Canadian Banks Prepared To Make Un-Persons of Protesters, at Government Demand
Our gentle neighbor to the North rushes toward grim authoritarianism.

As Canada tries its best to keep donations of cryptocurrency from helping protesters against the country's vaccine mandates on truckers, as detailed by Reason's Liz Wolfe, the Canadian Bankers Association has announced its intention to make sure that those associated with the protests are thoroughly locked out of all traditional financial services as well.
As Global News in Canada reports:
The Canadian Bankers Association said in a statement Wednesday that, as with other financial service providers, banks will "need to diligently implement the required measures."
"Banks in Canada follow all applicable laws and regulations in carrying out their operations, in keeping with their commitment to protect the integrity of Canada's financial system," the association said.
The details of those "required measures" Canada wants to enforce on dissenters not convicted of any crime are totalitarian grimness of a sort many naively thought could not happen in the allegedly democratic, free West. These moves embody the Chinese "social credit" mentality: combining ancient authoritarian ideology and modern technological power to control how anyone, free citizen or convicted criminal, can actually survive in the world. (Ottawa has even announced its intention to steal protesters' dogs, a truly cartoonish level of villainy.)
As the CBC reports:
The government's new directive, called the "emergency economic measures order," goes beyond asking banks to simply stop transferring funds to protest organizers. The government wants banks to stop doing business with some people altogether.
The order says that banks and other financial entities (like credit unions, co-ops, loan companies, trusts and cryptocurrency platforms) must stop "providing any financial or related services" to people associated with the protests — a move that will result in frozen accounts, stranded money and cancelled credit cards…
These financial institutions can't handle cash, issue a loan, extend a mortgage or more generally facilitate "any transaction" of a "designated person" while the Emergencies Act is in place.
Even more sinister, one need not be someone actually committing any act of civic disorder to be thusly punished: "The regulations define a 'designated person' who can be cut off from financial services as someone who is 'directly or indirectly' participating in a 'public assembly that may reasonably be expected to lead to a breach of the peace,' or a person engaging in 'serious interference with trade' or 'critical infrastructure."
What "indirect" support might mean will play out in the courts, one hopes, unless Canada just decides to really live up to its current flexing as a totalitarian hellhole by tossing people in jail without charge or adjudication. But given targeting of donations both traditional and crypto lately, it will not be surprising if the government considers an "indirect" participant in the protests anyone who donates to the protesters' cause.
The purpose of this sort of financial exile is to break dissidents' will without having to take the perhaps reputation-damaging act of publicly and physically tossing thousands in prison for expressing their anger at government vaccine mandates on truckers. The equally, if metaphorically, bone-crushing act of locking people out of the financial system mark-of-beast style is less easily filmed or tweeted.
It is not yet clear, despite the Canadian Bankers Association's statement, that the protesters the government thinks it has identified are all indeed financially un-personed already. While anons on 4chan are openly trying to meme a Canadian bank run into existence—once the government has announced and banks have agreed that they will block your access to your money or services on executive order, why should people trust banks?—there are scattered reports that Canadians are having more problems with accessing banking services electronically than normal this week.
What Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's government is trying to do here, with the obedient collusion of the banking sector, is far beyond acceptable business as usual for a Western government; it is vile authoritarianism, in service of a policy goal of little objective importance given the existing Canadian rate of vaccination, and it ought to destroy both the moral and actual authority of his regime.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
You mean giant corporations can act in concert with the government? What happened to "Go start your own Twitter"?
I guess only social media platforms are incapable of ever causing any harm or being agents of oppression.
Maybe you should find a few books published before 1970 and find out what the economic basis of fascism is.
I am well aware of what fascism is. Sorry if my sarcasm wasn't more apparent.
Sadly, there is no sarcasm anymore, just prophecy.
Yes, these people are beyond satire.
As Kyles dad said: “It’s not fascism if we don’t call it that.”
there has been a fair bit of VERY sarcastic prophecy......
Nice job, Briggs. Your Sarc font was very much a stealth job. Well done,Sir.
It would seem, then, that things have devolved to such a serious state of affairs such responses are not easily detected.
Yes, "fascism" defined, is government control of private means of production. Last Iknew, Canada's banks were still provate corporations, and not government entities. This means Jussie True Dough has played his fascist dictator card, and ORDERED banks to do HIS bidding. As if he WERE a dictator, which is is, at law, decidedly not.
Methinks such tyranny will not succeed long term. He could well find that every ticketed commercial vehicle operator in the entier Dominion will simply go home and park his rig. I remember well back in the late 1960's when all the trucks and busses operating in Mexico were privately owned/operated units, all one offs. Whenever the government owned/run motor fuel operation decided to raise the price above twenty five cents the gallon they would simply park the rigs, and bring alll of Mexico to a sudden stop. The longest government ever was able to hold out was three days. NOTHING and NO ONE moved inside Mexico till the fuel price again went to where it was supposed to be. No riots, sitins, boycotts, parades, passionate pleas on the telly.. nothing. All of Mexico shut down. Until the price went right again. Trudeau fails to realise he is sitting aon a powder keg. Anyone wanna bat that those weapons that were stolen were stolen for? I sorta smell why. No it was not to arm the truckers. They are THAT adamant about having their will enforced. Or perhaps more accurate: HE is that adamant.
