Reason.com - Free Minds and Free Markets
Reason logo Reason logo
  • Latest
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Subscribe
    • Crossword
  • Video
    • Reason TV
    • The Reason Roundtable
    • Free Media
    • The Reason Interview
  • Podcasts
    • All Shows
    • The Reason Roundtable
    • The Reason Interview With Nick Gillespie
    • Freed Up
    • The Soho Forum Debates
  • Volokh
  • Newsletters
  • Donate
    • Donate Online
    • Ways To Give To Reason Foundation
    • Torchbearer Society
    • Planned Giving
  • Subscribe
    • Reason Plus Subscription
    • Print Subscription
    • Gift Subscriptions
    • Subscriber Support

Log In

Create new account

Racism

Why the Right Should Celebrate the UT-Austin Football Photo

For decades, conservative and libertarian legal activists worked to ban race preferences in admissions. They won.

Robby Soave | 9.17.2026 1:40 PM

Share on FacebookShare on XShare on RedditShare by emailPrint friendly versionCopy page URL Add Reason to Google
Media Contact & Reprint Requests
Texas | bofrench/X
Texas (bofrench/X)

A photo of University of Texas at Austin students celebrating the Longhorns' come-from-behind victory over Ohio State University last weekend went viral on X—and for all the wrong reasons. Bo French, a Republican candidate for Texas railroad commissioner, chose to ignore those positive vibes (Texas was down 20 points in the final quarter, and won anyway), and instead commented on the racial makeup of the Longhorns' cheering section.

I heard UT graduation this year looked like this. I didn't believe it. The problem is now obviously far worse than anyone imagined. pic.twitter.com/Ys1bql0y4U

— Bo French (@bofrench) September 13, 2026

"The problem" to which French referred is apparently that there are too many non-white Texas students, particularly students of Indian heritage. In case there was any confusion about what he meant, French followed up with this observation:

"I cheered the win for the team," he wrote. "It was a great game. But I weep for the families in Texas who can't get into UT because they prioritize foreigners over Texans. Shame on you for ignoring that fact."

You are reading Free Media from Robby Soave and Reason. Get more of Robby's on-the-media, disinformation, and free speech coverage.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

French's observations drew widespread condemnation from many on the right. Radio host Eric Erickson used it as a launching point to scrutinize the white nationalist infiltration of the Republican Party. Karl Rove said he would vote for a Democrat, French's opponent, for only the second time in his life. Ben Shapiro made the entirely valid point that if self-described Republicans have such a problem with Indian over-representation, they're in for a rude awakening when they learn that Vice President JD Vance—the presumed successor to President Donald Trump and a man who is perceived to be ideologically sympathetic to some of their goals—has an Indian wife and half-Indian children.

Other conservatives pointed out the incoherence of being mad that some immigrants don't assimilate rapidly enough—a standard conservative complaint—and then choosing to fume over a photo that shows them proudly participating in one of the most quintessential American traditions: college football, and Texas football at that. Moreover, the students depicted are probably mostly Texans: By state law, UT-Austin is required to maintain a campus population that is overwhelmingly Texan. Just 10 percent of the student body comes from out of state, and even fewer come from outside the country. These students may be of Indian descent, but they are indeed Americans.

Unfortunately, that's not good enough for certain elements of the right. The truth is that French's comments also received plenty of support from conservatives involved with the groups that Erickson called out in his terrific article—the Claremont Institute, American Moment, and others—and also from right-wing commentators like Benny Johnson, Auron MacIntyre, Joel Webbon, etc. In effect, some of the loudest conservative voices on social media obviously agree with French that a photo of non-white kids at the UT-Austin is a symptom of some deeper failure or moral betrayal of white America, one the Republican Party and the conservative movement have failed to prevent. Elite institutions are overrun with people who do not look like white Europeans and who do not practice Christianity, and that's bad, according to these folks.

What's ironic about this whole discussion is that forcing universities to practice race-blind admissions has been a major achievement of the conservative (and libertarian) legal movement. Identitarian right-wingers who now say they lament that the relevant authority figures can't simply prioritize one race (white people) over another (Indians) are the ones betraying their own ideological heritage: The right won the war over affirmative action, and now these people are mad about what that means.


Race Conscious

There's an additional irony here, in that UT-Austin was an important battle along the way to banning race-based admissions. In 2008, Abigail Fisher was denied admission to the school and sued over its race-based admissions policies. At that time, the university automatically accepted the top-performing students from every high school in Texas. Other students could gain admission based on numerous criteria, including grades, leadership qualities, and their race—applicants in this category gained extra points toward admission if they were racial minorities.

The case went to the Supreme Court in 2013, and again in 2016. Fisher lost both times, as the Court maintained that it was OK for universities to consider race if it was just one of many factors. This had long been the Court's opinion; the majority decision in Grutter v. Bollinger (2003) decreed that a racially diverse campus was beneficial to the education experiences of all students, and thus race could be considered for admissions purposes if narrowly tailored.

Most conservatives and libertarians disagreed with these decisions, instead viewing race-conscious admissions as a form of racial discrimination, mainly against white and Asian applicants whose admissions rates fall when administrators were allowed to prioritize underperforming minority groups. And by 2023, the composition of the Supreme Court had changed significantly enough for a majority to agree: In Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard University, the Court reversed both previous decisions and made race-based admissions effectively illegal. Institutions of higher education can no longer cherry-pick their students in order to achieve their desired racial makeup.

