John Galliano Apologizes for Speaking His Mind at Farcical Anti-Semitism Trial
Because the French do not believe in free speech, former Dior designer John Galliano is on trial today in Paris for saying horrible things about the Jews, and proclaiming, "I love Hitler." If the couple who Galliano insulted at a French cafe in February can prove that Galliano made the statements "publicly"--if other restaurant goers, in other words, heard Galliano make Jew jokes--the designer could spend up to six months behind bars.
The Associated Press has more:
The outspoken British designer emerged Wednesday for the one-day trial after spending months staying out of the public eye. In a conservative look for him, Galliano was dressed in black with a polka dot neckerchief, sporting a pencil mustache and long hair.
Galliano is charged with "public insults based on origin, religious affiliation, race or ethnicity" and could face up to six months in prison and euro22,500 ($32,175) in fines. The verdict is expected at a later date.
The famed designer was escorted to a front-row seat in the wood-paneled, gilded courtroom at the Justice Palace, sitting next to an interpreter as he faced the three judges presiding over his fate.
Journalists, including fashion writers, packed the wooden benches in the courtroom, which features a high ceiling painted with a woman holding the scales of justice. Television cameras were not allowed in the courtroom but trail the designer as he went inside.
His lawyer, Aurelien Hamelle told The Associated Press this week that the designer's comments were "misplaced and hurtful" but attributed them to Galliano's addition to alcohol and prescription drugs.
Galliano issued a statement at the time saying: "Anti-Semitism and racism have no part in our society. I unreservedly apologize for my behavior in causing any offense." He also said he was "seeking help" for personal failures, spending two months in rehab in the United States.
The lawyer said he will call witnesses at the cafe during both incidents who say they did not hear any insults by Galliano.
Any conviction could depend on whether the court determines that the insults were made publicly or not. French law prohibits public insults toward others because of their origins, race or religion.
Earlier today, Sky News tweeted, "John Galliano admits to drink and drug addiction at anti-semitism trial in Paris." Dior fired Galliano in February.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Mon Dieu! Quelle femme laide!
A man's man.
I see what you did there.
I didn't until you pointed it out - now I'm laughing. Thanks, Mainer.
That's quite the puncable face.
His lawyer, Aurelien Hamelle told The Associated Press this week that the designer's comments were "misplaced and hurtful" but attributed them to Galliano's addition to alcohol and prescription drugs.
The strange sound you may just have heard was the utter evaporation of my sympathy.
"It war teh droooogz!"
Fuck you; rot in jail, pussy.
Just one more reason why legalization would be the most horrible of all possible worlds. We must continue prohibition! There is no limit to the blood and treasure which must be spent to prevent slurred insults!
My understanding was that he was reacting to a heckler--who he'd been hassled by before at a previous time in the same restaurant.
They set him up.
They knew he hung out there, and they'd hassled him before. So they made sure to have the camera ready, and they started instigating him again.
To me, that's what I would find difficult to understand--even if I agreed with the law. You have somebody who knows what they're trying to make him say--and then they go instigate it to try to make him say it?
And then file charges against him for saying what they were trying to make him say?
I'm not saying John Galliano is a sympathetic figure (although as a fellow entrepreneur I gotta respect what the guy's done), but the people who instigated this--and are now filing charges?
If they'd punched him in the face, I wouldn't have felt sorry for them if he'd punched them back. Are words really more hurtful than punches to the face?
Why would anyone feel sorry for those who purposely use hate speech laws to instigate criminal violations of the speech code--just because they don't like somebody or just to make themselves feel important?
And you all told me I was wrong about the Jews.
I get that, and I hope to god they never spy on people in their cars. Listening to me drive around in L.A. is like a smorgasboard of epithets, slurs, and althogether uncouth linguistic flourishes.
Ha Ha Ha! I'm actually a pretty open-minded guy, and not a racist. But I agree with you Sudden, driving in LA makes me weave a tapestry of profanity and epithets that lingers above the city to this day.
Careful... driving in LA they'll shoot your eye out.
