Biden Administration Says It Will Finalize Second Attempt at Blanket Student Loan Forgiveness This Fall
If at first you don't succeed, try, try again.

Last week, the Biden administration announced that it would unveil a second attempt at issuing blanket student loan forgiveness within the next few months. The announcement comes more than a year after its first attempt was blocked by the Supreme Court.
"The Biden-Harris Administration made a commitment to deliver student debt relief to as many borrowers as possible as quickly as possible," said Education Secretary Miguel Cardona in a statement last Wednesday. "And today, as we near the end of a lengthy rulemaking process, we're one step closer to keeping that promise."
The announcement builds on a release in April of draft rules that aim to enact student loan forgiveness primarily by expanding existing loan forgiveness programs. The Education Department says it has begun notifying borrowers about the coming rules and informing them about a deadline to opt out of forgiveness.
The proposed rules target specific groups of borrowers, including borrowers who now owe more than they originally took out in loans due to accumulating interest, borrowers who have been in repayment for decades, and those who are eligible but not enrolled in existing forgiveness programs. Borrowers who enrolled in low-value degree programs, such as those that "failed to provide sufficient financial value, or that failed one of the Department's accountability standards for institutions" are also eligible for new forgiveness efforts.
Last week's announcement also stated that those eligible would most likely receive forgiveness automatically, with no application or additional steps required.
If enacted, the rules could end up affecting even more borrowers than would have been affected by the Biden administration's first forgiveness plan. The Education Department predicts that if the proposed rules go into effect, the Biden administration would have made over 30 million borrowers eligible for forgiveness through its efforts over the last three years. In contrast, Biden's first attempt at blanket student loan forgiveness was predicted to impact just 27 million eligible borrowers.
"If finalized as proposed, these new rules would authorize relief for borrowers across the country who have struggled with the burden of student loan debt," reads last week's statement. "The Biden-Harris Administration has taken historic steps to reduce the burden of student debt and ensure that student loans are not a barrier to educational and economic opportunity for students and families."
The Education Department predicts that the finalized rules will be released sometime in the fall. However, with the election in November looming, it's doubtful whether the department can actually provide forgiveness before the end of Biden's term. And considering that legal challenges are almost certain to follow any attempt to enact large-scale loan forgiveness, it's unclear if there is any realistic chance that the Biden administration can enact this plan. At the moment, these latest efforts might be best thought of as a last-minute political stunt designed to energize young, college-educated voters rather than an earnest policy effort.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Do not underestimate how desperate the Biden admin is to shore up the pro-Hamas vote.
Votes aren't cheap; so let's pay for them with our tax revenue [actually they will just be added to the deficit].
They’re also paying for them with Israeli lives. And soon American lives too.
I strongly suspect this latest attempt to buy what should already be Democrat voters will drop right around the time absentee ballots/early voting starts, to lock up the votes before a legal challenge is issued, a court date selected, and the Biden administration finds itself in court (again!) explaining that despite all previous SCOTUS decisions against it, paying off student debt is something the President can do.
Is he promising Kamala will send everyone a $6000 check yet?
I have a brilliant plan. Tax outstanding student load debt. Who says we can't tax liabilities? Use that revenue to pay off the student loans.
Also a hefty federal tax on blue, pink, green, and purple hair dye. I'm sure we can come up with some environmental excuse. I'm sure those colors are killing turtles somewhere.
I have an even better idea: stop using taxpayer money to bail out useless universities to keep them afloat. No more federal funding for universities.
It's time to clean out the universities of all Marxist/communist trash by what ever means necessary.
You mean a ‘cunning plan’? Baldrick would have done quite well working for the Biden administration.
What do you call a president who keeps trying to circumvent the Constitution with power he does not actually have? A dick...something?
A traitor.
A Dick-Traitor
Is that anything like a Traitor-Tot? Tasty deep fried potato snack.
Dictator
Autocrat
Despot
Authoritarian
A president who recognizes the Constitution, clearly.
...who recognizes the Constitution as something that doesn't apply to him, perhaps?