This was a huge achievement, given elite admissions officials' penchant for using crude racial stereotyping to deny admission to very qualified students—usually Asian students—in favor of applicants whose test scores were objectively worse. The race obsessives lost, the individual merit enthusiasts won.

Even before the 2023 decision, Texas Republicans were doing everything in their power to stop the state's schools from practicing race conscious admissions. Current Republican Senate candidate Ken Paxton, Sen. Ted Cruz, and outgoing Sen. John Cornyn all called on the Court to end race-based admissions. Gov. Greg Abbott issued a ban on diversity, equity, and inclusion in education. Republican officials acted swiftly and decisively to make racial considerations a thing of the past.

So, what happens when a university can no longer use crude racial essentialism to pick its student population? Well, only the most academically gifted students get in. Unfortunately for French and other right-wing identitarians, this does not mean you necessarily end up with more white students. High-performing immigrant groups, like Asians and Indians, will scoop up a disproportionate share of the admissions slots on the strength of their test scores and grades. When French and his fellow travelers object to this, they are making mirror-image arguments of progressive educators who long desired to use skin color as a factor toward admission.

It is wrong to make admissions decisions on the basis of race, and enshrining that principle into law was a major achievement of the conservative and libertarian legal movement. It is a good thing that when we look at a photo of university students celebrating their football team beating Ohio State (hooray for them, says this Michigan kid), we know they all got there on their own individual merit: They are neither being punished nor unduly rewarded for some immutable characteristic.

If you object to that, and you also object to the kind of race-based sorting that the progressives were doing, well then, your political project really is just white nationalism—and you don't get to complain when other people on the right try to disassociate from you.

For a longer read on these same themes, you should order this brand new book by Reason's Stephanie Slade: Fusionism, Liberty, Virtue, and the Future of the American Right.


This Week on Free Media

I've been ill this week, and so I've managed to film very little. We'll have Freed Up tomorrow, however, and more Free Media next week. In the meantime, head to the YouTube page and subscribe!


Worth Watching

I just wrapped up my 80,000 rewatch of the television series Lost, which I still say mostly holds up, including the ending. If you haven't revisited the show since then, I'd recommend giving it another try. Contrary to popular belief that the show fails to deliver answers to most of its questions, I would struggle to point to any specific aspect of Lost that is not sufficiently explained by the end. The ability to binge-watch episodes really helps mitigate the feeling that the show is just an endless procession of unaddressed cliff-hangers. Also, in an era when everything on TV is way too dark (and I don't mean in terms of tone), my eyes were very grateful that I could always see what was happening on screen.

Start your day with Reason. Get a daily brief of the most important stories and trends every weekday morning when you subscribe to Reason Roundup.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

NEXT: New York Wants To Scrap Testing Requirements While School Spending Soars

Robby Soave is a senior editor at Reason.

RacismRaceAffirmative ActionConservatismSupreme CourtCollege AdmissionsFootballCollegeHigher EducationPolitics
Share on FacebookShare on XShare on RedditShare by emailPrint friendly versionCopy page URL Add Reason to Google
Media Contact & Reprint Requests

Hide Comments (101)

Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.

  1. Minadin   2 months ago

    No.

  2. scotterbee   2 months ago

    "Heritage Americans without children deserve being replaced."
    -Darwin

    1. charliehall   2 months ago

      The Heritage Americans are American Indians. French has called for them to be deported. He is the descendant of invaders and should be deported back to Europe.

  3. JesseAz (RIP CK)   2 months ago

    "The problem" to which French referred is apparently that there are too many non-white Texas students,

    Apparently is doing a lot of the lifting here. Did anyone ask Bo French? Was he talking race or talking party/culture? Nobody knows. But dont let that stop a broad media narrative.

    You can read his post as simply "kids these days" but chose a purely racist explanation.

    1. Heraclitus   2 months ago

      Come on. Party culture? You are obviously a bot if you think a Texas politician is complaining about party culture. Maybe they should be quietly sipping borst?

      1. JesseAz (RIP CK)   2 months ago

        I go to homecoming every year. I question my university's class of students every year the last few. And this comes from someone in that culture a decade or 2 ago.

        But to you leftists, race is the only thing.

        1. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

          Keep up the rage posting! Keep pretending it's only leftists who are obsessed about race when your own team is doing the same thing!

        2. TZM   2 months ago

          Karl Rove, Ben Shapiro, and Erik Erickson all saw exactly what French was doing — are they leftists?

          1. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

            To unprincipled boot lickers like Jesse, "leftist" is just a slur meaning "someone I don't like". That is why Jesse refers to Liz Cheney as a "leftist" even though she is as doctrinaire conservative as they come. So I have absolutely no doubt Jesse will now start calling Erick Erickson and Ben Shapiro "leftists".

          2. Jim Conley   2 months ago

            Yes, but they're not wrong about this. The Indian students are Americans and, though it may come as a surprise to both Robbie and the bigots, they are Caucasians.

    2. creech   2 months ago

      He was probably complaining about the complete lack of hot and busty Yellow Roses in the picture.

    3. James K. Polk   2 months ago

      He followed up his post to clarify that he meant his problem was with race, you hopeless moron.

      1. JesseAz (RIP CK)   2 months ago

        No he didnt. He said foreigners. Are there no white foreigners?

