Should the Supreme Court Be Celebrated for Sometimes Stopping Trump?
Plus: A headbanging holiday gift guide
Is the current U.S. Supreme Court a partisan right-wing body whose reach and authority should be fundamentally altered by the newly empowered Democratic majorities in Congress? Or does it actually deserve a big pat on the back for its overall behavior during the era of President Donald Trump?
Writing this week in The New York Times, University of Chicago law professor Will Baude, a former clerk to Chief Justice John Roberts, argues that "under the circumstances of the second Trump term, the Supreme Court is doing amazingly well. If anything, it deserves our celebration, not our condemnation."
It seems to me that a bit of both is actually in order. The Supreme Court does deserve real credit for overruling Trump's illegal tariff scheme and for rejecting his unconstitutional executive order on birthright citizenship. Not every justice got it right in those cases, but the ones who did get it right deserve some props for it.
But the Supreme Court has also done a lousy job in recent years on all sorts of other important issues, some of which involve Trump and some of which do not. Sustained criticism of those misguided rulings seems like an appropriate response to me.
You’re reading Injustice System from Damon Root and Reason. Get more of Damon’s commentary on constitutional law and American history.
One of Baude's main points is that an independent Supreme Court is inevitably going to annoy everybody at one time or another, which is a feature, not a bug, of the system when it is working properly. I agree with him on that and would add this: The fact that the president keeps attacking his own appointees for ruling against him reflects pretty well on the actions of those appointees in those cases.
While I would give lower marks overall to the current Supreme Court than Baude apparently would, I do agree with him that the sort of all-or-nothing attacks on the Court that we're increasingly seeing from both the left and the right pose real risks to judicial independence.
Whether or not giving the Supreme Court credit where credit is due will be enough to blunt the force of such attacks—and thereby help to raise the Court's increasingly dismal approval ratings—remains to be seen.
Odds & Ends
The year 2026 has been a banner one for new music from bands loved by me. With the holiday shopping season fast approaching, I thought I would use this edition of my newsletter to recommend a trio of great new albums that might just delight the music lover in your life (assuming said music lover is wise enough to enjoy heavy metal of one stripe or another).
Good God / Baad Man is the awesome new double album from hardcore punk heroes turned boogie-metal masters Corrosion of Conformity. If you have ever wondered what it might sound like if Black Sabbath, Black Flag, ZZ Top, and the Allman Brothers got together for a sweet leaf-fueled jam session, it might sound something like this.
An Undying Love for a Burning World from the incomparable post-hardcore/metal band Neurosis is my vote for album of the year and probably for album of the decade. This record dropped from out of nowhere earlier this year, a total shock and awe event from a band that I thought was broken up forever. To call this album a triumphant return from one of the greatest bands in all of heavy music would be a severe understatement.
Shapes of Midnight by the cult psychedelic doom band Uncle Acid & the Dead Beats sounds just like what it is: the work of killer musicians steeped in Sabbath and early Iron Maiden who have probably watched every single horror and exploitation movie from the 1970s multiple times. If these lo-fi headbangers aren't the best new heavy metal band to appear in the last two decades, I don't know who is.