Business and Industry

Pandemic-Slammed Small Businesses Require Regulatory Relief

Entrepreneurs discouraged by red tape even before COVID-19 need officials to leave them alone.

|

With the economy taking it in the teeth from mandatory social distancing and restrictions on "non-essential" businesses, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) worries that small firms may be unable to step into their traditional roles as drivers of economic recovery and growth. While a recent surge in applications for employer identification numbers may be a positive sign, it also may indicate failed businesses changing hands rather than a reversal of four decades of declining entrepreneurship. And while the CBO dances around the role that government plays in discouraging start-ups, other sources are clear that regulatory reform is needed if small businesses are to exit the endangered species list and return to creating jobs and rebuilding prosperity.

"Several measures of entrepreneurship have declined since the early 1980s," the CBO notes in a report published last week. "During that period, new firms' share of employment fell by a third, from 14 percent to 9 percent."

That's important because entrepreneurs allocate resources more efficiently than established firms, introduce new products, and boost economic activity. "The decline in entrepreneurship is associated with a falloff in labor productivity from at least 3 percent to 4 percent in the mid-2010s," the CBO estimates.

Unfortunately, small businesses that have launched are being devastated by pandemic lockdowns that limit or eliminate their ability to serve customers. "The economic contraction that initially chilled the formation of firms at the beginning of the pandemic also threatened the viability of businesses started in the past few years… from mid-February to late April, employment fell among them by more than it did among large firms," according to the report.

Before the latest round of restrictions, Yelp, the review service, reported that business conditions had improved since the early days of the pandemic, but that "in the wake of COVID-19 cases increasing and local restrictions continuing to change in many states we're seeing both permanent and temporary closures rise across the nation, with 60% of those closed businesses not reopening."

If you suspect that an environment like this is a morale-killer for entrepreneurs, you're right. Last month, Gallup reported its latest survey of small business optimism across multiple dimensions:

While up slightly from a score of 60 in the third quarter, the current Small Business Index score of 72 remains dramatically lower than the pre-pandemic high of 142 a year ago… signifying continued concern on the part of small-business owners about what they are seeing day to day.

As mentioned, even before COVID-19 and draconian public health reactions hit the scene, entrepreneurship was on the decline. The CBO report reviews several factors that impede business creation, including relatively vague references to financing constraints, economic conditions, and demographic trends. It also acknowledges that "an increasingly burdensome regulatory regime is often cited as a factor in the decline in new businesses" but insists "the available evidence is not clear" about the impact of red tape on small businesses.

Business owners themselves are more certain about the barriers posed by burdensome regulations. Pre-pandemic, entrepreneurs told the National Federation of Independent Business's 2016 Small Business Problems and Priorities survey that they placed "unreasonable government regulations" as their second concern, after the cost of health insurance (which itself is made much more expensive by government regulation). Amidst the chaos of the pandemic, regulatory concerns continue to rank in the top ten in the 2020 survey, with tax concerns taking four other slots and "uncertainty over government actions" yet another.

Likewise, National Small Business Association (NSBA) President and CEO Todd McCracken warned in 2017 that "the average small-business owner is spending at least $12,000 every year dealing with regulations. This has real-world implications: more than half of small businesses have held off on hiring a new employee due to regulatory burdens." In the NSBA's 2017 Small Business Regulations Survey, 58 percent of small business owners said federal rules were the most burdensome to their business, with a specific emphasis on the tax code and the Affordable Care Act.

Small business owners have every reason to especially resent red tape. "As of 2008, small businesses face an annual regulatory cost of $10,585 per employee, which is 36 percent higher than the regulatory cost facing large firms," according to a 2010 study published by the U.S. Small Business Administration (the higher NSBA estimate of compliance costs came almost a decade later).

Not surprisingly, small business trade groups support regulatory reform. "Congress and the administration must step in and curtail costly regulations, particularly those that disproportionately affect small businesses," insists the NFIB. The NSBA emphasizes "the need to greatly reduce regulatory complexity, streamline the web of federal, state and local regulations, and adhere to plain language statutes"

The Kauffman Foundation, which studies and encourages entrepreneurship, agrees in its Guidelines for Local and State Governments to Promote Entrepreneurship that, among other approaches, governments must "revisit the regulatory environment." Specifically, Kauffman recommends that governments consider alternatives to occupational licensing, simplify tax codes, rewrite laws regarding non-compete agreements, streamline zoning, and ease the way for new immigrants.

Despite much hemming and hawing, the CBO comes to similar conclusions. After lengthy discussion of expanded federal financial support, and some chatter about (newly popular in political circles) antitrust rules, the report concedes that "Congress could further lighten the burden of federal regulations on entrepreneurship by expanding the requirements for federal agencies to limit the impact of regulations on small firms."

The CBO also points to the state-level push to reclassify independent contractors as employees as a threat to gig work. "Those changes raised the cost of employing such workers and limited their ability to work flexible hours or part time—a hallmark of the gig economy."

That said, after a sharp initial drop during the early days of the pandemic, there has been a resurgence in applications to the Internal Revenue Service for employer identification numbers. That might be good news indicating a revival of entrepreneurialism as people seek new opportunities in an economy that has seen so many thrown out of work. But, as the CBO points out, the applications could instead indicate bankrupt businesses are just changing hands or represent fraudulent attempts to secure pandemic-related disaster-relief money. Honestly, it's probably a combination of all of the above as people scramble to survive a difficult environment.

But governments could make that environment less difficult. After a year in which officials ordered businesses closed and reopened, and then shifted rules in ways that almost seem designed to impose costs on struggling entrepreneurs, there's one obvious thing they could do to make life easier for small firms: they could get out of the way.

