Reason.com

Print|Email|Single Page

Last Chance for School Reform

D.C. schools are the worst in the nation, but they may also be ripe for big changes.

American public school teachers don’t get fired. They just don’t. In New York City, hundreds of teachers spend all day in “rubber rooms” because they’re deemed too dangerous or stupid to supervise children but can’t be booted because they have union-protected tenure. In crisis-ridden California, the mildest of threats from Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger to cut back on teaching staffs led to an immediate rebuke from the White House.

So when 266 teachers were unceremoniously canned in Washington, D.C., in the fall of 2009, the educators of America collectively slid their glasses down their noses and glared at the District of Columbia. Although 266 firings might not seem like a lot in a country that has lost 8.4 million jobs since December 2007, they could turn out to be more important to the nation’s long-term health than the $150 billion “jobs bill” legislators were debating on Capitol Hill.

D.C. is a divided town. In the heart of the capital, the federal government hums along, churning out paperwork and disillusioned interns at a steady clip. But the rest of the city is in pretty miserable shape. The District of Columbia Public Schools rank below all 50 states in national math and reading tests, squatting at the bottom of the list for years at a time. More than 40 percent of D.C. students drop out altogether. Only 9 percent of the District’s high schoolers will finish college within five years of graduation. And all this failure doesn’t come cheap: The city spends $14,699 per pupil, more than all but two states and about $5,000 more than the national average. Yet as unlikely as it seems, D.C. may prove to be the last best hope for school reform in the United States.

The District’s school system is sitting at the center of a remarkable convergence. A driven, reform-minded chancellor, endowed with extraordinary powers by the city council and mayor, arrived on the scene in 2007 just as the teachers union’s contract was about to be renegotiated. Charter schools are blossoming, with nearly a third of the city’s public school students now enrolled in nontraditional institutions. And a new presidential administration, which has been retrograde in other policy areas ripe for reform, has flirted with some of the more advanced ideas on the education front. Add an education secretary who has respectable reform credentials and a president who has two school-age children, and it’s hard to imagine a sweeter set-up.

One further advantage, paradoxically, is the city’s utter hopelessness. “D.C. schools have long been the poster child for paralyzing education dysfunction,” says Neal McCluskey, an education policy analyst at the Cato Institute. “It seems like they have a complete inability to educate anyone. Educationally, if you could save this patient, you could save anyone.”

But there’s a flip side to all these advantages: If D.C. can’t fix its schools in this context, probably no one can. And the first indications from the Obama administration have been ominous: As part of an omnibus spending bill in March 2009, union-backed Democratic legislators gratuitously killed a promising pilot program for school vouchers in the District. Meanwhile, the fate of reform hangs in the balance of a long, increasingly tense standoff between superintendent Michelle Rhee and the all-powerful teachers unions over the fundamental question of hiring and firing instructors. Depending on which side blinks first, education reform in America could be a long-lost dream come true or simply a lost cause.

‘You Don’t Want Me for This Job’

Michelle Rhee was an unlikely candidate to take over the D.C. school system, let alone wind up on the covers of both Time and Newsweek. “I was like the least obvious choice,” says Rhee, whose verbal mannerisms are those of a recent college grad. The person who suggested Rhee to D.C. Mayor Adrian Fenty did so with a few caveats: “She’s 37 years old, she’s Korean, and she’s never run a school district.”

In fact, Rhee’s only in-school experience was two years in Baltimore as a recruit for Teach for America, a nonprofit that places new college grads in troubled inner-city and rural schools for two-year teaching stints. In 1997 she founded The New Teacher Project, another nonprofit, which brings highly qualified teachers—people who are credentialed in the subjects they teach—to public schools. She was busy running that project when Fenty called.

Rhee immediately told the D.C. mayor, “You don’t want me for this job.” With a bluntness for which she would later become famous, she explained, “If I were to take over the school district, the kinds of things that I would have to do to transform the district”—closing schools, firing teachers—“would just cause you headaches, political headaches. And that’s not what politicians want. Politicians don’t want the dirt to get kicked up. They want everyone to be happy.” Fenty swore indifference to the political ruckus, and, much to Rhee’s surprise, he has so far remained true to his word. Rhee enjoys near dictatorial powers within the system, thanks to the absence of a school board, and she has used them to the fullest possible extent. “The man has not blinked once,” she says.

Rhee has become the Great Korean Hope for school reform advocates around the nation and a lightning rod for criticism locally. D.C. publications follow her every move. Blogs are devoted exclusively to hating everything from her policy proposals to her hairstyle. Almost every move she makes draws headlines. And no wonder: Rhee’s approach goes right to the heart of a decades-long political debate about what schools really need, more money or fewer lousy teachers. On that question her position is clear: No real change is possible unless good teachers are hired and bad teachers fired.

