California's Version of Pot Protectionism

The Golden State's leading marijuana initiative limits competition, favoring small producers.


Proposition 19, the California marijuana legalization initiative that lost by seven points in 2010, was about 3,000 words long. The Adult Use of Marijuana Act (AUMA), the legalization initiative that seems to have the best shot at qualifying for the 2016 ballot, runs more than 30,000 words. That does not necessarily mean the AUMA is 10 times as good as Prop. 19, but its backers seem to be betting that specificity will allay voters' concerns.

Recent elections do not provide much evidence to support that expectation, and there is something to be said for keeping things vague. Leaving details such as tax rates and warning labels to legislators and regulators avoids potentially contentious issues while making room for the considered judgment of people with more public policy expertise than the average voter. While legislators do not necessarily read the bills they pass, it seems even less likely that voters will wade through all 62 pages of the AUMA. Those who do, even if they are inclined to support legalization, are apt to be troubled by some of the initiative's provisions.

It is hard to say whether size matters to voters. Washington's Initiative 502, which weighed in at more than 20,000 words, won by 11 points in 2012. But so did Colorado's Amendment 64, a svelte contender at 3,700 words. Oregon's Measure 91, which won by 12 points in 2014, was 15,000 words long. In that same election, Alaska's Measure 2, which consisted of a mere 4,100 words, won by just seven points. But the District of Columbia's Initiative 71, which was one-third as long as Oregon's ballot measure, had the biggest margin of victory by far: an astonishing 40 points. Then again, Ohio's Issue 3, a relatively slim 6,600 words, went down in flames last year, losing by 27 points.

The AUMA, which has the support of Lt. Gov. Gavin Newsom, former Facebook president Sean Parker and some of the activists who originally backed a rival effort known as Reform CA, is longer than any of those earlier initiatives. It is much longer than the four other legalization initiatives that are expected to be on state ballots this year, the heftiest of which, Maine's, contains less than half as many words. That's because the AUMA, which incorporates the recommendations of Newsom's Blue Ribbon Commission on Marijuana Policy, is packed with prescriptions that will thrill technocratic meddlers but repel fans of free markets.

Ohio's 2015 initiative failed spectacularly, largely because of a provision that alienated legalizers as well as prohibitionists: a cannabis cultivation cartel that would have limited commercial production to 10 preselected sites controlled by the measure's financial backers. The AUMA includes a different sort of protectionist scheme: a five-year ban on growers cultivating more than 22,000 square feet indoors or more than an acre outdoors. That ceiling is aimed at "allowing smaller growers to establish themselves in the market."

The AUMA, which also bars "large cultivation licensees" from holding distribution licenses, says regulators should strive to avoid the "creation or maintenance of unlawful monopoly power." It is not clear what that goal, which is supposed to guide licensing decisions, will mean in practice. But it is not hard to imagine how a policy officially aimed at promoting competition might be used as a cover for protecting entrenched interests.

The AUMA's limits on marijuana advertising are also anti-competitive. It prohibits signs on highways that cross state lines or within 1,000 feet of various locations where children gather, ads "intended to encourage persons under the age of 21 years to consume marijuana," and "symbols, language, music, gestures, cartoon characters or other content elements known to appeal primarily to persons below the legal age of consumption." Although marijuana's continued federal prohibition complicates the question, the constitutionality of those speech restrictions is doubtful.

The Adult Use of Marijuana Act improves on earlier efforts in some ways—for example, by allowing deliveries of marijuana to consumers and cannabis consumption in settings outside of private residences. But it is also inappropriately harsh, prescribing a $500 fine and up to six months in jail for possessing more than an ounce in public or growing more than six plants at home.

It should go without saying that even the most picayune regulatory system is preferable to prohibition. But that is a pretty low bar.

This article originally appeared in The Orange County Register.