I wish truckers could organize that well.
It's like herding cats.
That's correct.
Note that it is different from what Briggs was saying; he was defining it as "cooperation" between government and private corporations, which is not fascism.
Maybe you should too.
It is not "giant corporations acting in concert with the government".
What it actually is is "government forcing giant corporations (in fact, all economic actors) to act according to its directions (supposedly for the 'common good')".
This is what Jeff, Mike, Shrike and Sqrlscasmic have been arguing for.
Yes. They are fascists.
They also to deny them service at hospitals.
“Free” healthcare, if you aren’t an unperson.
So that's how Ezra Pound ended up in St. Elizabeth's.
I have to admit, five years ago I never would have expected two laid-back British commonwealth nations to rapidly re-form into the kind of dystopian neomarxist technocracies that Orwell and Huxley wrote about.
I would not have either. I had pretty much written off the UK but I never thought that Australia and Canada would go this quickly. It is terrifying.
The irony is that the UK is actually ramping back on all this shit after Boris got embarrassed from the publicity wrought by throwing maskless cocktail parties for the upper crust.
That is what makes this whole thing even more pointless and stupid. Trudeau is turning Canada into a police state and risking a civil war over something that is ending everywhere else in the world.
It makes me think the rumors of his being Castro's son are true. That is Castro level stupid.
Yeah, and note that Biden openly encouraged Trudeau to crush the protesters, all while he, Fauci, and Walensky remain stubbornly devoted to keeping mandates in place while Democratic governors are ramping back on this stuff themselves to try and mitigate at least some of the Red Tsunami that's heading their way in November.
Biden and Trudeau is one hell of a brain trust. Holy cow how did two of the richest and most important nations on earth end up with those two in charge of their governments?
Mean tweets.
Idiots who think decorum is more important than policy and ignore a biased media highlighting and lying about said decorum.
Our real rulers don't want their puppets to have brains.
^THIS^ Those two are just avatars...
they are front men for the actual backroom boys that are running their show
In the case of the US, we elected a bloviating clown as President, and after 4 years of that nonsense a majority of voters were eager for most any alternative.
You mean easily fooled idiots who were told decorum matters over policy.
In the case of the US, we elected a bloviating clown as President four times in a row.
Fixed it for you.
Nothing wrong with a bloviating clown if he doesn't start wars, cuts regulations, negotiates trade deals and makes peace between Arabs and Jews.
Everyone knew what sort of wicked authoritarian fool Biden was. His senate record and decades of speeches showed that.
So we elected a want to be dictator, who also happens to be so inept that he causes damage to everything he touches. So much better.
They are all wannabe dictators! Finding one that is not would be surprising.
If the election was totally legit, that is one of the stupidest things Americans as a collective have done in my lifetime.
don't forget what Arden is making of EnnZed...... she's been a tyrant of the worst order for some time now, and getting worse as things degress......
Dude, New Zealand! That place was so nice when I visited less than 10 years ago. Now... *headshake*
It feels like just yesterday when it was just happening to Hong Kong.
The difference is that the one in Hong Kong was likely a CIA-led color revolution glow-op, like the Arab Spring. This one has largely been a true grassroots uprising against the country's globohomo elite, including the press in both the US and Canada, and without all the corporate sponsorship and soft-handed law enforcement that BLM and Antifa enjoyed for its destructive riots.
Chicoms tightening their grip over Hong Kong is a CIA-led color revolution?
No, the protests likely were. The playbook's been used more often than the Packers ran the off-tackle sweep in the 60s.
I don't know about that. Hong Kongers were protesting against everything our well-funded cabal stands for and their Democracy was Fortified against them.
As a Canadian thanks for this article, Brian. I pulled out $10k just-in-case money today (a bit of a rigmarole), and the teller said I wasn't the only one doing it.
Truck Fudeau, while I can still say it.
When are you planning to flee the country? I'm not exaggerating when I say I think it's time to bail because WAY too many Canadians think all of this is 100% kosher.
Yeah, I've seen a lot of people who say they want to get back to normal but have no problem with the government and businesses denying people work, travel and shopping if they aren't vaccinated.
It's notable here that the prairie provinces are on the verge of revolt because of this, and Quebec is taking advantage of the chaos to press its own ethnonationalist priorities. Meanwhile, no one gives a shit about how this is affecting the northern territories.
I would honestly fucking laugh if Trudeau's ham-fisted handling of resulted in Canada completely dissolving. That prissy fuckhead really needs to study up on what happened in 1989, not 1968, and act accordingly.
Can you provide some literature to read? I am not up on recent canada history. I am interested to learn.
Mother's Lament is our resident Canuckistani poster; he'd be the authority, not me.
If she'a a Neocan, why isn't she working for David Frum ?
What the hell?
Are you drunk?
This is a very short video on Canadian geopolitics that is an excellent breakdown of how the country works, or rather doesn't.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G3lRp-67z5U&t=9s
Thanks for that. Haven't watched Canadian TV since I got hooked on curling on the CBC growing up in Michigan. So Global warming is benefitting Canada's economy? Wonder if that could happen elsewhere. Not that I want Ron Bailey to be sad.
