Declassified Documents Detail the FBI's Surveillance of a Libertarian Sci-Fi Author
Vernor Vinge, who mocked the surveillance state in his writing, was investigated for alleged connections to socialist Sandinistas in Nicaragua.
Vernor Vinge—the Hugo Award–winning science fiction author who passed away in March 2024—imagined a world where individuals, not governments, held the power. His 1981 novella True Names featured hackers known as "warlocks" fighting a corrupt, incompetent government, while his 1985 novel The Peace War made the case for anarcho-capitalism.
"People are more diverse and distributed and resourceful and even coordinated than any government," Vinge told Reason in 2007. "That's a power we already have in free markets," he said. His ideas and influence extended far beyond libertarian circles; his 1993 essay, "The Coming Technological Singularity," has become a guiding concept in the modern tech industry.
Despite his clear libertarian leanings, the FBI worried about Vinge's association with socialists. His recently declassified file shows he was investigated for alleged "contact with Karl Amatneek," a computer engineer involved in TecNICA, an organization that sent technologically skilled volunteers to aid Nicaragua during the socialist Sandinista revolution.
When TecNICA leaders approached the Cuban embassy about expanding their volunteer projects, they were directed to meet with an intelligence officer, according to a 2021 interview with TecNICA member Louis Proyect. Soon after, the FBI began interrogating TecNICA members—and letting their peers in the computer industry know about it. TecNICA members told the Los Angeles Times that they were harassed for their foreign policy views, and Proyect insisted that the FBI's accusations exaggerated the reality.
A teletype message from January 1983 says the relationship between Vinge and Amatneek "has not yet been established," requesting more time to investigate. Ironically, Vinge had already mocked the incompetence of the surveillance state in True Names, describing a federal agent confidently insisting the government could catch any lone troublemaker if it devoted enough resources. Pollack, the character being questioned, knew better. "He had snooped on enough secret memos to realize that the Feds really believed it, but it was very far from true."
Vinge foresaw a world where individuals could outmatch governments. That made him a target of the very state machinery he critiqued.
This article originally appeared in print under the headline "Inside Vernor Vinge’s FBI File."
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please to post comments
If you think the FBI was bad 40+ years ago, Biden’s Arctic Frost was worse.
Fuck Joe Biden
Biden’s what now? Never heard of it.
— Reason
They’ll Brandon themselves oblivious.
It took years before the FBI uncovered the Jan.6 pipe bomber and they still can't figure out who brought in that baggie of coke into the White House.
Who is Ray Epps?
There is no good reason for the FBI to remain in existence. It needs to be shut down and never replaced either.
The long sordid history of that despicable organization , also known as one of the most corrupt law enforcement on the planet belongs in the book of sad, sorry mistakes.
Tom Woods TV/Abolish the FBI:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VNSthIxRQkw&pp=0gcJCQgKAYcqIYzv
This is incorrect. As long as there are (a few) Federal crimes that are not inconsistent with the Constitution there will need to be a Federal Investigation bureau of some kind. Although there would not need to be a Department of Justice, the Federal Prosecutors and Investigators could be brought to the Department of the Interior, which could likewise be downsized considerably, but they would still be Constitutional and justifiable.
This began as the US Marshalls?
As long as there is a federal law enforcement of some kind we will need a Federal Department of Internal Affairs. Watchmen to watch the watchmen so to speak.
When they're on the same Team (i.e.: FedGov) I have no faith that such a department would do anything but absolve their comrades for anything except the most visible, embarrassing, and damaging offenses.
"We," Paleface? "will"? Crystal ball gazer?
Just continue to bow and scrape in front of your masters.
By now it's obvious to anyone paying attention just how corrupt not only the FBI but the DOJ and anyone connected to any of it has become.
A Fire Upon the Deep and A Deepness in the Sky were fantastic books.
"Peace War" sounded familiar, but I had to look it up. Soon as the review mentioned the Bobblers, it all came back. My one sentence review is that it was a lot of fun, just ignore the simplistic politics. If the feds thought that made him a socialist, they were as deluded as everyone else.
Interesting, I had been under the impression this sort of thing had ended after Hoover's death, what with his paranoia no longer pushing things.
You should look at Harry Anslinger's career. It started out leveraging fanatical and superstitious prohibition laws into The Crash and Great Depression. In 1930 Bert (not J Eddie) Hoover appointed Anslinger dope Czar with an entire armed bureaucracy to command. By 1931, that bureaucracy had infiltrated Woodie Wilson's pet League of Nations leveraging its Charter Article 23 into a global War On Everything (except American cigarettes and chawin' terbacky.) German reparations funded "Allied" interest payments on U.S. loans to fight The Hun--until Bert and Harry ruined everything 13JULY1931 and made Hitler the voters' choice.
Of course, there's no such thing as the Deep State.
The attractive, anarchocapitalist society that is the setting of Vinge's novella "The Ungoverned" appears to be based on David D. Friedman's non-fiction book on anarchocapitalism, _The_Machinery_of_Freedom_. I recommend both.
Text of "The Ungoverned": https://www.baen.com/Chapters/1416520724/1416520724___4.htm
PDF of Friedman's book:
http://daviddfriedman.com/Machinery%203rd%20Edn.pdf
I read it. Young Friedmanstein really needed to get into Lenin's Party, which rejected his ilk. To understand the legalize-murder crowd it helps notice two things: for 200 years "anarchist" has been a synonym in all print media and fiction for "violent communist." The second is the 1972 LP platform--the one that brought us geometric increase in votes--THAT objective constitutional minarchist voting formula is what the commie anarchists and Jesus Nazis BOTH are against. Like their Dem and MAGAt masters, they labor to shift the LP off-mission and toward coercive collectivism of both stripes, leading to the OPPOSITE single square in the Nolan Chart from what Libertarians and objectivists (and voters) want.
I did just now buy two Vinge books, but did not find The Ungoverned for sale. Recently rereading Heinlein's "Harsh Mistress" and Eric and Frank Russell's "The Great Explosion," it's hard to object to an anarchist prison revolt or defection from a bureaucratized imperial crew. But the LP was born of a fanatical struggle between altruist socialism and basically identical altruist mystical socialism within a constitutional framework that leverages small party spoiler vote clout--but guns down prison riots and hangs communist traitors. The original platform did not need fixing.
I believe that "The Ungoverned" is in some editions of the omnibus _Across_Realtime_ (Baen Books) physically between the novels between which it chronologically is set.
Nicaragua, long coveted as a potential canal site, was invaded by the USA in 1867. Its economy collapsed when the Panama Canal effort went broke in 1893. The US went imperialist and exported shoot-first prohibitionism in all directions until, by 1933, everybody on the continent hated the fanatics that had destroyed their economies. Small wonder the communists were more popular than Harry Anslinger's Bureaucracy by the time JFK was assassinated. And today the DEA still labors to make everyone hate the fascists forcing gin and cigarettes on their countries.
McCarthy was right.
Why people continue to subscribe to the idea that the government is our friend staggers the mind.
The government is a creature unto itself with its own goals and self interests, not any of yours.
The FBI, DOJ, the courts are there for your benefit. They exist to protect the government from the people.
Under the Obiden regime both were used to persecute anyone who they felt was a threat to their power.