        Race is the most important thing though right buddy?

        1. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

          Please keep doubling down. This is completely amusing.

          Jesse will defend it all.

        2. charliehall   2 months ago

          My wife was born in Mexico, but her ancestry is entirely European. The same is true of Mexico's President.

    4. TZM   2 months ago

      From the article — French wrote: “ I weep for the families in Texas who can't get into UT because they prioritize foreigners over Texans.” So he looked at the faces and decided they must be foreigners, even though the school actually prioritizes Texans over foreigners by a wide margin.

      1. JesseAz (RIP CK)   2 months ago

        I mean Elon Musk is foreign too.

        1. TZM   2 months ago

          Did he post a photo of Elon Musk?

        2. charliehall   2 months ago

          Deport Musk back to South Africa.

      2. charliehall   2 months ago

        Correct. But French will probably get elected, as no Democrat has won any statewide election in TX since 1994. Note that although some Republicans have criticized French, none other than Rove will vote for Rosenthal. They dislike French's comments not because they consider them to be beyond the pale but because it is an embarrassment and exposes the true nature of the MAGA movement. Watch for actual Nazis and KKK leaders getting elected as Republicans there in 2028.

    5. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

      Even when there are *other conservatives* criticizing Bo French, Jesse will white-knight for the racist. Never change buddy.

    6. Zeb   2 months ago

      I very much doubt there would be any commentary on the photo if everyone in it was white and doing exactly the same things. I won't say it's all about race. It may be about them looking foreign (even though there are plenty of native born Indian-Americans). As far as culture goes, everything in that photo looks pretty much like American football game culture to me. I don't know what's up with throwing milk around, though.

      1. mad.casual   2 months ago

        (even though there are plenty of native born Indian-Americans)

        For a "melting pot" it certainly looks awfully pure. Maybe the photo was taking in the American Immigrant fan section but that specifically does not refute the point.

      2. JesseAz (RIP CK)   2 months ago

        I see quite a few tanned whites in the photo.

        1. mad.casual   2 months ago

          SSDD with "diversity": ~16% of the population seems completely unrepresented to me. Maybe the guy who showed up for a home game in a white jersey on the left counts, but he's not close to representing 16% of the population... and showed up to a home game wearing white.

          1. mad.casual   2 months ago

            Again, Marc Andreessen made this point about the whole "diversity" issue before Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard reached SCOTUS.

            That, for years, admissions initiatives sold to increase diversity and equality were rather nakedly discriminating against certain kinds of diverse people in order to generate a false impression of "diversity and equality" and not just one certain kind of diverse people either.

            His point was a rather libertarian take that both sides should be ashamed of the way the Ivies and public universities were taking loans, grants, and education money and that "poor minorities" *and* more mainstream and affluent natives should be kicking them to the curb. Creeping towards the whole thing was a/the obvious pro-woke, pro-AWFL grift that it is.

        2. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

          Yes, CLEARLY, Bo French's primary concern was the lack of proper sunscreen usage by students at UT. LOL

        3. Zeb   2 months ago

          I'm sure there are in the hundreds of people in the picture. But the foreground is pretty much all people that appear to be of Indian descent. I have no idea who Bo French is or what he believes. But facts are: there are a lot of Indian and Indian American students at US colleges and the focus of that photo is mostly people meeting that description. So I don't think it's an unreasonable first pass interpretation that he's complaining about too many Indians at US schools.

    7. mad.casual   2 months ago

      As someone who grew up around pigs and cattle, I'm frequently offended at the number of people wearing cowboy hats who couldn't distinguish a Holstein from a Duroc because they grew up in a place where eating pigs and cattle is a religious taboo. And by "places where eating pigs and cattle is a religious taboo" I mean, of course, San Francisco, Los Angeles, Portland, and... Austin. As broadly offensive and nonsensical as a white office worker wearing a sombrero with "Come And Take It" printed on it.

      Go ahead, tell me I'm being racially and culturally divisive, insensitive, and backwards.

      1. Jesse fantasizes about having a 3some with Dave Smith and Maddow   2 months ago

        “Go ahead, tell me I'm being racially and culturally divisive, insensitive, and backwards.”

        You’re being fucking stupid

    8. damikesc   2 months ago

      When the white population on campus was effectively cut in half in about 20 years, there might be concerns.

    9. sadhak   2 months ago

      As a brown man who has been like those students once upon a time I just shrug off this racism. All those kids will end up getting high paying jobs and Bo's kids and his supporters are likely going to end up working for those kids eventually. So these are not victims of racism but rather of envy.

      Having, said that it surprises me the lack of honesty among Republicans. They want to signal to their racist voters but lack the courage to say so. He posted that photo claiming these are foreigners because they are brown. It is a dogwhistle for his supporters to show his anti-Indian-American credentials. But you can't achieve much like this by being a p$$$y like this. At least man up and say what you want to say.

  4. Sometimes a Great Notion   2 months ago

    LMAO. Bo french prior tweet from just before:

    DEI in college admission
    DEI in hiring
    DEI in promotions
    DEI in home loans

    The entire system is biased against heritage Americans and for third worlders.

    Gen Z impacted the worst.

    Most people cannot conceive of what is coming.

    1. James K. Polk   2 months ago

      The entire system is biased against heritage Americans and for third worlders.

      Your complaints are so over-the-top, idiotically false, and so pathetic and overweening, they reek of flop sweat.