Also have to say I've never understood this virulent opposition to succession. Even amounts "libertarians". If Quebec or Eastern Oregon or Texas want to go their own way why should I care?
In any case I think a lot of us would like to see your impressions of the overall mood in Canada especially since the freedom convoy and Trudeau's tyrannical response.
Oh man, Canadian TV is some of the best TV.
You got your Kids in the Hall, then the little sci-fi 'Hollywood North' in Vancouver. All sorts of really good comedy.
Hell I'll even take Don Cherry (in small doses) over any NBC or ESPN hockey announcer, and he's their version of Dick Vitale.
Being remembered as the fool who broke up Canada is a fate Trudeau deserves, assuming his fate can't be at the end of a rope or dying forgotten in a dank prison cell.
I'm still holding out for "slowly drowning in the septic tank at the Cholula factory". Vladimir Poutine deserves no less!
I'd accept Saskatchewan and Manitoba as the 51st and 52nd states. I'm more mixed on BC and Newfoundland.
What's Alberta, chopped liver?
New name is Yukon Texas.
Yuxas.
The prairie provinces have been in revolt since before COVID, because their economy is a commodities based economy, especially agriculture and oil, and Trudeau's green policies have hurt them the most.
When are you planning to flee the country?
Heading to the US is a pointless no-go because Biden would kick us out. I'm Metis so maybe I could sorta pass as Hispanic, but I'm probably too tall to be a Guatemalan.
Besides it's my country, not theirs. I'm not going to let them have it.
My high school physics teacher and hockey coach was an illegal immigrant from Canada.
Besides it's my country, not theirs. I'm not going to let them have it.
*nod*
I feel the same way about the US.
60+% of the country is on board with this. Time for a new country
Haha, I knew when I saw that crap about freezing people's bank accounts that it was going to result in bank runs.
And all over a protest that has been bouncy, but mostly peaceful.
As I said last night:
SYRUP FOR THE SYRUP GOD!
HONKS FOR THE HONK THRONE!
Step #1: Prohibit banks from providing banking services to designated persons.
Step #2: Prohibit gas stations and grocery stores from accepting cash.
Or, ban all liquid cash, and make everyone use electronic cash, as some progressives have proposed. Not sure how you can open a bank account without a photo ID? Since we know, from progressives that minorities can't get photo IDs, this seems racist to me.
The quick decline into psychotic and narcissitic authoritarianism by our northern neighbors is shocking, to say the least.
Not that much considering Trudeau and his upbringing.
Hell, Trudeau has been slime from the word go. He's faced at least 3 ethic violations since coming to power.
No one seems to have mentioned that the banks are private businesses. Isn't that cartridge blanche here at Reason to excuse whatever they do? ????
Carte not cartridge, stupid autocorrect
Autocarrot sure isn't firing blanches today.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10524463/Elon-Musk-compares-Justin-Trudeau-Hitler-incendiary-meme.html
That's funny. For those who don't trust the Daily Mail, it's a pic of Hitler with the caption 'Stop comparing me to Justin Trudeau... I had a budget.' tweeted by Elon Musk.
Unlike Trudeau, Hitler did do ONE good thing in his life: He did kill Hitler.
Trudeau's only possible benefit to society is fertilizing the ground.
There's no proof of that.
You called this story a hobby horse earlier.
LOL, that’s true
Fuck that, the Daily Mail is the World's Greatest News Source.
That’s pretty funny. Say what you want about Musk, but his meme game is quite good.
Sounds like a great idea.
The banks will make it impossible for people to pay the loans to the bank, then go whine for the government to bail them out. Better for them and the country that they close all government accounts.
More to the point, it's a great way for the banks to skim money from seized accounts to shore up their balances.
This is how governments force the citizens to skip the peaceful protest phase and go directly to violence.
God, isn't that a fact.
It's needed. IMO.
More and more, it seems like the US and Canadian governments are deliberately trying to foment a violent uprising. Apparently they're confident the government would win. Sadly, they're probably right—the police and military are going to stand with the side with the bigger guns.
Meh. Police, maybe. But I think the military would fracture. Afghanistan pissed off a whole lot of people in the ranks, especially the ones who served there. And, at least in the Army, the brass' new policies, the military is making it abundantly clear that GWOT vets are no longer needed- or wanted. And that's where the bulk of your combat experience lives, with those guys. I think you'd see a lot of GWOT-era service members quit the ranks pretty quickly, and in big enough numbers that the remaining forces would have a tough fight on their hands.
I don't think so. They won't want to be on the wrong side when shooting stops.
Not to mention, focusing on "diversity, equity, and inclusion" above all else is going to dilute combat effectiveness. When the most important criteria is checking a box over being able to actually fight, instead of well oiled machine you get a paper tiger.
The military is comprised of nothing but radically leftist insane would-be dictators in the higher ranks, and high-school dropout braindead pussy bootlickers and order-followers in the lower ranks. When it comes time to mass murder Americans, the military if anything will be the ones seizing civilian authority to make sure it happens efficiently.
