Wrong-House Raid Victim: 'I See a Flashing Light and a Gun Pointed To My Head'
The sheriff's office has apologized-for its mistake, not its tactics.


The sheriff's office in Madison County, Florida, executed a raid on a mobile home early yesterday morning. The residents woke up scared and confused to the sight of cops with guns drawn. A sixteen-year-old boy was immediately handcuffed.
It was the wrong house.
From WCTV:
"I just kept hearing something, like a loud noise. I felt as if I was just dreaming," said mother Laretta McCaskill. "Then, once I woke up, I'd seen a flashing light and a gun pointed to my head, just cops yelling, 'hold your hands up, hold your hands up! Put your hands up!'"
According to the McCaskill family, the Madison County Sheriff's Office knocked down their door, entered their home and handcuffed their 16-year-old nephew at 5 a.m. Wednesday morning.
"They told me, turn around. Turn around, turn around," said Terrance Coleman, the nephew of the McCaskill's. "And put my hands behind my back. So, he had snatched me off the bed and put me in the living room. So, I came in here and there were guns pointed and me and my cousin. I just feel like they had misplaced me with somebody else."
That's exactly what had happened. Police were looking for Tommy Turner, a suspected drug dealer living next door. At some point in the process of obtaining a warrant, officers recorded the wrong address.
The McCaskills say they are traumatized but will try to move on. They are lucky, of course, that nothing worse happened. After all, plenty can go wrong when cops break into homes and point guns in people's faces while they are sleeping and disoriented.
The sheriff's office has apologized—for its mistake, not its tactics.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Maybe they should have thought of that before living next door to a suspected drug dealer.
Or don't live someplace with retarded incompetent cops. Wait... nevermind.
Kid is just lucky he wasn't holding the TV remote or something.
Did the cops pay to fix the doors, windows and furniture that they no doubt smashed on their way in?
Haaaaaaaaaaa ha ha ha ha ha ha!
"According to the McCaskill family, the Madison County Sheriff's Office knocked down their door"
They will get right on paying for, or fixing that door.
*joins sarc in laughter*
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
"You better fix that thing or someone could rob you."
/cop on the way out
+1 Res Burg
Seriously, why isn't there a code enforcement officer tagging along after these raids to cite people for having busted doors and windows? It's almost like municipalities are willfully ignoring the revenue potential.
It's almost like municipalities are willfully ignoring the revenue potential.
Not to mention legal justification. Sure you went into the wrong house looking for drugs, but you really did the community a favor when, while smashing open walls to search for drugs, you discovered the unlicensed homeowner wired up several ceiling fans using 20 gauge NM when he should've used 12 gauge ABX without a permit.
I mean, with all those code violations, you could cause a housing bubble.
Getting the address wrong -- not on the warrant paper work, but going to the wrong physical address should be prima facie evidence that the officers swore out a false warrant. If they don't know where the guy lives, how can they know what sort of drugs he's dealing from that place?
If they don't know where the guy lives, how can they know what sort of drugs he's dealing from that place?
Ooh! Ooh! I know this one!
If I were a LEO in the employ of a suspected drug dealer, one of the things that I might do to protect him (and my off-the-books pay) is write down the wrong address in a warrant.
In my city, it's pretty common that the search teams are specialized (i.e. just do searches all the time) and know nothing about the actual case other than what they get in briefing right beforehand. One detective on the actual case may tag along or show up during the search.
I live in a middle-middle class neighborhood. For the first four years, the young 20-something across the street was known for dealing drugs (out of his car/garage). There's no doubt that the local authorities were aware of his entrepreneurial actions. Perhaps as an elitist aside, the family was definitively white-trash who somehow managed to get into the neighborhood, not some reasonably well heeled family whose kid was experimenting and cutting other middle class kids in to pay for the habit.
While I disliked some of the people one could see running through the neighborhood, especially since I had two young kids, my bigger worry was that, some night, the authorities would decide to a flash-bang raid - on my house. As my neighborhood is laid out, there are only two houses on the corner of X and Y (or Y and X depending on which street the house faced), mine and the drug-house across the street. I had more overall fear from the possible stupidity of the gendarmes than I had from the kid next door or his patrons. There's something wrong when, of the two oblique fears between criminals and the LEO, I fear the LEO's more. The worst that could happen is a stray bullet from a deal gone bad from across the street. Ten hyped up LEO's, with a bad sense of direction, stood as a much greater worry, and more likely too. Both small in probability, but I dreaded the stomp of booted feet at 2 in the morning more than stray slug hurtling its way at the swing set at 2 in the afternoon.
Just put a sign in your front yard: NOT THE DRUG DEALER'S HOUSE
I keep saying that Rambo school should include a half day seminar on house identification taught by pizza delivery guys.
Alternatively, they could be taught driving routes by Thelma & Louise.
Police were looking for Tommy Turner,
Why didn't they bring Beulah Ballbricker on the raid to identify him by his penis?
*slow clap
The McCaskills say they are traumatized but will try to move on.
A benefit to living in a mobile home.
Mobile homes are only mobile before you live in them.
Saw a video of a 6 or 7 member SWAT stacking into a single-wide. Instant reaction was "reverse clown car."
It's actually m?-b?l, as in Mobile, Alabama. That's where prefabricated homes were first widely manufactured back in the 1950's.
Where's Road to Mandalay when you need him? Cuz this is surely way more uplifting than allowing people to use substances they want to use.