      This is no system. Only lazy morons perceive it as such because it's too much work to take a closer look.

      1. mad.casual   2 months ago

        Only lazy morons perceive it as such because it's too much work to take a closer look.

        You mean people who are just as bright and just as talented as white kids don't you?

        Your take was exceptionally retarded the first time back in 2016.

    2. Sometimes a Great Notion   2 months ago

      * was suppose to be a reply to Jessie's take that this was possibly about party culture.

    3. Normal Guy   2 months ago

      In the end, the point of all of your rhetoric and noise is simply to serve as a justification for taking other people's stuff. That job, that house, that car, all of it rightfully "belongs" to you instead, I'm sure. We've seen this before.

  5. James K. Polk   2 months ago

    Bo French, Auron MacIntyre, etc., are all proud racists, so there is no doubt about what they mean.

  6. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

    The whole "heritage American" thing is nonsense anyway. America is a creedal nation. It is not a "blood and soil" nation. If you are willing to come here and work hard and fully join in with the rest of the nation, then you are welcome here regardless of where you were born. That was the vision of America that I was raised on. That is the vision of America that I think is encapsulated by the Declaration of Independence when it says "All men are created equal..." How did we get from there, to this idea that if you were born here, you are somehow superior to people who were not born here? It is just sad to see what is happening.

    1. TJJ2000   2 months ago

      It comes from the 80% voting for UN-Constitutional socialism. That's where.

      1. TJJ2000   2 months ago

        To hit that nail directly...
        You can't claim to support "All men are created equal".
        While you simultaneously vote to STEAL from 'icky' people for *special* peoples entitlements.

    2. Purple Martin   2 months ago

      The issue with Heritage American White Nationalists is not just "...this idea that if you were born here, you are somehow superior to people who were not born here?" It's that ...if your parents and grandparents were born here, you are somehow superior to Americans whose parents and grandparents were not. "

      That is, except for visibly brown Americans. They're inferior no matter how many generations back their original American heritage stretches back.

      1. TJJ2000   2 months ago

        Voting statistics is the "how superior American" comes from heritage (born here) is based.
        It has nothing to do with a persons skin-color. Stop being so F'en racist.
        You're worse than the TX Senator in this article.

        Why don't you just say what that last line is meant to say.
        You think brown Americans should be celebrated just because they're brown.

        1. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

          It's not about fucking "voting statistics". Who voted to create the welfare state? Who voted to create Social Security and Medicare and SNAP and Section 8 Vouchers and all the rest? For the most part it wasn't brown people, it was "heritage Americans".

          1. TJJ2000   2 months ago

            THAT is EXACTLY what 'invasion' control is all about.
            ...the USA doesn't need to be invaded by [Na]tional So[zi]alist[s].

            Precisely why every nation has a 'common defense'.
            So it's foundation doesn't get conquered by a foreign ideology.

            1. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

              Precisely why every nation has a 'common defense'.
              So it's foundation doesn't get conquered by a foreign ideology.

              Sounds like you don't just want no immigration, you want no outside ideas coming into the country either. Wouldn't want to be 'conquered' by foreign ideology, after all! Maybe the USA should set up its own Great Firewall to keep out all the wrongthink?

              1. TJJ2000   2 months ago

                Sounds like you think Nazi Ideas should take over the USA.
                And maybe it already did set up its own Great Firewall to keep out the Nazi's.
                And that's exactly what ticks you off.

                Yes. Gov - 'Gun' Redistribution is WRONG ?think?. Armed-Theft is WRONG think. [WE] Identify-as gang building to 'Gun' down others is WRONG think ... because get this; they VIOLATE Individual inherent human rights (as defined by USA think; the US Constitution).

                Did you really think just because ideas (criminal or honorable) exist they're always right?

    3. charliehall   2 months ago

      Actually, you are NOT welcome here regardless of where you were born, because of the country-specific quotas. The wait for visas can be many years long in some circumstances. Ditch the quotas.

  7. Rick James   2 months ago

    So this happened.

    1. mad.casual   2 months ago

      Pattern recognition: I can't cite specific examples but it seems like this isn't the first time I've seen a police chief "freeze up" when put on the spot about a crackpot mayor or governor's criminal justice political scheme.

      Can't tell if the sideways glance directly into the camera is low-IQ, union-rehearsed, or "blink twice if they're holding you hostage" instinct, but I've definitely seen it before.

  8. Rick James   2 months ago

    mainly against white and Asian applicants whose admissions rates fall when administrators were allowed to prioritize underperforming minority groups.

    I count this admission as progress.

    1. Liberty_Belle   2 months ago

      After Asians allowed themselves to be used as stalking goats for anti-affirmative action lawsuit, Edward Blum laughed manically and twirled his moustache. The lawsuit harmed non-asian minorities while completely ignoring lower scoring legacy admissions and by wealthy whites.

      1. Rick James   2 months ago

        After Asians allowed themselves to be used

        Like black people (and option #1 on the woman checklist), they have no agency.

        1. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

          Well your team certainly seems to think that immigrants have no agency. That is why they continually complain about "importing" immigrants as if they were cargo, and want to keep them out because they "vote for socialists" as if they are pre-programmed robots who will only ever vote for how someone tells them to vote. Maybe your condemnation should be a little bit more bipartisan.

          1. Normal Guy   2 months ago

            That's just propaganda. Their version of it would be something like, "every Republican is a racist."

