NYC Teacher Stats to Go Public, Plus D.C.'s Michelle Rhee Gets (More) Political
New York teachers have been suing to keep their performance stats on the QT, but a judge ruled this week that value-added data, which compares student test score at the beginning and end of their time in a teacher's classroom to rate her performance, should be free:
The ruling would allow the New York City school district to release performance rankings for more than 12,000 of its teachers to the media outlets that have requested the information….
The rankings at issue in this court case—called the teacher data reports (TDRs)—were developed four years ago for more than 12,000 of the city's 80,000 public-school teachers as part of a pilot project.
At the time, the district promised to keep those ratings private, but in her ruling, New York State Supreme Court Justice Cynthia Kern said that the promise doesn't matter.
While the unions will appeal to keep the data locked away from the public, despite plans to begin using value added figures to account of 25 percent of a teacher's evaluation, starting in 2013.
A similar data dump in Los Angeles caused a heck of a ruckus, but it remains to be seen if parents will be able to use the data to take control of their kids' education.
Meanwhile, controversial former D.C. schools chancellor Michelle Rhee gives an interview revealing her plans to revamp the nation's education system from a perch at a newly-formed PAC in the mold of the AARP or the NRA, Students First. Rhee's reforms in D.C.'s schools were aggressively data driven, and that hasn't made he many friends among union types. Of course, her rhetoric is unacceptably violent and will probably cause a crazy person to shoot some people at a grocery store:
What kind of activism are you hoping for from parents?
In California, there's a new law called the Parent Trigger. It says that if 51% of parents sign a petition, they can take over a school or turn it into a charter. In November, I went and met with a group of parents trying to pull the trigger in Compton. My job was to rally the troops. It was terrifying to hear some of the parents' stories. This group was about 75% Latino, 25% African-American, and some of them had been told, "If you sign the petition, you will get deported." They were scared. If 51% of the people in that community are willing to say, "Enough is enough" anyway, that's huge.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Does anyone else find Rhee to be, um...totally hot? And it's not just the way she looks, it's the things she does.
Yes. Also, I keep trying to click on "the things she does" but the link must be broken because it's not taking me to any video of Rhee in leather with a cat of nine tails.
one of the greatest breakthroughs in labor relations
This
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_3Nrz.....e_rhee.jpg
Is probably what you were hoping for. Pervert...
for sure
with a long metal pipe
In the Billiards Room.
By Professor Plum.
I knew it!
I was coming here to make this exact comment.
+1
This may be old news, but apparently she is also education advisor to incoming Florida governor Rick Scott.
Ooh. Maybe I'll see her around Tally.
So you're the other libertarian here? I think I saw Charles Bronson (no, not that one) at Carrabas a while back.
If you don't drive the Jeep with 'Libertarian' sticker on the back, there's 3 of us.
Then she needs to be put up against a wall and shot too.
For making right-wing inflammatory comments!
Really? Maybe this corrupt businessman concept has merit.
she kind of looks like boomer.
"In California, there's a new law called the Parent Trigger. It says that if 51% of parents sign a petition, they can take over a school or turn it into a charter."
What? Really? I thought petitions were just for the Nationalizing of private interests, not the other way around. This is wonderful and Michelle Rhee is outstanding.
"Trigger"? She's targeting our children!
"and some of them had been told, "If you sign the petition, you will get deported." They were scared."
Threats like these are despicable. But typical of what we have come to expect from union-thugs.
how do u know it wasnt a rumor? pls cite the source for saying it was "union-thugs".
I took a shit in Ohio once.
As did I. Of course I lived there for a while so it would have been impractical not to.
Orrin is your son.
"I took a shit in Ohio once."
Seems it's following you around.
Take a shit? Fine, but don't take one of mine!
And that little boy that nobody liked... grew up to be... OhioOrrin. And now you know... the rrrrrrrrrest of the story.
You didn't take anything! Cleveland is still there.
Cleveland smells like shit.
It's quoted within a quote you fucking moron. You want the cite ask Rhee.
Most people who don't have their head up their ass are able to understand that something quoted in another quote is third hand information.
At least you grew up and have gotten around to the retarded cite needed meme.
ur mommy's callin lil one.
"ur mommy's callin lil one."
ur mistaken. She's summoning your penis.
It was your failure to use single quotes. Be ashamed!
The dipshit with a 4-year-old's grasp of spelling and grammar just called you a child, hmm. That must really sting.
I'm talking to my mom right now. She's helping me feel better.
Just wait, Orrin the five year old is going to use "you are rubber and I am glue" next. Mis-spelled and punctuated, of course.
