You Will Have Ben Bernanke to Kick Around
Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke is expected to get reappointed at 9 o'clock this morning. In honoring the man who in 2006 was still talking about solid fundamentals and a soft landing in the real estate market, and who predicted growth in the second half of 2007, President Obama will express gratitude on behalf of all the peoples of Planet Earth, with special praise for Bernanke's leadership "through one of the worst financial crises that this nation and this world have ever faced."
Got it? Not just this nation but this world. Self-dramatization buffs take note: This recession dwarfs not only the Panic of 1837 and the Great Depression, but the South Sea Bubble, Egypt's seven-year famine in the Book of Genesis, and whatever killed the Mayans. We're all heroes, just for being here, dammit!
The great missed opportunity is not economic (given that Larry Summers was in serious contention as a Bernanke replacement, the move may in fact be a blessing), but political. In the wake of the health care debacle, Americans are feeling the kind of misgivings not felt since Britney Spears woke up to Jason Alexander. Obama has demonstrated his fondness for announcing grand schemes in a golden cloud of "understand one things" and "let there be no doubts," but he has provided no evidence that he has an interest in the nuts-and-bolts job of keeping his customers satisfied. This is the moment for the president to give up the illusion of vision and start creating the illusion of results.
My advice: After the vacation that should have been in Hawaii, come back and fire Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner. Then announce that Bernanke will not be reappointed. Then announce that you've called together an international team of ninja economists and financial titans -- I mean stellar people, blue ribbon right down to their white shoes -- to craft a better, smarter Stimulus II (actually Stimulus IV or V, but who's counting?). Then spend the fall doing photo-opps with small business owners and chambers of commerce around the country, vowing to get this economy moving again -- for real American working families and such.
Nobody will be fooled, any more than anybody outside the Beltway is fooled by the "signs of life" and "green shoots" flapdoodle the Administration and its stooges keep ladling out. But they'll appreciate the gesture. And with luck we may see just one more big money dump rather than the methodical destruction of the federal budget.
Most people recognize that the economy is out of the president's control. They just don't like seeing Washington and Wall Street use this supposed disaster as an excuse to loot and pillage. This is a bigger political problem than Obama seems to understand.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
There are no words to express how little surprise this elicits from me.
-jcr
Most people recognize that the economy is out of the president's control
That's only half true. A president can be responsible for destroying an economy or preventing the recovery. What a president can't do is cause a recovery.
-jcr
Tim, I don't get this. You know Hopey McChange is not going to listen to your advice, so why this ridiculous "compromise" with the politically feasible?
Why not go the whole hog, and tell Obama what he ought to do, no matter how politically unpalatable?
How about recommending Jes?s Huerta de Soto?
Completely OT, but Tim, why do all of your links have the target="_blank" property? That's worse than your scheme to kill LoneWacko with the NOFOLLOW tag!*
*I loved how LoneWacko got pissed by the NOFOLLOW tag.
well done Tarran, about time someone said it...
Snark Meter?? peaking...redlining...run!
Was anyone else disappointed to discover that the Britney Spears reference wasn't about Jason Alexander, of Seinfeld's George fame?
"Was anyone else disappointed to discover that the Britney Spears reference wasn't about Jason Alexander, of Seinfeld's George fame?"
Actually, you're not. I had this vivid picture of him having to explain "shrinkage" to her 😉
gold, guns and ideas... the 3 things the govt. must control to run society...
GOLD, GUNS, IDEAS... what govt tries to control to run society... if enough gold, guns, schools are in private hands Liberty has a chance..
How about recommending Jes?s Huerta de Soto?
You forgot the preemptive "shut the fuck up, LoneWacko."
Anyway, Bernanke vs. Summers? We may have dodged a bullet merely by not stepping out of the fire we're standing in.
Doom doom doom. Missed a chance for a star wars reference
What's that smell?
We're all heroes, just for being here, dammit!
Couldn't have said it better myself.
I dated a few cougars in my day and loved it. No drama, great sex and I was not paying for everything all the time. It was really chill. Try this out:
**== Cougarster.com ==**
But let me tell all you young guys that want a cougar. eat your veggies and hit the gym cause they will ware you out...
LOL, corruption is bliss! There goes the neighborhood!
RT
http://www.anonymity.se.tc
LOL, corruption is bliss! There goes the neighborhood!
Couldn't have said it better myself.
Some idiot was on CNBC a few minutes ago saying, "We HAVE to keep Bernanke in the game;
he's got a feel for this thing, now. You don't want to throw a rookie in there."
If your "quarterback" is running around the backfield like a chicken with its head cut off, and throwing the ball into the stands, it's time for him to have a seat, and start writing his memoirs.
Some other idiot just said keeping Ben proves the Fed is independent.
!!!!
Ben is our Fed Chairman. We've won 10 games with Ben as our Fed Chairman, so we're going to continue having Ben as our Fed Chairman.
we could have just kept Greenspan! He would have had a chance to finish his "Undertaker" job...