Remember Kent State.
Most of the military, even the ones from blue states come from red areas and 60+% are the children of veterans themselves. So, you assumption on the military is not based in reality, especially at the Guard and Reserve level.
What difference does that make? They're all stupid, high school dropouts who spent an entire career gargling balls, licking boots, and taking orders without thinking. A man with a brain has no utility as a soldier. When it comes time to point them at the civilian population, they'll march nose-to-ass behind the leadership just like they always have. Because they're stupid and not good for anything else.
especially if they try to take their dogs. Nothing pisses people off more than threatening their pets.
Has Trudeau looked at the size of the Canadian military? About 100,000 strong all branches and reserves combined. How does he expect to fight a civil war with that number (if they all stay loyal) in a population of 38 million?
Sadly a surprising number of Canadians favor authoritarianism. Don't know how many would be willing to fight and die for authoritarianism, but history suggests lots of people around the world have done just that.
With our help.
That depends; what are the rates of private firearm ownership in Canada? Legitimate question too.
Try here:
https://military-history.fandom.com/wiki/Number_of_guns_per_capita_by_country
Thank you
I knew Switzerland was high, but I'm surprised by Sweden, Norway and France's gun ownership rates.
Hunting is a huge part of Scandinavian culture.
I mean, Germany is still right next to France, and France hasn't forgotten that.
Serbia is getting too close in the #2 slot though, the US is going to have to step up its game here. I wanna hit something better than 1.0 there. Only 11 points to go people! Buy some more guns!
They're even threatening 'pro-Trump' accounts.
https://www.bignewsnetwork.com/news/272308211/canada-threatens-to-freeze-pro-trump-bank-accounts
I have no idea what a "pro-Trump" bank account is. Is it any account that purchased a weekend at Mar-a-Lago?
They'll know it when they see it, my guess is by the number of commas. Commas are super pro-Trump.
I always knew the Oxford comma movement was a front for something. Now the truth can be told.
These accounts will be discovered by cross-reference to Republican voter registrations.
And this is in response to a protest that has resulted in zero arsons, zero assaults (aside from something that may not have involved any protestors but just happened to be in the same area) and isn't demanding anything from the government except a repealed regulation.
This protest is not seeking payouts. This protest is not seeking reparations. This protest is not seeking fundamental, constitutional changes to the government. This protest is not asking any elected official to resign. This protest wants, simply, to repeal a regulation from an executive health agency compelling certain behavior. This regulatory measure was not discussed in the House of Commons or in Parliament, to my knowledge, it was put in place by the Public Health Agency, an executive authority not directly accountable to voters.
And the response to this entirely peaceful protest is not negotiation. It's not to come out and meet openly with spokesperson. Their response is to attack, demonize, and then to utilize never-before-authorized emergency powers to remove their ability to live in society. This is Gulag-level shit, and it's happening in an open, ostensibly freedom-loving society.
Gulag level shit has been going on in Australia for a while now. The lack of a true Bill of Rights and strong federal system in the Commonwealth nations is really showing itself to be a problem.
This is scary shit.
Might be best for truckers to all quit, go on welfare, and allow the supply chain to turn to shit.
They would have been better off having a national strike, which they still can do. They need to take some lessons from the French. The French are masters at going on strike to fuck the government.
^^^This
The Parisians, aka the elite leadership, have always looked down on the rubes in the rest of France. But they also fear them, since les deplorables can get VERY serious about strikes.
Did the French ever have any other methods of dealing with tyrants that might be educational?
Yes, but then the outcomes tend to be even less desirable over the long term.
Yep walk away from your truck and say it was stolen.
It won't be a lie. The government is going to steal these trucks in the next week or so.
This isn't even a "mostly-peaceful" meme situation. This is an entirely peaceful protest. Unlike the BLM summer of love, this protest has overlapped with a significant REDUCTION in crime in the city-which you could argue might be due to the extreme cold, but it still doesn't indict the protestors. Propaganda is being whipped up, and it's largely successful, by a state-sponsored media organization to frame this protest as lawless and disgusting which is far from reality.
What's even more disturbing is the tacit encouragement that the US President is giving to this. If you're not condemning him, especially when the rights of Americans are being infringed by a close neighbor and ally, you're actually supporting his fascism. This is an embarrassment for the US as well.
I suspect most crooks are smart enough to know what would happen to a common street thug who tried a purse snatching followed by 'escaping' through this bunch of truckers.
"Nope officer, didn't see a thing. By the way, where is the dearest dumpster?"
What's even more disturbing is the tacit encouragement that the US President is giving to this.
Tacit? Shit, he's outright said that Trudeau needs to crush the protestors. I wouldn't be surprised if he's got the CIA and FVEY-level coordination going on with this.
I would be dollars to doughnuts that someone in the US intelligence community was behind the GoSendGo or whatever it is hack. No one did the little dweeb taking credit for it do that alone or at all.
The likelihood that fruitcake is a federal asset is pretty high.
I would agree. Somewhere near likelihood of Allison Gollust fucking her next boss.
Now you have to bet donuts to dollars.
