Reason.com - Free Minds and Free Markets
Reason logo Reason logo
  • Latest
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Subscribe
    • Crossword
  • Video
  • Podcasts
    • All Shows
    • The Reason Roundtable
    • The Reason Interview With Nick Gillespie
    • The Soho Forum Debates
    • Just Asking Questions
    • The Best of Reason Magazine
    • Why We Can't Have Nice Things
  • Volokh
  • Newsletters
  • Donate
    • Donate Online
    • Donate Crypto
    • Ways To Give To Reason Foundation
    • Torchbearer Society
    • Planned Giving
  • Subscribe
    • Reason Plus Subscription
    • Print Subscription
    • Gift Subscriptions
    • Subscriber Support

Login Form

Create new account
Forgot password

First Amendment

Maine Legislator Barred From Voting Over Social Media Post

Earlier this year, state Rep. Laurel Libby made a post criticizing trans women in women's sports. Her refusal to apologize has cost Libby her right to speak on the House floor and vote on legislation.

Emma Camp | 5.2.2025 1:50 PM

Share on FacebookShare on XShare on RedditShare by emailPrint friendly versionCopy page URL
Media Contact & Reprint Requests
Laurel Libby | lllustration: Eddie Marshall | Maine House Republicans | Midjourney
(lllustration: Eddie Marshall | Maine House Republicans | Midjourney)

A Maine state legislator has been prohibited from speaking or having her votes counted—all for a social media post critical of transgender athletes participating in women's sports. Rep. Laurel Libby (R–Auburn) has attempted to challenge the legislature's actions against her in court but has faced several defeats. This week, Libby filed an emergency injunction asking the Supreme Court to intervene. 

"If this statement were made by a non-member of the legislature . . . it would clearly be constitutionally protected," Nadine Strossen, the former president of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) tells Reason. "So the only argument they can possibly make is that somehow you have fewer First Amendment rights when you are an elected member of a state legislative body than an ordinary citizen would have, which is completely counterintuitive and counter to not only fundamental First Amendment principles but fundamental principles of representative government." 

In February, Libby made a post on Facebook and X criticizing the state's decision to allow a transgender girl to compete in a high school track championship. The post included the name and an unblurred photo of a transgender athlete who had won the girls pole vault after previously competing as a boy.

In the wake of the post, the Maine Legislature voted to censure her. The censure resolution stated that Libby should "accept full responsibility for the incident and publicly apologize to the House and to the people of the State of Maine." However, when summoned to the well of the House of Representative's chamber, Libby refused to apologize. According to legal documents Libby later filed, Rep. Ryan Fecteau (D–Biddeford)—the Speaker of the Maine House—then found her in violation of a House rule that any member who "is guilty of a breach of any of the rules and orders of the House … may not be allowed to vote or speak, unless by way of excuse for the breach, until the member has made satisfaction."

Ever since, Libby's votes have not been counted and she has been barred from speaking on the House floor. In March, Libby sued Fecteau and the House clerk, arguing that their actions violated her First Amendment and due process rights. However, the Legislature has claimed that its actions are protected by "absolute legislative immunity." So far, this theory has worked. Both the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 1st Circuit and a lower federal court have denied her requests that the Legislature count her votes. But even if Libby hasn't succeeded so far, that doesn't mean her First Amendment rights weren't clearly violated.

"The core of legislative immunity is to shield lawmakers for what they say or how they vote during legislative debate and processes. That makes sense, as we want to promote free and open debate in our Houses and Senates," JT Morris, an attorney at the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), a First Amendment group, tells Reason. "But it's hard to reconcile immunizing lawmakers who engage in free and open debate, and immunizing these Maine lawmakers who are punishing Representative Libby for her speech by stripping her ability to participate in legislative debate and voting."

Start your day with Reason. Get a daily brief of the most important stories and trends every weekday morning when you subscribe to Reason Roundup.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

NEXT: Pam Bondi's Absurd Claim About Fentanyl Overdoses Epitomizes the Illogic of the War on Drugs

Emma Camp is an associate editor at Reason.

First AmendmentCivil LibertiesFree SpeechCensorshipDue ProcessTransSportsSocial MediaState GovernmentsMaine
Share on FacebookShare on XShare on RedditShare by emailPrint friendly versionCopy page URL
Media Contact & Reprint Requests

Show Comments (62)

Latest

Farmers Need Free Markets, Not Tariffs and Welfare

Steven Greenhut | 5.23.2025 7:30 AM

With REAL ID, America Now Has National ID Cards and Internal Passports

J.D. Tuccille | 5.23.2025 7:00 AM

Review: The Free Market Comes to The Sims 4

Autumn Billings | From the June 2025 issue

Review: Was Charles Manson Carrying Out a CIA Experiment?

Brian Doherty | From the June 2025 issue

Brickbat: Parking Violation

Charles Oliver | 5.23.2025 4:00 AM

Recommended

  • About
  • Browse Topics
  • Events
  • Staff
  • Jobs
  • Donate
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Media
  • Shop
  • Amazon
Reason Facebook@reason on XReason InstagramReason TikTokReason YoutubeApple PodcastsReason on FlipboardReason RSS

© 2024 Reason Foundation | Accessibility | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

r

Do you care about free minds and free markets? Sign up to get the biggest stories from Reason in your inbox every afternoon.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

This modal will close in 10

Reason Plus

Special Offer!

  • Full digital edition access
  • No ads
  • Commenting privileges

Just $25 per year

Join Today!