America is Closer to Levels of "European" Spending Than the GOP Would Like to Admit
The GOP has released its 2012 platform, and it has some rather interesting suggestions relating to spending and the supposed crystal ball that is the euro crisis.
Unsurprisingly, the GOP has made a push to emphasize the state of the economy, and the platform warns early on of the perils of overspending and what the future looks like without reform:
Unless we take dramatic action now, young Americans and their children will inherit an unprecedented legacy of enormous and unsustainable debt, with the interest alone consuming an ever-increasing portion of the country's wealth. The specter of national bankruptcy that now hangs over much of Europe is a warning to us as well.
American politicians and policy makers have been talking about the threat of "European Socialism" for a while, and recently Mitt Romney made a jab at the President while on his memorable foreign excursion, saying:
If we keep going down the path we're on, we're gonna end up like Europe or worse. It's time to have leadership that will put aside Republican and par-- and-- and Democrat, and instead focus on what's necessary for the nation. I'm willing to do that. I think others in Washington have recognized the need to do that. I see hopeful signs we're gonna finally get America on track again.
Not sure exactly what Mitt meant by "Europe", but America has been enjoying levels of public debt similar to many European nations for some time. The Economist's debt clock (last updated this month) has the U.S. and Spain enjoying equal levels of public debt as percent of GDP (71.9 percent). The last year the U.S. had a lower public debt as percent of GDP figure than Spain was 2007.
It is important to mention that Spain did not get itself into its current troubles by spending like the Greeks and Italians. Spain had a huge property bubble that popped causing a series of events that looks almost certain to result in the latest European sovereign bailout.
It is true that many European countries have spent irresponsibly and are causing many in the rest of Europe to pay for their mistakes. That said, many American politicians would be happy to see America with debt figures like those of the Netherlands, Luxemburg, or the Czech Republic.
In the coming months we will almost certainly hear the Republicans speak more about the dangers of overspending as the euro-crisis worsens. What is important is to remember that a continent of almost fifty countries, hundreds of languages, and hundreds of millions of people is not bound by a single economic or political policy. Maybe when politicians begin to realise this we can start asking them exactly what they mean by "Europe" or "European socialism".
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
and recently Mitt Romney made a jab at the President while on his memorable foreign excursion
I forgot about that.
Third system, here we come!
Progressives: We will put the miracle in chimerical.
Video from the Third System future!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gdv5EtZQ6jg
Hey, it worked for Greece. Wait, no it didn't.
I just don't understand why anyone worships at the altar of John Maynard Keynes.
It is precisely because the US engaged in more Keynesian action than Europe that the US is actually doing better in terms of joblessness--and we'd have less of a debt problem if it were confined merely to the effects of the recession and not mostly caused by reckless tax cuts at the same time of trillions of dollars in extra spending on wars and other things.
Because everyone knows how jacking up government spending helps with sovereign debt crises every. single. time.
Money is wealth and wealth is money!
Government has the power to print money, which means it can create wealth!
The more money the government prints, the wealthier we all are!
It's this sort of thinking that has made Zimbabwe the economic powerhouse that it is today.
Come on! We all know that Zimbabwe's economy failed because of insufficient stimulus!
The current lousy US jobless numbers are the same as excellent jobless numbers in most of western europe during good years. The unemployment rate in France in 2004 was 10.1%! The differences are structural in nature (labor market rules, very cushy welfare state, free or near free education, etc.) and have pretty much nothing to do with Keynesian action or non-action.
I think you just got your answer, FIFY.
You expect most economists to admit that they really don't know anything and that the economy can't really be managed? Ha! Good luck with that one.