Yeah, and that's a major problem. The issue for the US isn't that this could happen here. This actually is happening here, right now. It's a humiliation for the western hemisphere.
I fully agree. You never go full derp, and Trudeau has gone full derp.
Your line seems to be 99% derp then?
Were this happening in the US, Brandyfuck would be screaming from the rooftops to bring in the military and gun down every single protester. Just like he did with the "J6 Insurrection". He's a fascist piece of shit.
And to accuse a Jewish female MP (the granddaughter of Holocaust survivors) of supporting swastika wavers and refusing to apologize, in fact Trudeau said he stood by his comment and didn't even seek to clarify.
I don't want the Republicans to impeach Biden (at least not right off the bat) if they win the HoR. But I want to see a plethora of investigations to bring all this shit to light. So many investigations that the media can't ignore them.
They won’t ignore them, they’ll mock them like the hypocritical propagandists they are.
Probably, no matter what they uncover.
I have mixed feelings about Signal letting people send cryptocurrency--because I think it invites the government to crack down on Signal's encrypted communication protocols in the name of financial regulation. See what happened to Cody Wilson at Defense Distributed. Why attract that kind of attention to Signal? Anyway, they're not taking orders from me.
So, that being said, you can send no-Bitcoin nonsense, apparently anonymous cryptocurrency (MobileCoin) via Signal. Just go to the settings menu on your Signal app, and you'll see a "Payments" option in beta. That will let you send MobileCoin to other Signal users through Signal's top of the line encryption service.
When Signal has been subpoenaed in the past by the feds, court documents show they send the day your Signal account was created, the last your account was accessed, and that's it--because that's all they've got. They don't know which account belongs to whom or who is communicating with whom on their service. The keys are all stored locally--not on a server somewhere. Meanwhile, MobileCoin appears to be reasonably anonymous, too.
You can get the 411 on MobileCoin here:
"MobileCoin is a peer-to-peer cryptocurrency developed by MobileCoin Inc., which was founded in 2017 by Josh Goldbard and Shane Glynn.[3] It focuses on transactional anonymity (fungibility), ease of use, transaction speed, low environmental impact and low fees.[citation needed] MobileCoin's mechanics build on Stellar (for consensus) and Monero (for privacy), using CryptoNote alongside zero-knowledge proofs to hide details of users' transactions."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MobileCoin
Don't do anything illegal, and if you're not sure whether something is illegal, seek professional legal advice. I am not a lawyer.
P.S. Every libertarian should have Signal installed on their phone and be encouraging their friends and family to do likewise. The more common encrypted communication becomes, the harder it will be for the government to take our privacy away. And why should you want your innocent communications with your friends and family to be subject to surveillance?
I have signal, but knowing it was developed by the DoD, I'm nervous.
?!
I don't get it.
Signal is the successor of the RedPhone encrypted voice calling app and the TextSecure encrypted texting program. The beta versions of RedPhone and TextSecure were first launched in May 2010 by Whisper Systems,[51] a startup company co-founded by security researcher Moxie Marlinspike and roboticist Stuart Anderson.[52][53] Whisper Systems also produced a firewall and tools for encrypting other forms of data.[52][54] All of these were proprietary enterprise mobile security software and were only available for Android.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signal_(software)
It's open source, and it wasn't invented by the DoD.
And you are relying on Wikipedia?
They're a great place for links. If you want to see the sources for that article, click on links 51 through 54.
I've been following Signal for a long, long time, and I'm pretty familiar with their history and how the protocol works.
I'm trusting subpoenas being answered with no data--because they don't have access to any among other things.
I'm also relying on the open source nature of the software. Everybody and anybody that wants to look at the software can and lots of people have done so.
Do you have some reason to believe that the software was developed by the DoD or rats out users to the Feds?
Here's another example of what Signal gives in response to subpoenas:
"The response to the subpoena, in which the American Civil Liberties Union represents Signal, explains that the communication service was designed in such a manner that prevents it from tapping into users’ information or correspondence and that messages and calls are always encrypted and out of reach of third-parties.
“Users’ calls and messages are always encrypted, so they can never be shared or viewed by anyone except a user and their intended recipients. Likewise, Signal does not have access to its users’ profiles, group membership or group data, contacts, social graphs, searches, or the like,” the response reads.
"Thus, as response to the subpoena, Signal provided only the information it could deliver, namely the aforementioned timestamps."
----Security Week, November 21, 2021
https://www.securityweek.com/signal-provides-only-two-timestamps-response-grand-jury-subpoena
Signal gives them the timestamp showing when the account was created and a timestamp showing the last time that account was accessed.
That's all they've got!
They don't even know whose account belongs to whom. The feds need to open the app on the phone to give them an account to check.
Do you have some conflicting information?
At this point, I just assume the NSA has workarounds for pretty much everything out there, regardless of how secure it may seem to be.
There's no target server. No way for them to get the key. The key is on your phone. It's on your desktop. The FBI certainly isn't acting like they have access to anything on Signal. They keep subpoenaing Signal, getting nothing, and crying about how there needs to be a back door. They actually put out advertisements looking for people who could break this stuff. I haven't seen any indication that they've ever successfully obtained information from a Signal account, and I haven't seen any indication that it's even possible.