Within months of taking office, Rhee foreshadowed the bloodbath that lay ahead by firing 30 percent of the school’s central bureaucracy. She commissioned an outside audit of school records. (Her staff is still finding rooms filled with unmarked file boxes and cabinets with no keys.) As her first year ticked away, Rhee staffed the human resources department with her own people, installed modern payroll systems, and generally tidied up the back office. Before her first school year started, she found 68 people on the books with no discernible duties, 55 teachers, three aides, and 10 assistant principals, costing a total of $5.4 million a year. She closed 25 underperforming schools (in a district that has 129) and replaced half of the system’s principals with candidates hand-selected by her personal staff and interviewed by Rhee herself.

In July 2008, Rhee revealed her opening gambit with the teachers union: She offered the teachers a whole lot of money. Under her proposal, educators would have two choices. With the first option, teachers would get a $10,000 bonus—a bribe, really—and a 20 percent raise. Nothing else would change. Benefits, rights, and privileges would remain as they were. Under the second option, teachers would receive a $10,000 bonus, a 45 percent increase in base salary, and the possibility of total earnings up to $131,000 a year through bonuses tied to student performance. In exchange, they would have to forfeit their tenure protections. To make good on her financial promises, Rhee lined up money from private donors; she has been close-mouthed about their identities, but The Washington Post has reported that likely contributors include Bill and Melinda Gates and Michael and Susan Dell.

Says Rhee: “I thought, this is brilliant. Everybody talks about how teachers don’t get paid enough; I’m going to pay teachers six-figure salaries! I’m going to pay the best teachers twice as much as they are currently making. Who could not be in favor of that? But people went ballistic.” Getting incentive pay required giving up near-absolute job security. “That,” she says, “is when the crap hit the fan.”

If Rhee has a model, it is Chicago, one of the only places in America where bad teachers can (eventually) get the heave-ho. In the Second City, failing schools can be dissolved and reconstituted. Teachers who worked at those institutions must reapply for their jobs, without seniority rights. Those who fail to get their old posts back are free to apply elsewhere in the city. If they haven’t found a placement in a year, they’re off the books. Just plain old laid off. There’s even a small merit pay program. The man who instituted this plan is Arne Duncan, who is now Obama’s secretary of education.

Page: 1 2 3 Last ›

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment or disable your ability to comment for any reason at any time.

|4.7.10 @ 12:32PM|

Sage, RC Dean, Warty...friends of Tall Dave and other apologist for blowing up makeshift ambulances. Lets take all your excuses and say they are legit. Is it now cool for the Pentagon to use taxpayer dolalrs and 4th amendment nullification methods approved for getting "terrorist" to wiretap/stalk/harass the people who work at wikileaks?

Stasi = Pentagon

It seems to me that fog of war and all is to be expected...it is silly to expect anything other than this type of violence to come out of war...however the Pentagon is guilty of Stasi like unamerican behavior ...they deserve strong condemnation if not court martial and treason charges.

7|4.7.10 @ 12:41PM|

I believe you took a wrong turn at Crazyville.

|4.7.10 @ 12:51PM|

I believe he is confusing the school thread with some other thread from yesterday.

Let it go, man.

DADIODADDY|4.7.10 @ 12:56PM|

must have taken a left at Asshole Junction and gone north on the Hershey Highway...

Jimmy 'Crack' Corn|4.7.10 @ 3:40PM|

Me too.

|4.7.10 @ 1:22PM|

however the Pentagon is guilty of Stasi like unamerican behavior

But but but...

Obama is in charge now!

|4.7.10 @ 3:42PM|

WTF?

|4.7.10 @ 5:52PM|

Oh no!... you took a red pill instead of the blue one.

Rob Paxon|4.7.10 @ 7:42PM|

Why don't you keep your trolling limited to where is relevant, such as the actual thread on this matter. Whichever side of the fence someone may fall in regarding the action (and it's a pretty damn grey area), this is a piss in the pot of what has happened to Iraqis as a result of this war and its resultant occupational conflict. The issue is the war, not some singular murky incident.

People like you are completely insufferable, narrowing in on specific, grey, ultimately inconsequential issues just for the sake of creating disagreement with those whom (mostly all) agree with you on the IMPORTANT over-arching matter. And then tying in this wikileaks thing, as if this place is littered with wiretap-loving police statists. And as if it has bearing on support for against the war... or one's thoughts on the specific incident. Just take a fucking hike.

Steve Nash Equilibrium|4.7.10 @ 12:47PM|

Non sequitur much?

mr simple|4.7.10 @ 12:59PM|

Anyway, Nice article. It amazes me, when I talk to teachers, how quickly burnt out they get about trying to reach kids and switch into more of a survival mode. They all claim the problem is too little pay and funding, like they would actually teach better if they got paid more. Then I present them with the figures on educational spending, national and local, and they just look at me confused and say "I hadn't heard that before."

dakotian|4.7.10 @ 3:58PM|

I was surprised a while back when I looked at the numbers. In some instances there seems to be a direct correlation between quality of schools and money spent. Southern states spend less on schools and have poorer results. But if you look at the numbers, the District of Columbia is high on the list of spending per student. So by "throw money at the problem logic" D.C. should have great schools.

Kroneborge|4.7.10 @ 1:23PM|

Apparently my post was marked as spam, let me type a bit more.

