Food Freedom

Judge's Ruling Means Foie Gras Is Back in California

California residents can now legally buy foie gras online from out-of-state suppliers

|

Last week a federal court in California handed a partial victory to the parties suing the state over its wrongheaded and unconstitutional ban on the sale of foie gras. Eater called the ruling "a major win" for the plaintiffs, who include a Canadian group that represents foie gras producers there and New York State's Hudson Valley Foie Gras.

Foie gras is a French delicacy made from a duck or goose liver that has been fattened using a process known as gavage. While some animal-rights activists claim gavage is cruel, many consumers, restaurateurs, and foie gras producers say the feeding process is not at all cruel.

The battle over foie gras in California has been a long and arduous one. The day after California's ban took effect in 2012, the plaintiffs sued, as I first detailed here. The case has been winding its way through the courts ever since. (I've taken an active role in fighting the ban, writing and submitting a U.S. Supreme Court amicus brief on behalf of the Reason Foundation—which publishes Reason—and the Cato Institute in 2018.)

In his order last week, Judge Stephen V. Wilson of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California granted the plaintiffs' motion for summary judgment on the plaintiffs' narrow question of whether the state ban applies to shipments and deliveries of foie gras inside California that are made as a result of an out-of-state purchase of foie gras. In its ruling, the court also rejected a pair of competing claims by the plaintiffs and defendant—rejecting the state's motion to dismiss the case and the plaintiffs' request to rule the California law violates the dormant Commerce Clause.

This month's "confusing" ruling holds that, under California law, sales are legal when an out-of-state seller sells foie gras that is not physically in California at the time of sale and the transaction and payment are processed outside the state (e.g., online). The ruling means a person in California may, for example, buy foie gras from an online seller based outside California and have that foie gras delivered to them legally in California by a third-party delivery service such as FedEx.

The court stated the obvious: that the state has no authority to regulate sales that take place outside its borders. The court also ruled California's foie gras ban was not intended to ban foie gras. "There is no evidence that California intended to completely ban the receipt or possession of foie gras in California, and there is ample evidence that this was not California's intent," the court determined.

Marcus Henley, vice president of Hudson Valley Foie Gras, one of the plaintiffs in the case, tells me he's thrilled with this week's ruling.

"We are gratified that the Court recognized that California's misguided ban was never intended to apply to foie gras products from out-of-state producers that are shipped to happy consumers in California," Henley says by email.

Others are, too.

"For 50 years, Reason has proudly supported Free Minds and Free Markets," says California-based attorney Manny Klausner, a former editor of Reason and Reason Foundation co-founder and board member who joined me in submitting the aforementioned amicus brief. "Judge Wilson's ruling is a limited, yet meaningful, judgment in support of the economic liberty of California consumers and out-of-state sellers—and is truly a delicious development for anyone who takes liberty seriously."

Exactly how limited is Judge Wilson's ruling? And how might it impact restaurants in California?

"Of course, once the foie gras reaches California, it cannot be resold within the state, even if the transaction processes 'out of state' via an explicit agreement or otherwise," Judge Wilson writes in his ruling. Elsewhere, he notes a legal sale of foie gras to a person in California "does not encompass situations wherein the Seller is present in California during the sale, or the foie gras is already present in California when the sale is made."

While that language makes the law's stance on in-state restaurant sales sound pretty airtight, the ruling may have made some existing wiggle room a little more spacious.

For example, some restaurants in California that oppose the law have challenged it over the years by giving away foie gras to diners as part of a meal. Even one foie gras opponent suggested this week's ruling could revive that practice. Though a previous court ruling said such gifts constitute an illegal "sale" of foie gras in California, this month's ruling, which also turns on what constitutes a "sale" of foie gras, could provide an opening for California restaurants. I wouldn't be surprised if some are already consulting with their attorneys. Another possibility, which appears even more promising, involves a situation "where customers bring in their own foie gras and pay a chef to prepare it." Other ideas come to mind, too.

