'Arbitrary and Capricious': Judge Blocks U.S. From Expelling Migrants Under COVID-Era Title 42 Order
The judge granted the Biden administration a stay, which will keep the policy in place through late December.
Yesterday, Judge Emmet Sullivan of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia vacated a pandemic-era public health order that has allowed border officials under both the Trump and Biden administrations to expedite the expulsion of migrants seeking asylum in the United States. Sullivan ruled that the order wasn't properly enacted and noted that the government's decision to ignore the potential harms of the policy "was arbitrary and capricious."
Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, Trump administration officials invoked the Public Health Service Act, part of Title 42 of the U.S. Code, which authorizes federal officials to control the interstate and international spread of diseases. In late March 2020, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) issued a rule suspending the "introduction" of people from "designated countries or places…in the interest of public health," even if the communicable disease to be mitigated "has already been introduced, transmitted, or is spreading within the United States."
Former CDC Director Robert Redfield extended the Title 42 order for one month and then indefinitely. The Biden administration sometimes fought to keep the order in place and then tried to rescind it, only to be challenged by a federal judge. Though the order applied to people crossing into the U.S. from Canada or Mexico, Title 42 expulsions have overwhelmingly taken place at the U.S.-Mexico border and have primarily affected Mexican and Central American migrants. Migrants expelled under Title 42 aren't allowed the opportunity to plead their asylum claims through processes outlined by longstanding immigration law.
Between March 2020 and August 2022, U.S. border officials carried out over 2 million Title 42 migrant expulsions. Though public health officials argued the order would help prevent the spread of COVID-19 on American soil, a host of medical professionals have since criticized the "junk science" behind that claim. Other critics point to questionable political motives underlying the order. Then–Vice President Mike Pence reportedly pressed Redfield to implement the border-sealing policy despite the CDC chief's initial refusal.
Sullivan found that the CDC failed to apply a standard it had established in 2017 requiring it to impose the "least restrictive means necessary to prevent the spread of disease" in all situations that involve "quarantine, isolation, or other public health measures." It also failed "to acknowledge and explain its departure from past practice." Further, the CDC failed to consider the availability of effective therapeutics and vaccines as it assessed ongoing public health risks, Sullivan ruled.
"It is unreasonable for the CDC to assume that it can ignore the consequences of any actions it chooses to take in the pursuit of fulfilling its goals," wrote Sullivan, "particularly when those actions included the extraordinary decision to suspend the codified procedural and substantive rights of noncitizens seeking safe harbor." Though Sullivan held that the CDC "has considerable flexibility in carrying out its responsibility," he noted that "its decision to ignore that harm could be caused by issuing its Title 42 orders was arbitrary and capricious."
The Biden administration has leaned into Title 42 as a border management tool to respond to border crossings. However, doing away with the order could eliminate some nasty unintended consequences. Because Title 42 is a health measure, immigration officials couldn't impose reentry penalties on the migrants they expelled—and repeat crossings spiked. Excluding repeats, the number of border apprehensions resembled pre-pandemic levels. With no orderly means of requesting asylum—such as processing at ports of entry—migrants congregated around the border, leading to scenes that signaled chaos. Contrary to what Title 42 proponents may say, the policy made migrant arrivals less predictable and manageable.
The Biden administration requested a five-week stay to Sullivan's order, which would keep the Title 42 order in place through late December. Sullivan granted it "WITH GREAT RELUCTANCE." As the policy is phased out, federal officials must restore orderly means of asylum-seeking and build out opportunities for temporary work visas and economic migration—both of which will reduce illegal migration.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
https://twitter.com/AuronMacintyre/status/1592945062803300352?t=Ixi5V5cuQB1J6IwtiguoJw&s=19
It’s not happening but it’s absolutely essential that it is
[Link]
https://twitter.com/greg_price11/status/1592928904112922625?t=lI8sUWzPDPxKRWMktuk3FQ&s=19
Schumer: “We have a population that is not reproducing on its own with the same level that it used to. The only way we’re going to have a great future is if we welcome immigrants… get a path to citizenship for all 11 million [illegal immigrants].”