            You are a victim in a way. Our leaders should strive to ensure that every American is able to have worthwhile conversations and make good decisions for themselves and their nation. When they can't do that, when their only interest is keeping their jobs, we risk catastrophic deterioration.

            1. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

              I largely agree with the second part. But I don't think it is "just propaganda" when they continually refer to "importing immigrants" as if they were cargo. I truly believe that they actually do view immigrants as lesser humans compared to themselves.

              1. TJJ2000   2 months ago

                They believe [Na]tional So[zi]al[ism] is lesser humane than US principles.
                The left has always been the party of [WE] Identify-as lesser/superior markers.

              2. Normal Guy   2 months ago

                Documented immigrant graduates tend to lead successful careers. You know that just by existing and needing anything more complicated than auto repair. I doubt they mind even if the language used could be interpreted as dehumanizing...

                The real "cargo" are undocumented immigrants, not the people relevant to this article.

                And on that, I doubt most of liberals think about it. Our current situation is a product of them not thinking about it for decades. Farmers benefited from them not thinking about it. Consumers benefited from them not thinking about it. So now, the left sees, "price go up," and says (in effect), "wait! We need undocumented wage slavery," and shield themselves from the dissonance by terminating any thought beyond that.

                If they must work here, I'd rather they get paid like Americans, but there's a consequence to that not far off from what we're experiencing now.

                1. mad.casual   2 months ago

                  The real "cargo" are undocumented immigrants, not the people relevant to this article.

                  That's of course not the only "cargo". Relative to Rick James' original post; a lot of these preferential admissions and grants were set up at taxpayers' expense nominally as reparations or to make up for American discrimination or oppression. The sort of thing that someone from another country didn't experience in the slightest and that, frequently being second or third generation graduates even in their own country, shouldn't qualify for, except for the color of their skin. An overt inversion of Purple Martin's retardation above.

                  1. Normal Guy   2 months ago

                    My assumption was that Indians dominated the rest of us academically on sheer merit. Though I refer to the Indians *we* get, not those remaining home taking advantage of less rigorous academic standards. Cheating will get you kicked out of any school here, even my humble commuter college.

                    We focus a lot on the Ivys and Tier 1 public colleges, but when you're done beating DEI out of them, how will you handle the schools anyone can get into? Will you still accept large numbers of legal immigrants at those? Will you opt for a reverse DEI (as I had assumed was already the case for Asians)?

                    1. mad.casual   2 months ago

                      We focus a lot on the Ivys and Tier 1 public colleges, but when you're done beating DEI out of them, how will you handle the schools anyone can get into?

                      If I could whimsically beat up the Ivies and Tier 1 public universities, precisely 0 federal dollars, including backed loan dollars, would go to any educational institution anywhere and this wouldn't be an issue. Public universities, as such, wouldn't exist. If Hindu temples wanted to blow their money teaching black Americans underwater basket weaving, it's their loss. Everywhere else would focus strictly on merit and ROI and fractionally "investing" in students who would/could simply take their education and go home would be a losing investment.

                      Have you been to a trade school? Seen a lot of Indians or other Asians at a trade school football game?

            2. Purple Martin   2 months ago

              "Our leaders should strive to ensure that every American is able to have worthwhile conversations and make good decisions for themselves and their nation."

              Absolutely correct, Guy! And part of that is consistently calling out members of one's own team who, like Bo French, have dedicated their lives to trying to make sure not every American has the right to have worthwhile conversations and make good decisions for themselves and their nation.

              From the evidence both available to Bo French at the time and surfaced since, nearly all the folks in his picture are Americans were having a good time worth discussion, and making good decisions (well perhaps outside of drinking to excess, but we can hope many made the decision not to let friends drive drunk)

              And applies no matter what team one is rooting for.

      2. Agammamon   2 months ago

        There are just sooooooooooooooooooooooo many legacy admissions at state schools. So, so many. Those legacies are just hogging up all those seats.

  9. Jesse fantasizes about having a 3some with Dave Smith and Maddow   2 months ago

    Bo French needs to be disarmed and his voting rights taken away.

    1. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

      For sure, if anyone vaguely left-of-center had posted an image with a bunch of white guys partying at a football game, but with the same caption, every single right-winger would have thundered "THEY HATE WHITE PEOPLE".

      1. Fats of Fury   2 months ago

        Really? How about when they manipulate the story?

        https://www.yahoo.com/news/ny-mag-accused-cropping-black-180817098.html

        1. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

          Is that article about a bunch of white guys partying at a football game? No? Then fuck off

      2. Marshal   2 months ago

        It's cute that Jeffey says "if" as if this has not happened. In fact left wingers have asserted crowds of whites are racist without any basis many times, but Jeffey tries to hide this because admitting it reveals his pretense to be principled is a lie.

        1. Jesse fantasizes about having a 3some with Dave Smith and Maddow   2 months ago

          What is more likely? That “leftists” have captured all the institutions that you claim they have? Or you’re just an uneducated, backwards bigot?

          You’re a traitor!!! A no good Trump fellating traitor!
          We have you outnumbered and outgunned. Shut the fuck up and stop causing problems or face annihilation.

          1. EISTAU Gree-Vance   2 months ago

            Lol. Hey, what’s your redneck kill count, tough guy?

            What a loser. You ain’t gonna do shit.

