Criminal Justice

After Years of Complaints, the D.C. Jail Has Been Deemed Too Wretched for Some Inmates

A 2016 Reason story detailed the D.C. Jail's long history of failure. Now the federal government is finally paying attention.

|

The U.S. Marshals Service announced Tuesday that it was transferring roughly 400 inmates out of the D.C. Jail due to unacceptable living conditions that reportedly included water and food being withheld as punishment.

In a press release, the Marshals Service said it found conditions at one of the D.C. Jail's two main facilities "do not meet the minimum standards of confinement as prescribed by the Federal Performance-Based Detention Standards." The people incarcerated there will be transferred to a federal prison in Pennsylvania.

The move follows years—more than a century, really—of complaints and reports from civil liberties groups about the wretched state of the D.C. Jail, which holds all pre-trial detainees and misdemeanor offenders in the District of Columbia. But the jail has been under more scrutiny as of late because it's holding defendants being prosecuted for their role in the January 6 Capitol Building riot.

In a letter from acting U.S. Marshal Lamont Ruffin to the director of the D.C. Department of Corrections, obtained by The Washington Post, Ruffin said investigators conducting a surprise inspection of the D.C. Jail on the week of October 18 found that it appeared water and food were withheld from inmates as punishment. 

"The water in many of the cells within South 1 and North 1 had been shut off for days, inhibiting detainees from drinking water, washing hands, or flushing toilets," Ruffin wrote.

As a result, many of the toilets were filled with standing sewage. "The smell of urine and feces was overpowering in several areas," Ruffin continued.

Inspectors also observed medical neglect and correctional officers bullying inmates into not cooperating with the inspection. "One DOC staffer was observed telling a detainee to 'stop snitching,'" the letter says.

Notably, the Marshals Service did not find substandard living conditions in the D.C. Jail's Central Treatment Facility, the housing unit that is currently holding all of the Jan. 6 defendants. Rather, the conditions were all observed in the Central Detention Facility.

The Jan. 6 defendants, and their many supporters in conservative media and Republican politics, have claimed that they are political prisoners being held in appalling conditions for mostly nonviolent crimes and low-level charges. For example, Tucker Carlson called the D.C. lockup "one of the foulest detention centers in the country… a truly repulsive, mismanaged place."

A week before the October inspection, U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth held the D.C. Department of Corrections in contempt for repeatedly failing to turn over the medical records of one Jan. 6 defendant, Christopher Worrell, who had been waiting for months for a scheduled wrist surgery. Lamberth also referred the matter to the Justice Department to investigate whether inmates' civil rights were being violated.

The truth is that those are the conditions under which D.C. residents have been regularly incarcerated. It's just an issue that didn't bother anyone on the FOX News primetime lineup until recently.

The antiquated jail, opened in the 1970s, has numerous structural problems. The air conditioning system barely works, leaving staff and incarcerated people to swelter during the summer. It broke earlier this year, and in 2016 the department had to move 200 inmates because of excessive heat. That same year, the department had to move inmates again because of roof leaks. A 2015 report found the facility was plagued by mold, vermin, and leaking.

Those problems became even more acute during the COVID-19 lockdowns, when jail inmates were held in their cells for 23 hours at a time.

"For years, the Public Defender Service for the District of Columbia, along with other legal and grass-roots organizations, has called out and challenged the D.C. Department of Corrections for its horrific treatment of nearly exclusively black and brown people detained at the D.C. Jail," The D.C. Public Defender service said in a statement. "The inhumane conditions have included long-term solitary confinement for people with no disciplinary issues, lack of running water, full illumination of cells for 24-hours per day resulting in sleep deprivation, cells soiled with feces and blood, lack of air conditioning during the summer and heat during the winter, lack of proper medical care, failure to provide mental health treatment, and physical and mental abuse by correctional officers of people in their custody."