Great article !

Jordan|4.7.10 @ 1:45PM|

Great work, Katherine!

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 1:59PM

Letter From the National Association of Secondary School … | Educational West Virgini links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…of Secondary School Principals. Vermont Principals’ Association. More here: Letter From the National Association of Secondary School … Related Blogs on School Reform Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Colorado to try again for 'Race to the Top' school- reform grant … Letter From the National Association of Secondary School … Related Posts More Than 175 Public…

|4.7.10 @ 2:04PM|

In California the Teachers Union spends $20 million a year to maintain the status quo, and their power. Some 50% of all education jobs in the state are held by non-teachers -- the state is being crushed under the weight if useless educrats and paper pushers who don't ever set foot inside a classroom.

A is Awesome|4.7.10 @ 2:13PM|

I like it, let's institute that system everywhere.

|4.7.10 @ 2:28PM|

88, are the custodians (janitors), grounds and maintenance people and bus drivers included in your 50% count?

Not quibbling with you about the true "useless educrats and paper pushers" but

|4.7.10 @ 2:29PM|

...there are a lot of school system employees who are neither teachers nor administrators.

A is Awesome|4.7.10 @ 2:12PM|

Paying teachers MORE for Performing better and firing the bad ones? HETHEN!

|4.7.10 @ 6:34PM|

A IS awesome, but apparently he doesn't show up to work sometimes.

|4.7.10 @ 6:38PM|

There's evidence that merit based pay doesn't work in education: http://www.overcomingbias.com/.....ching.html

However, I haven't seen all the data. One problem with the results, I suspect, is that it's being tested in the monopolized public schools, which would likely lead to massive grade inflation.

Jimmy 'Crack' Corn|4.7.10 @ 3:19PM|

"...reflecting the District’s 83 percent black student population."

Is there any correlation between the above figure and the fact that students from the DC area are the worst performing in the nation? Is this question the most non-politically correct on this website?

Is this racism, or is this just a fact? Does the "African American' culture produce the worst students in the nation, or is there someone or something else this can be blamed on? The liberals like Tony and Chad will of course always blame someone other than the community itself, but will we look at the harder questions here?

|4.8.10 @ 12:58PM|

Its probably not politically correct but I think its a valid question. Sensitive types might respond negatively.

I think culture certainly has something to do with it. Its not that they're less smart, but I think the black culture de-emphasizes education.

|10.13.10 @ 11:52AM|

I doubt that the 'African American' culture is the 'foundaton' for these results but I do think that the culture of 'entitlements' might well exert a significant influence because where entitlements prevail the quality of accomplishment is usually lacking.

If you were entitled to food, shelter, clothing, phone service, transportation, health care, etc., and then someone came along and told you you had to *work* for your education you'd certainly rebel - and thus we have the situation in the Big City schools - DC included.

A lurker|4.7.10 @ 3:33PM|

Just want to say I think this is a great article. Writing like this makes the print subscription more than worth it.

A lurker|4.7.10 @ 3:33PM|

Just want to say I think this is a great article. Writing like this makes the print subscription more than worth it.

A lurker|4.7.10 @ 3:35PM|

Apparently its so good I had to post that twice...

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 3:39PM

Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…School Reform – Reason Magazine April 7th, 2010 | Author: admin DC schools are the worst in the nation, but they may also be ripe for big changes. See the original post here: Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Posted in School | Tags: are-the, big-changes-, may-also, nation, ripe-for, School, the-nation-, worst Comments are closed. Categories School (1225) Links: Copyright © 2009

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 3:39PM

Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…School Reform – Reason Magazine April 7th, 2010 | Author: admin DC schools are the worst in the nation, but they may also be ripe for big changes. View original post here: Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Posted in School | Tags: are-the, big-changes-, may-also, School, the-nation-, worst Comments are closed. Categories School (1225) Links: Copyright © 2009 English School. All

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 4:00PM

What brand of handbag is this description and where can I get one? About how much wi links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…| Wall St. Cheat Sheet How to graduate from a clothing brand – Laurie Essig – Class … “Brand Palin” – Conor Friedersdorf – Metablog – True/Slant Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Wisconsin DA Threatens to Prosecute Public School Teachers for … High School Student Sent Home For Wearing Lady GaGa Shirt … Neil Patrick Harris – Old School…

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 4:03PM

Internet Marketing Online Sales Boosting Toolbox Software. | Launch Bonus Net links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…On Best Ways To Use The Scripts For Higher Profits. Internet Marketing Online Sales Boosting Toolbox Software. Related Blogs Last Chance To Get A Hummer | The Truth About Cars Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Cheryl Cole 'willing to give Ashley another chance but not until … Cloudy and cooler today, with a chance of showers | Finger on the … 'Jersey Shore'…

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 4:05PM

Read The Story Of Reform Of The D.C. Education System « Tai-Chi Policy links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…C. Education System April 7, 2010 Posted by taoist in Education. Tags: Democrats, Obama, Politics, Reform, School Choice, Teacher's Unions, Vouchers, Washington D.C. trackback All the problems stem from the Teacher’s Unions. They’re wrong on that last page where they say there’s no model to follow on how to successfully reform a school system though – Of all places usually…

