Even Trump's Supporters Are Slamming His Post About Rob Reiner's Murder
The president failed a not particularly challenging moral test.
Being outraged by President Donald Trump's offensive remarks is passe at this late hour, and largely pointless: His most ardent supporters excuse his coarseness, and his detractors already regard him as the lowest of lowlifes. Those who fall somewhere in the middle are understandably more worked up about his policy agenda than his mean tweets.
Yet even by the standards of previous nastiness, Trump's comments on Truth Social about Rob Reiner—who was murdered alongside his wife, Michele Reiner, over the weekend—were distressing. Rob Reiner was a well-liked director responsible for such iconic films as A Few Good Men, This Is Spinal Tap, and The Princess Bride. Yes, he also harbored intensely anti-Trump views and criticized the president obsessively on social media. The occasion of his shocking murder—a murder allegedly perpetrated by his son, Nick Reiner, who has suffered from drug addiction and homelessness—is not a fitting time for the president to whine about this, however.
Yet whine he did. As most people, including many conservatives, posted tributes to Reiner on social media, Trump said this:
— Rapid Response 47 (@RapidResponse47) December 15, 2025
"A very sad thing happened last night in Hollywood," he wrote on Truth Social. "Rob Reiner, a tortured and struggling, but once very talented movie director and comedy star, has passed away, together with his wife, Michele, reportedly due to the anger he caused others through his massive, unyielding, and incurable affliction with a mind crippling disease known as TRUMP DERANGEMENT SYNDROME, sometimes referred to as TDS. He was known to have driven people CRAZY by his raging obsession of President Donald J. Trump, with his obvious paranoia reaching new heights as the Trump Administration surpassed all goals and expectations of greatness, and with the Golden Age of America upon us, perhaps like never before. May Rob and Michele rest in peace!"
This was very wrong. Reiner's intense anti-Trump politics had nothing to do with his death. There is no reason to think that the alleged killer was motivated by political considerations at all. By suggesting that Reiner's "Trump derangement syndrome" was connected to his death, Trump is introducing a false notion. Note that this was the ostensible reason for the sanctioning of comedian Jimmy Kimmel, who incorrectly stated the motivations for the killing of conservative figure Charlie Kirk. Trump should have avoided making the same mistake.
He should also have avoided dwelling on his personal feud with a man who was just murdered in gruesome fashion. If he didn't feel like saying anything nice about Reiner, he could have opted to say nothing at all.
Trump's comments drew stern rebukes from Reps. Thomas Massie of Kentucky and Marjorie Taylor Greene of Georgia, both of whom are diehard America First Republicans, though currently estranged from the president. Plenty of Trump voters seemed perturbed by his statement as well.
"Deeply disappointed" Trump voters flooded the call-in lines to tell @emilyjashinsky they were disgusted by his comments on Rob Reiner. pic.twitter.com/MKXFz6Luv1
— Krystal Ball (@krystalball) December 16, 2025
As they should be. Trump has shown that he is capable of magnanimity, but for whatever reason, he utterly failed this week's not particularly challenging moral test.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please to post comments
If Hitler was murdered yesterday, would he be expected to say nice things as well?
If Shitler was murdered yesterday, Dear Deranged Orange Caligula would find a way to turn the focus to HIM, and HIM having been wronged!!! Shitler brought his own murder upon himself by having DARED to be afflicted by ODCDS, which is Orange Deranged Caligula Derangement Syndrome!!!
He couldn't say nice things since he died the day before.
Walz scale +5
DLAM scale -4
I’ve seen this posted before, but I don’t know the context. What is this “Walz scale” you have been referencing?
It is a retardation rating joke.
A famous director is Hitler because he disagreed with Trump. Might want to get your head checked
Idiot. Just looking at an extreme example. Of course, you have no answer.
Did you say the same thing about Saint Kirk? Or are you a big fat hypocrite?
Charlie Kirk was a very kind and decent man. Reiner was not,
Charlie Kirk was assassinated by one of your fellow democrats to silence him. Reiner and his wife were murdered by their junkie son.
Both are terrible things, but they are not equivalent. And funny how you’re outraged at Trump, but not at all towards the murderer.
