Held Hostage Overseas? The IRS Wants Your Back Taxes.
The IRS fines hostages for taxes they couldn't pay while they were detained. A bill in Congress is trying to fix this.

Many Americans who return home after being illegally detained overseas arrive to find they've been billed thousands of dollars by the IRS—including late fees for unpaid taxes.
That's the bizarre situation in which hostages Evan Gerskovich, Paul Whelan, and Vladimir Kara-Murza found themselves after they were released from detention in Russia last month. All three men say they faced a battery of surprise financial issues after returning home, including tax charges and hits to the credit stemming from bills they were unable to pay while behind bars.
"I got one of those bills from the IRS saying, you owe this much on this year, you owe this much on this year because of failure to pay on time—here's the interest that's accrued," Washington Post reporter and former hostage Jason Rezaian told NPR. He faced more than $6,000 in fees for unpaid taxes after his release, following 544 days of detention in Iran. "This is an oversight that nobody really thought about."
And they're not alone. Right now, between 40 and 60 American nationals are being illegally detained by other nations, according to NPR. Many of these Americans will return home to face startling financial penalties stemming from their unjust imprisonment.
The IRS, for its own part, claims that it doesn't have the legal authority to remove tax fees for returning hostages. However, that could change. Earlier this year, Sen. Chris Coons (D–Del.) introduced the Stop Tax Penalties on American Hostages Act, an aptly named bill that would require the IRS to exempt hostages from tax liability during the period of their detainment. The bill would also force the IRS to allow hostages and their spouses to apply to have their tax-related fines removed.
If Coons' bill passes, it would solve a small but frustrating problem in our robotic tax system. It's a no-brainer that someone illegally detained abroad can't pay their Netflix subscription on time—much less their taxes. In addition to dealing with the horrors of being held hostage in a foreign country and dealing with the rocky transition back to normal life, former detainees shouldn't also get slapped with thousands of dollars of fines for taxes they never could have paid in the first place.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Never oppose the KGB…I mean the IRS.
Sarc, an opportunity for your IRS wordplay.
THE + IRS = THEIRS
Will this cover FAFSA?
IRS is hilarious . I found out when my parents died in the same year that they were still on the hook for paying taxes for the year they died in. After being horribly offended and outraged, it was kinda funny.
They must have made over 400k. Everybody else is exempt.
Why the actual fuck would this require an act of Congress? The IRS seemingly is able to grant all sorts of reprieves on their own. Talk to them and the administration about how much of a dick move this is.
It takes a special kind of scum to seek out a job at the IRS. The kind of scum that sees no problem with this sort of thing.
Feature not bug. Many of those detentions in other countries get the unofficial blessing of our government cronies...to send a message or something. Good way to keep the punishment coming.
Many Americans who return home after being illegally detained overseas arrive to find they've been billed thousands of dollars by the IRS—including late fees for unpaid taxes.
Now THOSE are junk fees
The interest and penalties charged by the IRS for true taxes are designed to destroy the ones who owes the taxes. They are far above market rates. I haven't noticed that idiot in the White House addressing them. I guess junk fees are what someone else charges.
Price gauging is rampant.
But “one real rough, nasty day” or “One rough hour, and I mean real rough” in response to criminals perpetrating rampant retail theft is the real totalitarian, cruel-and-unusual-punishment shoe waiting to drop around this place.
1. I don't blame the IRS for going after back taxes if you were a hostage. I blame the dumb ass democrats and republicans who are so greedy to steal the money from a hostage.
2. Ask me again why I believe the income tax should be repealed.
"This is an oversight that nobody really thought about."
False. Funding government through (e.g.) tariffs or consumption taxes would completely obviate this.
You actually think tariffs and consumption taxes aren't nosy and intrusive?
Why do you think there are so many laws against too many yard sales, regulating flea market sales, and tracking everything stores sell?
Hey Stupid, have you ever been in and Iranian prison? Did you conduct a lot of yard sales while you were in an Iranian prison? I could understand that taking it up the ass for a living, your income probably didn’t or wouldn’t slow down in the least.
Unless, of course, rather than obliviously projecting that you’d still be making bank by turning tricks in an Iranian prison you were promising or threatening that, even if they were locked in an Iranian prison, you’d still find them guilty of conducting a yard sale or importing goods into the country they had left.
Dumbass.
They must have made over 400k. Everybody else is exempt.
Don't know why this ended up here. The Reason gods must be angry.
nm
I wonder if it gets you out of jury duty.
Philosophical question for the day:
Would a good reporter have found out how the hostages were earning taxable income while detained, and included that information?
The IRS is not monitored or controlled in any way. It bills, then meets and lowers the amount or forgives it. I've seen it. So, when it tells us that it has "no legal authority to forgive" it is lying. It does what it wants.
Side note: Reporters shouldn't allow any govt. entity to make anonymous statements that get printed. Govt. is people. They have names. They should be held accountable by printing their names.