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 4:08PM

Big Tits at School (06-Apri-10) Brooke Belle | Pornogys links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…… > Brooke Waggoner – Spring Tour With Rocky Votolato « drivebyMEDIA Brooke Banx Love C-List Celebs High School Student Sent Home For Wearing Lady GaGa Shirt … Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Philippine flight school to take part at Trainex | TRAINEX … Make: Online : Old- school Battlestar Galacticar Lady Gaga says school bullies used to make fun of her appearance…

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 5:21PM

Whitlock and Z.L. Madden closing at end of school year links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Too Much? | Warren Whitlock | Tech … Tiki Barber Leaves Pregnant Wife for 23- Year-Old Mistress | Snark Food SHJ: Magazine ranks Woodruff High one of best in U.S. … Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Wisconsin DA Threatens to Prosecute Public School Teachers for … This entry was posted on Wednesday, April 7th, 2010 at 21:16 and is filed under Uncategorized. You can follow…

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 6:49PM

EuroTrash Thursday! links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Truth About Cars VeloNews.com – Results, Ghent- Wevelgem VeloNews.com – Eisel sprints to Ghent- Wevelgem win VeloNews.com – Ghent- Wevelgem makes play for bigtime Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Eurotrash Microcasts – Shmoocon « ©????²² (in)s??u?it? This entry was posted on Wednesday, April 7th, 2010 at 5:47 pm and is filed under Health Information. You can follow any…

|4.7.10 @ 6:56PM|

The government at all levels is the problem, not the source of reform. Who decided that teachers ought to have degrees in "education" instead of their subject? Who decided that children ought to be encouraged to wonder if they are boys or are girls, despite the evidence of anatomy? Who decided that American History was to be taught with only the bad things in the course, not including any of the good? Who decided to take the hard parts out of the cirruculum, generally? It wasn't the parents. You know that the movers and shakers in this country don't send their kids to those schools; don't you? What does that tell you? Why should your kids got there?

Get government out of it. Start your own schools, your own textbooks, your own teachers. Teach your own kids, if nothing else. Stop thinking that the people who have been making kids stupid and murderous for the last 30 + years are going to do anything different, just because you give them more power and more money. Parents, take control and kick the politicians, the education establishment and the unions out of the business of pretending to teach your kids.

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 7:42PM

Allred Says State Should Run Health Care | Genuine Health Reviews & Stories links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Releases | Lithuanian Foreign Minister: attention to European … Why You Should NEVER Listen to Your Customers | Mark Cuban … Paying Attention – This is Photobomb Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Share Delicious Digg Design Float Mixx Reddit StumbleUpon Technorati Tags: Allred, Care, Health, says, should, State About the Author admin has written 275 stories on this site.…

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 8:18PM

Student loan? links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…An App For That! :: App Advice Clear Lake Golf Course In Manitoba Completes First Round Of … Expert Advice: Rachel Riley – The Bride's Guide : Martha Stewart … Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Wisconsin DA Threatens to Prosecute Public School Teachers for … High School Student Sent Home For Wearing Lady GaGa Shirt … Hey, College Basketball? Your Mom. | North…

|4.7.10 @ 8:21PM|

I hate to say it, but I don't trust Michelle Rhee. Giving someone that level of unlimited power is still a recipe for disaster. I said a year ago, before the Rhee minor-controversies. I say it again today.

|4.7.10 @ 8:24PM|

also my no-longer-libertarian ex-girlfriend seems to get her panties all wet over Rhee. I think it's beacuse like Rhee, she did the whole silly teach for america thing.

|4.8.10 @ 1:02PM|

I disagree, one of the biggest problems with education is bureaucracy. There are too many people involved.

I don't think she's trying to consolidate power, rather to reduce bureaucracy and give the people in direct contact with children more power over the classroom.

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 8:56PM

Email Marketing | List Building Blogger - List Building, Email Marketing, And Making links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Let's Build an Electoral Campaign From The Ground Up « It's … Michelle Obama plays unique role in campaign Last Chance To Get A Hummer | The Truth About Cars Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Weighing In On FITS: Your Chance To Vent :: FITSNews Share and Enjoy: Leave a Reply Click here to cancel reply. Name (required) Mail (will not be published) (required) Website…

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 8:59PM

The Moon and the Willow Tree: Bike Riders – Critical Mass Event to … | Bicycling Leis links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Read the original: The Moon and the Willow Tree: Bike Riders – Critical Mass Event to … Related Blogs on Last Marco Rubio Pulls in $3.6 Million Last Quarter | RedState Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Oprah Officially Becomes Last TV Host To Jump On 'Glee' Bandwagon … Related Posts Critical Mass Phoenix bicycle event « Wes Novack Critical Mass Maputo –…

Chad|4.7.10 @ 9:18PM|

I can't fathom why it costs over $14k per kid to education them.

I could cover my salary and benefits AND have 40k left over for overhead, simply by teaching ten kids all day than I make as a PhD chemist. wtf?

