Juneteenth Is the Most Libertarian Holiday
It is hard to think of something more pro-freedom than the abolition of slavery.

It took a while. But the most recent federal holiday to be added to the calendar, it turns out, is the most American holiday yet.
That holiday, Juneteenth, is today. It celebrates the abolition of chattel slavery in the U.S., marked by June 19, 1865—the day Maj. Gen. Gordon Granger informed slaves in Galveston, Texas, that they were free. It was the final major enforcement of the Emancipation Proclamation in Confederate territory, more than two years after President Abraham Lincoln had signed it. Some enslaved people would remain in bondage until the 13th Amendment was ratified in December of that year, but June 19 has come to symbolize America's attempt to move past one of its darkest stains.
The American project is, in historical terms, relatively young. At its core, it's an experiment. It is constantly evolving, owning its mistakes and trying to live up to its original promises in more robust ways. Juneteenth is, in one sense, a reminder of those intense growing pains—especially when remembering the enormous hurdles former slaves still faced in society after 1865—and the country's willingness to try to overcome them. Freedom didn't fully arrive that day, but it represents America's desire to improve, to correct grave errors, and to live up more faithfully to the country's founding ideals.
Those ideals, of course, were grounded in a vigorous vision of liberty—another reason why Juneteenth is fundamentally American. As I wrote last year, it is difficult to think of something more pro-liberty than the abolition of slavery, which is defined by the total absence of basic autonomy. Its presence in the U.S. is the most glaring instance of the country violating its founding principles, and its abolition is without a doubt the most dramatic example of America becoming more aligned with its premise.
But the latter is also why it is, by far, America's most libertarian holiday. It is not an exaggeration to say that slavery epitomized state-sanctioned violence. The practice permitted someone to completely extract the freedom of another. Slave codes codified this into law, greenlighting torture and family separation, and the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 required states—even free ones—to capture and return those who escaped. These people were deprived of any semblance of individual liberty, much less property. Because they were the property.
Though the U.S. made Juneteenth a federal holiday in 2021, people have been celebrating for well over a century. The government certainly did not need to formally recognize it for it to hold weight. Historically speaking, it's most accurately described as a grassroots day. But its broader cultural recognition is a welcome reminder of where this country started, and where we're going.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
The most libertarian holiday is Fuck-You-Don't-Tell-Me-When-or-What-To-Celebrate Day.
I think Juneteenth should have been left to the people and places who traditionally celebrate it. It is a marvelous thing to celebrate, but as I understand it it is historically a very regional thing and a fun happy occasion to celebrate and have some fun. I don't think making it another day of solemn reflection on how bad we've been historically improves it.
Federal paid holidays are libertarian. Especially when done for virtue signaling.
The only thing this holiday does for me is make it so my garbage gets picked up on Saturday instead of Friday.
Mine was picked up today! Think they get time and half though.
I picked today to cash out my retirement, move to Thailand and live like a potentate forever after. But to my surprise the markets are closed for the silliest reason imaginable. Everybody knows the after hours traders always conspire to fuck the retailers. Looks like I'm fucked.
zeb wins.
Wow Billy Binion! Pander and gaslight much? I'm so sick of people being afraid to tell the truth! Black people are not fragile, we are just entitled, ignorant of history, and blame everything on racism because the white and black liberals don't challenge us because they want our votes! The truth is that Biden thought that by making June 19th, a Texas thing when the slaves found out they were free, a national holiday, it would make us vote democrat similar to the infamous LBJ with his handouts. It is ridiculous and does nothing for anyone! Just teach real history, stop with the gaslighting, the constant cry of racism, pandering to illegals and gays, creating more and more underclasses, and just let people follow their own path to happiness without asking the taxpayers to forgo their own savings, and save those who are reckless. The best teacher in changing behavior is to let people suffer. We will help those that can't help themselves, but it's time to put able bodied people to work and stop dividing the country with b.s. made up opinions!
The last few years have shown that the MAGAs defiantly need more days of solemn reflection on how bad they have been. That is why they are so against Juneteenth now.