Fuck you; rot in jail, pussy.
Nice, but no anal-rape joke thrown in for good measure?
STEVE SMITH got bored with Frenchmen.
No friend of liberty should ever express "fuck you; rot in jail" sentiments regarding a person facing incarceration due to a hate speech allegation-even if the subject of the hate speech were of the hebrew national variety.
No humor Mike has no humor.
You're right. Anal rape is hilarious.
It is when done in a surprise buttsex way.
I have the ? on the alcohol + prescription drugs = Joos excuse
damn why didnt i think of that?!
So every time I lament how fucked up we are in the US, losing more freedoms daily, the French come along to remind me, "Hey, we could be THE FRENCH."
Thanks, France!
But I'm not sure if I should feel good because we're not the French, or feel bad because that is our future. I don't even have the consolation my Uncle state, that at age 86, he'll be dead before we really hit bottom.
Yeah, I know. I say the same thing to my kids that your uncle says to you, and I'm only 49.
"It war teh droooogz!"
For a second there I thought you were making a Clockwork Orange reference.
How did you know he was talking about Milk Plus?
Droogs will be droogs.
He had some with "knives in it" - to sharpen him up...
His lawyer, Aurelien Hamelle told The Associated Press this week that the designer's comments were "misplaced and hurtful" but attributed them to Galliano's addition to alcohol and prescription drugs.
Really? Really? Good god, it's just one absurdity piled on the last. The law is idiotic, but so is the defense. They should be challenging the law directly. But, eh, I don't know a lot about French jurisprudence. Maybe the twinkie defense is standard.
My understanding is that French law isn't based on the precedent of other court cases. It's like it was in Louisiana.
It's not like English common law at all. So even if they challenged the law on its merits and won, that wouldn't set any precedent whatsoever.
My understanding is that the only way this case would have an affect on the law is if he were convicted--wrongly in the popular imagination--and his conviction produced such an outcry that the National Assembly changed the law.
Napoleonic code / Code Civil.
<music src="sesame-street">"One of these things is not like the others..."</music>
Stories like this show the success of the 1st amendment. The numerous exceptions the courts have invented out of thin air shows it's failures. How are we supposed to achieve true free speech?
I'll give you one guess.
Stories like this show how feckless the law really is at trying to control people's speech.
People continue to say what they want to say, even in totalitarian societies, and there isn't anything any law can really do to stop that.
They might discourage some forms of speech for a while, but laws can never really stop it.
Still, it's only a matter of time before we see laws like that in this country.
You know, people should be free from being offended. Freedom of speech should not include mean and hateful speech intended to hurt peoples' feelings. I'm sure the First Amendment doesn't protect being a big meany. Does it?
now see...that was kind of sarcastic...you ARE expected to live up to your handle.
back off
Clich?s? We don't need do stinking clich?s!
They've tried in the past.
I think if speech codes are ever introduced again, it will be during wartime--and it will be about protecting the reputation of the executive during wartime.
They've done that before--hell, going back to the Adams Administration. They'll try it again.
With the war on Terror brown people throughout the world of a specific religion won't we be in a perpetual state of war forever?
Yes, we are and until we renounce the proposition that the king is the sole arbiter of the law, we will always be.
Not this shit again.
I don't know. I have some hope for free speech. For the most part the SC has been pretty strong on speech issues.
Ending the "loser pays" system for alleged civil rights violations would be a good start. That travesty lets the PC police coerce limits on speech by merely threatening a lawsuit.
Also, http://www.filipinocupid.com? LOVE the new advertiser! It fits well with the subject, too.
It's almost as if there's logic in teh intertoobs that puts ads up that are relevant to the topic being discussed.
SPOOKY!
http://www.filipinocupid.com - check it out, at reason.com!
I don't know what you've been looking at, but I've got Lenovo computer ads.
See - it's like teh REEEZON KNOWS what you want. SPOOKY!
I got the hot Filipino chicks ad when I was commenting on this article. So probably teh interwebs thought Galliano was a Filipino chick? I can see how it would make that mistake...
Me like cookies...