In 2016, I wrote a cover story for Reason about the long, ignominious history of the D.C. Jail and its repeated failures to meet the low bar of basic human decency. I could cite any number of historical comments from disgusted observers, going all the way back to 1861, but here's the late U.S. District Court Judge William Bryant, who ruled in 1976 that the conditions inside the D.C. Jail violated the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment:

"For imprisonment under such conditions," Bryant wrote, "where a man may be stuffed into a tiny cell with another, surrounded by the nocturnal moans or screams of mentally disturbed but untreated fellow inmates, plagued by rats and roaches, sweltering by summer and shivering by winter, unable to maintain significant contact with his family in the outside world, sometimes going for long periods without real exercise or recreation, can only have one message for him: Society does not acknowledge your existence as a fellow human being. And when that message is delivered in the D.C. Jail, whatever small chance may have existed that a person might act as though he were a member of a civilized society is obliterated, along with his decency and humanity."

NEXT: Cops Arrested Her for Exercising Her First Amendment Rights. They Got Qualified Immunity—but the Appeals Court Wasn't Having It.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. Does that mean that the political prisoners will be released?

    1. Despite the remonstrations of one Federal judge, slowly via verdicts such as misdemeanor disorderly conduct.

      1. Seriously I don’t know why more people haven’t tried this, I work two shifts, 2 hours in the day and 2 in the evening…FhOL And i get surly a check of $12600 what’s awesome is I m working from home so I get more time with my kids.

        Try it, you won’t regret it.... READ MORE

    2. The living conditions are fine for those accused of the horrific crime of trespassing.

    3. These are 2 pay checks $78367 and $87367. that i received in last 2 months. I am very happy that i can make thousands in my part time and now i am enjoying my life. Everybody can do this and earn lots of dollars from home in very short time period.THf Your Success is one step away Click Below Webpage…..

      Just visit this website now.......... Pays 24

    4. Sarah getting Paid upto $18953 in the week, working on-line at home. I’m Student. I shocked when my sister’s told me about her check that was $97k. It’s very easy to do.GYj Everybody will get this job. Go to home media tab for additional details……

      So I started.............. E-CASH

  2. Fake news. Democrats run DC’s government and would never let this happen.

  3. But not wretched enough for those horrible trespassers that wandered around the halls of Congress.

  4. >>the January 6 Capitol Building riot

    honesty in jornolism important

  5. Withheld water and food .
    That's not a living condition, that's an issue relating to power over people and the culture it produces. I'm sure the living conditions are poor, but it's people, i.e. government officials and employees, that cause and let it fester.

  6. After years of complaints, DC has been deemed too wretched for most.

  7. To insure that the prisoners are treated fairly and humanely, we should transport all of them to just south of the border, and let them cross illegally. $450,000 should fix them up nicely.

    1. Save the DC prison space for anyone in the government proposing anything illegal, like spying on everyone's bank accounts.

  8. Because they suck at EVERYTHING.

  9. Difference between local prisoners and protestors is that the locals voted for this shit.

    1. Yep. Didn’t expect that “Your brain’s not fully formed until you’re 25” wouldn’t actually keep them out of jail for violent crime.

  10. "It's just an issue that didn't bother anyone on the FOX News primetime lineup until recently."

    Apparently, not many other large media concerns did, either, if they do even now.

    1. You'd think CJ would appreciate the media attention on the highest rated cable news network. Nah.

  11. Huh, so the Kyle Rittenhouse prosecutor just admitted that the protests weren't peaceful, and in fact were very violent.

    That's quite a turnaround.

    1. He's been a better advocate for self-defense than the defense has been, because Richards has been pretty wretched. I've never even been to lawschool and I noticed the repeated failure to object on basic bitch stuff yesterday. The prosecutor got a cop up on the stand and allowed the cop to introduce into evidence all the videos he'd found on the internet, without laying any foundation for how the officer was aware of the truth or the context of any of the videos, and the prosecutor was basically testifying instead of the cop!

      It was a shit-show for such a highly publicized trial.

  12. Another false story, the only problems in prisons occur in private prisons

  13. No mention of Nathan DeGrave's letter? That seems like a major omission.
    I saw it on Twitter first, but it's reprinted in its entirety here at The Last Refuge.

  14. "The truth is that those are the conditions under which D.C. residents have been regularly incarcerated. It's just an issue that didn't bother anyone on the FOX News primetime lineup until recently."

    It apparently didn't bother anyone on NBC, ABC, CBS, CNN, MSNBC, The Washington Post, The New York Times.........

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.