L.A. Can Still Regulate Medical Marijuana Shops

When he described L.A.'s medical marijuana industry in the April 2010 issue of Reason, Brian Doherty noted that no one really knew how many dispensaries there were, although "more than 500" was a reasonable estimate. There is still no complete count, but the Los Angeles Times reports that 372 shops have filed forms so they can pay the city's new 5 percent tax on dispensary revenue, meaning they are keen to be as legitimate as it is possible to be when your business is a criminal enterprise under federal law. But those efforts may be for nought, since the Los Angeles City Council is considering a ban on all dispensaries. The Times says "a recent appeals court decision...thwarted the city's plans to cap the number of dispensaries at 100 through a lottery," which is true, and "raised doubts about whether the city has the power to impose significant public safety regulations, such as restrictions on locations," which is misleading.

Two months ago, California's 2nd District Court of Appeal overturned Long Beach's licensing system for dispensaries, saying it "goes beyond decriminalization into authorization," thereby violating the federal ban on marijuana. In particular, the court concluded that using a lottery to award permits represented an official stamp of approval for medical marijuana suppliers, whereas declining to punish them under state or local law does not. But the court explicitly said cities can still impose restrictions on dispensaries, including rules about location and hours of operation; they just can't award permits to a subset of applicants. So while L.A.'s cap on dispensaries violates the logic of this ruling, that does not mean it cannot regulate pot shops. Even the tax should pass muster, since it is a levy imposed on the gross revenue of each dispensary, as opposed to the $15,000 permit fee collected by Long Beach. The appeals court noted that the state Board of Equalization taxes medical marijuana sales, a process that involves issuing a "seller's permit," which "does not 'allow individuals to make unlawful sales, but instead merely provides a way to remit any sales and use taxes due.'" Still, the L.A. City Council may decide that banning dispensaries altogether, an option approved by another state appeals court last month, is the easier course.

[Thanks to Richard Cowan for the tip.]

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • Gojira||

    Am I the only one who gets creeped out everytime a news story mentions that California has a "Board of Equalization"?

  • ||

    It looks like your mental handicap radios need to be adjusted, citizen.

  • John Tagliaferro||

    Those fruits, nuts and granola bars in LA love regulation so here is another layer for them.

  • ||

    They've shut down every dispensary near me. And the feds have also started going after licensed growers, with the support of the local cops.

    I can only imagine how fucked up it is in LA-LA land.

    On a positive note, you can smoke pretty freely in SF. Of course, you can also take a dump on the sidewalk freely as well.

  • ||

    Speaking of teh dread medical marihooch, those cretinous octogenarians at the Christian Science Monitor editorial board have an editorial* up bemoaning the "smokescreen" of medical mj as a backdoor legalization effort. The best part is their sorrowful headshaking over state governors' insane and unpatriotic refusal to blindly obey the Drug Enforcement Agency and defer to the Ascended One's superior wisdom in all things.

    *Sorry, I'm not going back there to get you a link.

  • ¢||

    That font is the Comic Sans of burnout world.

    NIXON DID 9/11*

    *Pretend this in that font.

  • AdvocateReason||

    Support H.R. 2306! Support H.R. 2306! Support H.R. 2306!

    H.R. 2306 - The Ending Federal Prohibition of Marijuana Act of 2011
    This is what everyone should be talking about! Please spread the word about this bill! This is where the marijuana discussion needs to be. End federal prohibition and allow state governments to manage marijuana however they think is best. First end federal prohibition and allow states determine their own marijuana laws! Spread the word about this!

  • Muzzylu||

    Medical marijuana, and all marijuana should be legal! It is helpful to people for pain reduction and other maladies, plus marijuana can be a much less harmful recreational drug than liquor, heroin, crack, and cocaine.
    Great book on medical marijuana: MARIJUANA - Guide to Buying, Growing, Harvesting, and Making Medical Marijuana Oil and Delicious Chocolates to Treat Pain and Ailments by Mary Bendis. This book has great recipe for marijuana oil and tasty, yummy chocolates!

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Video Game Nation: How gaming is making America freer – and more fun.
  • Matt Welch: How the left turned against free speech.
  • Nothing Left to Cut? Congress can’t live within their means.
  • And much more.

SUBSCRIBE

advertisement