Jimmy 'Crack' Corn|4.7.10 @ 11:28PM|

Here is Chad again, gratuitously mentioning his PhD...

Pingback| 4.7.10 @ 10:42PM

Greenwich Roundup: Putting Connecticut Back To Work | Educational Connecticut links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…….. Read the original here: Greenwich Roundup: Putting Connecticut Back To Work Related Blogs on School Wisconsin DA Threatens to Prosecute Public School Teachers for … Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine » Stop School Bullies Before the Next Phoebe Prince – Blogger News … Related Posts Greenwich Roundup: 02/19/09 The Raw Greenwich News Feed Greenwich Roundup: 3/17/10…

Some Guy|4.7.10 @ 11:21PM|

In his January State of the Union address, he said, “The idea here is simple: Instead of rewarding failure, we only reward success.”

Now just think of how awesome it would be if he wasn't lying out his ass. Not only for schools, but banks, tyrants that we put into power in various countries, etc.

Pingback| 4.8.10 @ 12:14AM

Buy software from our software store :International Catalogs links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…| The Plum Line Garden Shed Plans – Admit It, You Need Em' | Solar-Power-For-Home Saving On The Essentials » Blog Archive » How to Save Money: Introduction Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Over 1200 plans for shed designs – download your free shed plan | Plans For Sheds How Do I Acquire A Us Passport Name Change | Plan Your Wedding Today How To Save Money At…

Pingback| 4.8.10 @ 3:36AM

Brand New in Box Classic Tobacco Smoking Pipe | Health Medical … | Smoking Health Wis links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Brand New in Box Classic Tobacco Smoking Pipe | Health Medical … Related Blogs on Original New original science video series from QUEST: Science on the SPOT … Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine …My heart's in Accra » Abdoulaye Wade: Monumental Ambition Related Posts Some thoughts and tips on tamping – Video | Smoking Pipe Tobacco What Are Good Ways To Quit…

Pingback| 4.8.10 @ 5:27AM

Asia Vacation Specials: South Korea Culinary Vacation From $7420 | South Korea Travel links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Korea. Here is the original post: Asia Vacation Specials: South Korea Culinary Vacation From $7420 Related Blogs on Last Marco Rubio Pulls in $3.6 Million Last Quarter | RedState Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Related posts: Asia Vacation Specials: South Korea Culinary Vacation From $7420 Asia Vacation Specials: Visit the Land of the Morning Clam, South … Asia Vacation Specials:…

Imp|4.8.10 @ 5:57AM|

The problem with tying teacher pay to merit is that merit often means "how well students do on standarized tests." But those tests are bullshit and are designed by governmental, idiotic-educationcrats. They serve to distract kids from any meaningful learning. So, paying teachers based on who has a greater percentage of kids passing these tests, means that teachers who spend more time teaching to a test that measures nothing meaningful will be higher paid than teachers who are actually attending to developmental knowledge and skills as well as individual needs.

|4.8.10 @ 6:39AM|

+1

Pingback| 4.8.10 @ 9:25AM

READING ASSIGNMENTS | Obama.....Aggregated! All the Obama news you can FEED on. links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…advance climate change legislation. Absent a nuclear war, pandemic or another Great Recession, oil demand is going back up faster than supply. D.C. schools are the worst in the nation, but they may also be ripe for big changes thanks to superintendent Michelle Rhee. Chris Matthews is upset with liberal bloggers for not making a good enough case for some sort of "social state." First the charges to use the…

Wegie|4.8.10 @ 9:26AM|

More money will be thrown...nothing good will happen.

Pingback| 4.8.10 @ 11:21AM

How many chances should a HOF candidate get before he’s not eligible anymore? links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Support the Equality Pledge Opinion: Travels in hyperreality Kscope » Blog Archive » The Pineapple Thief – Someone Here is … Your Last Chance | WithoutWax.tv by Pete Wilson Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Needs someone to care | Ask the Therapist OPINION: The GOP's Neo-Confederate Problem, Rewriting The Civil … Plagiarism – Someone is copying my content. What do I do?…

Pingback| 4.8.10 @ 12:18PM

Read The Story Of Reform Of The D.C. Education System | Zero Rich Party Power links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

Read The Story Of Reform Of The D.C. Education System | Zero Rich Party Power Zero Rich Party Power Read The Story Of Reform Of The D.C. Education System Thursday, 8 April 2010 All the problems stem from the Teacher’s Unions. They’re wrong on that last page where they say there’s no model to follow on how to successfully reform a school system though – Of all places usually…

Pingback| 4.8.10 @ 1:07PM

How long after bankruptcy shall I wait to apply to refinance my mortgage? | Bankruptc links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…7 Vs. Chapter 13 Bankruptcy: Which Is Best For Your … Your Last Chance | WithoutWax.tv by Pete Wilson As White House Assures Senate on Missile Defense, Obama Makes … Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine In Case You Missed It… | PerezHilton.com Screech Loses His Home! | PerezHilton.com High School Student Sent Home For Wearing Lady GaGa Shirt … GM posts $4.3 billion loss…