That speaks volumes about you. You’re a sick, soulless piece of shit.
Kirk was a nativist bigot who had no problem with deporting people in the US legally to Bukele's torture chambers.
Walz scale +9
Guess this proves it is a sarc sock.
Fu Manchu is a lying pile of TDS-addled lefty shit, since it is.
And it should fuck off and die.
Just disagreed huh shrike?
“ If Hitler was murdered yesterday, would he be expected to say nice things as well?”
Rob Reiner is the same as Hitler? Dear God, I hope this is Poe’s Law in action.
"Deeply disappointed" Trump voters flooded the call-in lines
Trump voters listen to Megyn Kelly?
So the the take-away according to MAGA-maggots is... Rob Reiner and his wife DESERVED to be murdered... Because they did SNOT slurpport "Hang Mike Pence"!!!
HANG MIKE PENCE, I say, ass I say again, HANG MIKE PENCE, Dear Orange Caligula SAID so!!! All those SNOT on board with HANGING Mike Pence, are afflicted with TDS!!!
“Hang Mike Pence”!!! Dear Leader agrees!!!
https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/trump-defends-jan-6-rioters-hang-mike-pence-chant-newly-n1283798
Trump defends Jan. 6 rioters’ ‘hang Mike Pence’ chant in new audio
The audio captured part of an interview ABC News’ Jonathan Karl conducted with Trump at Mar-a-Lago in March for Karl’s upcoming book.
Trump is PROUD of His Imperial Support for His Storm Troopers and His Political Violence, and can SNOT shut His Trap about shit!!!
PS, Mike Pence’s dangerous words and ideas were that votes, voters, established democratic norms and processes, peaceful transfers of power, and the USA Constitution should actually be RESPECTED!!! Now just IMAGINE THAT!!! This was HERESY to True Trumpaloos!!!
MAGA supports murdering political opponents of Trump.
Much of the US still is in denial about this.
Nope. You’re a goddamned liar. And democrats support murdering anyone who dares dissent. Hell, you’ve tried to murder Trump twice now, assassinated Charlie Kirk, and engage in domestic terrorism around the country every day.
You and your party should be imprisoned, at a minimum.
Thank you for proving my point.
Uh no. You have given zero support for your statement that "MAGA", whoever the H you mean by that, supports murdering political opponents of Trump, and that "much of the US is still in denial about this."
Unless you come up with proof, or at best a vastly more intelligent remark, it remains true and already proven that it is the DEM party that wants to murder opponents.
Robby is more horrified by someone who said ‘mean words’ than the person who brutally slaughtered both of his own parents.
Typical leftist.
Red Herring (red her·ring) -
1. "The definition of a red herring is to use misleading information to redirect away from the original topic. These logical fallacies may also be used intentionally to distract from the main topic of an argument."
2. "Another form of argumentation for stupid MAGA motherfuckers."
Hey, don't get mad at me - that's what the world wide web says..
Oh look. Sarcasmic did pony up the $25.
I was sure he'd blow it on a case of bum wine instead.
He has 2 socks going in this thread It's pretty pathetic.
I wonder how many cocks he took to pay for those socks?
No, the ‘red herring’ is your nonsensical bullshit. And I’m 100% correct. All you people that celebrated the assassination of Kirk are outraged at Trump, and have zero problem with Reiner’s junkie murdering kid.
You are scum. Did you know that?
The Average Dude (Who's Smarter Than You)
Who is a fucking imbecilic lefty TDS-addled shit.
Fuck off and die, shitstain.
The person who brutally slaughtered both of his own parents does SNOT have Shit's thumbs on the Big Red Nuclear Button, nor does this murderer (who shit seems murdered 2 people) have a history of cummanding the murders of some 80 (?) or so peaceful travelers on the high seas. We pay MORE attention to the derangement of possible murderers of the whole human race (via nukes), than we do to a 2-bit murderer of 2 people. Twat is wrong with THAT? Twat is wrong with YOU?
One is a random homeless druggie nobody had heard of. The other is President. Makes a bit of a difference, doesn't it, retard.
You are completely correct.
Trumps words hurt no one (except those with shallow skin), while the addict actually killed someone.
