Drug Policy

Dodging Baseball's Speed Limits

|

The number of baseball players who claimed to need stimulants for attention deficit disorder, and who therefore received "therapeutic use" exemptions from the disciplinary consequences of a positive drug test, rose from 28 in 2006, the year Major League Baseball banned amphetamines, to 103 last year. Rep. John F. Tierney (D-Mass.) thinks this sudden, 268 percent increase looks suspicious. "When you see the number 28 one year go all the way to 103, it makes you think that we have a loophole here with performance-enhancing drugs," he said at a congressional hearing yesterday. You think?

Since Adderall (a mixture of amphetamine and dextroamphetamine) and Ritalin (methylphenidate, a drug with pharmacological effects very similar to cocaine's) enhance the performance of people diagnosed with ADD, and since Major League Baseball has decided to give medical exemptions to people with that diagnosis, this "loophole" is not an accident; it's a deliberate policy decision. Presumably Tierney thinks the recent diagnoses are mistaken or fraudulent. But maybe a bunch of baseball players with bona fide, genuine ADD (not the fake kind) were self-medicating until the amphetamine ban and have now decided to come out of the shadows. The New York Times lends support to that hypothesis:

Dr. Steven Safren, an associate professor of psychology at Harvard Medical School, said it was estimated that 2 to 6 percent of the adult population had attention deficit disorder.

Rob Manfred, baseball's executive vice president for labor relations and the official most directly involved with the drug-testing programs, said Tuesday night that the commissioner's office was not overly concerned about the increase in attention deficit disorder exemptions.

"Nobody really knows why it jumped," he said, noting that 103 therapeutic-use exemptions out of a baseball population of 1,354 players in 2007 meant 7.6 percent of those players were claiming attention deficit disorder as an affliction, a percentage not that much out of line with the general adult population.

Dr. Safren, asked about baseball's numbers, and the surge from 28 exemptions to 103 in one year, said: "It certainly is a big jump. It could be that people weren't disclosing it. At the same time, the percentage is at the high end."

Intriguingly coincidental as the spike in ADD diagnoses looks, a more important question is why this is any of Tierney's business. "We shouldn't have to have hearings like this all the time to stay on top of these problems with baseball," he said. They don't have to, of course; they choose to. They can stop anytime they want. And given that the Constitution does not grant Congress any authority to dictate the rules by which baseball is played, that would be a good idea. 

Nor is it clear what "problems with baseball" Tierney has in mind. Amphetamines were first marketed in the United States in 1932. Seventy-four years later, Major League Baseball, under government pressure, told players to stop using them. This does not seem like an emergency of any kind, let alone one that should occupy the federal government.

NEXT: Puff, Puff, Give In

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. The problems with baseball are among the most pressing concerns our country has right now because drug use in baseball is cheating and unacceptable because the players are role models for America’s children.

  2. I’m not going to be shocked if many are fraudulent, but people with ADD tend to be more interested in physical activities that don’t require as much higher cognitive concentration. That certainly describes athletes. Additionally, I have tried Adderall and it is not a fun drug to take if it’s not for you. It made me irritable as hell and didn’t seem to help me focus at all.

  3. it was estimated that 2 to 6 percent of the adult population had attention deficit disorder.

    Is that equal for males and females or not? If not, then 7.6% may not even be on the high end.

  4. I like baseball as much as, if not more than, the next guy. I’m concerned about players getting an unfair advantage over their opponents.

    This (congress) is getting too stupid for words.

  5. Is this the same government that allows fighter and bomber pilots to take ‘go pills’?

  6. …but people with ADD tend to be more interested in physical activities that don’t require as much higher cognitive concentration. That certainly describes athletes.

    Strictly anecdotally, as the manager of a youth sports team, the number of athletic kids with ADD is very high. Our team typically has about one third of the kids taking ADD meds.

  7. Is this the same government that allows fighter and bomber pilots to take ‘go pills’?

    Yep, and you can get a DUI for driving a car on them, but landing on an aircraft carrier is OK? Go figure.

  8. What the fuck is wrong with people that athletes improving their performance is an issue. What kind of a fucked up society is this. Why don’t you fight against poverty or police abuse instead of whining you stupid cunts.

  9. Preach it, Brother, er, Francois!

  10. Cindy —

    Maybe the problem is that baseball players are our kids’ idols? Seriously, if I see another vignette during a televised game about how amazing someone is for having the courage and commitment to actually put several hours a day into preparing for and playing a game for absurd amounts of money all while being idolized and lavished attention, I just might puke.

  11. Hmm, I need an “upon” somewhere in there toward the end…

  12. adderall , and hgh are the fucture for our kids. the older generations are jealous thats all.

  13. Don’t know if you got the memo, but ADD is the clinical term for being “absent minded”, part of the general movement to make eccentricities pathologies.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.