Montreal Student Riots, Quebec's Speech-Killing Bill 78, & Something Called the "Anarchopanda"
The city of Montreal has been in turmoil for much of 2012, following massive student demonstrations in opposition to a government-imposed hike on university tuitions.
While mostly peaceful, some demonstrators resorted to vandalism and blocked access to bridges and schools. Protesters were also met with violence from riot police, and accusations of brutality became a nightly occurrence.
Desperate to restore order, the Liberal provincial government of Quebec passed the emergency law Bill 78, which has effectively ended the larger protests. Hailed as a pragmatic solution by supporters who say it has rescued the city from anarchy, critics such as the United Nations' Human Rights Council have condemned Bill 78 as an egregious violation of free expression.
The upheaval caused by the protests and the government's heavy-handed reactions to them have divided Quebec society, and produced controversial and memorable figures like the Anarchopanda, a junior college professor dressed in an oversized Panda costume who intervenes between riot police and protestors in the hopes of diffusing potentially violent situations.
ReasonTV went to Montreal to explore this complex and still unresolved conflict, which raises all sorts of fundamental questions about free expression, political dissent, and governmental overreach in the name of restoring order.
About 10.30 minutes.
Produced by Anthony L. Fisher. Camera by Joshua Swain and Fisher.
Music: "The Cuchifritos Groove Instrumental {Wildabeast, 6th Sense, Jelani}" by 6th Sense (http://notherground.blogspot.com)
Go to http://reason.com/reasontv for downloadable versions and subscribe to ReasonTV's YouTube Channel to receive notifications when new material goes live.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please to post comments
If only our anarchist Epi were as cute as Anarchopanda.
Anarchopanda? This guy is trying to defuse violent situations and everybody knows that anarchists are a bunch of ultra-violent nutjobs.
/retard
Hey, Sexual Harassment Panda had to do something. Pandas gotta eat, too.
So will we be treated to the spectacle of Anarchopanda going to the Canadaian courts to argue for his civil liberties, thus pegging our irony meters?
All this over $0.50/day?
I've said this before: everyone knows pandas are not pure anarchists, so this is ridiculous. I told you: they're an anarcho-syndicalist commune. They take it in turns to act as a sort of executive officer for the week. But all the decisions of that officer have to be ratified at a special biweekly meeting. By a simple majority in the case of purely internal affairs, but by a two-thirds majority in the case of more important ones.
Look, strange pandas in ponds distributing bamboo swords is no basis for a system of government!
Bloody peasant!
Ooh, what a giveaway!
Normally I'd be the first to decry police brutality against non-violent protesters, but somebody's gotta beat the shit out of these kids. It might as well be the cops.
The kiddies don't seem too shy about siccing the fuzz on taxpayers so they aren't burdened with an unconscionable $182.50 in extra fees per year, are they?
I mean, they might have to forego cable or a latte now and then.
Arachnopanda is all about the creation of pants-shitting terror.
John Goodman was in that, right?
Arachnopanda was the straight-to-video sequel starring, who else, Dean Cain.
There's never a good time to admit this so Imma just come right out and say it: Lois and Clark-era Dean Cain was super hot. How did such an attractive man end up with such a shit career?
You should go ask Vanessa Angel, because maybe she has an answer seeing as she's in the same boat.
What kind of moron wastes a perfectly good porn name like Vanessa Angel on a regular acting career? That was her first mistake.
With a name like that, I was expecting yet another round of "H ampersand R Edition: Googling An Unfamiliar Female Name!" Wherein the top Google result is the Wikipedia entry that invariably reads: "_____ is a(n) [insert nationality here] pornographic actress."
I was going to make a snarky reply impugning your taste in women and involving the words "Blandy McBoringface" but I suppose that would be poor form. So I will just say that I seriously doubt our high-cut bikini aficionado here is in the female equivalent of young Dean Cain's league.
Don't tell me you never saw Spies Like Us, Beloved Dags. She's the main thing worth remembering about that movie.
Dean Cain, on the other hand, just looks like I want to punch him in his fucking handsome stupid goddamn dreamy face.
I'm just going to not say anything about women's complete inability to judge other women's looks. Let's leave it at that.
Maybe she got bad plastic surgery like Nikki Cox.
Apparently there's more to acting than dimples and muscles. My personal theory is that he never did his "gritty, against type" movie. Or it was shit and I never even heard of it.
