All Hail the Grocery Store
American grocery stores are an underrated symbol of free market abundance.

If I had one chance to show a medieval peasant the glories of the modern world, I wouldn't take them to a space launch or a science lab. I would take them to a grocery store.
What more could you want to awe the medieval imagination? Ginormous, GMO'd strawberries in January? Check. Fifty different kinds of soup? Check. Whatever the hell this is? You bet. American grocery stores don't just have a shocking abundance of food; they have a variety almost completely unknown to humanity.
Our grocery stores are famously astounding to outsiders—from Mikhail Gorbachev to Venezuelan immigrants like Daniel Di Martino, our grocery stores showcase the bounties available in a free society with free markets.
And never is this abundance more on display than during Thanksgiving.
As the holiday approaches, Americans everywhere will be whipping up their favorite stuffing recipe, cranking open a can of cranberry sauce, and possibly burning down their house in an attempt to deep-fry a whole turkey. And adding to the holiday cheer, not only will they be able to pick from a truly massive range of culinary options, they'll do it much, much less than their parents did.
According to data from The American Farm Bureau Federation, an agricultural lobbying group, the cost of a Thanksgiving dinner for 10 is down around 21 percent since 1986, when adjusting for inflation. As Marian L. Tupy, a senior fellow at the Cato Institute, recently pointed out, with increases in typical blue-collar wages, it now takes the average blue-collar worker 2.01 hours to afford a Thanksgiving dinner, while it took the same workers 3.2 hours in 1986.
While inflation has increased the estimated cost of a family Thanksgiving over the past few years, it's still thankfully true that making a ginormous meal for your family and friends is much more affordable for current American workers than in previous generations.
The only thing keeping us from grocery store maximalism—and even better access to cheaper and higher quality goods—are bureaucrats and politicians, who use protectionism and overwrought regulation to prop up favored industries. While municipal governments have attempted to tax us away from soda and booze, politicians in Congress have given billions in subsidies and bailouts to the faltering dairy industry while trying to spike sales of plant-based milk. And perhaps worst of all, last year's devastating baby formula shortage shows just how harmful anti-competition regulations can be.
But despite the ample room for improvement, I can't help but keep loving grocery stores.
When I think about what makes me proudest to be an American—something that fills me with true, cheesy, unadulterated patriotic pride—I think about those aisles and aisles of abundance. And this Thanksgiving, I'm particularly grateful for the, ahem, cornucopia they offer.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
If you like grocery stores you should check out a typical French "Hypermarche". The Italians aren't far behind.
True, they don't polish the apples before carefully stacking them like the Americans do, but the variety of high quality food and drink of every description makes up for the small advantage in presentation.
If you like grocery stores you should check out a typical French “Hypermarche”.
You mean a hypermarket aka supercenter? Those were invented in the US, in 1962. The first one was at the corner of 28th and Kalamazoo in Grand Rapids, Michigan, opened by Hendrick and his son Frederick Meijer.
I'm making $90 an hour working from home. I never imagined that it was honest to goodness yet my closest companion is earning 16,000 US dollars a month by working on the connection, that was truly astounding for me, she prescribed for me to attempt it simply. Everybody must try this job now by just using this website... http://www.Payathome9.com
A hypermarche? You mean a standard American supermarket? The stuff we've been doing since the 1980's that the Europeans were only able to match come the late 1990's?
1960s in some states, like Michigan.
I had vague memories from being a kid on how much of the average person's income was spent on housing (1/2?) and food (1/3). Many years later, I saw reports on how much it had shrunk, and that was my first understanding of how much wealthier we all are.
Along the way, I found that US government taxes are something like 40% of GDP, much more than when I was a kid, but that was just one more example of how much government steals from us. How much of that 40% is actually useful, even if not necessary? I'd guess 10%, ie 4% of GDP. How much of that is necessary? Much much less.
~1% of the 40% stolen
First of all, taxes aren't stolen. They are part of living in a civilized society. There are two ways to not have taxes. You can have the government run revenue producing businesses that pay its bills. Saudi Arabia is an example. The other is to have anarchy. Somalia is an example. If you resent taxes, you should emigrate to one of them. You probably will need to convert to Islam.