You mean when the democrats were fighting to maintain slavery and Jim crow?
Lol.
Trolling?
Forget it Jake, it's Biniontown
Paying government workers not to work while I do, nope. Most libertarian holiday still 4th of July.
The only federal holidays (if any) should be Independence Day, Thanksgiving and Memorial Day.
I figure just Independence Day and Memorial Day and absolutely nothing else.
Thanksgiving is unrelated to our government. One could call the original Thanksgiving a secular holiday between two groups of non-government people having what amounts to a potluck dinner, or one could call it a religious holiday where thanks was expressed to God for divine providence.
In the interest of separating church and state, all religious holidays should NOT be observed by the US governments (federal, state, local). Religious organizations can celebrate whatever they like, so long as govt workers do not get paid time off.
Damn straight, and Juneteenth was pushed to dilute Independence Day.
"That holiday, Juneteenth, is today. It celebrates the abolition of chattel slavery in the U.S..."
Chattel slavery was safe in the Kentucky and Delaware until the following December 31.
Independence Day and the "freedoms" associated with it meant nothing to those oppressed and/or enslaved.
How white are you dr retard?
Unfortunately, Juneteenth federal holiday will always be associated with the George Floyd riot and race baiting Marxism that gave birth to it. You cannot be guilted or coerced into celebrating freedom.
Let us remind ourselves that to win the war, President Lincoln had to appease loyalist states that had slaves. He only freed slaves in confederate territory. He suspended habeas corpus. Runaway slaves were returned. The union threatened to hang slaves fighting for the south just as the south threatened to hang those who fought for the union.
Were the war fought by fanatics who only cared for their cause and not the wellbeing of their nation and its people - Lincoln on our side and Robert E Lee in the south, who chose to surrender than fight to the bitter death and go scorched earth - the nation would have been ruined by the war no matter who won. Lincoln never considered the secessionist south as anything other than American. Zelenskky would hang hundreds of russian sympathizers the second the wins the war.
You cannot have liberty without a foundation of a freedom loving nation. You think a million people who lean libertarian could live in prosperity in some deserted island where everyone pink swears not to take more than 3 coconuts a day - no. If 70% of them says they want all the coconuts one day, it's game over. Lincoln would not tolerate the attacks on ICE officers, not matter how much free labor the illegals provided to his nation. We have more cause to celebrate Juneteenth than the commies of this country.
I largely agree with you, but I consider Lincoln to be total scum.
Fundamentally, he overrode the South's right to self-determination with extremely lethal violence, and that's as anti-liberty as one can get. That said, the Southern slave owners were also overriding the slaves' right to self-determination with lethal violence, so the question becomes: do two wrongs make a right?
Or perhaps, does one huge wrong (based on numbers killed) undo a slightly less huge wrong (based on numbers killed/enslaved) that eventually would have been resolved peacefully with technological advances (slavery was going to become economically unviable anyway)?
In a parallel universe, the USA could have avoided the civil war had the North not tried to ruin the South, ended slavery peacefully, and continued to maintain states' right to secede. That would be the most libertarian alternate timeline of them all...
This guy gets it.
I don’t particularly care about Juneteenth but if you think slavery could be ended peacefully you are taking the wrong pill. As for slavery ending of itself? There is still lots of slavery. There will always be difficult or degrading work and people who would enslave others to get it done if slavery wasn’t illegal.
"Unfortunately, Juneteenth federal holiday will always be associated with the George Floyd riot"
Nope. I have not seen one George Floyd Juneteenth reference. What you said is a way for you to denigrate Juneteenth according to your own biases.
The holiday was a direct result of Floyd protest. An appeasement.
I was in an adult school class last year and the Latino heavy class has no idea what Juneteenth was. No one cared. Juneteenth will be the equivalent of bastille day from here on out.
Is it worthy to be celebrated? Sure. But like I said, you can’t guilt anyone into celebrating anything.
It is hard to think of something more pro-freedom than the abolition of slavery.
How about not being subject to the draft?