Thanks for ranking 47 over a drug user.
Idiot. Trump has now ordered the murder of approximately 80 people.
Nope.
Walz +6
You have been owned.
"Trump has now ordered the murder of approximately 80 people,"
Really? Name three.
Are we back on the “mean tweets” thing again?
No, as always the point is that Trump is a loathsome and disgusting human being with nothing but rage and hatred in his heart, an irrational sense of self-worth, and zero empathy or compassion. There’s a word for people like him.
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/psychopathy
“There’s a word for people like him.”
I don’t think trumps a progressive, Nelson. But you’ve been on this “people are what I say they are” schtick for awhile, so maybe you believe that.
Lol. Idiot.
One is a nepotism baby scumbag democrat murderer, the other is a great man who is saving our country, much to your ire.
Oh, and your comment is rated Walz +7.
Or in short, YOU are the retard.
Why should I give a shit about the death of a Leftist POS? You fuckers run around defending every Leftist outrage, lie and narrative so, no, I have no good will for you cunts anymore. Each and every one of you deserves to have your throats slit for the evil you perpetrate on the world, but alas we do not live in a world where people get what they deserve.
Charming AND intelligent. Thank you for being a spokesman and delegate for all of MAGA everywhere. Your words will be heard for generations to come.
Sorry about the hurty words, Sarc. But take heart, you (D)s will be remembered even longer for all the grotesque violence you indulged in.
We've seen the violence, degeneracy and societal destruction that you cheer, what makes you think you mean anything?
LOL, this is MAGA in a nutshell. Everyone we disagree with should die.
Look at all that projection. All the violence, all the killing has been 100% blue on red.
As I said on another article:
Dylann Roof
Anders Brevik
Brenton Tarrant
Vance Luther Boelter
Robert Lewis Dear
Tim McVeigh
I could go on all day.
The ones I recognize are not conservatives. And I doubt the others are either.
You’re a liar, but we already knew that. Everyone knows that assassins and terrorists are always on the left.
Spelled "Lying pile of TDS addled steaming shit". Your welcome andf make sure we recognize a "Lying pile of TDS addled steaming shit" when we see one.
The liar should be set on fire.
Two of those are not even Americans, none are less than a decade old and one isn't even from this century.
As I said on another article:
Get with the fucking times, old man.
Lol. Idiot.
Just catching up to decades of you vile commies doing exactly that, but you've got the bodycount to go with it.
Meanwhile your party keeps actually killing jews and conservatives sarc.
Because murder is bad. I thought we were all board with not wishing literal death on people we disagree with.
“ Why should I give a shit about the death of a Leftist POS?”
For the same reason that Rob Reiner condemned the killing of Charlie Kirk and praised Kirk’s wife for her grace and decency. Because that’s what people with a moral compass, compassion, and integrity do.
Not only is Trump a narcissist but he's also a frigging dumbass and can't help posting his verbal diarrhea for everyone to see.
And you just did the same.
Trump didn't just get killed ya retard.
Walz scale +10
Lol. Another proof this is sarc. Hilarious.
You seem to be upset trump wasn't killed buddy.
But you fags tried twice last year. Cheered on by hateful democrats like Rob Reiner. And you.
DLAM scale +6.
Poor thirsty, angry bitch. It must be tough to get through the day when you’re as worthless, cowardly, and stupid as you.
You need help:
https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/health-services-benefits/medical-assistance-dying.html
Oh, and seethe harder.
Maybe your team should take another shot at him sarc.
If a guy tries his damndest to have you imprisoned on false charges, and his rhetoric leads to two assaination attempts, one which misses by millimeters and clips your ear, do you have to nice when he bites it?
This isn't like Charlie Kirk where Kirk was trying to get past the acrimony and engage in fair debate only to be killed by a stranger because of it. Rob Reiner was a vicious demagogue whose own son killed him for personal reasons.
And this after he somehow survived being fork stabbed by Eric Cartman.
“ If a guy tries his damndest to have you imprisoned on false charges, and his rhetoric leads to two assaination attempts”
So if someone says true things about a reprehensible human being, they are responsible if someone else, with no connection to them whatsoever, tries to murder that terrible person? That seems like an awfully loose standard.