Ah - I run a script blocker with my Firefox, removing ads from Google, etc wherever I go. Lucky me.
You get ads for filipinocupid. I get ads for vistaprint.
Leave the Filipina pr0nz alone.
Galliano is charged with "public insults based on origin, religious affiliation, race or ethnicity" and could face up to six months in prison and euro22,500 ($32,175) in fines.
If France were a Muslim country, that would enough for the US to begin a kinetic action.
If France were a Muslim country
Just wait a few years.
If Galliano was a Muslim designer, that would enough for Al-Qaeda to begin a kinetic action.
Also, if France were a Muslim country, there wouldn't any Joos to publicly insult.
Q: What's the object of a Jewish football game?
A: To get the quarter back!
Q: How many Jews can you fit into an oven?
A: Six million!
Q: How was the Grand Canyon formed?
A: A Jew dropped a penny down a gopher hole!
A priest and a rabbi are standing on a corner. Two young boys walk by. The priest says, "let's go screw those boys." The rabbi says, "out of what?"
A half-black/half-jewish boy looks so distraught that his mother asks what's wrong. He replies, "A guy I know wants me to buy his bike for $80 and I can't decide whether to jew him down or just steal it."
In Soviet Russia, half-Chechnyan/half-Ukrainian boy steals YOU!
Q: How do you keep a Baptist from drinking all your booze when he stops by for a visit?
A: Invite another Baptist to come over.
Whatta ya get when you cross a black guy with a gay eskimo ? A snow blower that doesn't work !
Whatta ya get when you cross a rooster and a bag of M&Ms;? A cock that comes in your mouth, not in your hands!
Threadwinner. And not even racist!
+1
Oh, that's paddlin'
Q: How many Jews can you fit in a Volkswagon?
A: 100 - in the ashtray
My first girlfriend was Jewish. She taught me ALL the jokes. Go figure...just like my Polish aunt taught me all the Pollack jokes.
Speaking of which - Newfie joke for our Canadian friends!
Q: How'd the Newfie die drinking milk?
A: Cow fell over on him.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
Q: What's problem with Pirelli tires?
A: Dago flat, and when Dago flat, Dago Wop, Wop, Wop, Wop...
Wop's up? How's your dago?
Q: How many astronauts can you fit in a VW Beetle?
A: Eighteen. Two in the front, two in the back, and fourteen in the ashtray.
Q: Why don't blacks and Mexicans marry?
A: They're afraid their kids will be too lazy to steal.
What's the difference between a black guy and a snow tire ?
The snow tire doesn't dance when you put chains on it.
How come you never see a black guy at a square dance?
Every time someone yells "Hoedown!" he thinks his woman been shot!
A black guy walks into a clothing store, whistling and grinning ear to ear. The salesman asks how he can help him. The black guy says, "I need a new suit. My doctor jes toll me I'm impotent and I wants to look the part!"
I heard it as a black guy couldn't figure out why is woman got pregnant, after all his mom always told him how impotent he was.
Why did the Aggie hang his diploma from his rear view mirror? He thought it would let him park in the best spots.
My brother the Aggie has a standing bet that if you tell him an Aggie joke he hasn't heard, he'll pay you $5.00. If he's heard it, you pay him $1.00.
I think I just got $5.00.
Smoother variant:
Why did the Aggie hang his diploma from his rear view mirror? To get a good parking space.
Did you hear about the new tires being made by Firestein? Not only do they stop on a dime, they pick it up too.
hear about the spic & jew who were in biz together? >they went blind watching each other!
What is the difference between a pizza and a jew?
A pizza doesn't scream when you put it in the oven.
Will Reason sponsor an equivalent to the Muhammad cartoon contest? Because that wasn't just about picking on Moozlims, right?
Does your butt hurt? Cause it sounds like your butt hurts.
The young ones always forget the first rule: Lube, lube, and more lube.
Aren't we learning fast
I'm down for a contest that mocks the religiosity of fashion designers, but that's been more than ably covered by Sacha Baron Cohen. Why not tread upon virginal grounds?