Certainly important but doesn't really compare.
How so? You are pulled from your home against your will, told what to do and what to wear, when to sleep, what to eat, when to shit. You might get killed. Your drill Sargent will probably beat you up. You have no say in any of this.
And you get proper food and you can still marry who you want and you aren't going to get whipped to oblivion for being uppity and you are protected by laws and when your time is over you can go back home and your kids won't get taken away from you to be sold, etc etc.
What a vile and miserable cattle-truck-loader you are, to be sure
An important difference is that slavery was inherited from a time before the USA and practiced worldwide, whereas the draft was instituted by government to intentionally oppress and exploit young men.
Wrong.
As D-l-a-m mentions, there is little to distinguish between the two, except that the draft affected all races.
You’re right, because you’re also forced to kill people. Good job shrike!
You really are a fuckwit, and I'm still not shrike.
How would you rate being forced to kill people on your victim scale shrike?
I have a feeling you haven’t thought this position through.
True, your chance of dying in a war are far greater than dying due to slavery, especially chattel slavery.
Maybe. But, chattel slavery is for life, whereas the draft was for two years.
You obviously weren't around to see the body bags come home from Nam.
Only a slave for a while is ok?
Prove it.
Conscription *is* slavery.
Those drafted were born free, their children born free. It is amazing how much racist MAGA shits want to denigrate Juneteenth.
White savior syndrome as you chat with your white friends is strong in you.
America Celebrates Juneteenth, The Day Republicans Freed All The Democrats' Slaves
That holiday, Juneteenth, is today. It celebrates the abolition of chattel slavery in the U.S., marked by June 19, 1865—the day Maj. Gen. Gordon Granger informed slaves in Galveston, Texas, that they were free. It was the final major enforcement of the Emancipation Proclamation in Confederate territory, more than two years after President Abraham Lincoln had signed it. Some enslaved people would remain in bondage until the 13th Amendment was ratified in December of that year, but June 19 has come to symbolize America's attempt to move past one of its darkest stains.
Once again and by your own take, it isn't actually a celebration of the abolition of chattel slavery. That happened later (and even then, only in this country). It, like many other parts of the war, is a celebration of the imposition of the will of the Executive on a civilian populace via arbitrary proclamation and military force.
It's not an attempt to move past anything, it's an attempt to ensure that people keep using the phrase "darkest stain" and keep their false narratives surrounding it front and center.
Everlasting divisiveness.
Billy bravely comes out against slavery.
Stunning and brave.
it wasn't even a thing in Texas where it was the thing.
Cinco de Mayo for Black LatinXes.
"It is hard to think of something more pro-freedom than the abolition of slavery."
The Declaration of Independence comes to mind.
Anyone who argues that the DoI was followed by 90 years of slavery had better acknowledge that Juneteenth 1865 was followed by 100 years of Jim Crow mandated segregation and — so far — 60 years of mandated integration.
Government-mandated holidays are not very libertarian.
well sure there was that...the day we all said "no mas" to the jackass brits and went home to load our guns to get busy with the shootin' part. and putting it on a thursday makes it a pain in the ass
On this day, Juneteenth, we remember the fallen. (Pics included)
https://x.com/JebraFaushay/status/1935659681491349663
On Juneteenth, I remember the Rosenbergs.
https://m3.gab.com/media_attachments/96/39/73/963973ba235c151e2c65e8fcd2b6590e.jpeg?width=568
May they Roast in Hell
The first I ever heard of Juneteenth was when I moved from a small town to Milwaukee for college. Every summer around this time I'd hear on the news about the routine riots and violence that universally accompanied the holiday. It hasn't left a good impression on me.
I'm all for a holiday to celebrate the end of slavery, I just would've gone with the date of the ratification of the 13th amendment or the emancipation proclamation.
MKE started grassroots celebrations of Juneteenth in 1972.
https://www.jsonline.com/story/news/2020/06/19/how-juneteenth-celebrations-started-and-grew-milwaukee/3207453001/
Unfortunately, violence has, over the years, marred the celebrations. Search: [ Milwaukee | Juneteenth | riot ]
Some enslaved people would remain in bondage until the 13th Amendment was ratified in December of that year, but June 19 has come to symbolize America's attempt to move past one of its darkest stains.