It a little like being a cracked-out whore. No one wants to do a SyFy movie, no one really chooses that life. But you get desperate, and then you do. At first you are really nervous and grossed-out, then you get paid and the money numbs you. You kid yourself for a while that you still glamorous, you're still desired, but the cracks start showing. You do another and another, disgusted but resigned to your fate. Then finally, the offers to do anything else dies up. People go, "Hey, he might be right for this" but saner voices say "We can't have a cracked-out whore over for dinner. What will the neighbors say?" And then you go doing "Hey, he looks familiar." gigs and working with anyone that can stand it, sucking dick in an alley for pocket change, or starring in The Dog Who Saved Halloween. Then you find yourself 46 and used up, drinking yourself fat and reverse-stunt-guest-starring on Criminal Minds... can an OD be that far away?
Reflections on your own life, huh, NutraSweet?
It's pretty much exactly how I ended up going to library school. Library school is where they punch, kick, scrape, and burn your dreams out of you and then send your husk out into the low-paying night.
Requiem for a Dean.
We have a winner.
Wait, does this mean we get a naked dildo scene between NutraSweet and...you?
I guess we get to cut your arm off then.
Such a mess. I'm sure the students and administrators alike will at least take joy in Canada winning its sole Olympic gold medal in trampoline.
I'd post more comments, but I'm closely following the progress of the robot army the US has sent to freakin' Mars.
I thought it was ArachnoPanda. That'd be some scary shit.
Wow too late.
Shit like this (oh, and their retarded high taxes) is why, even though it is one of my favourite cities in the world, Montreal is off the list of places to expat (or repat, I guess, in my case). Idiotic freeloaders whining about getting more free stuff, jackbooted thugs being thuggish. Better hope the current leader doesn't try to pull a Trudeau and bust out the trusty War Measures Act.
Do you guys still have the Riot Act? And do anarchopandas have to disperse like regular people?
Yeah, actually, I think they do still have the Riot Act. [...] Yep, Wikipedia sez it was most recently read during the Vancouver Stanley Cup riots last year. Proud times to be an ex-Vancouverite, let me tell you.
I was pretty impressed by that video of the guy beating up the mob that was trying to torch his truck. That man is almost good enough to be an American in my book.
As a student in Montreal, tuition as it stands for one year is less than $3000 and, because we are wallowing in debt from the unsustainability of our welfare state (fueled by rampant corruption) the government has taken measures to raise the tuition by about $0.50/day. The vast majority of colleges, and departments of many universities have since gone on "strike," in protest of this increase. Episodes of violence are regular.
There was the march across the busiest highway in the city, where they stopped traffic for three hours, the repeated smoke bombs in the metro, the repeated pelting of bricks at metro cars, the march on the bridge, the marches every night for three months, locking down downtown, featuring the destruction of storefronts, the burglaries many of those nights, and the businesses who closed shop because of the destruction. There are the hundreds of police cars that have been lit on fire, vandalized, shat into, or otherwise destroyed, and the tens of colleges where less than 500 votes locked thousands of students out of the school for a semester, causing reasonable students to lose thousands of dollars. The picket lines in front of the colleges, preventing any student from entering, and the faculty who give up and leave. The city has been taken hostage by thugs, whose primary goal is more government services.
While I support their right to a boycott, and to free speech, I do not support their right to march as they have, and am profoundly in favour of bill 78.
Jesus, another Canadian around here?
Be nice or you go back in your cage.
Fine, as long as you've cleaned all the Canadian out of it.
No more treats for you!
I'm Canadian.
So there.
Go trampoline!
I know it's a stupid question, but is that $0.50/day spread over the entire year or just the school year?
I mean, it seems like a very uneconmical use of one's time, spending several hours a day protesting to avoid FIFTY MOTHERFUCKING CENTS in charges.
a very uneconmical use of one's time, spending several hours a day protesting
Maybe they use that time to arrange hookups, too.
Tuition is currently $2168/year. It will increase $1,625 over five years, bringing it to $3793/year.
The problem is that is still shockingly cheap. What is minimum wage in QB these days? In BC it is something in the vicinity of $9/hr, I think. So you'd have to get a minimum wage job and work for ~4.5 weeks to earn the difference. Fuck, if you're worried about that kind of chump change you should probably just move to AB and get a job in the tar sand or tar sands-adjacent industry.
It was just increased to $9.90/hour. Less if you get tips. Believe me, I plan on leaving here as soon as I can.
It is a shame, because Montreal is absolutely lovely. I'd move there in a heartbeat if it weren't so economically retarded.
You rather be in Montreal than in Vancouver? You must love that dry cold...
Have you been through a Vancouver winter? Absolute shit. Ideal scenario would be winter in somewhere low-tax and beachy, like St. Kitts, and summer in Montreal.
I live in Victoria; apparently it gets less rain than Vancouver.
I lived through a Montreal winter (and several of them in Ottawa). Plus the summer gets really hot and steamy there, too. I'm done with continental weather; rather the rainy winters and the very pleasant, not too hot summers of the West Coast.