Regardless of whether these or other exceptions will allow California restaurants to serve foie gras legally—coupled with the fact the COVID-19 pandemic has forced top restaurants in the state to close temporarily or even permanently—fine dining is in trouble in California and across the country. Many cities and states, including California, have relaxed pointless prohibitions that harm consumers and businesses.

Could California lawmakers use that solid line of reasoning to decide their state should no longer be the only one in America that bans foie gras sales? Of course. Should they? By all means. Will they? Probably not.

For the plaintiffs, that means their decade-long fight against California's foie gras ban continues.

"We look forward to continuing our efforts to correct California's mistake," Hudson Valley Foie Gras's Henley tells me.

Advertisement

NEXT: Adult Daughter Who Relies on "Faith-Based Medicine" Loses Guardianship Over Intellectually Disabled Mother

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. ?Earning money online is very easy nowdays. Eanrs every month online more than $17k by doing very easy home based job in part time. Last month i have made $19754 from this job just in my spare time which is only 2 hrs a day. Very easy work to do and earning from this are awesome. Click For Full Detail.

    1. Making Cash more than $15k to $18k consistently just by doing basic online work. I have gotten $18376 a month ago just by working on the web. Its a simple and basic occupation to do from home and its profit are greatly improved than customary office work. Each individual can join this activity now just by pursue this link……..go to this site home media tech tab for more detail support your hear Here══════❥❥❥❥USA Dollars.com

  2. “The court stated the obvious: that the state has no authority to regulate sales that take place outside its borders.”

    So the proposed New York tax on ALL stock transactions is going down?

    1. Google easily work and google pays me every hour and every week just $5K to $8K for doing online work from home. I am a universty student and I work on my part time just 2 to 3 hours a day easily from home. Now every one can earn extra cash for doing online home system and make a good life by just open this website and follow instructions on this page…

      ►══════► Online Income Websites

    2. You would hope but then again NY politics is lunacy and may find there is no reason the exchanges need to stay in NY. Imagine one of them moving and advertising investment returns improved by no NY taxes.

  3. Do libertarians oppose animal cruelty laws in their entirety?

    If not, I fail to see how this one is irrational, even if you don’t agree with the specifics.

    “I oppose animal cruelty except when it is tasty” doesn’t seem like a bedrock foundation of libertarianism.

    1. Every time you brush your teeth, or eat anything other than the softest food or liquids, you are mass-murdering the bacteria (and other micro-denizens) in your mouth! Sending them, in their millions, to be cruelly dissolved in stomach acids! You mass murderer you!

      On the other hand… I can see that the above-described decision is good for neither the goose, nor the gander! It means that our goose is cooked!

      We need to become fully enlightened, and subsist on air alone! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inedia

      Inedia (Latin for ‘fasting’) or breatharianism /brɛθˈɛəriənɪzəm/ is the belief that it is possible for a person to live without consuming food, and in some cases water.

    2. Foie Gras is NOT animal cruelty.
      Read this and try again.

      1. Exactly. Cruelty is a judgement call in many cases. Animal rights nutbars would draw the line of cruelty at even touching animals, let alone eating them for food.

  4. Right now there is a goose in Canada choking for your sins.

    1. Make 6,000 dollar to 8,000 dollar A Month Online With No Prior Experience Or Skills Required. Be Your Own Boss AndChoose Your Own Work Hours.Thanks A lot Here>>>ReadMore.

      1. Doing what? Strangling geese?

        1. Don’t you know how they make foie gras?

          Deliciousness isn’t pretty.

          1. Yes, do you? Read this.

  5. Well maybe this will reach the Supreme Court and Gorsuch can give part of California back to the native tribes who have long disappeared.

    Defund California!

  6. I would also like to take this opportunity to point out that geese are dicks.

    1. Hey, every dick deserves some choking.

    2. If geese are dicks, then what are ducks? And what are docks?

      1. Well I don’t know.

        Classic Groucho and Chico bit.

