The Surveillance State Isn't Coming—It's Already Here

The national Panopticon is a messy work in progress, but it's already in place.


Public Domain

For weeks, headlines have trumpeted revelations about the National Security Agency's tracking of Internet traffic and phone communications and the secretive rubber-stamp court intended to provide us some illusion that our privacy and civil liberties are being respected, but which approves virtually every domestic spy scheme it reviews. It's almost… almost like we live in a surveillance state, we stammer as we blink at the brave new world revealed around us. But there's no "almost" about it; from the CIA spying through local cops, to FBI snooping through driver's license databases, to police departments tracking your movements with license-plate scanners, the NSA is only one part of the growing, unfinished, but very real surveillance state that the United States has become.

If intention automatically manifested itself in the real world, we'd already be living in the Panopticon. There's little doubt that many government officials lust after scrutiny and control. Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-The Bunker) famously told reporters, "If I thought censoring the mail was necessary, I would suggest it." Graham's soulmate, Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Deeper in the Bunker), joined other lawmakers in calling Edward Snowden's revelations about NSA snooping "treason." And, even as the NSA revelations unfolded, FBI Director Robert Mueller complained to the Senate Judiciary Committee that "there is a growing gap between law enforcement's legal authority to conduct electronic surveillance, and its ability to conduct such surveillance" and asked for enhancements to the Bureau's already vast snooping capabilities—just two years after the FBI unilaterally revised its Domestic Investigations and Operation Guide to loosen restraints on intelligence-gathering.

Among the FBI's most powerful surveillance tools have been national security letters, which act as subpoenas forcing disclosure of private data, but with a gag order attached forbidding the recipient from revealing that they've been forced to cough up information. Since third parties, like Google or phone companies, are the usual recipients of NSLs, the actual targets are effectively denied a chance to appeal. Such recourse-free data-perusing was recently declared unconstitutional by a federal judge in California, but that's not the end of the legal battle—and recipients are still being forced to comply.

U.S. Government

Even if NSLs go the way of the (extremely nosy) dodo, the FBI has plenty of other eavesdropping tools. the  Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act gives the Bureau such easy access to telecommunications systems that phone companies must tailor their technology for easy wiretapping. Now, the FBI wants to extend that authority to Internet companies. In fact, federal officials refer to comunications that aren't easily wiretapped as "the Going Dark problem," to be addressed by new resources and powers.

While the FBI knows what you're saying, and to whom, it also can find out where you're saying it. Through the use of stingray devices which masquerade as cell phone towers, the feds can get your own mobile devices to reveal your location. The feds have been a little lax about asking judicial permission for using the widgets, too, often disguising them as much less intrusive older technology. Local police departments, not surprisingly, emulate federal practice.

Oh, and that crappy photo of you on your driver's license? That's been digitized, stored and, in 26 states, it's being used as a mugshot to compare to surveillance camera pics of suspected criminals, terrorists, or people some cop finds really cute. The software behind that photo matching almost certainly comes from the FBI's Next Generation Identification facial recognition technology. The Bureau intends to create a national database.

That the FBI plays the role of Uncle Creepy probably isn't a shocker—if anybody is going to do it, it's going to be J. Edgar's old outfit, right? And now that we know the NSA spies directly on Americans, it's no revelation to learn that the FBI fields cases handed off by both the NSA and CIA. It's one big government, after all. Just because intelligence agencies aren't supposed to operate domestically doesn't mean they can't find somebody to do it for them. That is, if they don't just go ahead and do it themselves anyway, because "the Fourth Amendment does not apply" to gathering phone records, as Deputy Attorney General James Cole told Congress.

Among the other bodies that acts as a proxy for a CIA that can't legally conduct domestic operations is the New York City Police Department. With a retired CIA officer appointed deputy director of the NYPD Intelligence Division after the 9/11 attack, and other spooks seconded to the department, the NYPD was off to the races, spying on targets with a special emphasis on Muslims who complained about discrimination, including those outside its jurisdiction, without generating a single lead.

The CIA connection may explain why the Justice Department never got around to conducting a promised investigation of the NYPD's spying, though the CIA's own Office of the Inspector General voiced concerns about the relationship's potential for "negative public perception" and "the risk that CIA officers could become involved in law enforcement matters."