It won't be that way forever.
Meanwhile, if you want to send cryptocurrency to a Canadian, that may not even be against the law. The legal question may just be about how the Canadians use it once they get it on their phones. The answer may be that they use it through payment apps on their phones that are perfectly legal. Meanwhile, if you're using anything but Signal for privacy, you're using an inferior product. And people who use Facebook's WhatsApp for privacy should be ridiculed. I understand that people are skeptical of eternal anonymity, but all the evidence shows that Signal is the most secure thing out there--and the FBI can't seem to get what they want out of it.
Even if they could break in, it's an empty vault. You can set your messages to expire in seconds, as well, if you want. You can chat over video so that there is no record and see the person with whom you are communicating. There is no indication that the feds have the access to your communications on Signal and there are plenty of indications that they don't have access to your communications on Signal.
There is, actually, since Signal is not P2P. Your "encrypted" messages are held in a cluster on a server until they are delivered. That's why you're able to use Signal to message someone when they are offline. It's not very important anyway since cracking your messages while they're in transit is a waste of time and resources when they can simply read them once they've been decrypted on your compromised surveillance device that hosts the messaging software.
Don't worry, Ken's completely fucking technologically illiterate, but it never stops him from trying to be an evangelist for whatever meme software he's most recently decided to install. Signal has been a honeypot from the get to. You want secure communication? First off, stop using your smart phone for it. You can't have secure communications on an inherently insecure device. Man in the middle attacks haven't been the way to spy on messages in 20 years. They simply read the decrypted messages right on your security-compromised device. Install a P2P, E2EE messenger, on a computer, preferably not running Windows, and then you're in the ballpark of being able to communicate securely. Jami or Tox are your best options.
"Signal has been a honeypot from the get to."
Do you have a link for this, or are you just making this up?
Sounds like the Canadian government decided to start their own Operation Choke Point.
Just start your own bank!
That's how it works, right?
They can start by taking their money out of existing banks.
That wouldn’t cause trouble would it?
bUiLd y0ur oWn moNEtarY sYstEM.
thats what crypto was for, so much for that idea
The oligarchy is a private company.
This is so obviously inappropriate it's hard to believe they are going ahead. But it reveals the truth: leftists don't really believe in any of the mush they use to protect BLM and antifa. It's just shit they say. In reality they will do anything to maintain control and punish their enemies.
Hopefully it results in cutting their parliamentary representation by half.
It makes me think of Orwell's "Shooting an Elephant", where he slowly and inevitably feels himself being compelled to do something awful--even though he knows it at every step. In the end, there's really no substitute for Trudeau backing down except for more authoritarianism. Oppression doesn't breed peace--not even when you have the best of intentions. And it's been that way since forever.
Yes, there will be blowback at the next election.
Or maybe not. Is Canadian media even reporting on this?
Yeah, but they're entirely running cover for the government.
Basically, anyone who's not a neocon or a left-wing globalist shill has come out against it. Cripes, even Ihlan Omar is criticizing the donors having their livelihoods destroyed.
Omar is actually on the right side of something. It is stunning isn't it?
She apparently got fucked by her new boyfriend so hard that she flew straight to the right-wing end of the horseshoe.
Maybe good sex did something to her brain and caused it to start working.
When Ilhan Omar and Tucker Carlson agree that someone has fucked up, that person has fucked up.
The media is running for the government because the premier news source in Canada is CDC, which is run on government subsidies. It's state-sponsored media.
CBC.
Right right. Sorry, one acronym just comes more quickly to the reflexive typing.
Both push propaganda.
Omar sees a pretty straight line from today to the next BLM riot where they like to actually, you know, kill people and shit.
She'd be showing a hell of a lot more future-time orientation than she's ever displayed otherwise, if that's the case. Maybe Sinema's stubbornness in the face of all that shrieking over her refusal to nuke the filibuster left an impression.
I'll assume the state media is not terribly upset over it.
Only if absolutely delighted counts as upset.
there will be blowback at the next election.
"Next election"? That's optimistic.
These fucking banks. I left two messages and sent an email to BOA, asking to speak with someone regarding sharing of information with the government regarding 1/6. I was in DC on InSuRrEcTiOn DaY, visiting my father and did withdraw cash (can't remember if I was in DC or Bethesda), and wanted to know if any of my information had been given out. No response.
I made my reasons quite clear when I went in to close my accounts.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10517345/CNNs-exec-VP-CMO-Allison-Gollust-RESIGNS-relationship-former-President-Jeff-Zucker.html
In other news CNN canned Zucker's girlfriend. It is a tough break but I am sure she will land on her back somewhere.
I think she is kind of hot and the fact that she seems to have no standards with regard to the physical attractiveness of the men she will bang makes her even hotter.
She looks like the type of woman that does 'scream therapy' at home every night.
You say that like it is a bad thing. Crazy sexy is pretty sexy.
Jesus, who knows if any of these sexual assault allegations are true. But I can tell you one thing, that goddamned industry is packed to the rafters with snakes and reptiles and you deserve whatever you get by working in it.
