New York Spent a Record $1.1 Billion on Jail Last Year, and Got Even More Violence


Photo credit: Gìpics / Foter / CC BY-NC-ND

New York City's criminal justice system continues to have severe problems. Rikers Island prison, New York City's primary jail facility, has more staff and fewer inmates than in previous years—and yet it also has sky-high costs and increasing levels of violence, according to a forthcoming comptroller's report reviewed in an article in The New York Times.

The cost is higher than ever, and way out of proportion with comparable urban areas. The City of New York spent $1.1 billion to run its jails last year, a record sum, according to the report.

Housing a prisoner for a year in New York cost the city's Corrections Department $100,000 last fiscal year. That's a huge increase from a few years ago, and much higher than in other major metro jail systems. As the Times notes, the cost "is 42 percent higher than seven years ago and more than twice the amount spent per inmate by correction departments in other large cities like Chicago and Los Angeles."

Those cities have larger jail populations but significantly lower costs per person housed:

New York spends far more on its jails than other large American cities, even those with much larger inmate populations. Los Angeles, for instance, has an inmate population of nearly 19,000, about 7,000 more than New York. But taxpayers there spend only $44,965 a year per inmate, nearly half what New Yorkers spend, according to the report. 

But the skyrocketing costs haven't resulted in a more peaceful prison system. In fact, the city's jails have become even uglier even as spending has ramped up. During the fiscal year that ended in June, the Times says, "there was a 124 percent increase in assaults on the staff by inmates at city jails, and triple the number of allegations of use of physical force by guards."

The violence at Rikers is horrific, and the city has tried to hide it from public view. A July report from The New York Times is chilling:

[The Times] found that over an 11-month period last year, 129 inmates suffered "serious injuries" — ones beyond the capacity of doctors at the jail's clinics to treat — in altercations with correction department staff members. The report cataloged in exacting detail the severity of injuries suffered by inmates: fractures, wounds requiring stitches, head injuries and the like.

The report was based on information that the city health department refused to make public. 

Union representatives for prison guards have long argued that the solution is more guards. And it's true that the number of guards in the city's jail system has declined somewhat, from about 9,200 in 2007 to 8,922 this year.

But those guards are also tasked with guarding a declining prison population, and so the ratio of guards to prisoners has actually increased by 19 percent, according to the report. In other words, each guard now has fewer prisoners than ever to look after.

That hasn't helped. According to the Times, "a vast majority of the cost in New York, about 85 percent, goes to pay for personnel." Much of the excess spending can be attributed to overtime, which is apparently not being limited the way it's supposed to.

The improved staffing and lower inmate population have somehow produced a counterintuitive result, translating into a rise in overtime costs to $139 million in 2014 from $101 million in 2007, the report said.

Correction Department regulations are supposed to limit the amount of overtime a guard can work to 57 hours a month. But Elizabeth Crowley, a City Council member who oversees corrections, said that some officers worked as much as 80 hours a month. 

Scott Stringer, the comptroller who put together the report, was blunt when he spoke to the Times about the situation in the city's jails, saying: "We're spending more money on inmates and we're getting worse results."

NEXT: Friday Funnies: Groupies

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. Overtime in the DoC isn’t mandated by number of prisoners. It’s mandated by the number of guard stations at the facilities. Because procedure says Prison X must have Y guards on duty at all times, and the number of guards has dropped without a policy change, the existing guards are given more hours so that there are always Y guards on duty.

    The number of prisoners has nothing to do with that policy.

    1. Disclaimer – This was merely an informational statement about how the bureaurcracy works. You go arguing with the Prison Guards’ Union about the overtime and they’ll rail at you about “Mandated Staffing Levels”. So hit the policy makers who mandate staffing levels, and perhaps the design of the prisons proper.

      1. None of this nonsense will get fixed until the money train derails.

        1. The run the printing presses. 🙁

          1. When you get to that point, the money train has derailed…

        2. So what you’re saying is that the whole throwing more money at a problem isn’t fixing and won’t fix it? Shocking!

  2. Wait till they put those ‘big soda’ people in there.Don’t for get the ‘life style’ crimes too

    1. They use “Big Soda” people for currency in prison.

      And by “they” I mean the prison guards as much as the prisoners. 🙁

  3. I marvel at it all. New York government – a model for the world.

    1. Yes, a shining example of what not to do.

  4. Spending more money while getting worse results seems to be par for the course among America’s political class.

    1. That’s only because you don’t understand that it even requires more money. And if that doesn’t fix it or creates problems of its own, the answer is spend even more. It’s a well known fact that not spending enough government money causes problems that only government spending can fix.

  5. “We’re spending more money on inmates and we’re getting worse results.”

    Unpossible! I have been told repeatedly by shrill progs that more spending solves all problems, even the problem of spending too much.

    1. They’ve shrilly told me that this is 100% the fault of the private-prison industry. Government is both omnibenevolent and infallible, dontcha know.

  6. Imagine if they took all that money they were spending on criminals and spent it on SCHOOLS!


  7. Those cities have larger jail populations but significantly lower costs per person housed

    Economies of scale.

    WTF?? Are we asking NYC to jail more people to make their cost rates look better? Because they sure as fuck aren’t going to cut employees – even if cutting employees would reduce the violence.

  8. So tear down the prisons and build gallows. Capital punishment for all violent crime.

    That’ll stop all your whining.

  9. Perhaps if New York would ease its restrictions on the ability of law abiding citizens to exercise their Second Amendment rights to carry concealed weapons then-as statistically proven empirical evidence supports-the crime rate will drop and perhaps more criminals will come under the DSAF rule by an armed citizenry.

    DSAF=Did society a favor

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.