Oh look, it's the Ayaan Hirsi Ali concern troll.
Read the comments, a. We've already got it covered with plenty of jokes.
The lack of alt-text is shameful.
"Yeah buddy, that's his own hair"
French law prohibits public insults toward others because of their origins, race or religion.
Origin? Like how Spiderman got bit by a radioactive arachnid?
Three guesses what Galliano was bit by...
Episiarch's mom, judging by the thin moustache.
Part of free speech means I get to express my disgust with ethnic jokes too, right?
Yeah, I know, and people get to express their disgust with me...but just for the record?
Ugh!
What's long and white?
Nuthin!
Q: What is Jewish foreplay?
A: 3 hrs. of begging.
Q: What is Catholic foreplay?
A: No such thing, but there is 3 hrs. of guilt afterwards.
Q: What is Protestant foreplay?
A: Washing the dishes.
Q: What is Muslim foreplay?
A: ??????
Someone help me out with the last one to complete the set.
Tickling the goat under the chin.
FTW
That sounds like some kind of euphemism.
No, I like the current answer. Only problem is that it has to be written down, but it sounds perfect.
Finding the snaps that hold the burqa closed?
Picking the lice out of the hen's feathers first...
Hitting the camel over the head?
Suicide.
I don't know, but how about this:
Q: Why are camels called the ships of the desert?
A: Because they are full of Arab semen.
(not sure which gets the humor across better in writing, semen or seamen)
Q: What is Muslim foreplay?
A: KA-BOOM!!
Hello seventy two virgins
Q: What is Muslim foreplay?
A: Wiring up the blasting caps.
How about the one about the new French battle flag?
A white cross on a white background.
Is that one OK?
A couple years ago the French came one game away from winning the World Cup.
They almost had to invent a word for "victory"!
That's great
When the Wehrmacht approached the French border in 1939 they were met with a guy with a white towel around his arm who said "Table for 18,000?"
Q: What is libertarian foreplay?
A: Arguing about the meaning of "foreplay" for so long that they never actually get around to doing anything.
Would that be thin-crust or deep-dish foreplay? And served with which micro-brew?
Actually, Kodos, the day I lost my virginity, I signed a contract specifying the roles me and the woman would take. Then she and I had sex a few hours later.
I wonder if Nolo ever considered publishing boilerplate libertarian sex contracts. Sure would speed things up to get things standardized.
Well, my ketubah was standard Ashkenazi with an addendum in case of divorce.
You call getting high not doing anything?
Here's some humor for the sensitive people:
Q: What's brown and sticky?
A: A stick
Q: What has four wheels and flies?
A: A garbage truck
Q: What do you call a dog with no legs?
A: It doesn't matter, he's not going to come
A woman was making muffins one day. She poured all of the batter into the baking pan and put it in the over. After about 5 minutes one of the muffins says "Man it's getting hot in here!" Just then, the other muffin says "Holy crap! A talking muffin!"
Q: What's invisible and smells like carrots?
A: Bunny farts.
Sir, you have gone too far. I demand an apology!
Q: What's long and green and smells like pork?
A: Kermit's finger.
One day, a little English girl was walking her dog in a London park. A policeman came upon her and asked, "What's your name, little girl?"
"My name's Petal."
"Petal?" the policeman asked. "That's a very unusual name. Tell me, how did you come to be named petal?"
"Well," replied the little girl, "When I was born it was a beautiful spring day. The sun was shining the birds were singing and spring flowers were in full bloom. And because the day was so beautiful and I was so beautiful and the flowers were so beautiful, that my mum decided to name me Petal"
"Why, that's a beautiful story, Petal and such a beautiful name. You mother couldn't have chosen a better one"
"No,she couldn't," Petal replied, "I love me mum"
"So, tell me, Petal, What's your little doggy's name?"
"Why, his name is Porky."
"My, my! That's an unusual name too! So, how did you come to name your little dog Porky?"
"He fucks pigs."