Of course de gustibus non est disputandum.
Sheeeit, that's still less than half of what I'm forking out for Number One Son to go to Mizzou.
It should be noted that none of the striking students are english and that the french strikers are all from liberal-arts programs.
(Yes, there are a few english people left in Quebce).
This may have started with a protest against tuition fees, but it's really about the unions behind the students. We have a provincial election on now, and the unions wants the opposition separatist party to win.
Any chance the rest of Canuckistan will kick the Quebeckers out rather than waiting for them to quit?
Brutus, the narrative to "keeping Quebec in" has certainly shifted to "call their bluff and let them walk" over the last few years. As Alberta, BC and even Saskatchewan gain confidence and coin, the less they feel they need Upper and Lower Canada (Ontario and Quebec); or at least put up with their bull.
If the bluff is called, Quebec is NOWHERE NEAR prepared to be "independent." How can it be when it's so dependent WITHIN Confederation?
Rufus J. Firefly| 8.8.12 @ 4:58PM |#
..."If the bluff is called, Quebec is NOWHERE NEAR prepared to be "independent." How can it be when it's so dependent WITHIN Confederation?"
Simple:
Quebec will appeal to the UN to force the newly-independent nation of Canada to provide support for the 'orphaned' state of Quebec!
Don't you know how that works? 'I shot myself in the foot and now someone owes me compensation!' (and cheap tuition!)
That or they will ask for military protection from both Canada and Washington.
Then the Americans will dictate where the hydro-electricity will flow and the Cree will refuse to let their lands be used and then Montreal will break off because Montrealers want nothing to do with the hinterland.
But seriously folks, Quebec wants to use Canada's military and maintain the passport and NOT pay its portion of the debt when they leave.
Bunch of dolts.
"Dad, I want to leave the house but can you give me the rent money for an apartment? And the car...and an allowance for food..."
Notice Nadeau's comments and compare them to others. Who sounds more rational and mature? The guy actually justifies "force" as if there wasn't a choice.
Spoken like a true, hard core socialist-liberal. They can only get results by coercion. Without it, they have nothing.
Rufus J. Firefly| 8.8.12 @ 10:47PM |#
..."But seriously folks, Quebec wants to use Canada's military and maintain the passport and NOT pay its portion of the debt when they leave."
Re: Tony Judt, "Post War".
Judt is a confirmed lefty, but (unlike shithead) has a degree of honesty which seems to require an admission that the Euro-socialism is a dead end.
If you make marginal notes while reading it, you'll find Judt trying to back-track ("lying" is the proper term) from page to page and see he shows the exact same desire of the Euros; 'the US can provide defense while we criticize. And relax'.
He ends before he 'squares the circle' on the issues, but the result is obvious; you can't have free stuff.
I'm a Montrealer.
I was wondering when Reason was going to cover this because it's a text book case of a society feeling entitled to all sorts of goodies like post-secondary education. Quebec is a corrupt have-not" province with low productivity, and high taxes that relies on equalization payments from riche "have" provinces like Alberta.
And Ontario is no better. Bunch of liberal sissies.
My friend is a professor at a French university and he agrees the students have not a damn thing to stand on. Even after the hike it's damn cheap but Canadians are so obsessively paranoid of "becoming American" they latch on to stupid things like this.
And yes, it is mostly the French side doing all the complaining and whining. The English speaking minority are too pragmatic and realistic to waste time banging on pots and pans with tin-pot student association hucksters with Marxist-socialist outlooks backed by big Union.
On a value level, I COMPLETELY disagree with the students. Moreover, Premier Charest is gutless for letting students push him around. Over 70% of Quebecers are ok with the hikes.
He had a mandate to fricken govern. The media and students talk and act as if there's no dialogue when all I hear on the radio and publications are students railing with their "like, you know" and "ums."
Sell your bonds.
I'd like to add, we're having an election for this crap. The parochial, nationalist Parti-Quebecois and their merry-band of anti-business, anti-Canada, anti-English, anti-liberty wannabe Scandinavian socialist dolts are going as far as calling for a freeze in a province in massive debt.
And no one mentionned to them then Sweden dropped some of their socialists ideas http://reason.com/blog/2012/06.....d-bearer-a or they know it but they put their hands on their ears saying "lalala I can't ear you!"
All it miss is another Oka crisis...
Am I the only one who looks at Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois and wonders if this is all an elaborate publicity stunt for a not-yet-announced movie starring Michael Cera?
Now then you mentionned it, it's so tempted to wonder if they're separate twins?
And Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois decided to left the building. http://www.montrealgazette.com