people, rather than punish them, for calling authorities in similar emergency situations.
Earlier this month Rep. John Nygren (R-Marinette) introduced four pieces of legislation that he hopes will save lives. Nygren explained in a video how his daughter, Cassie, overdosed on heroin. The 24-year-old nearly died despite being with friends. They refused to call 911 and fled the scene likely in fear of legal retribution.
The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel sums up the major points of Nygren's bills:
- Provide limited immunity for people who either call 911 or bring those suffering an overdose to an emergency room.
- Clear the way to drop off narcotics at drug repositories.
- Expand the numbers of first responders allowed to carry and administer the drug Narcan, which is used to counter an overdose of opiates.
- Require people to show identification when picking up opiate prescriptions at pharmacies.
According to WUWM, heroin use killed nearly 200 people in the state last year. The Green Bay Press Gazette suggests that property crimes and prostitution related to the drug have trended upward over the last five years.
Nygren acknowledged, "I don't think any of the [proposed laws] are the silver bullet that everybody might be looking for. Unfortunately problems like this don't have easy fixes, but these are just the start." Nygren also suggested that he intended further reforms, which would provide "alternatives for treatment in rural and underserved areas." In the video, he emphasized the role of families, rather than the government, in dealing with addiction.
Nygren seems to have local law enforcement on his side. He explained to WUWM, "My county sheriff says you can't arrest your way out of this problem. There needs to be treatment to help break that cycle."
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
But...zero tolerance...
also
Drugz!
Better they die for the good of society.
/Team Red & .5 Team Blue
I think it's more like /Team Red-(Rand Paul+John Nygren) + .5(Team Blue)
It's a bit of a complicated equation.
0 (tolerance) = Team Red - (Rand+John) + .5(Team Blue)
-.5(Team Blue)=Team Red - (Rand + John)
-Team Red - .5(Team Blue) = -Rand - John
-Team Red - .5(Team Blue) + John = -Rand
- Rand = -Team Red - .5(Team Blue) + John
Rand = Team Red + .5(Team Blue) - John
What if I am addicted to blowing on cheap plastic flutes w/o a Doctor's prescription? Or using a small battery-powered air pump used to help me do the same thing as pinching my nose and blowing on it? Without the blessings of our moral and medical superiors, once again, that is? The "lung flute" (the former) and the "earpopper" (the latter) are beyond the ken of us mere mortals to use safely, unless we have been officially blessed by our moral and medical superiors (and that is only here in the US of A, the Home of the Free and the Brave, I might add). See http://www.churchofSQRLS.com for details? All I am saying is, Rep. John Nygren needs to keep us addicts of non-prescribed "medical devices" in mind? Yes, I know, we are morally benighted heathens, we who sometimes are tempted to disobey Government Almighty? But he needs to look out for us "medical device" savages, as well as the drug addicts, when he is out and about do-gooding? PLEASE!?!?! I need my lung flute fix now, must go off and run, see ya?
I cannot imagine myself, if I were a DA, charging someone with anything if they called 911 in an overdose situation or dropped someone at the ER. It would be sociopathic to do so.
Oh, wait, we are talking about DAs here.
I cannot imagine myself, if I were a DA, charging someone with anything if they called 911 in an overdose situation or dropped someone at the ER. It would be sociopathic to do so.
Sociopathy is a prerequisite for the job. I mean who else but a politician would be willing to ruin a person's life so they can claim in a campaign that they put X amount of drug offenders in jail?
Perfect murder: Overdose victim. Call 911 too late to matter. Get immunity.
Less perfect murder: Overdose victim. Call 911 too late to matter. Get time for a dime bag.
Morons: Overdose victim. Don't call 911.
Government: Put lethal dose on the tip of an umbrella...
"I don't think any of the [proposed laws] are the silver bullet that everybody might be looking for. Unfortunately problems like this don't have easy fixes."
I can think of one.
Sell that Heroin shit otc in clean pre-measured doses*. Then only the stupid and the suicidal will OD.
*SLD: just slap a warning label on the bulk "family-packs".
In the video, he emphasized the role of families, rather than the government, in dealing with addiction.
Crazy Teabagger!
Of course you can't "arrest your way" out of the situation.
But you can kill your way out.
Singapore is often spoken of in glowing terms in conservative/libertarian circles (and has been so on this very website) as a bastion of freedom and prosperity. They execute drug dealers in Singapore. Though I know Newt Gingrich is not thought of highly around here, he has suggested the same penalty be applied in America.
If it's good enough for that wonderful freedom-loving one-party ruled bastion of liberty Singapore, surely it's good enough for dumb evil socialist oppressive America, no?
People here say good things about Singapore's economic policies. I haven't seen much applause about their penchant for canings and the death penalty.
Not content with one strawman, you erect two!
You could have been kind enough to support that with a cite. Reason's site has its own search bar right at the upper right of the webpage, you know.
Eat it 'bagger:
Well, I stand corrected.
Look at 'at strawman burn! Woooo!
Hospital|10.21.13 @ 8:16PM|#
"Of course you can't "arrest your way" out of the situation.
But you can kill your way out."
Did you go through the registration just to make an irrelevant 'argument' that got shot down in 3 minutes?
Retard trolls gonna retard
Slate is so cute when it's not being self-aware.
Stupid Republicans! Saying that government control of health care would result in death panels just because it's already resulted in death panels in a bunch of other countries!
Sir! Your link is drunk!
But the tone of that article is hilarious. I guess whoever wrote it never thought rationed care and its outcomes was possible.
Boom.
MORE!
Let the bolded sentence sink in. When humanity demands haste (in killing people the collective has deemed to no longer have a use) and justice demands expert knowledge (without the consent of the family), Ontario's death offer a solution (of murder.)
I find "the question is no longer whether we can "play God," but when, how, and who should do so" to be creepier.
So Palin was a shit for mentioning it, and she shouldn't do it again, but we need to embrace them, 'cause Canuks!
I see the VP in charge of Logic took the day off.
The VP in charge of logic is Joe Biden, and he didn't take the day off.
*looks up the author's name*
"Adam Goldenberg"
*facepalm*
You'd also think a Jewish guy wouldn't be so blase about the right to bear arms.
I can think of a few times that various Jewish populations might have been helped by firearms.
I think Adam is counting on "capo" status when the time comes. Much like his hero, Soros.
"First they came for the infirm and the 'tards".
Rep Nygren's district has been plagued with an abnormal amount of overdoses of cheddar enemas.
SOFT ON CRIME.
Sometimes man, you jsut have to roll with the punches.
http://www.AnonWonders.tk
Jack Frapp's not gonna like thsi one bit!
http://www.fuckCanadashealthkillsystem.ca/deathpanel
Well of course no one dialed 911. More and more people are learning that you only do that when you want someone to be shot and/or a dog or two killed. And it's really a roll of the dice who the cops are going to shoot(other than the dogs--that's a given), could be the OD victim, could be the caller, could be a witness, or random bystander....