Georgia Cop Who Killed Unarmed, Naked Vet Indicted for Murder by Grand Jury
Will face trial on six charges.


Atlanta area police officer Robert Olsen fatally shot and killed Anthony Hill, 27, in March 2015 when responding to a call about a man behaving erratically. That was Hill, who was unarmed and naked, and his family said he struggled with mental health issues and post-traumatic stress disorder. He was an Air Force veteran who served in Afghanistan. The officer claimed the shooting was in self-defense.
Today a grand jury indicted Olsen for several charges in Hill's death, including felony murder, aggravated assault, and violation of oath of office. All in all he faced six charges and the grand jury indicted him for each charge.
WXIA, the NBC affiliate in Atlanta, provides some interesting details about the special treatment officers get from grand juries:
Officer Olsen has the right, under Georgia law, to sit in the Grand Jury room and hear all of the evidence and testimony against him and then, under oath, make a statement. The district attorney is not allowed to say anything in response. The officer gets the last word before the Grand Jury deliberates.
And partly as a result, Grand Juries in Georgia usually side with the police officers. Police officers in Georgia are almost never prosecuted.
Out of 51 police-involved shootings that the Georgia Bureau of Investigation has investigated in the past 10 years, only one case has ever made it to trial.
Read more about the case here as well.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Air Force? Then where does the PTSD come from?
Prolly convoy duty. I certainly wouldn't want to drive around for hours wondering when my rig might blow up underneath me.
He could have been a TAC-P, SF, combat controller, etc.
If not, I can only point to my own experience of not being in a combat AFSC, but enduring several months worth of being shot at day and night, and seeing some people get killed. At least the Army got to shoot back. (Maybe that's a reason a did blue to green!).
I don't have PTSD or anything, but it wasn't a great time.
Plenty of time for the prosecutors to throw the game
The officer gets the last word before the Grand Jury deliberates.
Reminding the members that he has a good memory for faces?
It's a wonder they don't let all his cop buddies in the room as well.
"Out of 51 police-involved shootings that the Georgia Bureau of Investigation has investigated in the past 10 years, only one case has ever made it to trial."
OK, but let's be clear
who is to blame:
"through an open records request, 11Alive was able to study 51 fatal shootings in metro Atlanta investigated by the GBI in the past 10 years. Of those, only eight have gone before a grand jury."
Georgia's law doesn't just protect cops from the grand jury, it protects other public officials, too.
From p 30 of this grand jury manual:
"Although generally the accused has no right to appear before the Grand Jury, Georgia law requires that special procedures be followed when the Grand Jury is considering indicting some current and former public officials or peace officers. These procedures do not apply to all crimes committed that might be committed by an official or officer but only those specifically designated by statute. The courts have held that these procedures are based on the belief of the legislature that "... the smooth, uninterrupted functioning of government, so important to the public welfare, may be endangered by requiring high public officials to endure a time consuming trial ... (on) an unfounded indictment.""
Oops, I should have warned you to put on one of these before reading that passage.
Oops, try p. 14 of this document:
http://www.stephenscountyga.com/documents/clerk of superior court/grandjury.pdf
One more time
Oh, never mind.
I'm summoning you to the Grand Jury to explain your bad linking!
Try the Stephens county, Georgia Web site and poke around a little.
Nah, not really.
I mean, only if you're *really* interested.
This happened in DeKalb County, not Stephens County.
(Stephens County? That's four counties away!)
It's a summary of a state statute - you found similar language in a statewide document.
It doesn't make Stephens County any less boonies.
Stephens County is where the cop got away with murdering the Baptist preacher, Pastor Ayers.
DeKalb County is where I pay taxes.
McKinney territory!
Page 26?
Yes, you found it! Thank you.
Or this?
It didn't work for me 🙁
I can barely stuff these message down the tube of the Internet, I guess I bumped up against the limits of my competence.
Thou shalt learn thy a tag and its href attribute or thou shalt SugarFree they links forever.
Forsooth, it usually doth worketh.
SugarFree wouldn't like the idea that he and I have anything in common.
(I don't think he likes me)
Unpossible, Eddie, everybody likes you.
I like you. Sometimes, most of the times, you're annoying as shit. But that is what makes eightchandarrr so much fun. I guess I like steel cage death match of the reason comments section.
I like you. There's absolutely no way I'm discussing religion with you, but I like you just fine.
You guys are like the crazy uncles I never had!
/wipes away tear
some current and former public officials
Former? Amazing.
For crimes committed back when they were public officials, not for crimes committed after retirement.
I see. It was bad enough for current officials, but at least they could somehow justify it or defend it.
"No State shall enter into any Treaty, Alliance, or Confederation; grant Letters of Marque
and Reprisal; coin Money; emit Bills of Credit; make any Thing but gold and silver Coin
a Tender in Payment of Debts; pass any Bill of Attainder, ex post facto Law, or Law
impairing the Obligation of Contracts, or grant any Title of Nobility." (emphasis added)
The problem is, who has standing to sue Georgia for granting de facto Titles of Nobility to certain "current and former public officials or peace officers"?
The cop thought he might've had a secret gun jammed up his ass. Good shoot, IMO. This calls for a re-hiring with back pay (including overtime, of course).
Not happy with indictments anymore when they'll just lead to acquittals anyways.
You're hired!
/GBI
I'm already making a serious dent in my snowpocalypse beverage stash. Current forecasts have the Hell unleashing around 10 AM. Too bad all the liquor stores in this carpetbagger and scallywag-run state are owned by the government. They'll take a "snow day " just like they were teachers.
Just when they're needed most.
Fuck me. Right before this incapacitating blizzard some piece of shit broke into our house. They stole about $700 cash, the comforter off our bed, and ... nothing else. They busted up the lock on the back door pretty good. FUCK THIS! 2016 SUCKS right out of the gate. I'm so fucking pissed off about it. I want to crack this motherfucker's skull. Goddam. I want 2016 over with right now.
Who's on the list of suspects?
was the ca$h in plain view? Inside job?
Juice, I've had two break-in/thefts. What pissed me off more than anything is reaching for X a month later and seeing it is no longer where is was.
I hope they got the cash and the comforter and NOTHING else, so it doesn't continue to ruin your day for months.
Sorry to hear about it, too.
Did they use your toothbrush?
Naah. That was in my kit when I returned home.
OMG CHECK YOUR CAMERA!!!!1!1!
The adventures of Florida Man, OR, hold my beer and watch this
It can't beat Hold My Beer.
The special treatment accused cops get, as outlined in the post, is appalling.
Why are people who are supposedly professional, who get training and practice dealing with danger, held to a lower standard than the general public, and treated with such deference? Cops are held to much, much lower standards than actual Soldiers in real combat.
That's strange, he doesn't look like a ham sandwich.