Uncle Sam Makes Thanksgiving Worse
We have many things to be grateful for this time of year. The government isn't one of them.
Readers of Reason are no doubt familiar with the true story of the first Thanksgiving, when the collectivist pilgrims almost starved, only to be saved by the voluntary charity of the local population.
A lot has changed about America since those early days of settlement. Sadly, the interfering tentacles of government continue to get in the way of a proper Thanksgiving feast.
While many younger Americans might wish to give thanks for their ability to host a Thanksgiving dinner in their own commodious home, unfortunately, zoning regulations and federal mortgage regulations have made the goal of homeownership a far-off one indeed. The age of the median first-time homebuyer today is a wizened 40 years.
That means the family dinner will have to occur at the house of Boomer parents or grandparents who managed to lock down a place of their own before homebuilding restrictions really started to jack up prices.
There's of course a certain joy in being home for the holidays, even if it's not your home. Getting there nevertheless requires some travel. And that, too, has been made a much more painful ordeal thanks to Uncle Sam.
Some 80 million Americans are expected to travel on planes, trains, and automobiles for Thanksgiving. Regardless of mode, government interference will ensure your trip is longer and less convenient than it could have been in a free market.
Should you fly, you can expect long security lines staffed by latex-gloved TSA agents rummaging through your belongings to make sure you're not traveling with a jar of cranberry sauce larger than three ounces.
Thanksgiving is hard on the turkeys we consume for dinner on the day. At least the birds are dead by the time people remove the giblets from their cavity. Air travelers picked for enhanced screening by error-prone scanner machines won't be so lucky.
This is to say nothing of the flying experience itself. With government price controls preventing the construction of new gates and the entrance of new airlines, you can expect to pay more and wait longer for your flight home.
At least these restrictions on entry relieve some strain on our outdated, government-monopolized air traffic control system.
Should you wish to avoid the hassles of government-guarded airports and government-protected airlines, driving is always an option, but it comes with its own government-created hassles.
Thanksgiving traffic can always be a pain that's made worse only by the federal government's general prohibition on tolling interstates.
Instead of at least having the option of paying to ride in a congestion-free toll lane, we're all stuck paying the time tax to get to wherever home is.
TSA might not be breathing down your neck during the drive. But you'll still have to contend with ICE's watchful eye as you travel to celebrate a holiday inspired by early immigrants to America.
Affordable, for-profit bus lines contend with many of these same problems as well, even if they do offer an intercity option that does not require you to actually be behind the wheel.
If you were hoping to travel on government-promised high-speed rail, too bad! It's still not built yet.
Things will start looking up once you do successfully navigate the statrix to finally reach your destination. You're at last surrounded by loved ones, and the struggles of the journey make you feel all the more grateful for it.
Even still, the heavy hand of the state will, on the margins, reduce the quality and quantity of the soon-to-be-served Thanksgiving feast.
Federal restrictions on direct-to-consumer meat sales mean your turkey will have to come from a factory farming operation that, whatever its merits, sacrifices quality for efficiency. Tariffs on imported ingredients and libations will raise the bill. The costs of pandemic-era inflation are baked into more than just the pies.
While this doesn't apply to every family, the increasing politicization of everything will no doubt make dinnertime conversation a bit more contentious than it needs to be.
At the end of the day, these are all survivable hardships. God is good, and He's provided our country with many blessings. State economic planning notwithstanding, the miracles of modern capitalist production ensure that almost everyone has a heavily laden table this time of the year.
Still, one can't help but look at the many things to give thanks for this Thanksgiving and realize how few of them come from the government.
Rent Free is a weekly newsletter from Christian Britschgi on urbanism and the fight for less regulation, more housing, more property rights, and more freedom in America's cities.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please to post comments
CHRISTIAN BRITSCHGI, thank you.
Speaking of needless hassles when travelling to your Thanksgiving get-togethers, you forgot one:
Do SNOT travel on the high seas in a speedboat, especially ANYWHERE near where there might be illegal substances or illegal sub-humans being smuggled, or ye might be summarily executed, without ANY semblance of apprehension, a trial, or basic fact-finding!
Or you can not travel across the ocean in a $100 "fishing boat" that has no fishing gear, $75,000 in motors and is filled with odd square bales of something.