Pingback| 4.8.10 @ 6:02PM

Megamillions News – See yourself as the Grand Prize Winner Today! | Comprehensive New links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…of a Good Amount Monthly Bandwidth in Your Web … Apple's ' Game Center' Social Gaming Network Announced | Touch Arcade TouchArcade 360iDev Game Jam | Touch Arcade Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine New York City Marathon | NYC Marathon Lottery Announced 8 game shows that every kid wanted to be on | Guyism HELP! Questions about the amount of student loans I have borrowed…

Pingback| 4.8.10 @ 7:29PM

My Dad died of Liver/Lung cancer. I have his cremated remains in a non airtight conta links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Nеw E- Cigarette Review Asbestos іח Toys аחԁ Tools – аחԁ Aсrοѕѕ tһе Americas « Tһе Pump Handle Last Chance fοr School Reform – Reason Magazine Share and Enjoy: Related posts: lung cancer and cantron:Prostate Cancer Symptoms Prostate Cancer Symptoms Smoking Lung Cancer colon cancer early... Mesothelioma is Danger? True?…

|4.8.10 @ 7:29PM|

Maybe they can come to Florida and help our clueless lawmakers with their idea of education reform. They think alienating educators is their best tactic. Hmmm, a GOOD plan for getting rid of bad teachers..how novel is that!

Pingback| 4.8.10 @ 10:12PM

Health Care Reform Bill Addressed at Forum | Competitive health insurance policies | links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Church on the defensive amid pedophilia revelations … Luther Allison : Watching You – Stellenbosch Health Care's History of Fiscal Folly – Reason Magazine Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Pajamas Media » In Bid To Reform Fannie and Freddie, Obama Can't … Nuggetpalooza » The Pitch Report – Tuesday's Game .cbadss{ background-color:#FFFFFF;…

Pingback| 4.8.10 @ 11:37PM

sea world san diego_sea animals_sea world san antonio_sea temperature_sea world orlan links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Your Last Chance | WithoutWax.tv by Pete Wilson Arctic Sea Ice Reports: who to believe? « Watts Up With That? Nebraska Lecture explores Dead Sea Scrolls research – The Scarlet Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Supply- Demand – Cost of Water « Climate Science: Roger Pielke Sr. Stock Photo – Sky, Sea | Full And Free Download rapidshare … graham4601173 › Watch Day the World Ended/She…

Pingback| 4.8.10 @ 11:49PM

The Risks And Profits Of The Forex Market links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Ignore HREF Attribute Value « Akbar's Blog What’s Forex Trading Software? | NewsDX Blog Last Chance to Take the Mobile Add-on Challenge « Mozilla Add-ons Blog Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Can Forex Trading Robots Make Money For You? use href to diplsy database results · design and development Share this on del.icio.us Digg this! Post this on Diigo Share this…

Pingback| 4.9.10 @ 1:49AM

Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine « Snow Report Blog links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…all but two states and about $5,000 more than the national average. Yet as unlikely as it seems, D.C. may prove to be the last best hope for school reform in the United States. via Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine. from → News, Politics No comments yet Click here to cancel reply. Leave a Reply Name (required): Email (required): Website: Comment: Note: You can use basic XHTML in your…

Pingback| 4.9.10 @ 2:08AM

Frank Kern – Mass Control 2.0 Relaunch – Internet Marketing – Sneak Attack | RH Sterl links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…by Pete Wilson Last chance to claim misplaced items at Olympic lost and found | Vancouver Review Letting Up debuts new video for “Our Younger Noise” | sneak attack blog Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Mass Control » Hot Damn! Share and Enjoy: Tagged as: Attack, Control, Frank, Internet, Kern, Marketing, Mass, Relaunch, Sneak { 2 comments… read them below or add one }…

Pingback| 4.9.10 @ 5:58AM

How To Choose A Diet? | HealthTips links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…with new publications about fat burning furnace industry and other topics of this big market. Related Blogs Last Chance to Take the Mobile Add-on Challenge « Mozilla Add-ons Blog Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Media Group Italia – Worth Last Chance Greatest Plays (Softball … NFL.com Blogs » Blog Archive Cunningham, Rolle finally get their … The South Beach Diet…

Pingback| 4.9.10 @ 11:26AM

Houston: Where the Chefs Eat, by Sharon Hoge | eastwestbakery.com links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Last Chance to Take the Mobile Add-on Challenge « Mozilla Add-ons Blog Sukh by Chance to end? The Blue Walrus – indie & electro penalization for the group » Bestival … Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Chef's Choice 610 Premium Electric Food Slicer | Snipsly Why are there no someone sushi chefs? Blame hearty safekeeping and … Houston Launches “Where the Chefs Eat”…

Pingback| 4.9.10 @ 12:08PM

Date and Switch? School Accused of Holding Fake Prom For Lesbian … | Educational Miss links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…For Lesbian … Related Blogs on Last Last Chance to Take the Mobile Add-on Challenge « Mozilla Add-ons Blog Massey Mine Was Shuttered 61 Times in Last 15 Months « The … Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Related Posts School Prom Off After Lesbian's Date Request – Education News … Mississippi School SUED For Canceling Prom After Lesbian Date Request Mississippi Prom…