Second, the US tax burden is 26.6% of GDP, not 40%. Lower than the 34.1% OECD average. You pay less in the US. Your grandchildren will be paying for the fact that Americans aren't willing to tax themselves for the government services we demand (with politicians who don't provide those services getting voted out).
https://data.oecd.org/tax/tax-revenue.htm
If you are willing to put up with some of what you falsely call theft, but less than the US, you can emigrate to Mexico. It has the lowest tax to GDP ratio. It also has universal health insurance. It has asset/income requitements for immigrants but most middle class Americans would be able to meet them. You will need to learn Spanish, though.
Interestingly, if you look through the graphs, you will find that the US has the lowest taxes on goods and services relative to GDP. Some economists point out that this is one reason why we have so much debt -- spending is encouraged by such low tax rates.
https://data.oecd.org/tax/tax-revenue.htm
Recall when Elizabeth Warren (D) tried to obfuscate Bidenflation by attacking grocery store chains for high food prices. Liarwatha didn’t understand that grocers’ profit is about two percent. The high food prices come from Washington devaluing the dollar.
All true, but the narrative of “greedy corporations” “overpaid” CEOS, and the sins of the 1 oercenters plays so well to the progressive crowd who vote for her. They want equity, and much prefer it be taken from those who have rather than choosing a productive path and earning it themselves. Financial success is a right that shouldn’t only benefit those who strive…
And besides, who needs a dozen varieties of deodorant? Central planning would make much better uses of resources, right? And everyone would be equal and there would be no more envy.
And besides, who needs a dozen varieties of deodorant?
Tell that to the assholes at Old Spice. They’ve got multiple dozens of varieties, yet had to discontinue the one scent that I liked.
I haven’t used Old Spice since the Proctor and Gamble CEO defended that Gillette ad about how terrible men are, and claimed it was worth it for sharing such an important message. Stopped using my head and shoulders, switched from Crest to Colgate, and found other deodorant products I liked.
It wasn’t the ad that pissed me off, it was the guy who defended it because he believed the message was more important than profits. It let me know that this isn’t a company that just wants to make good products for me, it’s a company that judges me for checking out an attractive woman, (or letting boys wrestle!?) and is willing to sacrifice profits to virtue signal.
"I haven’t used Old Spice since the Proctor and Gamble CEO defended that Gillette ad"
That's when I abandoned P&G stuff too. On the upside I found a lot of far better products.
I still miss Desert Spice by Sure. Best scent ever!
As with other populists like Fatass Donnie, Pocahantas used a bit of truth to spin her tall tale:
Corporate profits hit record high in third quarter amid 40-year-high inflation
BY TOBIAS BURNS - 11/30/22 12:33 PM ET
https://thehill.com/business/3756457-corporate-profits-hit-record-high-in-third-quarter-amid-40-year-high-inflation/
While Americans were "suffering" with the high cost of their Cheesy-Poofs corporations were raking it in like never before - including oil and gas.
The inflation made the amount of profit higher but the small percentage of profit remained consistent.
People weren’t bitching about the two percent of their much higher Bidenflation food bills for profit. People were bitching about the Bidenflation causing their food bills to skyrocket. Fauxcahontas was doing a chaff and redirect to shift focus away from the Biden economy failures.
Biden economy failures
Your narrative is wrong but popular.
Record employment, demand, and productivity tend to send prices higher.
See 2008 for an economic failure. Americans are either too stupid or too young to remember the Great Recession. We haven't had a mild recession since Donnie left office despite the Fed trying to force one to cool off the economy.
Record employment? What's the percentage of working adults again?
News: Unemployment is at its Lowest Level in 54 years
February 3, 2023
https://www.commerce.gov/news/blog/2023/02/news-unemployment-its-lowest-level-54-years
That was February. What, about a million jobs added since?
exact opposite of 2008.
Didn't answer his question, did you?