I read the article carefully and at first thought Binion was suggesting that this was the most American of holidays when it's definitely not. But he seemed to be holding in comparison with other American holidays, and I don't have much beef with that. However, slavery being America's "darkest stain" is clearly suggesting that slavery is a uniquely American institution, and America has highly visible stain on its shirt that other nations and cultures don't have. I presume that given Binion's age, he got the same education everyone else under the age of 45 in this country got: A whole lot of time on slavery, a little on WWII and the NAZIs, and nothing else of note.
Slavery was the natural state of the world until the 19th century. The English had slavery, the French had slavery, the Spanish had slavery, Africa had slavery, the middle East had slavery, the Barbary Pirates had slavery... hell the Ottoman empire was the largest slave trading empire in the history of human civilization. I don't see anyone wagging their finger as a tourist in Ankara, lecturing the Turks on their "darkest stain".
There are certainly worthy debates over whether America needed to fight a civil war over slavery-- the English were able to end slavery in something like 1830 (in fits and starts) however, the crown compensated those slave owners to keep those economies from collapsing. Either way, the idea that there was the world, trucking along having not even conceived of Slavery when... ALL OF A SUDDEN, there came America and the world was introduced to this darkest of mustard stains on the frock of civilization.
Yeah that pretty much sums it up. All of this obsessing about slavery in the US is nothing but propaganda. Was it a good thing? Obviously not. Was in any way unique? Obviously not. Sorry but I'm really not in the mood for this shit today.
They traded one form of slavery for another.
Hilarious. It's not - as the article points out - the day of the abolition of slavery, it's the day some slaves in a different country were told they were 'free' by a foreign military officer.
The slaves in the rest of the US? Yeah, they would remain in bondage until the end of 1865.
>"It is not an exaggeration to say that slavery epitomized state-sanctioned violence.
I disagree. Slavery existed - even in the US -*before* the state had any meaningful role.
*Private* violence - super libertarian - and a completely unfettered free market is what started and maintained slavery.
So don't get so high and mighty about how libertarian anti-slavery is when it's actually the use of state violence to interfere in these interactions that ended slavery.
No, stupid. Easter is the most libertarian holiday. Followed very closely by Independence Day.
But you know what, I actually agree with this article in general. And, ngl, I'm very surprised and offended by people who don't.
I've been going around to black people all day long and saying, "You're welcome." When asked for what, I casually explain, "For Republicans getting your brothers and sisters off the Democrat plantations."
Some of them got really pissed off. It's like they don't understand Juneteenth at all.
Easter? Because it is a private sector holiday? So is Halloween.
No, because Easter is the most libertarian thing that has ever happened to the human race.
You didn't have a choice before that (edit: well, you kinda did, but with no promise of anything in return for making it). Now you do. Nothing compels you to make it except yourself. It was the single-most liberty-embracing, autonomy-encouraging, self-determination thing that has ever happened to this world.
If I drew you a map from your house to mine, following it would get you to my house. But you don't have to follow it. There's an infinite number of other paths you can take. Some might even get you to my house in a roundabout way. Most of them won't.
Follow the map, or don't. But if you don't, then don't complain about your arriving at your destination when you get there.
Create as many BS holidays as you like, the only thing I care about is: Do I get the day off?
I agree in theory, but not in practice. This holiday feels contrived, like Kwanza, but not so nonsensical. It's not very inclusive.
They didn't really need to make it a government holiday. We have St. Patrick's Day with no day off. St. Floyd's Day could have been just like that, but without the fun.
Does Africa have a holiday equivalent to Juneteenth? Oh that's right. Chattel slavery is still okay there. We're talking about shit that the US left behind like two and a half centuries ago, which as it happens was long before my ancestors came to Ellis Island. I apologize to no one for slavery whether it happened in the Antebellum south of old or Africa today.