$250,000 a Day: That's the Fine the Feds Threatened Yahoo With for Resisting Data Demands


Today, on Tumblr, Yahoo's general counsel announced that 1,500 pages of classified documents related to the company's fight against federal government demands to provide user data are in the process of being made public.
Yahoo resisted in 2008—but lost—when the federal government and National Security Agency (NSA) broadly demanded they provide information about its users without a court review for each target. They ultimately became one of the tech companies that joined PRISM, the mass metadata surveillance program exposed by Edward Snowden. Until last year, we didn't even know that Yahoo was the company who fought them, and though the documents aren't all out yet, Yahoo's lawyer gave us all an indicator of how menacing and threatening the feds were: "At one point, the U.S. Government threatened the imposition of $250,000 in fines per day if we refused to comply." The brief Tumblr post does not indicate where that number came from or by what authority such fines could be ordered. Slate explained last year the complexities of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court trying to assign contempt charges to anybody who resisted them here.
The Washington Post has a story here and Yahoo will be updating its Tumblr feed with links to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court documents as they become available.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
"At one point, the U.S. Government threatened the imposition of $250,000 in fines per day if we refused to comply."
"How many times must we tell you? Those drives were *destroyed*!"
"Yo massa! You can suck...my...DICK. Suck my motherfuckin' DICK!"
*WHACK*
"AAAAAGH!!!"
/Eddie Murphy
They did it to protect Our Freedom. How could you object to this; on 9/11 of all days!
/adjusts American flag pin and salutes
The Feds' thuggery just keeps on getting shown to be more than you ever imagined.
A spiked iron gauntlet concealed by a silk glove.
So true. Who is the government?
by what authority such fines could be ordered.
The authority vested in the NSA.
By....
The NSA of course.
Silly Boy.
By this fully operational death star
Thumbs
On that basis, I would say that it is known.
It's from the FYTW authority.
We should pass this acronym down to Amash and see if he can rig up a FYTW congressional panel. If anyone would be game for trolling the statists, it would be him.
Fuck Yahoo That's Why?
The original visionaries that brought us fascism are turning over in th
The original visionaries that brought us fascism are turning over in their graves. Why would government have to threaten businessmen to get them to cooperate? I mean, seriously people, what the actual f---?
Fuck YOOOOOOOOO-ooo-wooo!
+1 yodel
This is why it's so important to pass, err, regulate net neutrality. So that the government will have one more weapon to protect us from big companies.
Look, terrorists use yahoo mail. The NSA had to collect all of their mail because until they had read it all, they didn't know who was a terrorist! Duh! Once they discovered other criminal acts while looking for terrorists, what are they supposed to do?! Ignore crime?!
Only 250K a day? Google should have told them to F off, and paid the fines. I guess Yahoo doesn't have that kind of coin though.
Don't forget the threat of jail time for talking about it or protesting
$250,000 a Day: That's the Fine the Feds Threatened Yahoo With for Resisting Data Demands
This is even worse than the shit the EPA (I would say "tries", but...) pulls.
No sympathy! These pukes supported the Obama regime, falsely believing they'd be spared the broad powers they endorsed. Payback's a bitch, Yahoos!
To be fair, and I hate defending the guy at all, but Obama wasnt president in 08.
And to be fair, it would appear that their collaboration with our benevolent overlords came to be under business crippling duress.
My Yahoo email works slowly sometimes. Is that because I have a lot of messages or because the internet police are punishing them?
#iamdouglass
Where's the asshole craig to tell us about how dangerous businesses are?
Maybe yahoo will change their tune after supporting all these dictators, and be a new champion of freedom and liberty. Though I doubt this will happen.
No matter how many different ways they try and make spotted dick and potatoes.....it always winds up being a dicktater.
So I hope yahoo suffers from the pain of every inch of the dicktaters they helped create.
The brief Tumblr post does not indicate where that number came from or by what authority such fines could be ordered.
"That law is classified, sir. You're not allowed to know what it says. But you are expected to comply with it. And ignorance of the law is no excuse."