        Hammer: (pause) Well, we’ll Passover that…You’re a peach, boy. Now, here is a little peninsula, and, eh, here is a viaduct leading over to the mainland.

        Chico: Why a duck?

        Hammer: I’m alright, how are you? I say, here is a little peninsula, and here is a viaduct leading over to the mainland.

        Chico: Alright, why a duck?

        Hammer: (pause) I’m not playing “Ask Me Another,” I say that’s a viaduct.

        Chico: Alright! Why a duck? Why that…why a duck? Why a no chicken?

        Hammer: Well, I don’t know why a no chicken; I’m a stranger here myself. All I know is that it’s a viaduct. You try to cross over there a chicken and you’ll find out why a duck.

        Chico: When I go someplace I just…

        Hammer: (interrupts) It’s…It’s deep water, that’s why a duck. It’s deep water.

        Well there you have it.

        So what is this stuff, chopped liver? Around here there is a deli that makes a chopped liver and pastrami sandwich on thick sliced rye bread. Side of cole slaw and a pickle. You never ate that good. The only people complaining about it are the cardiologists. They are having the latkes and corned beef so pay them no attention.

        Look be kind to the animals before you kill and eat them. I really mean that.

    3. Geese are total dicks, especially the Canadian ones. Which is weird, considering that their human counterparts are pretty chill.

    4. Geese are evil.

    5. Goose story time.

      I work for a company of several thousand people, we have 2 main campuses on the east coast but have people all over the country. One of our campuses had a problem with Canadian geese hanging out and harassing people as they tried to get into the building. Our solution was to get a dog (it had an employee number and everything), and the dog would go out each morning and chase the geese away. It was trained only to chase, not to hurt the geese.

      Well one day during winter someone decided it was “too cold” for the dog to go do his job. The geese now had free reign to harass employees as they crossed the icy parking lot.

      Our company had a site on our intranet where employees could go to post questions anonymously, and someone in leadership would have to answer them. Someone took the opportunity to ask “I know there’s a policy against bringing guns to work, is there any policy that prohibits me from killing these geese with my bare hands?”

      This generated A LOT of responses, from people horrified that someone would consider doing it to people discussing the best methods to murder a goose with your bare hands. Someone even suggested getting a mechanized dog. The official response was that no policy about goose murder currently existed, but please do not make HR write one up.

  7. Every month start earning more cash from $20,000 to $24,000 by working very simple j0b 0nline from home. I have earned last month $23159 from this by just doing this 0nline w0rk for maximum 3 to 4 hrs a day using my laptop. This home j0b is just awesome and regular earning from this are much times better than other regular 9 to 5 desk j0b. Now every person on this earth can get this j0b and start making dollars 0nline just by follow instructions on the given web page>>>Click Here For Full Detail.

  8. Canadian geese deserve it

    1. “I do not like the cobra chicken.”

  9. Considering how many Americans, maybe even some Californians, have fatty liver disease from over eating it is hardy cruel to stop foie gras. Maybe when the end time comes we can have soylent foie gras.

  10. STAY HOME AND STARTING WORK AT HOME EASILY.? MORE AND MORE EARNING DAILY BY JUST FOLLOW THESE STEPS, I am a student and i work daily on this site and earn money..Go this site home media tech tab for more details thanks you.CLICK HERE══════►► USA TODAY  

  11. nice post stay at home

  12. The court stated the obvious: that the state has no authority to regulate sales that take place outside its borders.

    So I imagine that I’ll soon be able to buy ammo online and have it shipped to me in California.

  13. Weird ruling. Seems like the court revived the long-rejected original package doctrine.

  14. What is it, some kind of fancy pants chopped liver?

    C’mon. If you are ever in the neighborhood I’ll show you chopped liver. There is a deli not far from here that will make you a chopped liver and corned beef sandwich on real rye bread that will spoil you for life. I like it with sliced onion and mustard. Unless it gives you a heart attack but what is life for anyway.

    1. Oops forgot I posted that already. Food articles make me think about food.

Please to post comments