A few years back you posted kiddy porn to this site, and your initial handle was banned. The link below details all the evidence surrounding that ban. A decent person would honor that ban and stay away from Reason. Instead you keep showing up, acting as if all people should just be ok with a kiddy-porn-posting asshole hanging around. Since I cannot get you to stay away, the only thing I can do is post this boilerplate.
https://reason.com/2022/08/06/biden-comforts-the-comfortable/?comments=true#comment-9635836
That's not what he asked, Plugstick. What’s the percentage of working adults?
Pluggo messes things up like reading comprehension, age of consent, and “Get your adult hands off me you creepy clown” means no.
Depends on how you define "adult". But here are stats for you.
https://www.bls.gov/emp/tables/civilian-labor-force-participation-rate.htm
The apparent drop in labor force participation is mostly due to teenagers not working. That is good. They should be in school instead.
Liz Warren (D) started her anti-grocer campaign almost two years into the Biden (D) regime. Take it up with the white woman that has high cheek bones.
The govnah (D) in this state sent checks out to combat high prices. Take it up with her too. The Democratic Party congressman (D) also sent a letter out to the citizens complaining about high prices. You’ll want to address this with him.
Shrödinger’s inflation?
Correct. Biden has pulled off an economic miracle and the liars out there are trying to diminish those accomplishments because they don't like other things he has done.
"The high food prices come from Washington devaluing the dollar."
That is a lie. The value of the dollar against most other currencies dramatically increased during 2021, as inflation started up. The US dollar today is worth more than it ever was under Trump.
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DTWEXBGS
The high food prices come from Washington devaluing the dollar.
Not how FX works.
The Cheesy-Poof Price Index is now more important than GDP or UE.
Your user name experienced inflation and now includes a 2. Why is that?
Spittin tobaccy only up 10¢!
Make sure to consume Red Man today… skin color is the most important thing when choosing you tobaccy.
In honor of the Native Americans who welcomed the Pilgrims and helped them survive the first winter.
I'm now using an index instead of just spittin' tobacky - the Cheesy-Poof Price Index.
Besides the obvious it contains the current prices of:
Mountain Dew
fryin' grease
a big Mac Meal
porkskins
Bud Light (under review for replacement)
NASCAR tickets
Amazing how ignorant and in denial you are all to protect Joe.
I'm not protecting Joe. He should retire Jan 2024 and go sit in a chair.
No one reads this site - about 100 people a day tops. If you think you are impacting elections you are more delusional than I imagined.
Buttplug swings and connects! I've noticed some delusional posters here who think a handful of reason staffers doomed OBM's re-election by endorsing Biden, or others who think Bill Weld's "endorsement" of Hillary had any impact on the Libertarian vote in 2016. But Buttplug harbors delusions too. For example, he seems to think the typical Democrat voter is an Upper East Side intellectual who meets his friends at a pre-ballet cocktail party in a multi-million dollar condo on Central Park West where they drink Grand Cru Bordeaux and pore over Ta-Nehisi's
latest in the "New York Times." In reality, the typical Democrat voter is lucky to have a GED, be sitting on a stoop outside a crumbling row house, drinking a 40, reading a gossipy tabloid,
thinking Ta-Nehisi is that new rookie the Knicks just brought up, and knows La Sylphide is what you catch when you visit the skanky ho down the corner.
Sadly. Thanks to the [Na]tional So[zi]alist invasion (Democrats) the grocery stores are starting to see empty shelves and supply shortages.
The empty shelves and supply shortages were during Trump. His botched response to the COVID pandemic and his trade wars did that. Libertarians aren't supposed to like trade wars; they produce exactly the results of inflation, empty shelves, and supply shortages. But the Trump Cult isn't Libertarian or even in favor of free markets. It wants corporate welfare on a massive scale.
Wow.... You leftards sure do know how to project. You just described everything Democrats did entirely on their own except tariffs which were implemented YEARS before COVID came.
You, "Everything Democrats do is Trumps fault and every undeniable consequence is a result going back as far as it has to to blame Trump for."
because of course when Democrats got a trifecta there was no such thing as inflation until it couldn't be denied anymore and now that it can't be denied it has to go back to Trumps fault. /s
Ignorant partisan projection 101.
