You Don't Have to Sleep at Home, but You Can't Sleep Here
Playing chess in the park (if you are unaccompanied by a minor) may be illegal in New York, but in Roselle Park, New Jersey, you can be fined or arrested for falling asleep while watching people play chess in the park:
"Isn't that a little crazy? I mean, if you fall asleep, like if I were to sit down on this bench and wait for a bus and I fell asleep, that's against the law?" [a randomly chosen resident] said. "Don't you think that's a little crazy?"
Even though that's the letter of the law, Police Chief Paul Morrison said drowsy drivers and napping babies need not worry.
"This ordinance was amended to help assist the police in addressing the increasing problem of homeless people sleeping on benches," Morrison said.
It does seem a little crazy to me, especially since it gives police yet another pretext to harass people who offend them in some way. But I doubt that anxiety about this ordinance is keeping very many babies awake, and you'd think drowsy drivers would be more worried about veering into oncoming traffic or crashing into a telephone pole.
[Thanks to Tricky Vic for the tip.]
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Everything you do is illegal somewhere.
And they are not hiding from the fact they don't plan to enforce this law equally.
""Even though that's the letter of the law, Police Chief Paul Morrison said drowsy drivers and napping babies need not worry.
"This ordinance was amended to help assist the police in addressing the increasing problem of homeless people sleeping on benches," Morrison said.""
They plan to assist the homeless by arresting them.
Uh, I think you misread that. He's not saying that homeless people have problems, he's saying that homeless people are problems.
Ah, yes.
So, wouldn't that be an explicit admission of an equal protection violation?
If you haven't slept anywhere wrong, you have nothing to fear.
Uh-huh. Right. Sure.
"...need not worry." Yeah, my aunt Sarah was told the same and ended up knocked up.
Here in Santa Cruz, we're much more compassionate than that. We let people sleep in the park during the day. But if they sleep in the park at night, or anywhere else that is not indoors, they get a ticket.
Many US cities have such laws.
Sleeping in public illegal.
Camping illegal. And so on.
OTOH shelters are closed except in winter.
Essentially, if you are homeless in one of those cities, you are breaking the law.
That's the main idea.
So, instead of taxing just people into prosperity, we'll arrest them into it?
I've read that they also offer the homeless one-way tickets to some other part of the US.
Does not achieve anything, but makes somebody's statistics look better.
If the residents of Rosselle Park pointedly didn't want the public spaces or park benches for which they pay filled with sleeping bums, that would be one thing. Then, sure, it would be the cops' duties to give homeless park bench sleepers the 23-skidoo. Even then, however, the difference between a briefly-napping, taxpaying resident with a place to live, and a homeless guy, should be fairly obvious.
But if this system was the Rosselle Park PD's recipe for revenue, yes, it needs to go.
Cops have a bad habit of forgetting for whom they work. I wish we could remind them, by replacing them with private security contractors.
I suspect this is a common law, as I was harassed by a cop in Daytona Beach a few years ago for sleeping in a public park. He told me that I would be fine as long as I sat up. I sat up for 5 minutes after he was gone and went back to sleep.
They should provide free coffee to the chess spectators.
Sleeping is a gateway activity that can lead to other, more serious crimes. Statistics clearly show that most serious crimes are committed during the state of wakefulness.
Because sleeping precedes waking, society has a clear and present interest in eliminating sleeping, in order to protect The Children?.
It has been long before I can find some useful articles about pandora charms. Your views truly open my mind. I love this pandora bracelets uk article since it is one of those which truly convey useful ideas. I am glad to read some fantastic
I have a solution to the problem of unequal application of this law.
All you need to do is amend the law to exempt any person under the age of 17 and any person who owns a home.
Problem solved. That way they can apply the law equally.
I remember after a long night of partying in San Francisco, I was still wandering around as the sun was coming up. I tried to catch a little shut-eye in one of the parks there, but was roused by cops in a patrol car (I thought I had gone off the beaten path, but apparently not), and told to move on.
Then, another time in SF, same sorta circumstances, but this time another park. I was only blocks away from where I was staying, but it was late morning, and so I just kicked back in the park and fell asleep. This time, cops on foot patrol roused me, this time because 'something fell outta one of my pockets' (not drugs, thankfully) :). Anyway, after the cops left, satisfied that I wasn't a homeless person, a black lady who was walking through the park came up to me and said, "What was the po-leece fuckin' witchu fo'"? And I simply replied, "You know The Man, always gettin' in your business", to which she gave a hearty "Uh-huh".
Good times - I love San Francisco...