NEXT: Humans Innovate Their Way Out of Scarcity

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. Ohio wasn’t lost it was stolen.
    Activists must do pre and exit polls and take regular screen shots of the poll results.
    And be prepared to fight when it looks suspicious.…..impossible…..nitiative/

  2. It’s all too easy to get sucked into caring whether this passes or not, acting as if a single vote will matter, as if I alone were deciding the matter. This ballot initiative is the typical statist wet dream, and I hope it dies, but I am not going to bother myself about it.

  3. Looks like another bullet hole for California’s foot.

    I’m gonna laugh my ass off if this vote fails but the other states pass their MJ measures.

  4. Research at the University of Saskatchewan indicates that, unlike alcohol, cocaine, heroin, or Nancy (“Just say, ‘No!'”) Reagan’s beloved nicotine, marijuana actually encourages brain-cell growth. Research in Spain and other countries has discovered that it has tumor-shrinking, anti-carcinogenic properties. These were confirmed by the 30-year Tashkin population study at UCLA.

    Drugs are man-made, cooked up in labs, for the sake of patents and the profits gained by them. Useful, but bearing lists of side effects as long as one’s arm.

    Marijuana is a medicinal herb, the most benign and versatile in history. “Cannabis” in Latin, and “kaneh bosm” in the old Hebrew scrolls, quite literally the Biblical Tree of Life, used by early Christians to treat everything from skin diseases to deep pain and despair. Kaneh bosm, ‘the fragrant cane’ of a dozen uses: ink, paper, nutrition. . . . It was clothing on their backs and incense in their temples. Medicinal oil could impart a sense of benevolence and connection with all living things. No wonder that the ‘anointed one’ could gain a sense of the divine and the confidence to share this feeling.

    What gets to me are the politicians, and prosecuters who pose on church steps or kneeling in prayer on their campaign trails, but can’t face the science or the historical truth about cannabis, Medicinal Herb Number One, safe and effective for thousands of years, and celebrated by most of the world’s major religions.

  5. My last pay check was $9500 working 12 hours a week online. My sisters friend has been averaging 15k for months now and she works about 20 hours a week. I can’t believe how easy it was once I tried it out. This is what I do..

    Clik This Link inYour Browser….

    ? ? ? ?

  6. Start working at home with Google! It’s by-far the best job I’ve had. Last Wednesday I got a brand new BMW since getting a check for $6474 this – 4 weeks past. I began this 8-months ago and immediately was bringing home at least $77 per hour. I work through this link, go to tech tab for work detail.

  7. Favors small businesses over big ones (for five years, anyway) and advertising restrictions comparable to those for cigarettes.

    Forgive me I’m not up in arms about how utterly terrible this is.

  8. A picayune regulatory system IS Prohibition.

    1. No more taxed or regulated than tomatoes.

  9. Start making cash right now… Get more time with your family by doing jobs that only require for you to have a computer and an internet access and you can have that at your home. Start bringing up to $8012 a month. I’ve started this job and I’ve never been happier and now I am sharing it with you, so you can try it too. You can check it out here…

    Open This Link For more Information………

    ??????? http://www.Wage90.Com

  10. If I were a illegal pot dealer, I am not worried about Joe growing pot in his backyard. I am worried about Walmart selling 1 lb of pot for $2 grown and processed in China.

    Ban on advertising is something that helps illegal pot dealers. As long as there a taboo around something rest assured rebellious teens would rush after it. If Walmart cant sell cant advertise, the Joe might have to resort to not so clean tricks to enlist dopers.

  11. Analysis based on number of words, versus margin of success is stupid.
    Fewer words can lead to more varied interpretation, while overly verbose can be used to distract.
    Simple is usually better but, with the prevalence of “case law” – judges and lawyers going around the intent of a law – makes for wordy legislation.
    Some of these provisions are intended to assuage the concerns of the pro-prohibitionists and “but what about the chilluns” crowd but the biggest concern would be to lock in a tax rate that makes illicit sales, still profitable, under the theory that “those dopers will be willing to pay anything for it to be legal”.
    There’s more, than allowing people to put what they want into their own bodies, at stake, here. There are other downsides to prohibition that a free, or relatively so, market would eliminate.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.