NEXT: Trump's Conversation With Georgia Election Officials Shows His Conviction That He Won Is Impervious to Evidence

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. “Unfortunately, small businesses that have launched are being devastated by pandemic lockdowns that limit or eliminate their ability to serve customers…
    Business owners themselves are more certain about the barriers posed by burdensome regulations. Pre-pandemic, entrepreneurs told the National Federation of Independent Business’s 2016 Small Business Problems and Priorities survey that they placed “unreasonable government regulations” as their second concern, after the cost of health insurance (which itself is made much more expensive by government regulation).”

    I’m confused, this all sounds vaguely libertarian. Where are the odes to woke that my Reason is famous for.

    1. Let’s see how the fawn over SleepyJoe and his new regulatory and taxing campaign of terror .

      1. [ PART TIME JOB FOR USA ] Making money online more than 15$ just by doing simple work from home. I have received $18376 last month. Its an easy and simple job to do and its earnings are much better than regular office job and even a little child can do this and earns money. Everybody must try this job by just use the info
        on this page…..work92/7 online

  2. Why wasn’t this article written/published before the election?

    Reason demonized Trump after he eliminated, reduced and/or delayed more costly federal regulations than any president in US history, while Reason campaigned for Biden, who has enacted and advocated even more costly and economically disastrous regulations (including a 100 day mask wearing mandate even for people who remain in their own homes).

    1. Biden also advocated the unconstitutional, unscientific and economically disastrous lockdowns that Tuccille now correctly bemoans.

      1. Get $192 hourly from Google!…Yes this is Authentic since I just got my first payout of $244567 and this was just of a single week… I have QAf also bought my Range Rover Velar right after this payout…It is really cool job I have ever had and you won’t forgive yourself if you do not check it… =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= USA ONLINE JOBS

    2. Mr. Anderson, that is the sound of the Status Quo returning…

  3. “Specifically, Kauffman recommends that governments consider alternatives to occupational licensing, simplify tax codes, rewrite laws regarding non-compete agreements, streamline zoning, and ease the way for new immigrants.

    I bolded the most important part.

    Drumpf’s draconian anti-immigration policies have been the most burdensome regulations affecting American businesses over the past 4 years. Indeed, Reason.com’s benefactor Charles Koch lost over $5 billion in 2020, largely because Koch Industries hasn’t had access to the unlimited influx of highly-skilled labor (especially from Mexico) it needs to thrive.

    That will of course change once Biden is inaugurated. You’ll quickly realize why billionaires, Wall Street, and Reason writers overwhelmingly backed his candidacy.

    #GetReadyForTheKochComeback
    #InDefenseOfBillionaires

    1. That will of course change once Biden is inaugurated.
      DAY ONE!

  4. After a year in which officials ordered businesses closed and reopened, and then shifted rules in ways that almost seem designed to impose costs on struggling entrepreneurs

    Yes, and? Closing small business competition was the point. Only large (donor) businesses will remain.

    Never let a crisis go to waste.

    1. Indeed. While I am not normally supportive of government giving money to people, people are massively in debt SOLELY due to government actions.

  5. This is exactly why Trump, despite his weaknesses, was better for the country. As bad as it is in a few US states that are run by the Control-Left, the country overall has been preserved by the government having simply not destroyed it. Small business doesn’t need a government program. It needs the absence of government programs.

    1. Small businesses need the steady hand and wise guidance of SleepyJoe, who has never run a business.

      1. You can check the background of any SF elected official and find absolutely none has ever held a job from which you can be fired.

  6. check this out Buzz News Post you are going to enjoy this

  7. share this Buzz News Post with everyonee.

  8. latest news and press las vegas updates are given here.

  9. see this Las Vegas News and update this thing in your life.

  10. hello United News Post everyone.how r u all?

  11. hello everyone
    United News Post
    check this out
    share this

  12. hi
    star news express,
    enjoy this content
    which i am providing to u all

  13. great news
    star news express,
    great day,new begginig
    new journey

  14. My state won’t allow a small business to caulk or paint a window sill (using non-toxic, non-lead paint) without working for a competitor for 2 years. Ironically my state brags about being a “Right to Work State” – just not for small business!

    Removing those non-competitive Occupational Licensing laws (that harm consumer choice) sure would help the Covid unemployed.

    1. Along with hurting consumers, occupational licensing laws have been shown to hinder job access among poorer people, who are less able to afford the specific training needed to get licensed. In certain jobs it’s conceivable that you would grant a license to ensure that someone incompetent isn’t doing something dangerous, but in many fields that could be done with a day-long test in which the person is observed doing tasks associated with the job and/or an employer-supervised apprenticeship.

  15. The author left out the job killing capital destroying inequality generating welfare increasing Stimulus Proposals that do nothing except stimulate the Business Cycle and make people poorer in the process.

  16. Regulatory relief, sure. Bailouts? Why not just let people go back to work?

    1. How about all of the debt they’ve been forced to accumulate over the last year due to government policies?

  17. What they need and what all governments will deliver are not going to be anywhere close to congruent.

  18. “other sources are clear that regulatory reform”

    In other words regulation that has been reformed but still regulation is needed.

  19. I can tell that many people now have issues with recruiting a competent business solution manager from Salesforce. I already know it for my own sake. It is good also that my friends supported me and told me where I could go for assistance. It helped me to contact professionals about the hourly rate of the https://www.ergonized.com/case-studies/payne-auto-group/ , I could learn a lot for myself and I know what to expect from these people. I hope that good luck and success will also be beneficial for you all!

  20. Yes, I agree with you in this pandemic there are a lot of problems are faced by small businessmen. I am also a businessman and doing Import Export Business Plan with the help of OGS capital site and the plans of this site are saved me in this pandemic.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.