Not that the NYPD needs federal help to be intrusive. Stop-and-frisk policies aside, the department has rolled out portable terahertz scanners that can "see" metal objects through clothing, like guns, knives, expensive watches, or recording gear that you may use to monitor the cops in a case of turnabout is fair play. New York City Police Commissioner Ray Kelly isn't the type to fret over the peeping tom nature of such technology, having announced after the Boston Marathon bombing, "I think the privacy issue has really been taken off the table." He referred, specifically, to the deployment of surveillance cameras to watch comings and goings in public places, but that sentiment is appropriate for so many occasions.

License-plate camera
Vigilant Solutions

New York City is hardly alone. Municipalities across the country rushed to embrace the all-seeing eye of the video camera after the bombing, despite warnings that there may be some downsides to a national Panopticon. Oregon is even repurposing existing traffic cameras for surveillance use.

Traffic cameras are also being further enhanced and deployed to capture and automatically identify license plates as they pass by. License-plate scanners have been set up along Interstate highways in the southwestern states by the DEA, ostensibly to detect patterns that might indicate drug trafficking—though they also record the movements of everybody else who travels along those roads. Local police departments in northern California are connecting their databases of captured license plates to track and store people's movements far and wide. But private vendors have already created vast systems, such as the National Vehicle Location Service, that police departments can plug into with minimal fuss.

Oh, and in Maryland, among other jurisdictions, you can get audio with that video, as recording devices on public buses now capture all conversations in transit.

Feeling faint? Maybe a little paranoid? Well, you might want to think twice before sharing that information with your doctor. As the Affordable Care Act—Obamacare—is implemented, patient information is centralized in a "Data Services Hub" in order to determine Americans' privileges and exemptions in using the health care exchanges established under the new law. Data will be shared with federal agencies, state agencies, agency contractors, consultants, CMS grantees, and non-profit entities operating exchanges for states, all "without the consent of the individual to whom such information pertains," according to an obscure regulatory notice. So far, the centralized information includes "personal, employment, financial, demographic, and pregnancy status and tobacco use," but not actual medical records. Even assuming the data collection and sharing stops there, isn't that enough?

And a final note — if you needed anything more to chew over — is that the NSA's perusal of telephone records is echoed by the Postal Service's photographing and recording the outside of every piece of mail it transmits. You won't keep your pen pals secret by going old school.

There's no obvious grand plan here to strip privacy from Americans and allow government scrutiny of every detail of American life. But fear of terrorism, fear of crime, and promises of more efficiently allocated services have combined together to create exactly what many of us feared: the surveillance state. It's not fully formed, it's ever-evolving in a direction that's likely to surprise even its creators, and it's parts aren't all on speaking terms, but it's here.

NEXT: Courts Disagree on Rules for Warrantless Cell Phone Tracking

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. How are there no comments yet?

    1. Because [REDACTED]

      1. slow clap….

        …followed by sound of silencer-shot, a body hitting the floor, it being dragged into a darker corner…

        1. Start working at home with Google! It’s by-far the best job Ive had. Last Monday I got a new Alfa Romeo from bringing in $7778. I started this 9 months ago and practically straight away started making more than $83 per hour. I work through this link, http://www.Bling6.com

      2. If Government Almighty can dictate that software writers, cell phone manufacturers, etc., must put spy hooks in there, then, will embedded medical devices (think pacemakers etc.) be forced to contain the same? Government Almighty will soon have its army of cyborg slaves, now ALL HAIL Government Almighty!

        1. In related news today, Government Almighty has announced that Obamacare is going to now mandate the placement of four electrodes (go right, go left, pleasure center, pain center) and a radio-controlled remote health-care guidance unit, on all health-care-recipient units. Inspired by robo-rats, see http://news.nationalgeographic…..orats.html , Government Almighty pursues its vision of EVERYONE being optimally health-and-safety aware! Onward and upwards, comrades!

    2. like Johnny implied I’m blown away that a single mom able to get paid $4012 in four weeks on the internet. did you see this webpage… http://www.Blue48.com

  2. If you are not doing anything wrong, you have nothing to worry about. Oops. I probably actually just broke a few laws there.

  3. Why does Reason want the terrorist to win?

    1. There’s only one? Then why the Hell is the War on (some) Terrorists so difficult?

      1. Because the war is not real. It is just an excuse to curtail liberty.

  4. I really need to start researching encryption and fake identification. For academic purposes only of course.

    1. Yeah, because sending all of your email encrypted won’t raise any red flags…and I’m sure the stuff you can buy commercially is way better than the decryption software used by the feds…and of course, the vendors of your software would never put in a backdoor for the government…and as for the fake id, that won’t help with the new generation of facial recognition software.