Can you folks not be its porn? This one is particularly stupid; it makes Edward look literate.
Shorter Epi: Get off my lawn, you darn kids!
Get off my lawn, you darn...kids?
I'm a child at heart.
Or I have a child's heart.
I get confused.
In a jar, I'm sure.
Dammit, 6 minutes too slow...
...with a computer that takes a minute to upload a 5 word comment.
With some fava beans and a nice Chianti?
SF, I'd believe you if you said you ATE and child's heart...
Can you folks not be its porn? This one is particularly stupid; it makes Edward look literate.
Hey, at least I have been able to resist responding to the idiot blogwhore, which is more than I can say for you.
I still havent incifed it and Im not sure why.
Orrin, if you don't behave, I won't let you have that sleepover with me and Max.
Stop responding to the troll that you keep responding to by telling people not to respond to him.
Here is another source of information on the topic. As others have stated however, it is a quote within a quote.
http://blogs.laweekly.com/info.....illara.php
A quote within a quote?
A quote within a quote within a quote.
This ain't Livejournal, learn to type whole words.
It's what we should consider from the left and the right.
I would never in my wildest imagination someone from the right threatening deportation of brown people after all.
"In California, there's a new law called the Parent Trigger."
Clearly an incitement to violence.
Nice catch. I wonder if they mentioning "targeting" of problem schools? Also a clear incitement to violence.
" My job was to rally the troops. "
Jesus. Could you blame teachers if, in such a climate of violence and hate, they stayed home and demanded to get paid anyway?
threadus jackus:
Looks like the government of Lebanon collapsed cause the crazy fuckers walked out.
http://www.voanews.com/english.....75064.html
A government that depends on the support and participation of crazy fuckers is probably one we can do without.
A government that depends on the support and participation of crazy fuckers is probably one we can do without.
Just to let you know:
SOMALIA
That is all.
I figured Iran would just absorb Lebanon. Then it could be run by all crazy fuckers. (however many mullahs they have)
geebus. I'm having a rough day. Syria is the one that boarders Lebanon. Iran is the one that supports it. Either way let those hell holes absorb it..
Too late for that, RC. About fifty years too late.
IOW it's worth exactly as much as any other promise by a government agency.
Why the job performance ratings of any public employee should be kept private is a little mysterious to me.
They have to protect their phoney balogna jobs.
I'm not saying I oppose releasing the data. I'm just saying that a government guarantee in writing is a waste of a good piece of paper.
Exactly. They are public employees. There is no privacy right in their performance reports.
^this.
Don't we pay their incomes? Aren't we entitled to see how they're doing?
oops.
At RC Dean
Next you'll be saying your private employer should have access to your performa-
Oh boy, almost got me there.
the government is implying mind control and brainwash on the people by controlling grammar!
It's better than us being called retarded.
The end is near for the public education establishment. It's obvious to everyone, even them.
No. Even if Rhee manages to shake up the union thugs running the public schools, rest assured that they will have significant input when the new status quo is formed.
If an asteroid struck the earth and wiped out all life, the NEA would be able to strike a sweetheart post-apocalyptic retirement deal.
Sure Rhee demands higher standards. She's Asian. Asians do better at...school. So her trying to make the schools better is racist.
ALSO:
group of parents trying to pull the trigger in Compton
My job was to rally the troops
Right-wing, racist, sexist, homophobic violence inducer!!!
Palin! She's Palin!
"but it remains to be seen if parents will be able to use the data to take control of their kids' education."
That there is any parental involvement in education is what makes this statement funny. If parents did more than provide a steady stream of Wii games for their children education wouldn't be in a state of crisis.
Rhee's endorsement of the parent trigger is important, and it's nice to see her organization has picked up on it. California's law was passed and signed by Schwarzenegger a year ago last week. Other states, including New Jersey, Indiana, West Virginia and Wyoming, have picked up on the idea and run with it. The New Jersey and Indiana bills even have a voucher component. Anyway, for anyone interested, you can find more detail than you could possibly want here: http://www.heartland.org/schoo.....igger.html
Ky just had an education bill die, it passed the state senate but the head of the house committee says he isnt even going to hold hearings on it.
It really only applies to Louisville, but would guarantee a child the ability to attend his neighborhood public school.
The current plan after the Supremes overturned Louisville's previous desegregation plan makes it possible for a neighborhood school to "fill up" with outsiders. The biggest problem is with black parents who want their kids to go to the close school instead of getting bussed out to the burbs.
The bill also containted charter school provisions, but dont know the details.