“ Kirk was trying to get past the acrimony and engage in fair debate”
This is probably the most ridiculously retconned take on Charlie Kirk I’ve seen yet. He reveled in and stoked acrimony. He interrupted those (especially women) who accepted his “prove me wrong” challenge when they made valid counterpoints. He was a misogynist, a racist, and a homophobe. He wasn’t trying to get past acrimony, he reveled in and profited from it. He loved it.
“ Rob Reiner was a vicious demagogue whose own son killed him for personal reasons.”
Uh, your handlers called and they insist you get back on message. Rob Reiner was killed because he opposed Trump. Trump himself said so.
Walz +7
You’re a lying, retarded piece of shit Nelson. You malign ML, who was only telling the truth.
If only Rob Reiner had moved a little to the left...
I don’t think there was much room left for that.
I always thought this would be the only test of whether Trump is cognitively declining. He's always been an asshole and a bully - who never learned basic manners by getting the ever loving shit kicked out of him when he was young and stupid.
And a good test of cognitive decline for that personality type is that they start attacking everyone who can't fight back for increasingly what-the-fuck-is-that reasons. Especially since - now that he's Prez - no one can kick the ever loving shit out of him to teach him some fucking basic manners now that he's old and stupid.
MEAN TWEETS!
So Trump has always been an asshole and a bully, and he is still an asshole and a bully, and that shows that he is cognitively declining?
Serious question. Just how dumb are you?
He’s Walz +6.
That’s Tim Walz retardation PLUS SIX. Which is really dammed retarded.
"I always thought this would be the only test of whether Trump is cognitively declining."
1) Not surprisingly for a slimy pile of lefty shit, you had no idea of when "this" happened, nor any way to describe it. It's not surprising since you are an imbecilic piece of lefty shit
2) Your claim hear is as imbecilic as slimy pile of lefty shit. Care to define your terms, asswipe?
Walz +8
You Jew hating commie.
Is this science like all the science you pushed during covid?
Psychology is not science.
Trump and his followers are a disgrace to humanity. They prove that every day.
Poor baby.
MG is a steaming pile of Chinese TDS-addled lying lefty shit who should fuck off and die.
Is that the official position of the ChiCom Party, Tiananmen Tony?
Maybe you should join sarc in a half million dollar air bnb and plan out another assassination attempt.
lol at anyone who is surprised or disappointed by the old asshole doing old asshole things.
Your kind are angrier at Trump than you are the scumbag murderer.
Yeah, what Trump said was uncalled for, regardless of what kind of person Reiner was when alive. Don't speak ill of the dead unless that person *did* rather than *said* something hateful.
But here's the thing: Trump was mean, and therefore... what? I should have voted for Harris despite Trump rolling back the left's economy-strangling energy policies, starting the process of dismantling the Department of Education, demanding the Europeans pay for their own defense, reining in the bureaucracy, and reducing foreign aid spending? My support is based on policies, not personality, and while I don't agree with Trump on everything, those things are what I base my decisions on.
If presented a choice between a nice candidate and a mean candidate who had 100% identical policy positions, yes, I'd prefer the nice one. But that's the only situation where this would matter to me.
Basically. This is all the usual leftist media distraction that Reason runs with over actual analysis or policy description these days.
Well said!
I think it means that the walls are finally closing in, this is the end of the beginning, the beginning of the end and his chances at a 4th term are probably kaput.
women vote for prom king. This is the only thing you need to understand
Trump is rude, crude, and vulgar. So what? He only hurts himself with these tweets. Many women find this icky. I’d rather he act better, but he gets things done, so i don’t care whose feelings are hurt.
OMG! Even Trump supporters get disgusted by petty public displays of anger? /s
Yeah; In leftarded sheeple-land that must seem like a major WOW...
In the other half of the political world; not so much.
"His most ardent supporters excuse his coarseness."
Skimming the comments of his ardent supporters, I'd suggest a minor edit...
"His most ardent supporters celebrate his coarseness."
He said the dead guy was crazy and maybe brought it on himself without asserting that others share his fate.
