Guvmint Is Not Done Screwing Over Flint Water Victims Yet
Victims can't sue government, that's the other crime

The Flint water mess is wholly and solely a government creation, as I have noted before. But innocent taxpayers— federal and state—are on the hook to pay for the cleanup. President Obama has announced an $85 million "relief" package for Flint victims and is also considering handing everyone under 21 years free Medicaid (arguably a fate worse than drinking poisoned water itself!). Snyder himself has arranged for $28 million in state aid.
All of this sounds like a lot of money, but it is actually a pittance compared not just to what Flint residents are in for but also what General Motors and Toyota have paid their crash victims, I point out in my morning column at The Week.
The main reason why Flint residents won't get more is that, unlike private companies, they can't sue the government, thanks to the doctrine of sovereign immunity, which protects government from tort lawsuits. In fact, prestigious law firms that are representing victims of the recent California gas leak in a class action lawsuit against Southern California Gas Co., owned by the non-governmental Sempra Energy, are so far declining to help Flint victims because the odds that they will succeed against the government are low to zero.
"Scrapping or at least circumscribing sovereign immunity may be worth considering although that isn't a great answer because it will only expose taxpayers to liability for snafus they have not committed," I note.
The real answer, however, is privatization, getting the government out of the business of running utilities completely. But that will of course give lefto-liberals like Castro lover Michael Moore a coronary—which would be reason alone to go for it.
Go here to read the whole piece.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Why not just hold government employees personally liable for what they do?
Go on, tell us another.
Putting cameras on cops will prevent abuse.
Government is just another word for things we choose to do together.
dammit
"The Flint water mess is... a government creation. But, innocent taxpayers... are on the hook to pay for the cleanup."
'Government is simply the name we give to the things we choose to do together.'
Government is simply the name we give to the things we do to each other.
And sometimes to other psuedo-random people on the other side of the world.
Like sterilize women as an imbecile for having a child out of wedlock?
Only when it's the child of her rich employer's son.
Well, sure, as long as they're Rethuglikkkans! That's why it's fine to demand Snyder's resignation, but the mayor of Flint can keep his job.
Ha! If they could hold them responsible for contaminated water, DC would have been partitioned off into small parcels years ago.
Obama said that people shouldn't be upset with government because government is us, so the people of Flint poisoned themselves.
"Now poison yourself! Not with your water, numb nuts! With my water!"
+1 Sgt. Hartman
Lead poisoning: you did build THAT.
Nice, Woodie, nice.
Look,with out government there'd be no water in Michigan at all!!!! None for hundreds ,maybe thousands of miles. You want that? As a Buckeye,I say ,yes.
No water for miles and miles and miles.... Ya, just like Michigan surrounded by fresh water lakes. That's what happens when you start a war with Ohio and lose Toledo, Oh wait, no...its what happens when you let governments decide things for you.
"prestigious law firms that are representing victims of the recent California gas leak i"
Facepalm.
I just drove by there yesterday. The firms involved in that are shitty lowest tier law school grads begging for crumbs. The bottom of the bottom of the barrel.
The difference between a attorney and a catfish? One's a bottom feeding scum sucker and one's a fish.
That reminds me: fish tacos are the special at the hospital cafe today!
Arizona fish. My favorite.
They were good, as always.
Plus, they are working up some new salsa recipes. They've got a green chile & tomatillo that is first rate.
I'd like to see student loans incorporated into a few lawyer jokes.
What's the difference between a lawyer and a failed energy company?
One took on massive debt based on a fraudulently over-represented promise of income, and the other was Enron.
Immunity from personal responsibility is that higher standard I keep hearing about.
Im making over $7k a month working part time. I kept hearing other people tell me how much money they can make online so I decided to look into it. Well, it was all true and has totally changed my life. This is what I do,
...................... http://www.richi8.com
Can individual bureaucrats be sued for incompetence that leads to harm? Is that the same as suing the "government?" Serious question.
Only individuals of corporations should be held criminally liable, not noble public servants!
Yes, it is.
By, there will be accountability.
In the next election, this'll choose another governor.
This will ruin Snyder's life.
Pols hate it when that happens. Therefore, this water stuff that happened? That will never happen.
See? The system works.
Its really unfair to Michigan. They have Detroit, the burbs and the rest of the state. At least they have an emergency plan for screwed up cities. Democratic(small d) or not. New York has NYC and a lot of shit holes and no way to help any of them but to bleed NYC, which is already bleeding, We see a lot of articles on Michigan and the emergency Managers, but who else is even trying to solve these problems?
Stop blaming people trying to find solutions. I am talking to you Michael Moore! And start blaming the asses that created the problems.