Pingback| 4.9.10 @ 11:07PM

adventures_adventure trips_adventure trip_free online adventure games_adventure quest links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…2? – Film Junk online assistant services | Drama Forum ICE DANCING WARS: ITV vs BBC – Deadline.com BEHIND THE SCENES>> SUMO POWER GT-R GT1 TESTING – Speedhunters Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Digital Music Sales Slowing | Peter Kafka | MediaMemo | AllThingsD Britain's Digital Economy Bill Causes Outrage College Football Assistant Coaches Make A Shit Load |…

Pingback| 4.10.10 @ 5:39AM

What are the chances of becoming pregnant? links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Review of HBO's Treme – Tuned In – TIME.com Simon Crump: Twilight Time « Asylum 'Danger Girl' Movie In The Works From 'Hack/Slash' Producers Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine PlayStation LifeStyle » Konami Takes Life or Death Chance with Saw II Exclusive Deets On Gossip Girl Drama | PerezHilton.com Another Gossip Girl Couple Donezo? | PerezHilton.com…

Pingback| 4.10.10 @ 8:09AM

Letter From the National Association of Secondary School … | Educational Oklahoma links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Education Act, as detailed by the bills in this letter, … See the article here: Letter From the National Association of Secondary School … Related Blogs on School Reform Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Letter From the National Association of Secondary School … Related Posts FOI Oklahoma: Legislators want Oklahoma Secondary Schools … Emekwulublog: Review by Penny…

Pingback| 4.10.10 @ 11:50AM

HELP!! Does a person who has Mesothelioma have a better chance of having heart proble links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Ticket increase in Chicago for playoffs | Crash The Crease Mesothelioma Life Expectancy | Types of Cancer More knowledge of epithelial malignant mesothelioma « Treatment Of … Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine 2 Responses to “HELP!! Does a person who has Mesothelioma have a better chance of having heart problems than a average person ?” b1911: April 10, 2010 at 4:41 pm Yes it…

Pingback| 4.10.10 @ 1:00PM

Are You Into Online Poker? | Brad's Poker Spot links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Parent … Sukh by Chance to end? PlayStation LifeStyle » Konami Takes Life or Death Chance with Saw II Sony Cooking Up Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2? – Film Junk Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Last Chance to Take the Mobile Add-on Challenge « Mozilla Add-ons Blog Beyonce Ego Spoof – (Who's ya Granny)- Dcfan4life | HoodShack.com News Tags: fun, gambling, games,…

Pingback| 4.11.10 @ 7:22PM

Letter From the National Association of Secondary School … | Educational Iowa links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Education Act, as detailed by the bills in this letter, … Excerpt from: Letter From the National Association of Secondary School … Related Blogs on School Reform Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Related Posts School Choice: Policy Developments and National Participation … British National Party wants to bring back corporal punishment in … Scholarships Grants.…

Pingback| 4.12.10 @ 11:02AM

Teachers Unions Causing Problems - U.S. Politics Online: A Political Discussion Foru links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…News - MiamiHerald.com In miami, teachers called in "sick" to protest the state legislature attempting to change their pay to be based on student progress instead of time. Last Chance for School Reform - Reason Magazine In DC, the superintendent offered the union double pay in exchange for losing tenure. No go. New Jersey Governor Chris Christie Not Laughing After The Bergen County Education…

|4.12.10 @ 6:25PM|

The article says: "In D.C. today, 50 percent of a teacher’s evaluation is based on student outcomes. In any other industry, this standard would be absurdly low, like basing only 50 percent of a salesman’s performance review on how many units he sells."

But in what other industry does the "employee" only have control of the "product" for about 20% of the time? (8 hours a day for 180 days in the school year, versus 24 hours a day 365 days a year) And then the remaining 80% of the time the "product" may be struggling with poverty, abuse, learning disability, or simply indifference. The largest indicator of student success is parental involvement.

By all means, get rid of poor teachers--and I've seen many poor teachers continue to "work" year in and year out. But rating teacher performance on student outcomes is misguided at best--especially since the "best" teachers in the "best" schools (ones that are perceptive enough to actually recognize and adapt to the diverse needs of their students) tend to get assigned the most difficult students. This article does nothing to address the very complex issue of what makes the best environment for student success. No, money won't help that much. Yes, getting rid of poor teachers will help some. But the biggest success will only come from the home. Everything else is just a band-aid on a bullet hole.