My moral ladder may not have all the same lofty rungs as Robby's, but that's a step above his contemporaries who called for more deaths like Brian Thompson's and Charlie Kirk's and threatened their opposition's living, minor, children.
Let's remember Alan Berg, who was assassinated in Denver in 1984 by a hardcore antisemite who thought that Hitler didn't go far enough. Berg was an opinionated, left-wing, atheist radio talk show host who ruffled lots of feathers across the spectrum. I don't know enough to say whether Berg was murdered for being a Jew or for his politics, but it was probably both. So while it probably is true that Rob and Michele Reiner weren't killed because of their political opinions, it's not crazy to wonder if maybe they really were. Alan Berg was.
Yes, it is crazy. We know who killed them. Do you MAGA lunatics ever think, “Hm, this is clearly and obviously both idiotic and delusional. Perhaps I shouldn’t say it out loud.”?
They were killed by their son. What is the matter with you?
When someone repeatedly calls you a racist and a rapist you're not obliged to not shit on them. Remember that anyone who refers to Trump as a "felon" because of his "34 felonies" is a shithead. It's that simple. Calling Rob Reiner deranged is too forgiving.
“ When someone repeatedly calls you a racist and a rapist you're not obliged to not shit on them.”
When you are a racist and a rapist, with all necessary receipts, perhaps you should examine your own life and behavior rather than doubling down on being a terrible person.
“ Remember that anyone who refers to Trump as a "felon" because of his "34 felonies" is a shithead.”
Oh, so we aren’t calling people who have been convicted of crimes (specifically felonies) a felon? Well then, I’ll just go and update my dictionary.
Walz +6
It was a shitty thing to say. no doubt.
dont care.
women vote for from prom king.
Joe Biden after Kirk's murder: "There is no place in our country for this kind of violence. It must end now. Jill and I are praying for Charlie Kirk’s family and loved ones."
Donald Trump after Reiner's murder: “A very sad thing happened last night in Hollywood. Rob Reiner, a tortured and struggling, but once very talented movie director and comedy star, has passed away, together with his wife, Michele, reportedly due to the anger he caused others through his massive, unyielding, and incurable affliction with a mind crippling disease known as TRUMP DERANGEMENT SYNDROME, sometimes referred to as TDS. He was known to have driven people CRAZY by his raging obsession of President Donald J. Trump, with his obvious paranoia reaching new heights as the Trump Administration surpassed all goals and expectations of greatness, and with the Golden Age of America upon us, perhaps like never before."
Exercise for the reader: Compare and contrast these two comments by a former and a current US president about the murders of two prominent Americans.
Extra Credit for the reader: Look around at the other responses to Charlie Kirk's murder. Look around that the calls endanger living Supreme Court Justices and the threats against other politician's children. Look at Reason's exuberant defense of "journalists" doxing LEOs and even just private citizens on Social Media for notoriety. Then choose to realize, or not, that Trump didn't actually make any threats or call for action. Just expressed a crass and uncouth, but honest, opinion.
A big part of the problem with the "comparative" quote from Joe Biden is that the left has nearly-literally effaced or erected a facade of "polite = good" even if, behind the scenes, Joe Biden can't even sign his own name and Barack Obama and Jesse Jackson are calling people bitter clingers and threatening to cut each other's balls off.
Even though Rob Reiner has always been a raging lunatic, it is not the time to point it out. Even more disturbing is the narcissistic twist that Trump is compelled to express. A person is murdered and you have to turn the conversation back to you.
Does it really matter if any of the involved people have either TRUMP DERANGEMENT SYNDROME or TRUMP SYCOPHANT SYNDROME? It is not the appropriate time to go off on a rant based upon what we know at this time.
Perhaps if Rob Reiner and his son were at loggerheads over Trump then there might be a different conversation, but this is not the case and the reality is that Trump is being narcissistic and caustic. It's about time fro Trump to grow up and act like an adult.
Trump is being narcissistic and caustic.
The country was run for years by a man who couldn't sign his own name and his impossibly-even-emptier-suit replacement was anointed, without primary, entirely without any nasty Tweets.
Even if Trump's post was completely out of line, it didn't call for or even implicate violence or policy of any sort, and is a distraction from any real libertarian idea.