      Face it folks…its over. The Republic is dead, and it ain’t coming back. Time to join a sea-stead, too bad I get seasick.

      Here it comes: “a boot stamping on a human face forever.”

      1. It’s called open source. Download the code, review it, and compile your own version using no smaller that 1024bit keys.

        1. my classmate’s sister makes $78/hour on the laptop. She has been without a job for 5 months but last month her payment was $21145 just working on the laptop for a few hours. Read more here….. WEP6.COM
          Click on website and then go to Home page for more details.

      2. I don’t know. I’d like to think I could outsmart the government. That doesn’t seem like it would be that difficult of a task.

  5. my classmate’s sister-in-law makes $79 hourly on the computer. She has been fired for eight months but last month her paycheck was $14798 just working on the computer for a few hours. Read more on this web site Go to site and open Home for details

  6. I agree with the article! The fact that even some high-profile libertarians rationalize the spying or discount its significance suggests the challenge of achieving liberty in the US.

    See, e.g., John Stossel’s “I Shrugged,” http://www.realclearpolitics.c…..9073.html.

  7. There’s no obvious grand plan here to strip privacy from Americans and allow government scrutiny of every detail of American life.The life of America will be better!

  8. “The surveillance state is already here”

    Yeah, what are you going to do about it? Vote for a third party libertarian candidate who will vaporize the NSA, the department of education, and legalize online gambling? Hahahaha

  9. My best friend’s ex-wife makes $66 every hour on the internet. She has been out of work for eight months but last month her pay check was $19549 just working on the internet for a few hours. Read more here and go to home tab for more detail http://www.Pro67.com

  10. Your site is good Actually, I have seen your post and that was very informative and very entertaining for me. Thanks for posting Really Such Things. I should recommend your site to my friends. Cheers.

  11. until I saw the draft four $7371, I did not believe …that…my mother in law could actually bringing home money part time on their laptop.. there moms best frend has been doing this for under twentey months and a short time ago cleared the debts on their place and got a brand new Renault 5. go to, Go to site and open Home for details

  12. Don’t only are the fake items illegal, they are also dangerous and have been known to catch fire and burn the hair. Therefore, the question has to be. How can you know if you are purchasing a counterfeited straightener? Well, there are a number of factors that cheap ghd straighteners can help to give it away.It is so easy for fake merchandise to be passed off as actual, the cash to change hands then for the vendor to disappear. Do not forget to check to ratings and reviews in the seller, but try to avoid utilizing this site to get GHDs.Does the web page appear like the official GHD one? If so, they’re most likely promoting fakes by making you believe they’re the official internet site. Qualified suppliers inside your country will not just be promoting GHD hair straighteners, but numerous other brands, so be aware of individual brand web sites.

  13. Okay. We know that the government has incredible amounts of access to information, but how good is it at coordinating all of it?

  14. my best friend’s mother-in-law makes $74 every hour on the internet. She has been fired from work for five months but last month her pay check was $18367 just working on the internet for a few hours. Read more on this site……..Buzz55.com

  15. The detail and content in this article were fantastic! I like it so much!
    Guangzhou Icesource is specialize in research, design, produce and sell large production cube ice maker machine, block ice maker machine, plate ice maker machine, tube ice maker machine and flake ice maker machine, and its accessory equipment, for example cold room, crane, ice crushing machine and so on.

  16. I really liked this post. It is truly awesome. The author might be quite talented. I pretty appreciate the opportunity to read such posts on this site.Guangzhou Icesource is specialize in research, design, produce and sell large production cube ice maker machine, block ice maker machine, plate ice maker machine, tube ice maker machine and flake ice maker machine, and its accessory equipment, for example cold room, crane, ice crushing machine and so on.

  17. I am happy when reading your blog with updated information! thanks a lot and hope that you will post more site that are related to this site.Guangzhou Icesource is specialize in research, design, produce and sell large production cube ice maker machine, block ice maker machine, plate ice maker machine, tube ice maker machine and flake ice maker machine, and its accessory equipment, for example cold room, crane, ice crushing machine and so on. http://www.cbfi-icemachine.com

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.