Lawsuit Accuses Cops of Rape, Florida Police Department of Habitually Ignoring Complaints


Two women are suing the city of Lauderhill, Florida and two police officers, Franklin Hartley and Thomas Merenda for an alleged rape for which the two cops, on unpaid administrative leave, are already facing criminal charges. They allege in their lawsuit that the police department "hires violent and dangerous individuals as police officers" and regularly fails to investigative complaints about cops.
What's being alleged, via The Sun Sentinel:
According to the lawsuit, the women had drinks at the Vegas Cabaret strip club on University Drive in Lauderhill and left when it closed at 4 a.m. Within minutes, Hartley pulled them over in a Taco Bell drive-through in Tamarac.
After taking the driver's vehicle registration and insurance documents, the lawsuit says Hartley ordered the women to follow him and led them to the back of a closed tire shop at 7300 West Commercial Blvd. Moments later, Merenda showed up in his patrol car.
Hartley took Jane Doe 1 to the front of his vehicle and under threat of arrest ordered her to perform oral sex and then raped her, the lawsuit says.
Merenda, according to the suit, remained with the driver at the rear of his vehicle and "engaged her in [bizarre] conversations about his family, wife and marital problems."
After the rape, the suit alleges that the officers swapped women and fondled their breasts and genitalia.
GPS data shows that both patrol cars remained at the location for more than 90 minutes, according to the suit.
According to the lawsuit, the two officers were the target of another suit in 2012 over an alleged false arrest which was settled for $75,000 and never led to any disciplinary actions. The lawsuit also lists four other cops lawyers accuse the department of not disciplining appropriately in their attempt to show the department's pattern of not holding officers accountable for their actions.
Hartley and Merenda face felony charges of unlawful compensation and a misdemeanor charge of battery—the officers are also accused in the criminal complaint of coercing one of the women to punch Merenda in the genitals, because apparently he liked nut punches.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Unpaid administrative leave? Holy crap, this is serious punishment!
(and I thought liking nutpunches was a normal thing. Why else would anyone visit this website?)
..."hires violent and dangerous individuals as police officers" and regularly fails to investigative complaints about cops.
Gasp.
apparently he liked nut punches
I'm sure there are a number of people happy to arrange that for him.
With a spiked metal glove, holding brass knuckles?
Orrr...
because apparently he liked nut punches.
I was gonna say 'Self hating Balko fan?'
Lawsuit Accuses Cops of Rape, Florida Police Department of Habitually Ignoring Complaints
It's not like cops are violent sociopaths like college men are.
Typical of Florida police the shitheads outnumber the decent cops here by a vast majority.
Typical of Florida all police the shitheads outnumber the decent cops here everywhere by a vast majority.
FIFY
Hartley and Merenda face felony charges of unlawful compensation and a misdemeanor charge of battery
But not, you will note, rape or any other sexual assault offense.
It must be pretty sweet to be on the right side of that double standard. One that the police department, DA, grand jury, and judges are happy to apply.
And it's just another example of how even if you purposefully avoid any kind of interaction with the cops, they might just find you anyway.
Those poor policemen.
Meanwhile, in Bozeman, a sheriff's deputy received a suspended sentence (to be wiped out if stays out of trouble for six whole months) for beating up a teenage girl at the jail. Because he's a basically good person, in a stressful job. So if some girl less than half your age sasses you, deck her. You deserve to blow off a little steam, once in a while.
One of the rapists has previously been spotted in Milwaukee and New York
He is known for frequent group rape attempts
He is considered extremely dangerous
because apparently he liked nut punches
Yeah, but we're the ones receiving them.
One thing doesn't ring true to me:
Who has to be coerced into punching a cop in the junk? Hell, I'd pay for the opportunity.
R C Dean
the officers are also accused in the criminal complaint of coercing one of the women to punch Merenda in the genitals, because apparently he liked nut punches.
You know who else likes to nut punch.
I have no problem believing cops can be malicious, stupid, and venal, but this is a rare combination of the three that leaves even a die-hard skeptic of police wondering how a person can be so evil as to perpetrate a crime like this and so stupid as to trip up knowing the GPS would rat him out. Especially when they can claim the girls followed them there willingly? so one hopes there's evidence of the stop.
Of course, they might have expected their administrators to reflexively cover for them, so perhaps it's not that farfetched.
I'm pretty sure having the administrators cover for them is in the union contract.
WTF is "unlawful compensation"?
I'm guessing accepting a bribe/ extortion.
But it's UNPAID leave! Haven't they suffered enough?