The only actionable outcome of the hyperfixation, no matter how polite, is to begin to stipulate whom The President can and cannot badmouth and how, however, close in proximity to their death or other life event.
Otherwise, you're 100% equally free to declare Trump "The one President so retarded that he couldn't even feed goldfish correctly." the nanosecond after his death.
Jim Geraghty argues in the conservative National Review Online that Trump's Reiner tweet has policy implications:
"This president cannot discern moral right and wrong through a person’s actions, like a normal human being. Donald Trump’s entire worldview of whether someone is a good person or a bad person depends entirely on whether that person offers praise or criticism of Trump. This is the person who runs the executive branch of the U.S. government, and this is a formula for disaster. This is, I suspect, a factor in why the Trump administration is so friendly to the likes of Xi Jinping and endlessly patient with Vladimir Putin, while sneering with contempt about leaders of European democracies. Trump does not see anything inherently morally objectionable about a brutal autocrat with a long history of egregious human-rights abuses, but he will never forget or forgive a European leader who ever uttered a critical word in Le Monde."
https://www.nationalreview.com/the-morning-jolt/trumps-appalling-reiner-reaction-is-a-sign-of-something-deeply-wrong/
Specifically the opposite from your own source, the only time he even says the word "polic(y|ies)", retard:
Since 2015, people solidly in the Trump camp have been explicitly invoking the Christopher Nolan "He's not the hero Gotham deserves..." meme in specific reference to this issue.
mad.casual, Jim Geraghty writes, "_You_ [emphasis added] can prefer the president’s policies." For himself, he writes, "This is the person who runs the executive branch of the U.S. government, and this is a formula for disaster."
My comment gives an example in contradiction of your assertion that, "Even if Trump's post was completely out of line, it didn't call for or even implicate violence or policy of any sort..."
Does your use of the word "retard" accomplish anything other than demonstrating that you are a practitioner of one of President Trump's most common rhetorical strategies, which I characterize in a phrase that I was taught in my youth as, "strong words imply weak thoughts"?
Donald Trump has progressed to the point where he is the grandpa or older uncle that you can't take anywhere because he no longer has the verbal control to not say embarrassing things. You know the person that commends on a person weight when introduced or tell your friend he liked their first wife better. It is all part of the mental decline spiral he continues down. At what point do his handler give up and admit that he needs to step down? Will he make it another year? I don't really think that will be the case. He physical and mental health are declining very rapidly. I see the problem for Republicans being the proximity to the mid term elections. The sooner Trump leaves the more time they have to regroup, wait too long and he pull them down further in the election.
Walz +4
Censure and impeachment are the proper process' to punish a sitting President. Get your Reps on it.
Or you can try to cancel him, get on X and work the mob into a lather like the old days. Oh right, Bluesky then - pity.
I hear there are vacancies with the lithium-eyed Turtle Island folks?
The president failed a not particularly challenging moral test.
Did he define what a woman was *without* a biologist to tell him?
Your moral tests mean nothing, I've seen the morals you cheer.
What was it that Reiner said after Trump was shot in the head?
Ah.
Trump's response was remarkably restrained.
Fuck Rob Reiner. He was a hate filled lunatic.
It doesn't matter what Trump says, including nothing. The TDS addled are going to bitch about it. So knowing that, why be polite?
In the online version of the conservative magazine _National_Review_, Jim Geraghty discusses Trump's Reiner tweet in the article to which I link below. I recommend it, especially for conservative-leaning commenters.
"Trump’s Appalling Reiner Reaction Is a Sign of Something Deeply Wrong"
https://www.nationalreview.com/the-morning-jolt/trumps-appalling-reiner-reaction-is-a-sign-of-something-deeply-wrong/
"We must talk about it because there are some Americans still so blinded by partisan animus and cult-like loyalty that their first instinct will be to defend the president’s remarks."
It is good to see so many in the conservative community stepping up to address Trump's remarks. I think the article toward the end gets to the point I tried to make which is Trump is losing his mental faculties that would rein in remarks like those he made. Whether it was Biden or Trump it was a mistake to elect a person this old to the Presidency.