Heck. Stuff in grocery stores is so cheap that Progressives believe that stealing it should not be a crime.
The old five-finger discount. Take as much as you can carry. The first 950 bucks worth is free.
Well said Emma, happy Thanksgiving.
"If we were directed from Washington when to plant and when to sow, we would soon be out of bread."
Fortunately we are still (mostly) free to try to make a buck. "Profit" is a dirty word to leftists, but those who earn the most profit are those who provide the most of what people want, at prices people are willing to pay, while consuming the fewest resources to produce those things.
I am on the Left and I don't have any problem with profits. Or anything else businesses do as long as it is legal. The people who do are on the Right, most notably Ron DeSantis.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=FHiBhzdBCjg
Obligatory
Now remember what they looked like during the Scamdemic, and vow right here and now never to let government pull that kind of garbage ever again.
We don't need 23 different choices of deodorant.
Much better to have the government specify a deodorant suitable for all people and how many resources to allocate to production.
Did I ever tell you all how I once ate a grocery store?
Thanks for the skinny.
"Creamjeff criminal pervert"
I'm going to steal that.
ML, got a question. Does your nation have any antiquity stories about larger people that were more primitive?
Ran across some tales from other nations in the northern prairies that had oral traditions of what may have been contacts and conflicts with neanderthals.
I lived near that Randalls that Yeltsin visited when he came to visit NASA. Fresh produce, low prices and made communism despair.
Yeah, Soviet socialists saw American supermarkets, and thought "Shit, we'd better do something for the people at home". American socialists see American supermarkets and thing, "Shit, we'd better crush this business while milking them for every tax dollar and vote we can get."
Foreign socialists are despaired by the success they can't compete with. Domestic socialists know that success is the enemy to their goals so they undermine it in every way possible.
Don't worry Emma you progressives are working on making grocers as convenient as a big city Wallgreens with all the product behind locked barriers, if there is product at all.
The posh and hipster cocktail party enclaves in urbia will still have uber eats deliver.
Shhhh!...Talk like that might summon Rev. Artie with his flourishing cape.
🙂
😉
Ginormous, GMO'd strawberries in January? Check. Fifty different kinds of soup? Check. Whatever the hell this is? You bet. American grocery stores don't just have "a shocking abundance of food; they have a variety almost completely unknown to humanity."
The same can be said of retail establishments in general, up to and down from Tiffany's diamond glut to the piles of unripe melons at WholeFoods.
At the very same time, they fail to beat the outcry price criterion than makes literlly open markets worth the trip- and the exercise !
Huh?
He is still more tolerable than the hyper-greens who swear off bathing and hair washing in order to praise Gaia.
Fuck off cunt. There is little to no difference in quality among the major brands but when one decides to signal that they hate you it is time to switch.
“If U don’t use Proctor and Gamble products U will B smelly!”
Too bad they’re the only hygiene products manufacturer on earth.
Dummy, you use generics and store brands, which are made in the same factories as name brands and have the same quality, but without paying the Wokesters who sell the name brands and their insulting ad campaigns.
That’s what I did and I am clean, good-smelling, and unavailable to stupid bitches like you.
Yup. The only thing that P&G had going for them was brand recognition and consumer goodwill. It’s like Bud Light: nothing they offer is a superior product, just a comfortable, recognizable one.
I’d been using Old Spice just out of habit because it was what I started using in my teens and never bothered looking for anything different. But it’s not the only product out there.
I wasn’t that confounded by the ad. As I said. It was pretty tame, considering some of the garbage beliefs you find in corporate culture. So if you come out and say the ad was a misfire, no harm done. Defending it and saying the customer alienation was completely worth it for the message, though, does a shit ton more to convey your corporate values than just running a poorly conceived ad.
So the feeling is mutual.
Fuck Off, Karen/Mrs. Grundy/Gladys Kravitz/Nurse Ratched!
Well, the only ones who worship Satan.