...the collectivist pilgrims almost starved, only to be saved by the voluntary charity of the local population.
And those immigrants took advantage of their generosity AND LOOK WHAT HAPPENED. No need to read any further, Britches. I understand the lesson you're trying to impart. Not sure what it has to do with the headline you chose, though...
Ha! No, I get the actual point of the article. Best for everyone to stay home instead of dealing with the hassle that is the state. Gen Z should instead just come out to their parents the old fashioned way: via Insta.
It's almost as though it is being said Thanksgiving should be cancelled.
People should stay home to avoid "that relative" who won't shut up about politics, Gaza or display her TDS in as loud a manner as possible.
You could have just said, "I hate America and Americans, everything is awful and I'm thankful for nothing" and called it a day, Christian.
I'm trying to find a way to accuse you of hyperbole. So far, I have no arguments.
Nor is he grateful for anything. Just another soft, leftist whiner who never did any heavy lifting in his entire life, bitching and whining while he prospers on the backs of better men. All while being a huge part of the problem. Just like the rest of the Reason Rats.
He’s done nothing but aid and abet the democrats and their cronies for years, then has the audacity to complain about government.
Fuck him.
I had a ham roasting, scalloped potatoes baking, a big Italian salad, cheese cake, Sam Adams, and Makers' Mark and football.I'm set
If I cook for thanksgiving I usually go for a prime rib.
Ham for Thanksgiving? You are banished from the comment section, heathen.
**Thanksgiving traffic can always be a pain that's made worse only by the federal government's general prohibition on tolling interstates.
Instead of at least having the option of paying to ride in a congestion-free toll lane, we're all stuck paying the time tax to get to wherever home is.**
Who the fuck sent out the congestion pricing memo at Reason three months ago? Suddenly this is up there with abortion, drugs and 2A. You can look over the statistics and tell me that tolls and congestion pricing make traffic more efficient or result in less accidents or something. What you can't do is tell me that this in any way equals more freedom. Quite the opposite. Trying to compel me to drive only when Mommy Government says it's okay is more COVID authoritarianism.
I'm going to get in my car and drive on the highway at 6 a.m. and 8:17 a.m. and 5:42 p.m. and any other time. You know why? Because I have somewhere to be. But mostly because I paid for the road and I fucking feel like it.
Only fools commute into midtown or lower Manhattan by car. The congestion tax is a tax on the low IQ folks.
Nah, it’s just commie bullshit from pinko retards.
Congestion tolling is a liberal fantasy of revenue raising until you realize all those delivery trucks are going to pay over twice as much as the cars which will raise prices on everything.
Everything is so terrible and unfair.
At least we have soldiers patrolling cities, masked federal agents grabbing people off the streets, and federal prosecutors dreaming up charges to punish political opponents. So it's not all that bad.
Yep. All because of the horrific messes you and your democrat friends have made. This is ALL YOUR FAULT. We’re just cleaning up after you, while you whine and complain.
As usual.
"true story of the first Thanksgiving, when the collectivist pilgrims almost starved,"
It wasn't government. It was a private sector colonization project. Basically a 17th century Homeowners Association. And another such private sector enterprise, Virginia, really DID have starvation, which killed the majority of settlers. I am descended from some od the few survivors.
If they knew you were the end result, they likely would have starved themselves to death on purpose.
It was an attempt at the first HOA and 400 years later we still haven't learned our lesson.
Only fools commute into midtown or lower Manhattan by car. The congestion tax is a tax on the low IQ folks.
The TSA is a reminder that if someone like Donald Trump was president in 2000, and ICE kicked out the 9/11 plotters once their visas expired, we'd be in a country far better than one without TSA.
Those terrorists who all but ended American prosperity were given visas despite one of them listing "hotel" as home and were given pilot licenses.
When I was working full time, I wasted away hours of my life sitting in traffic. Thanksgiving was like the one time I was spared the nightmare of LA gridlock. CA is a dystopia where cost of living is a crime against humanity and cities can burn down any minute because the one party rule prioritize fishes and diversity.
The bureaucratic nature of government can be a nuisance. The democrat party who runs most of the country is a direct threat to our safety and prosperity. Make the distinction, or you don't understand current day America.
It was an attempt at the first HOA and 400 years later we still haven't learned our lesson.