She’s ok by leftist asshole standards (all that hate makes so many of them look like Emperor Palpatine). The low standards on physical attractiveness is directly inverse to how much money and power you might have, so no points there.
FREE RUFUS!!!!!
Just like so many of us who have studied history said they would. What I struggle with is how stupid you have to be to think the inevitable result of every socialist experiment is somehow going to end differently this time.
The secret police state has been ready to go for years. The rubber stamping of warrants deserves a response with violence. If you stand back when they arrest your neighbor for a political crime, you will deserve it when they load you onto the train.
"Why do you need a gun?"
"You. I need it because of you"
Any bets on whether Trudeau sold himself to the CCP? After all, Canada sold Vancouver to the Chinese, and used to sell citizenship--is that still a thing?
He's peddled his ass to Schwab, Soros and Pfizer for big money. I don't know why the CCP wouldn't get a turn.
Yes, it’s called EB5 visas, and every money laundering despot in the world can apply. That’s not to say every applicant is a despot. The truth is that world population sits at around 8 billion, I expect there are billions of people from around the world that would love to live in the US permanently.
In north Philly there are no go zones of squatters from Muslim counties (harems - no cops anywhere). The row homes are deteriorating crumbling and there’s no running water. It looks like Mogadishu.
I don’t know if the founders or libertarians thought of that number or scale of population.
Ottawa police chief resigned, btw.
Listen to this... LISTEN TO THIS!
Now, compare and contrast to BLM 2020 riots.
Now, imagine you're cheering on Trudeau because he invoked the War Measures Act for the first time in Canadian history because people were "having a party, ignoring by-laws and receiving fuel and supplies, including bouncy castles, barbeques and a hot tub."
You turn into this woman
https://twitter.com/libsoftiktok/status/1493078599611478020?cxt=HHwWiMCj-evEvbgpAAAA
At first I thought these videos like this were staged; that no one is really like that. No, they are not staged. It is a cult with these people.
When you say people are 'literal terrorists' that means you're aware of the lie you're telling.
The Canadian flag has been turned into a modern-day swastika. And she thinks somehow the truckers are responsible.
July 1st is going to trigger her to the point of an aneurism then.
Only if you don't understand that Webster's does not give give a shit about the preservation of the English language. Figuratively is now a synonym for their second definition of literally.
Definition of literally
2: in effect : VIRTUALLY —used in an exaggerated way to emphasize a statement or description that is not literally true or possible
will literally turn the world upside down to combat cruelty or injustice
— Norman Cousins
It is literally a crime against humanity.
Yeah, I hate it. A word can have multiple meanings, but a word's secondary definition should not be the ANTONYM of the word's primary definition. A word shouldn't mean both one thing and its opposite because that is beyond confusing.
Once we can get people to start using 'figuratively' to mean 'literally', the circle will be complete!
As if I needed more evidence that they have no credibility…
You notice her mask was around her chin? She doesn't believe they work either. Pay attention to what people do, not what they say.
To be fair, she's so fucking fat that it won't even fit on her bloated face properly.
Ugh and barf.
I mean, it's no orgy of rape and arson like Summer of Love '20 was...
Damn! Trudeau just gave the Biden administration some great ideas on cracking down on those evil white supremacists. You simply have to find out who contributes to conservative causes or candidates(leftist hackers will happily provide those lists if the NSA is too busy), seize their bank accounts, revoke their professional licenses, and everyone will suddenly comply with government dictates. Coming soon to a banking institution near you (any free toasters or whatever they are giving away these days for opening an account will also have to be returned). Isn't fascism great!
This is absolutely a dry run for what the Davos crowd have planned for America. Canada's always been a sandbox for anything ultimately aimed at the US.
Get ready, because they're going to pull something before midterms.
“What are elections?” The kindergartners asked.
“Oh, just an antiquated idea that mean old white supremacist used to disenfranchise minorities and keep the government from fulfilling its purpose.” The teacher answered before the child was picked up to be taken for advanced education on why we don’t ask questions.
"Our gentle neighbor to the North rushes toward grim authoritarianism."
Ooh, so grim. Things there are very dire. But we're all good down here south of the border where proud Americans love their strongman. Did you hear, the strong orange strongman is still actually president? He and Biden traded faces last year and Biden's face is on Trump's body. Biden was arrested long ago and has been languishing in Fort Leavenworth under ultra-heavy guard, being fed thin gruel and stale bread crusts. I read it on 4chan, which I love nearly as much as Tucker Carlson and Infowars.
#resist called, they want you back to 2016.
Seek help, your obsession with Donald Trump is unhealthy.
It's so funny watching your side failing to find actual authoritarian behavior from the right, and when confronted with actual fascism by the left (this is the literal defining characteristic of fascism, coordination between state and private business to punish political enemies of the state) you instead try to deflect the blame back on the right.
LOL You have to be a special kind of stupid to think only one side wants authoritarian power. If you only see examples of this from one side and not both you really hate freedom and America.
Goddamn the left is so shit at this.
What's also scary is how popular this is among the left on the internet. The posts about this on reddit have thousands of likes
He didn't do this in a vacuum. He knew he had the support of his base when he did this.