An Indian boy asked his mother one day, "Mommy, how do we Indian's get our names?" His mother replied, "Well, at the moment of your birth, we look outside the teepee and name you after the first thing we see. What do you ask Two-Dogs-Fucking?"
(I know, I know. Older than the hills, but I still like it.)
What Why do you ask, Two-Dogs-Fucking?
Meiczyslaw, I just went to your site and listened to the Chinese chick singing Jambalaya. Jambalaya always picks my mood up. I hadn't heard it since I watched the movie Blaze a few years ago.
I had a day where I couldn't get the song out of my head. The only thing worse than getting a song stuck in your head is not knowing the words; I couldn't even do the Eric-Cartman-sings-Come-Sail-Away thing to fix the brain worm.
Luckily, the brain worm went away after I watched three versions of it. (Don't point that post at a mirror.)
We should worry about our own country, and our own country alone.
Mocking the French is always in our national interest.
Mocking the French is as much an obligation as it is a way-of-life.
God spies an Indian (Native American) canoeing down the river singing "HO! ha hum ah ho ha hum ah HO! ha hum ah ho ha hum ah" and decides to pluck out half his brain. The Indian stops singing, looks around, then starts back up with is "HO! ha hum ah ho ha hum ah HO!". So God reaches down and pluck the other half, whereupon the Indian immediately starts singing "Alouette, gentille Alouette - Alouette, je te plumerai"
lol
I'll be here all week. Don't forget to tip the waitress.
The French Army tanks have 6 gears,1 forward and 5 reverse
For sale,French WW 2 rifle,never fired ,dropped once
Why one forward gear?
In case the Germans come up from behind!
so they can drive through Paris in victory after the British and U.S. armies liberate it
So, the fact that the French incurred more casualties in six weeks in 1940 than the socialist states of amerika incurred in the whole of the western campaign, does not move you?
No humor Mike still has no humor.
And the French sat on their asses while Poland was invaded.They had a huge chance to deal a hard blow to Germany while they were busy in the east.Same goes for the reoccupation of the Rhineland.
It says they're good at getting shot.
Why should anyone be moved by 50,000 Frenchmen incurring self-inflicted wounds.
Libertymike|6.22.11 @ 3:55PM|#
"So, the fact that the French incurred more casualties in six weeks in 1940 than the socialist states of amerika incurred in the whole of the western campaign, does not move you?"
Uh, the Soviets beat that record all hollow. Stupid governments spend people instead of bullets.
Stupid governments spend people instead of bullets.
And desperate governments spend people when they have no bullets.
The huge Soviet deaths were a result of lack of equipment coupled with an indifference to human life. More inefficient and evil than stupid.
So, the fact that the French incurred more casualties in six weeks in 1940 than the socialist states of amerika incurred in the whole of the western campaign, does not move you?
You don't win a war by dying for your country - you win a war by making the other poor dumb bastard die for his!
Anal rape is hilarious.
Unlike you.
Read harder.
Why I am not surprised that you guys know every single sick joke ever uttered?
I think it's about time to break out the dead baby jokes.
I never do!
lol, OK that dude totally cracks me up man.
http://www.real-privacy.no.tc
Normally, we would applaud his rabid Antisemiticism, but have you seen the Jews lately? Do we really want to risk Israelis commandos parachuting in on the Louvre and kicking our asses? Best just to pretend we like them.
Or just ship 'em off to Germany and let the Nazis take the blame.
See how clean my hands are?
OOOHHHH YYYEEAAHH!!!!.....Hitler would have loved him right back. Especially with that hair.
He looks like Orlando Bloom.
If France is going to make being an asshole illegal, they might as well just wall up the whole country.
Freedom of speech is generally interpreted by the legal system to mean that you are entitled to express your opinions, but you can't do so in a way that would cause harm or distressed to someone else. And many filipino girls are physically and verbally abuse. Government should take action about these matter.
If you've tried your luck in your country but couldn't find the love of your lifetime there, then it is probably a sign that you need to search beyond your borders. Filipina dating sites have profiles of girls who are waiting to meet their foreign mates who are gentlemen. Don't you want to try your luck in this tropical land?