            1. Jesse fantasizes about having a 3some with Dave Smith and Maddow   2 months ago

              Hey moron, like I’ve said before, if you are ever down here you have an open invitation to meet up with me.

              You’re a traitor! You’re lucky the democrats are incompetent cowards. If I was in charge you would be lined up against the wall and your brains(or in your case lack of them) would splatter everywhere.

    2. Normal Guy   2 months ago

      Oh my goodness.

      1. Jesse fantasizes about having a 3some with Dave Smith and Maddow   2 months ago

        God damn fucking right!!!

  10. TJJ2000   2 months ago

    Yeah. The right should celebrate a photo with the right skin-color in it! /s
    Maybe we should shame all those white skinned people in the background too?
    That Senator is a moron. He doesn't change the fact that...
    "For decades, conservative and libertarian legal activists worked to ban race preferences in admissions."

    The fact you want to pretend he does leans far more into the first sentence than the later.

  11. Marshal   2 months ago

    It's juvenile and naive to believe universities have stopped or will ever stop racial discrimination until the people who support it are removed from academia entirely. At most UT made their discrimination practices less obvious and focused them more tightly on the races they most want to effect.

    1. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

      Note how Marshal cleverly tries to change the subject. Marshal wants you to think that the real concern here is about racial discrimination for admission into UT; however, Bo French's concern was explicitly about *foreigners*, and he posted a picture full of brown people to illustrate his "concern". What is the evidence that any of the people in that image are "foreigners"? There is none; but Bo French wants you to believe they are "foreigners" solely based on skin color. That is the racism that French is illustrating and that Marshal wants to defend by deflecting and obfuscating what is really going on here. In the end, Marshal is just like Jesse above, defending a racist because he puts team over principle. Marshal is just not as comically crude about it as Jesse is.

      1. Marshal   2 months ago

        Note how Marshal cleverly tries to change the subject. Marshal wants you to think that the real concern here is about racial discrimination for admission into UT; however, Bo French's concern was explicitly about *foreigners*,

        I think I see Jeffey's problem. When he cites the "subject" he refers to Bo French seeming to mistake him as the author instead of Reason writer Robby Soave.

        What's most amusing about Jeffey's screed, and there is a lot to choose from, is that my comment is one of the few actually on subject. The article's point is not that French's comments are bad, which is the setup, but rather that the picture shows the effect of eliminating race preferences. The entire article after the introduction focuses on this, suggesting Jeffey didn't even read it. As usual he was so eager to attack he didn't bother understanding what was going on.

        In the running for stupidest element though is the reference to "foreigners" is quotes even though my comment has nothing to do with national status. His mind is so disorganized he can't separate one issue from another. He seems to think everyone he disagrees with is addressing the same issue and thus his only response is relevant to them all. He's not the sharpest knife in the drawer.

        1. Purple Martin   2 months ago

          And...in arguing that a picture of a tens of thousands of people in a crowd, all seeming by dress, grooming and behavior to be true Texans (unless any Michigan regalia sneaked there) Marshal doubles down on the impression that his underlying motive has little to do with "eliminating race preferences [, well, except for the white people people forming the strong majority of that crowd]" but in trying to dog-whistle through racial and xenopobhic animus.

          Message received by both sides. We all hear you, Marshal, loud and clear.

          1. Marshal   2 months ago

            I see Jeffey has a new sock, and unsurprisingly it can't form coherent thoughts either. It asserts my comment has something to do with the picture although his language is so garbled it's impossible to understand what he believes creates this link. In truth though I only addressed Robby's belief conservatives have "won" and we no longer have race preferences in admissions.

            But because Jeffey thinks he has a winning attack he's going to pretend my comment has something to do with the picture instead of addressing Robby's article. Never change Jeffey!

            1. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

              I see Jeffey has a new sock

              Note that Marshal cannot argue honestly against an earnest interlocutor without inventing some slanderous lie about him. Purple Martin is not my "sock", and the fact that you claim he is only shows that you refuse to acknowledge even the most basic dignity of those against whom you argue, that they are even people. This is typical of those on the right: they refuse to acknowledge the world as it is, and so any contradictions to their narrative are manifested as "hoaxes" or "sock puppets" or some other type of trickery. It is because they are intellectually stunted mental morons with the moral reasoning capacity of a 12-year-old.

              1. Marshal   2 months ago

                In reality your incoherent thought process is pretty identifiable, there are multiple tells even in one paragraph.

                People's language and grammar choices give away much more than they want to believe to the point that AI can identify the author of even brief articles (1500 words) from an author population of many thousands with near perfect accuracy.

        2. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

          my comment is one of the few actually on subject.

          Note that Marshal continues to deflect by bald assertion: by just declaring himself to be right. Bold move there!

          In the running for stupidest element though is the reference to "foreigners" is quotes even though my comment has nothing to do with national status.

          Of course it didn't, because if you had focused on what the actual subject of the tweet was, you would have been forced to agree with me that Bo French's racism is odious and abominable. That is if you were intellectually honest, which of course you are not. You would rather defend a racist than agree with me on anything because you, like Jesse, put team over principle. Didn't you get mad at me a little while ago for a racist accusation? Of course you did, but now we know that was all an act. We now know that you don't care one whit about racial discrimination or racism, they are just arguments of convenience to attack your enemies. In reality, you are completely fine with racism as long as your team wins, and that is the saddest part of all.