And one that by subverting the constitution -er, … i mean recognizes the constitution as toilet paper…. ‘will save democracy’
Democrat.
Depends. Is the president in your tribe or the other tribe?
Obligatory.
sarcasmic 12 months ago
Flag Comment
Mute User
Why wouldn’t there be? Despite all his faults, at least Biden recognizes the Constitution. Can’t say the same about Trump.
I know. Trump said he could fire political appointees without involving congress so they are the same
see my comment above – he ‘recognizes’ the constitution alright !
The same way he recognizes dead people in his rally audiences.
And I was just wondering how you were going to try to chaff and redirect from Democratic Party criticism in this thread, Sarckles.
I suppose hoping for something original was just too much though.
This president is in yours... so you tell us?
bOaF SIdeS!
If the "other" tribe does it, we can discuss it then.
Got any friends or family left who hasn't been divided over politics?
Projecting again buddy?
My friends and family are quite unified, thanks just the same.
So, when did the Right actively try to subvert the Constitution? I'll be happy to condemn it. Unlike you with Biden.
Scheming and corrupted , dishonest and untrustworthy.
Corruption/def: the Biden Family.
Impeachable.
Just leave it at dick.
Yes. A dick.
Imagine the cheek of overhauling your policy proposal to comply with Supreme Court rulings.
When they said it violates the law, what they really meant was, don't do it even if it doesn't violate the law. Stop trying to read Supreme Court decisions as guidance for policymaking!
Plus, it's totally UNPRECEDENTED (since Trump did it with his "Muslim ban", anyway)...
Trump's so-called "Muslim ban" was based on a very logical idea - if the country an asylum seeker is fleeing can't provide any information on the asylum seeker, we can't vet the asylum seeker, so we should deny their request.
Seems pretty simple, doesn't it.
If you want to make the Student Loan Debt cancellation make sense, means test it. A doctor making six figures doesn't need their loans paid off, do they? Rich people took out student loans because it was cheap money, and took their time paying it off because, again, it was cheap money. I remember when Obama ran for President, after collecting several million dollars in book advances, speaking fees, etc, he STILL had student loan debt.
>>Biden Administration
was ist das?
Ich glaube, dass er die obama regierung gemeint.
This administration is clearly socialist. Use other people's money to pay for bogus college educations that young people stupidly thought would gain them some important position. There aren't enough H.R. positions available anymore and that degree in transgender studies is about as useful as a bad case of the clap.
So as a tax payer I resent the hell out of this phony dick brained president and equally dick brained administration for forcing the rest of us to pay for other's stupid mistakes.
Go to hell Joe Biden and take Harris and the rest of your people with you.
So, the Biden administration will try to over rule the SCOTUS again.
I'm impressed with their power to do so.
I never thought the executive branch had such power.
All the previous POTUS stand corrected.
Well, he has immunity now, so no downside for him.
Good point, lol.
But, taking steps to comply with the Supreme Court's ruling is not "overruling" the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court's job is to interpret the law, not to make policy, so they have no policy Biden can "overrule".
I actually got a letter about this scheme from the Department of Education.
I'm still making my automatic accelerated payments. I don't believe that they will be able to do this without legislation. Not that I want them to.
It's always equitable to make the people who could not afford to even think of attending to college pay for a bunch of entitled middle class student loans which are typically for liberal arts poor paying non-productive jobs. Attend 4 years of school for a worthless degree so you can get a job as a barista instead of just getting a job as a barista out of high school, but don't worry Joe Biden will make the poor pay for your tuition even if it was ruled unconstitutional. As we have seen the Democrat party is all about saving democracy through authoritarian force even if the voters do agree with their dystopian agenda.
This program isn't means-tested, so it will not only pay off state college transgender study degrees, but also Georgetown law and Harvard medical degrees.
The fucking Democrats really should focus media coverage on their free shit schemes, as opposed to trying to fabricate redeeming qualities for their presidential candidate.
Smart move.
I would prefer they focus their efforts on killing themselves. They can call it retroactive abortions.