Pingback| 4.12.10 @ 8:53PM

RSS agregator » Blog Archive » Teachers Unions Causing Problems links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…News - MiamiHerald.com In miami, teachers called in "sick" to protest the state legislature attempting to change their pay to be based on student progress instead of time. Last Chance for School Reform - Reason Magazine In DC, the superintendent offered the union double pay in exchange for losing tenure. No go. New Jersey Governor Chris Christie Not Laughing After The Bergen County Education…

Pingback| 4.12.10 @ 8:53PM

RSS agregator » Blog Archive » Teachers Unions Causing Problems links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…News - MiamiHerald.com In miami, teachers called in "sick" to protest the state legislature attempting to change their pay to be based on student progress instead of time. Last Chance for School Reform - Reason Magazine In DC, the superintendent offered the union double pay in exchange for losing tenure. No go. New Jersey Governor Chris Christie Not Laughing After The Bergen County Education…

Pingback| 4.13.10 @ 2:55PM

Teachers Unions Causing Problems - Page 2 - U.S. Politics Online: A Political Discus links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…hated the school system because even the good/mediocre teachers had their hands tied by stupid administrators and stupid administrative policies) Quote: Originally Posted by jviehe Last Chance for School Reform - Reason Magazine In DC, the superintendent offered the union double pay in exchange for losing tenure. No go. New Jersey Governor Chris Christie Not Laughing After The Bergen County Education…

Pingback| 4.13.10 @ 3:13PM

Teachers Unions Causing Problems - Page 2 - U.S. Politics Online: A Political Discus links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…hated the school system because even the good/mediocre teachers had their hands tied by stupid administrators and stupid administrative policies) Quote: Originally Posted by jviehe Last Chance for School Reform - Reason Magazine In DC, the superintendent offered the union double pay in exchange for losing tenure. No go. New Jersey Governor Chris Christie Not Laughing After The Bergen County Education…

Pingback| 4.18.10 @ 2:33PM

New Treatment Options for Breast Cancer | Business Tip | Cancer Health Wisdom links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…| Business Tip Related Blogs on May Also Do you know the difference between Health Care and Health … Oxford Circus escalator replacement leads to access restrictions … Last Chance for School Reform – Reason Magazine Related Posts Welcome Back to Pottersville: Cancer Treatment and Health Care … The Provocateur: Cancer Treatment and Health Care Reform Prostate Cancer Treatment – Available…

nikeoutlet|9.1.10 @ 4:16AM|

i like here.

nfl jerseys|11.4.10 @ 10:50PM|

mbng

Sheepskin Boots Sale|11.22.10 @ 7:29AM|

We also access the comment made central identical analyze acclaimed name cast away ahead of the curve of Women Uggs . We will access the application for the precision Ugg Sheepskin Boots we are in the bazaar in both winter and summer. These auction access ugg been

Sheepskin Boots Sale|11.22.10 @ 7:39AM|

added details about the Ugg Sheepskin Boots , for example, apparently used the best Sheepskin Boots Sale boots accurately auction

Sheepskin Boots Sale|11.22.10 @ 7:45AM|

Because the administration of the affidavit of all equipment in the Classic Ugg Boots Online Store Boots Shorten, will charge a mild cleanser or cleaner natural that affidavit could be assertive with the highest absolute accuracy delicate added. And Ugg Boots Outlet need to adulterate your vacuum bubbler baptize according Arctic stop in the administration of the instructions

Jillian Michaels Diet Pills|3.20.11 @ 7:05PM|

Great article - I am subscribing to your blog

jewelry|4.1.11 @ 10:36PM|

I am really impressed that there is so much information about this subject

ليبيه|6.21.11 @ 11:30AM|

Thank you, my dear on this important topic You can also browse my site and I am honored to do this site for songs
http://www.libyh.com
This website is for travel to Malaysia
http://www.libyh.com

insulin resistance|7.27.11 @ 11:52AM|

I am really impressed that there is so much information about this subject

Scarpe Nike|8.3.11 @ 4:19AM|

is good

cheap wholesale|8.12.11 @ 5:15AM|

so perfect

Athletic Shoes|8.12.11 @ 5:43AM|

so perfect

Derek|8.16.11 @ 3:14PM|

All schools need to be reformed. They need to focus on more "real world" subjects and promote kids to think on there own.

Hersheys|1.8.12 @ 2:29PM|

Someone I work with visits your site quite often and recommended it to me to read also. The writing style is excellent and the content is relevant. Thanks for the insight you provide the readers!

- http://www.americangrocery.co.uk

|1.23.12 @ 2:33PM|

Cool post thanks for sharing

Real Estate IDX

xiaoyang|1.24.12 @ 9:12AM|

Beer and wine kisumu 2 possess a small amount of methyl alcohol, also known as fuel line antifreeze along with cook oven fuel. It is just a harmless quantity in ale and wine beverage but when distilled atmbt sapatu the wrong temp a dangerous amount of methyl alchol can be done.

sd|1.25.12 @ 4:04AM|

sd

Tom|3.28.12 @ 11:33AM|

As you say, Washington's case is extreme, but in general we greatly undervalue our teachers.

More Articles by Katherine Mangu-Ward

Related Articles (Education, Choice)

advertisements

Get Reason E-mail Updates!

Manage your Reason e-mail list subscriptions

Site comments/questions:

Media Inquiries and Reprint Permissions:


(310) 367-6109

Editorial & Production Offices:

3415 S. Sepulveda Blvd.
Suite 400
Los Angeles, CA 90034
(310) 391-2245