          1. Marshal   2 months ago

            because if you had focused on what the actual subject of the tweet was,

            As already noted the subject is not the tweet, the subject is Robby's article which claims the tweet should be understood as evidence schools have eliminated racial discrimination in admissions.

            You would rather defend a racist

            I have in no way defended a racist, I have not addressed him at all. You lie that this is true because you have a pathological need to attack your enemies and the truth can't help you do that.

            you... put team over principle.

            We now know that you don't care one whit about racial discrimination or racism, they are just arguments of convenience to attack your enemies. In reality, you are completely fine with racism as long as your team wins, and that is the saddest part of all.

            The interesting fact about these comments is how true they are of you. I think this is why dries our animosity to me, you know that you fail the principles you pretend to hold and try to drag down those who do live up to them.

            1. Purple Martin   2 months ago

              So, Marshall, you finish your long whine of endlessly extended bumbersticker sloganing, never attempting original thought or rational reasoning but only personal insults and unsupported assertions, with the ever popular, indisputable, 4th-grade logic of I'm rubber, you're glue! Doody-head! (Albeit grammatically correct, with nicely constructed sentences and appropriate word choice—I appreciate that!).

              Marshall, Assertion ≠ Fact. Provide verifiable evidence of what you relate as fact. Please at least attempt to counter facts with additional or stronger verifiable facts. Counter opinions with well thought-out, better supported, more logical opinion. That does happen here occasionally and, when it does, I love it because it makes me better!

              But until you can do that, all you're creating is extended graffiti, just gang-tagging, the simple vandalism of virtue-signaling other members of your tribe by spray-painting obscenities on somebody else's wall.

              By the way, I've been commenting on Volokh Conspiracy with my single nym for decades, back when they were their own WordPress site and Arizona Jesse at least sometimes made sense. I followed as then went to WaPo and, when WaPo paywalled, to Reason.

              Grandfathered in, I engage on the Reason's main Gateway Pundit-level comment strings much less frequently than VC (whose agreement with Reason precludes charging their commenters, and the balance among different PoVs is much greater).

              I observe that accusing of sock-puppeting those you see as effective enemies, is one of your tells, as is your inability to discern the difference between a principled 'Classical Western Liberal Democracy' Conservative (like me), and a thoughtful, rational, more traditional Liberal/Progressive like chemjeff. (Personally, Politically, I'll accept existing within the boundaries of the noun, Liberal, as opposed to its opposite you represent, the adjective, illiberal. I'm neither a Democrat (left-center or otherwise) nor Progressive but don't deny the existence of those and other liberal sub-sets within those same boundaries.)

              The Reason strings are bearable only because I mute most of the the duplicative Gateway-Pundit wannabes, which leaves a dozen or so of the regulars not greyboxed, as archetypes of different strains of modern, new Right Trumpist MAGAism. I'm adding you to that list, as a fairly unique version—a competent, well-written concern troll. Good luck…I'll be interested to see if you ever manage to come up with anything new.

  12. Dillinger   2 months ago

    Bo French is an asshole but I'm not celebrating anybody for where they are from or the color of their skin. MLK to the end, baby.

    1. mad.casual   2 months ago

      Races are like assholes. Everybody's got one and they all stink. White people just eat less curry, objectively.

  13. MWAocdoc   2 months ago

    "Vice President JD Vance has an Indian wife"

    Shame on you! Apparently there's plenty of bias to go around here.

    Vance may be married to an Indian but he does not HAVE his wife. Women have been equal under the law in America for quite a while now. Women as regulatory chattel no longer exist. They have the right to vote, to own propery, to contract and to work for pay without permission from any man nowadays.

    1. Purple Martin   2 months ago

      This is the tell. They stop trying to argue any point of logic, and fall back to torturing syntax:

      What meaning HAVE, has.

      I HAVE a wife: Ms. Purple . Ms. Purple HAS a husband: Me.
      No chattel involved. And that's has been true for the last fifty years.

      1. mad.casual   2 months ago

        No chattel involved.

        Same thing next issue. If you fudge the definition of 'chattel' enough, there has been chattel involved.

        In reality, while the US isn't exclusive, it has never known de jure chattel sex slavery outside broader chattel slavery. Even de rigueur it was more between open secret and taboo rather than mandate. Something north of a third of Southern slave owners were women. When Britain paid slave owners to emancipate their slaves, something like 40% of the payments were to women. We fought the Mormons in part against bigamy before we started The Civil War.

        Even coverture requires a (retroactive) Marxist false dichotomy whereby two people voluntarily entering into a contract (without capital) must have a victim and an oppressor. Saying "Women couldn't own property and were (sexual) slaves until the 1960s (or whenever)." Is like saying CFOs are slaves to Sales and Executive officers because all the CFO does is write checks and make sandwiches while Sales and CEOs make all the money.

  14. MWAocdoc   2 months ago

    I agree with those who pointed out that the original comments by the perp here specifically said "foreign" students, not students of color. How that justifies a "Reason" rant against racism is not clear to me either.

    1. chemjeff radical individualist   2 months ago

      What is the evidence that any of those individuals pictured in the image are "foreign"? Answer: none. But people like Bo French want us to believe that people who are brown are automatically "foreigners", as if native-born and naturalized US citizens can't be any color at all. That is the racism.