The damndest part is that this is a workers revolt over bodily autonomy. The two touchstones of left-wing ideology since forever. They know that the accusations of racism and bigotry are absolute bullshit, so you'd think that they'd have jumped to the front of the parade.
But they didn't. Instead they went mental.
They were already mental (see the last two years). This just put lie to the idea that they ever cared about civil liberties or freedom.
I think every 'voting' social media site is flooded with votebots.
Trudeau will enjoy his ride for now, I suspect changes are coming for him. I hope he can get a job doing something else.
I wish I could believe that. I think he and his side will succeed in their authoritarian coup and he'll spend the rest of his life in his real Daddy's family business.
In places where it's possible, maybe western Canada, or go around posting pictures and names of bank employees, fight back by denying services to bank employees. Refuse service at gas stations. Refuse service at grocery stores, etc. Do it anywhere you can.
I love that idea. Surprised I haven't seen it anywhere else.
Bank executives. Not employees. Posting pictures of employees would be very, very wrong.
They've chosen which side they're on.
If anyone still remembers back to January 2020... a huge number of folks in the US saw this handwriting on the wall. Their first priority was to procure firearms and ammunition. It was actually pretty scary, watching people with absolutely no training -- young but "straight-laced" types -- paw the few remaining handguns at the sporting goods store while in the ammunition aisles, the most common round calibers were nowhere to be found. The reality is that when you take away someone's ability to live, but appropriating their savings - which is the economic proxy measure of their life's sacrifice - you are taking away their life. To someone who sees an opportunity to smash down the undeserving to the level of the previously oppressed, this is basically what BLM would claim has been done to the black community - banks refusing to do business with them because of bad credit history; inability to find gainful work due to past criminal convictions. But in Trudeau's mind, in a perverse way, the existence of those wrongs makes his actions seem reasonable. And in that construct of a false equity, where law and property rights are not things that can be counted on, there is one final bastion of certainty, and that is the authority of power and lethal force. In the end, if Trudeau continues to play his cards this way, he will find the guillotine being put up for him as its the guest of of honor. One would hope on the orders of the Supreme Court rather than on the order of a citizens' court.
The story behind the “Nazi Flag” at the trucker demonstration
https://youtu.be/fCJHgrYa_NY
Reason finally finds its balls when people get unpersoned and denied critical infrastructure services because of politics. Hey Brian, did you know that's been going on right here in the land of the free for the last fucking decade?
There is little difference in governments around the world.
And the little weasel has a point. It is a bit rich for them to fire him for "failing to meet company standards" but then allow the CEO to be banging the chief PR flack.
This story isn't to the level of attacking criticism of the cleanest election ever.
Thank you. Worse shit than this has been going on in Australia for 2 fucking years and Reason barely noticed. Instead we got ENB whining about arsonists being taken away in unmarked white vans and daily covid porn from Ron Bailey. Suddenly, right after the Democrats started to back off of their covid tyranny, it's OK for Reason to actually report on this shit. I appreciate the information in this article but yeah too little to late. Silence is consent and Reason consented for 2 years.
Based off this timeline I guess we’ll get the Durham story in just another couple weeks.
It's good to see this article, but yeah, too little - too late.
He's able to do that in this particular case because it's in Canada and therefore has no personal or professional consequences for him. He's literally been cheering this behavior loudly and proudly when it has been taking place in the United States for the last 10 years.
I am always surprised that his firing was portrayed as "didn't disclose the relationship". That is about as disingenuous as "undocumented immigrant". The problem isn't that they failed to file some paperwork. The problem is that as soon as that paperwork hit their desk, HR would have said "HELL NO!" There is no way a big corporation like that would allow a romantic relationship between two people in a reporting chain. One of them would have been forced to move to a different part of the company. Which, fortunately, AT&T is a big place, so HR could have certainly facilitated a move into a roughly comparable position for one of them. But, it would have been inconvenient and disruptive to their careers, which is likely why they didn't tell HR.
Don't forget about the kiddie fiddler on the payroll on his watch. Tobin was embarrassing but at least it was legal behavior.
Well they updated those guidelines just in time.
Something like 90% of the truckers are supposedly vaccinated.
Durham who? /s
We may not. It has been officially denied, man, therefore it's just "a Trumpian fantasy, hallucinating that Hilary Clinton would be involved in something that is borderline unethical. /WaPo
Especially when you consider that this may be the biggest story in the Western Hemisphere since COVID lockdowns started. A liberal democracy instituted War Powers to stop a peaceful protest. No rioting, no property damage, and there's been no attempts from government leadership at reconciliation, they went straight to jackboots.
It's insane. And literally every news outlet should be covering this nonstop. It's not a throw-away story.
That fat fuck looks like just the type of beta cuck that would dox you for pointing out that he is a disgrace to journalism, an authoritarian of the highest order and a garbage human.
"Suddenly, right after the Democrats started to back off of their covid tyranny, it's OK for Reason to actually report on this shit. "
Seems their guiding principle isnt individual liberty but ensuring they dont stray far enough away from the given media narrative to get uninvited to cocktail parties and media appearances. Welchy boy likes his regular spot on Maher.
It's true this man has no dick.