The Best of Reason: Government Can't Fix America's Baby Bust
The obstacles to having more babies can't be moved by tax incentives or subsidized child care.

This week's featured article is "Government Can't Fix America's Baby Bust" by Elizabeth Nolan Brown.
This audio was generated using AI trained on the voice of Katherine Mangu-Ward.
Music credits: "Deep in Thought" by CTRL and "Sunsettling" by Man with Roses
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Seriously? You don’t think if government stopped leaning on people so hard it wouldn’t make a difference, miss AI?
The government could fix the baby bust on Nov. 6th, just not with subsidies and tax incentives practically designed to support the Bootleggers and Baptists, Feminists and Patriarchy, “Vote for me, I’m the guy/gal who isn’t part of the evil patriarchy that expects you to be in control of your own actions. The other guy has binders full of women and thinks abortion should be returned to the States.” status quo…
On Nov. 6th every military-age male and any female who isn’t pregnant or would otherwise fit under the FMLA gets conscripted to go to Ukraine, Gaza, Taiwan, the Korean DMZ… take your pick.
It would be like a Handmaid’s Tale with men getting dropped into a meat grinder in the background while women (continue to) exploit each other non-sexually reproductively except, you know, a good thing… because vaginas.
Capitalism is the answer of course. We must prohibit government coercion.
Capitalism is what gave us this low birth rate. Three cheers for capitalism!
I feel like I’ve read and replied to this already. Like I’m repeating myself.
Well, anyway – here’s the solution:
1) Eliminate no-fault divorce.
2) Eliminate abortion and contraception.
3) Eliminate social services eligibility for families with children born out of wedlock.
4) Eliminate EMTALA eligibility (and all other social services) for illegal aliens.
5) Dismantle the institutions that promote second- and third-wave feminism and LGBTpedo ideology at a social/cultural level, eliminate all civil policies based upon them, deprogram its victims, and jail its leaders.
6) Take whatever large-scale economic reforms (which will largely be tax/regulation related) necessary to lower the cost of living and home ownership.
There. All those are intentionally frustrating the forming and developing of happy, healthy, prosperous families. Fix those, and you’ll bring the birth rates back up.
Yeah, just as stupid as before.
1 is slavery.
2 is your religion and none of government’s business.
3 is none of the government’s business.
3-6 are too stupidly piecemeal. Just get government out of the charity business and LEAVE PEOPLE ALONE.
How is #1 slavery?
How is #2 anything related to religion?
How is #3 NOT the government’s business? It’s your and my money they’re handing out to these broken homes, facilitating nothing but MORE broken homes and MORE handouts.
#3-6 are going to necessitate intervention. It’s that simple. Social services and EMTALA? I can’t believe you’re defending either. Promoting the socially destructive religions – at a State level, I might add – of feminism and LGBTPedo? How do you even call yourself a libertarian? What, you DON’T want economic/regulatory reform to give more buying/selling power to the people?
Tell me you’re a Marxist without telling me you’re a Marxist.
No one wants to live in your theocracy you stupid goddamn hick.
Language.
It’s not a theocracy. I’ve not asserted a single religious principle or argument. Also, you’ve got a lot of gall saying that, given that you try to justify your pedophilia from behind the flag of the rainbow cult.
I fucking told you I would watch my goddamn language if you stopped gay bashing you stupid goddamn redneck.
Language.
And I haven’t gaybashed here or on any other thread.
My solution is much simpler:
Eliminate AT and his ilk.
Don’t forget we have you outnumbered, outgunned, and are much more intelligent than you.
But we’re more subtle. You literally wave a pedo flag.
The only flag I wave is the American flag.
You believe a guy died and came back to life after 3 days you stupid bigoted fuck.
I would keep your inbred fucking mouth shut and hide even deeper in your flyover rural shithole. Or else you will find out your stupid goddamn god doesn’t fucking exist you backwards hick.
Language.
No, you wave a pedo flag. Literally everyone here has seen you do it and called you out for it.
LGTBQ is not pedophilia you backwards goddamn redneck. If you got of your backwater, incest filled shithole and you would see that.
You goddamn fucking Christian nationalists started the war. Don’t be surprised when real Americans like me annihilate you. You are just to backwards to realize how fucking stupid you are.
You are the aggressors you goddamn fool. Knock it off before you force real Americans like me to make an example out of you.
Language.
LGTBQ is not pedophilia
Yes it is. Your creepy weirdo cult has literally spent the entire month of June proving it.
You goddamn fucking Christian nationalists started the war.
Why do you say “Christian nationalist” like it’s a bad thing? What could ANYONE possibly have against that?
You are the aggressors you goddamn fool.
We’re not coming after your children, you pedo. You’re coming after ours. And there will be a reckoning for that.
Fuck off, slaver.
(Do people still say that around here?)
Very appropriate for Juneteenth.
Let’s riot. For justice. (And stuff.)
“Fix those, and you’ll bring the birth rates back up.”
You’ve got the social engineering instincts of a V I Lenin.
I don’t see this as a problem to be ‘fixed.’ If people don’t want to have children, they have their reasons, which are none of our business, and we should respect their choices and their privacy.
What if their reasons are based on misinformation? (Like, say, the idiotic notion that the angry sun god is mad because there are too many people on mother gaia.) What if they’ve been deliberately led and manipulated and terrorized into that belief because someone in power wants more power? (Like, say, the idiotic notion that wife and motherhood are shameful things that deprive women of opportunities to be just like men, instead of women, and shackles them in the kitchen with no freedom or autonomy.)
Wouldn’t you say that’s a problem? Or would you just accept that as “their reasons, which are none of our business.”
If a guy was driving down the road at 100mph because he was misinformed that mph=kmh, would we say “he’s got reasons, none of our business” – or would we want to correct his misunderstanding of things?
This is a major problem with libertarian theory, incidentally. Like Marxism, they seem to depend on a certain level of stagnation. Though, it’s not an economic stagnation like Marxism – libertarian tends to be more of an intellectual stagnation. Like their “individuality” is somehow threatened because society demands corrective action of whatever they’ve been led to believe that forms their dumb and wrong position on a subject.
Your reasons are based on a god that doesn’t exist you stupid jock.
You’re the one who is misinformed and people are sick of you forcing your evil beliefs on everyone.
Which god would that be exactly? Please cite which line of text evidences your claim for that.
Pedophile.
Unchaperoned mixed-sex slumber parties for persons 14-18.
Plenty of booze.
Plenty of music.
No electronic entertainment like smart phones, X-Box, Switch, or PS5.
No other forms of birth control.
Gross you fucking perv!
Teenagers don’t have sex anymore.
Or drink booze. And everybody carries all their music on them at all times everywhere they go. The idea of going somewhere to listen to music, rather than see a live performance, there is dumb.
Nope. ‘Guns’ won’t fix it but they certain do know how to cause it.
Nothing like a ‘Gov-Gun’ packing sexist gang (feminism) that blames the world for all their own personal problems and then throws childish fits demanding forced entitlements they refuse to *earn*.
The baby bust is abetted greatly by government. Abortion is the main culprit: 63 Million abortions since 1973, with Blacks and Hispanics being the main targets, so racial problems are also part of this government intrusion. And the marriage tax penalty adds to this.