They say that it’s empowering to stay single forever and never start a family, claim having kids destroys the environment, promote abortion as a moral good, and their solution when they realize people aren’t having enough kids is to import the third world to replace them.
Chuck Schumer has also been in government since the 1980s and helped create the economy of today that makes it virtually impossible for people my age to build wealth and start a family. The man has literally done nothing but preside over America’s decline.
[Video]
They’ve been using that 11 million number for years, never mind that Jao Bai Den has allowed additional millions of undocumented Democrats into the country during his reign of destruction.
I get paid over 190$ per hour working from home with 2 kids at home. I never thought I’d be able to do it but my best friend earns over 10k a month doing this and she convinced me to try. The potential with this is endless. Heres what I’ve been doing..
HERE====)> http://WWW.RICHSALARIES.COM
https://twitter.com/Timcast/status/1592908773768953858?t=m_NCQvniPp-BuRb4y3Qc_Q&s=19
Ha, its real
The “World Government Summit 2022” literally asks “Are you ready for a new world order” and youtube is like “this official and VERIFIED video is a conspiracy”
[Link]
Disinformation! Now that they’re actually doing it, it’s no longer a conspiracy *theory*.
Conspiracy theories become spoiler alerts.
Alphabet feels confused when its masters decide it is time to take off the masks.
‘Arbitrary and Capricious’
I wouldn’t know myself of course but I’ve heard that ‘Arbitrary and Capricious’ was the nickname for the two biggest sluts in my (then) girlfriend’s college dorm. Supposedly, they had a pretty open borders policy too. Or was it a firm, but liberal policy of “Whomever walks in the door.”?
I guess, either way, that’s considered principled by University of Arizona standards.
Chi-O, Chi-O it’s off to bed we go lol
Need to get laid? Tri Delt
“La la la-la la la, sing a happy song. La la la-la la la, smurf the whole day long.” – Arbitrary and Capricious Smurf
Trumpista hardest hit. “Why they steal our places in line to leave the country?!?!”
Make money online from home extra cash more than $18k to $21k. Start getting paid every month Thousands Dollars online. I have received $26K in this month by just working online from home in my part time.
Every person easily do this job by just………>>> onlinecareer1
Funny how you leftists were all for locking down the citizens but were all fine with criminals and illegal aliens roaming free.
★I am making a real GOOD MONEY (123$ / hr ) online from my laptop. Last month I GOT chek of nearly $30k, this online work is simple and straightforward, don’t have to go OFFICE, Its home online job. You become independent after joining this JOB. I really thanks to my FRIEND who refer me this SITE. I hope you also got what I…go to home media tech tab for more detail reinforce your heart.
OPEN>>
https://www.pay.hiring9.com
>>Between March 2020 and August 2022, U.S. border officials carried out over 2 million Title 42 migrant expulsions.
right thing to do if 2 million unqualified immigants are at the door?
HEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEY Abbott, ramp up those caravans to D.C.
How many will you personally fund and house?
You can riot and invade the country during COVID … but NOTHING else!!!!
Why is Reason taking vax propaganda ad money?
Great article, Mike. I appreciate your work, i’m now creating over $35000 dollars each month simply by doing a simple job (knd-07) online! i do know You currently making a lot of greenbacks online from $28000 dollars, its simple online operating jobs.
Just open the link———————————————>>> http://Www.RichApp1.Com
Google pay 200$ per hour my last pay check was $8500 working 1o hours a week online. My younger brother friend has been averaging 12000 for months now and he works about 22 hours a week. I cant believe how easy it was once I tried it outit..
🙂 AND GOOD LUCK.:)
HERE====)> http://WWW.WORKSFUL.COM