"Blanket Student Loan Forgiveness This Fall"
Fall, eh? Anything else going on fall 2024?
Imagine immediately going after a former president with lawfare for paying off a porn star after an election and calling it illegal campaign contributions, while actively bribing a large part of the voting population in real time, against the constitution and advisement from the SCOTUS that its illegal.
That would be crazy, right?
Should Trump win, he might need to charge Biden and Harris with election interference over this nonsense.
He should do much lot than that. The FOJ should start going after democrat media outlets, and prosecute them for serial FEC violations, which should be easy to prove. Then as ongoing criminal enterprises, RICO attaches.
This is a great way to throw the democrat propaganda media in prison under existing law. Thus taking away one the democrat’s most powerful weapons.
I never understood Biden't obsession with student loan forgiveness. It's just a Democrat tax give-away, used in the same way tax cuts are by Republicans, but in both cases the target voters are probably going to vote for those proponents anyway, so it doesn't seem to be tax dollars very well spent (even if it weren't corrupt).
But it must work, or both parties wouldn't make an effort to do it in election years...
Eh....C- attempt at the reverse concern troll. It's okay, ONS, everyone can see whose tank you are in. Just let the blue flow through you.
What ground was the previous unappropriated spending struck down on that's different for this one? Is it just like the joke about their being out of doughnuts, so you order just a doughnut?
https://www.scotusblog.com/2023/06/supreme-court-strikes-down-biden-student-loan-forgiveness-program/
That plan was based on the HEROES Act, which Betsy DeVos used to suspend payments and accrual of interest during Covid.
The HEROES Act, Roberts emphasized, gives the secretary of education the power to “waive or modify” laws and regulations governing the student-loan programs. Congress’s use of the word “modify” means that the Biden administration can make “modest adjustments and additions to existing provisions,” Roberts wrote, “not transform them.” But the debt-relief program, Roberts stressed, instead “created a novel and fundamentally different loan forgiveness program.” The plan “modifies” student-loan laws and regulations, Roberts suggested, “only in the same sense that the French Revolution ‘modified’ the status of the French nobility — it has abolished them and supplanted them with a new regime entirely.”
Roberts rejected the Biden administration’s contention that the secretary of education also has the power to “waive” laws and regulations relating to the student-loan program. When the secretary has invoked this power in the past, Roberts observed, he has done so for a specific legal requirement, such as the requirement that a student provide a written request for a leave of absence. But in this case, Roberts noted, the secretary has not indicated that he is waiving a specific provision.
Roberts also rebuffed the Biden administration’s argument that the debt-relief program is consistent with the purpose of the HEROES Act – that is, to give the secretary of education the power to provide relief to borrowers during a national emergency. “The question here,” Roberts countered, “is not whether something should be done; it is who has the authority to do it.” On this point, Roberts invoked the “major questions” doctrine, which is the idea that if Congress wants to give an administrative agency the power to make decisions of vast economic or political significance, it must say so clearly. But in this case, Roberts said, the HEROES Act did not authorize the debt-relief program at all, much less clearly.
Presumably, it won't be based on the HEROES Act.
Borrowers who enrolled in low-value degree programs, such as those that “failed to provide sufficient financial value, or that failed one of the Department’s accountability standards for institutions” are also eligible for new forgiveness efforts.
https://i.giphy.com/Ow59c0pwTPruU.webp
Seems targeted at all the cultural and gender studies dimwits working as Starbucks coffee-slingers.
I will support it --- if the money has to, instead, come from the endowments of universities.
Make them hurt for ripping off young morons.
Oooohhhh... that would be delicious!
The loss from the market,with the growing interest on the debt, will crash everything
$6.4 Trillion Stock Wipeout Has Traders Fearing ‘Great Unwind’ Is Just Starting
Biden Deficits Increase by $400 Billion in Four Months
Consider that the Biden administration are mostly Obongo socialists/Marxists who do not recognize the Constitution as their only goal is a Marxist state.
Joe McCarthy was right.
Did he suggest parts of it could be "terminated", too?