  15. Agammamon   2 months ago

    Soave, if the admissions were fair and without racial bias then

    a) There would not be a photo of a thousand Indians at UT.
    b) There is a problem that Texas has such a large Indian population that they're displacing the native whites, Native Americans, and Mexican-Americans.

    Its literally population replacement but you want to pretend its not.

    Why TF are there so many Indians? Because they pay out-of-state tuition, displacing the Texans for those seats.

    1. mad.casual   2 months ago

      It's also notable that, despite all the "White (and Black) native-born Americans just don't work hard enough." these schools are conspicuously abandoning any sort of standardized testing (because math is racist), devaluing degrees, and consuming ever larger amounts of public loan dollars to support bloated administrations rather than strict educational rigor.

      Even if Bo French or whomever is being overtly racist, they A) aren't calling for anyone to have any sort of violence or non-contractual harm done to them and B) aren't wrong that lots of money and other social and cultural capital is being set on fire at the expense of taxpayers to do little more than produce the photo in question.

    2. Jim Conley   2 months ago

      Tejanos don't generally consider themselves "Mexican Americans " just because a Great-Grandmother still speaks Spanish better than she does English.

    3. Purple Martin   2 months ago

      Again, Aggie, neither you nor Bo French have any evidence at all that the vast majority of individuals in that picture are anything other than Texas-born native American citizens just like your "native whites, Native Americans, and Mexican-Americans," including some possibly Indian-Americans that are so triggering to you because they're of a duskier hue that you deem proper in America.

  16. mad.casual   2 months ago

    I heard UT graduation this year looked like this. I didn’t believe it. The problem is now obviously far worse than anyone imagined.

    Good fucking God I just realized how we've come full circle back to 2012-2014.

    Even racist assistant railroad dog catchers of Buttfuck County, TX have free speech, to be sure. Eh, Robby?

    FFS, we're citing Karl Rove sympathetically against an "I'm not a conspiracy theorist, I'm a 'This shit doesn't add up and it's obvious ' theorist." take. Apparently, Reason and Libertarianism didn't get the full value of the "It's not enough to be non-racist, we must be actively anti-racist." check when they tried to cash it the last time and trying to cash it again.

    1. mad.casual   2 months ago

      Are we really, today, going to take the position that the *entire* modern university system that brought us Claudine Gay, Jason Arday, Ketanji Brown Jackson, Dr. Christine Blasey Ford, Dr. Jill Biden, Dr. Anthony "The Science" Fauci, *and* two smacked down attempts at student loan foregiveness is beyond *any* sort of reproach when it comes to questions about favoritism and/or merit?

  17. IceTrey   2 months ago

    The guy in the cowboy hat was on tv, he was born in Texas.

  18. charliehall   2 months ago

    "a symptom of some deeper failure or moral betrayal of white America, one the Republican Party and the conservative movement have failed to prevent"

    The deeper failure is the unwillingness of a large fraction of White America to work hard. Their resentment at being outhustled, outworked, and outeducated by immigrants is what led to MAGA and its destruction of so many American institutions.

    It should be noted that while UT Austin's undergraduate body is mostly from Texas, its graduate programs attract the best students from everywhere. And it has a huge endowment because the Texas legislature gave it a lot of useless land a long time ago that turned out to be floating on immense oil reserves.

    1. TJJ2000   2 months ago

      You must be pointing to Asian Immigration specifically and exaggerating.
      Or more likely; just making up fantasy realities that fit your personal agenda (selfishness).

      The statistics on immigration is that the only "'out'-anything" special about immigrants is their HAND-OUT taking ability. Which is precisely the reason their home nation sucks. Born to believe the Gov 'Guns' should/could make sh8T for them.

  19. BigFish92672   2 months ago

    Wait. What? So now it's okay to say White Replacement Theory is real?

Please log in to post comments

Mute this user?

  • Mute User
  • Cancel

Ban this user?

  • Ban User
  • Cancel

Un-ban this user?

  • Un-ban User
  • Cancel

Nuke this user?

  • Nuke User
  • Cancel

Un-nuke this user?

  • Un-nuke User
  • Cancel

Flag this comment?

  • Flag Comment
  • Cancel

Un-flag this comment?

  • Un-flag Comment
  • Cancel

Latest

China Approved This Lung Cancer Drug. The FDA Is Making Americans Wait.

Jeffrey A. Singer | 11.18.2026 7:30 AM

Get Government Out of Air Traffic Control

J.D. Tuccille | 11.18.2026 7:00 AM

Brickbat: Watch Where You Point That

Charles Oliver | 11.18.2026 4:00 AM

Trump Says He Welcomes Foreign Students. His Policies Tell a Different Story.

Jacob Sullum | 11.18.2026 12:01 AM

Trump Can't Stop Talking About His Vanity Projects Because He Will Never Get the Gratitude He Craves

Jacob Sullum | 11.17.2026 4:35 PM

Recommended

  • About
  • Browse Topics
  • Events
  • Staff
  • Jobs
  • Donate
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Media
  • Amazon
Reason Facebook@reason on XReason InstagramReason TikTokReason YoutubeApple PodcastsReason on FlipboardReason RSS Add Reason to Google

© 2026 Reason Foundation | Accessibility | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Reason

The All-Argentina Issue is Here

New from Reason: a look into what Javier Milei has accomplished and what it will take to make the most of Argentina’s window for real change. Out now for subscribers.

Subscribe & Start Reading Learn More