Oh great, a guy who helped create the financial bubble, who denied that the bubble existed and who bailed out the people who created the bubble will be in charge of our currency and debt. But I guess since he has a proven track record of being willing to saddle future generations with massive amounts of debt to keep the Bush/Obama administrations in power then he is the obvious choice for FED Chairman.
The one thing I usually count on from reason is accurate and appropriate cultural references. So I have to object to that Jason Alexander comment. Alexander was a good looking, reasonably intelligent, salt of the earth type kid from an upper middle class family in Brit's home town. Brit may have felt misgivings, but in the context of her life, this was probably the best decision she ever made. Her most high profile relationships since the annulment have been a marriage to a no account wigger back up dancer and long term romance with an Arab Paparazzi who kept her drugged and out of her mind for most of their time together. The metaphor just doesn't work. A better choice would have been comparing the relatively stable Nicky Hilton's brief marriage to Todd Meister.
"Some idiot was on CNBC a few minutes ago saying" Kudlow is not usually on this early...
Difficult to argue with the naysayers but choice A was Larry Summers, no question..
Lovie Hussein Obama | August 25, 2009, 9:50am | #
Ben is our Fed Chairman. We've won 10 games with Ben as our Fed Chairman, so we're going to continue having Ben as our Fed Chairman.
Well done!
Obama's praise for Bernanke made me literally nauseous. He actually listed every expanse of government intervention and heaped on the "didn't want to, but had to, and how glorious it is that we did".
doom
DoooM
DOOOOM
Well, so long as we are indulging in celebrity matters, what I consider the greatest news of the 21st century, and another notch in the fine service of humanity for Darren Aronofsky.
It's too bad Bernanke didn't stick to his helicopter plan, and drop money on everyone. Instead he just hooked up a giant pipeline from the taxpayer to his former employers at Goldman Sachs.
Oh great, a guy who helped create the financial bubble, who denied that the bubble existed and who bailed out the people who created the bubble will be in charge of our currency and debt.
DJF for the win....
Bob:
Was anyone else disappointed to discover that the Britney Spears reference wasn't about Jason Alexander, of Seinfeld's George fame?
[raises his hand] What a letdown. That would have been the celebrity news item of the century.
You're doin' a heck of a job, Brownie Bernanke.
The only question is, when's the Fed gonna need a bailout?
when's the Fed gonna need a bailout?
Don't worry; they have plenty of checks left.
My favorite part of the media coverage of this is the "reasoning" that since Bernanke was able to avert crisis by "skillfully" dumping incredible numbers of dollars into the economy, he's also going to be able to skillfully remove them without killing the recovery (whenever that happens). It's sort of like saying that someone really good at shooting people should also be really good at removing bullets from them. But I don't see a lot of overlap between snipers and surgeons.
"Then announce that you've called together an international team of ninja economists and financial titans"
How about just regular ninjas? I might even vote for Obama if he decided to replace his entire economic team with ninjas.
Its a good news and i think its a great move for Obama's health care reform.
I noted in this morning's WSJ that Obama praised Bernanke's "bold, persistent experimentation" for bringing "our economy back from the brink."
These words strike me as quite frightening, especially after having read Jonah Goldberg's Liberal Fascism. This idea of "bold, persistent experimentation" is a calling card of the fascist and pragmatist movements, and was the central "strategy" in FDR's approach to fixing the economy in the Great Depression. (Not sure what to do? No worries. Just boldly and persistently experiment with the nation's economy -- after all, it's only the living standard of millions of people that's at stake. Go for it!)
Can it be a mere coincidence that Obama is using this phrase? I don't think so. This guy really thinks he's FDR II.
"...And Bernie (Brownie) you're doing a hell of as job."
To paraphrase Obama basically kept on the Michael Brown of the financial world by allowing Bernanke to stay on as Fed Chair.
One starts to wonder if Obama really understands the mandate he was given. I could have voted for McCain and gotten Bernanke. Hilary Clinton too. Obama was supposed to be different and yet it seems he'sm operating under the theory that what the people want is a more competent Bush II-style government. Now, that's setting the bar pretty low. Again, I could have voted for the aforementioned and had gotten it.
The reason Obama's poll numbers have soured is the support he's lost on his left and his decision to keep around the architechts of the financial crisis (Bernanke, Geithner. Who's next, Henry Paulson to head the SEC?) shows his committment to real change is quite hollow.
The establishment can praise Bernanke's helicopter flying skills all they want, but the reason he's staying on is quite obvious: Bernanke will do exactly what Obama wants and keep interest rates artificially low and keep printing money to pay for all the administration's promises. Thus Bernanke becomes another Arthur Burns, a prisoner to an Administration with little understanding of economics outside of crony capitalism.
With every move that seems to reward those that got us into this mess, Obama is further recking his mandate among those who really did think he was going to be different. Those voters may very well be up for grabs sooner than we think.
OK, now I finally know why we use paper as money instead of gold and silver.
Dropping silver dollars and $20 gold pieces from a helicopter could be dangerous to the plebes down below.