Chinese Censors Target a Textbook
In China, 27 people were punished for their involvement in producing math textbooks that featured drawings of a child sticking his tongue out and making a peace sign.

The Communist Party of China has punished 27 people involved in producing state-approved math textbooks that featured "subversive" images of children, including drawings of a child sticking his tongue out and making a peace sign, male children grabbing female children, and a girl in a bunny outfit. The Global Times, a state-controlled newspaper, reported in August that the head of the People's Education Press was given demerits and the editor in chief was fired. Illustrators who worked on the book, according to The Guardian's translation of the Ministry of Education's announcement, were "dealt with accordingly."
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
This is proof that the US needs allow illustrative pictures of kids giving men blowjobs in their school libraries.
I don't think it proves that at all, unfortunately. The child on the right is gesturing the number 2, and the one on the left, 6. Chinese have a system for gesturing numbers using one hand only. Numbers 1-5 are clear, but also 6-10. The Chinese child giving the hand job to a gentleman in the school library still has one hand free to gesture any number from one to ten.
China gonna China
I work from home providing various internet services for an hourly rate of $80 USD. I never thought it would be possible, but my trustworthy friend persuaded me to take the opportunity after telling me how she quickly (aps-02) earned 13,000 dollars in just four weeks while working on the greatest project. Go to this article for more information.
…..
——————————>>> https://smart.online100.workers.dev/
American progressives are thinking “can’t wait till we can do things like this.”
Dr. Seuss, Huckleberry Finn and TinTin prove that they didn't wait.
Neither leftards nor right wingnuts are big fans of free speech. At least not for anyone sufficiently wicked and depraved to disagree with them.
Chinese wokism.
Says the Nazi who advocates prosecuting people when he thinks they're lying.
Lying is coercion, compelling others under the false authority of truth to act in the liars interest instead of their own.
It should be criminalized.
Why do you lie, and call me a Nazi? You have zero proof for your claim.
I challenge you to prove it or how you or anyone else has refuted anything I’ve said and prove your claim with a link to the alleged conversation.
This is where all you lying, bleating, waste of skin trolls cut and run.
I don't know anything about you, Rob, but I'm going to have to agree with you there!
This is how I clearly and unambiguously ensure that what I say represents truth, reality.
I value the inalienable human right to free speech.
I value the supremacy of correctly applied logic and science in discerning and demonstrating truth aka reality.
I value the application of both in open debate to conclude and demonstrate that truth can never be refuted while untruths can be.
I commit that if what I say is ever refuted, I’ll never say it again.
Who else can honestly say this and back it up as I do?
Does this represent the character of the bogeyman?
It sounds almost like the Fauci “I am science speech.” Well done.
Freedom of speech means freedom to say what is wrong. Without a freedom to speak openly, one’s freedom is undermined fundamentally. Free speech is how we articulate ourselves, our world and our solutions. We have to engage in that debate in a “good faith” approach or we risk losing our ability to decide for or govern ourselves.
While there is such a thing as a subjective truth, but there is no such thing as a subjective *authority* to truth. Therefore, “truthful limits” to speech (absent obvious violations of fraud, libel, etc) cannot be subjectively understood or regulated. False statements cannot be regulated in a free society; however they can be refuted by those who exercise their own free speech to speak the truth.
“Therefore, “truthful limits” to speech (absent obvious violations of fraud, libel, etc) cannot be subjectively understood or regulated. “
Subjective understanding is your straw man.
Obvious violations are objectively understood.
Of course all lies need to be objectively proven to be prosecuted as crime as they should be.
"dealt with accordingly."
Wood chipper?
Nah, how would you harvest the organs?
I understand it's a brickbat, but it would be nice to know or understand some of the context. Like, I know the symbol above supinated is "flipping the bird" in Kingdoms loyal to
herHis Royal Highness and our "OK" (or white supremacist dog whistle) is the flipping the bird in Chinese, but how do the censors know that symbol isn't just "2"? Are the censors actually opposed to even a passive implication of peace or is the 'tongue and peace' a specific message (like free Hong Kong)? Similarly, (included for Jeffy's benefit) presumably the boys are grabbing the girls inappropriately rather than Jack grabbing Jill's hand to go up the hill to fetch a pail of water.It's OK to be explicit about the Chinese censorship's infractions. No one here will get offended.
The girl on the left definitely seems to be flashing the hang loose sign. The only person claiming it's '2' so far is trueman, who's a socialist apologist. If the illustrator was savvy enough to know hang loose, I think the peace sign isn't a stretch. Maybe most importantly. How the fuck is this not too local?
"The only person claiming it’s ‘2’ so far is trueman,"
Because 2 is an important part of a Chinese math text book. So is 6.
The hand gesture for 2 consists of the index and middle fingers extended. The hand gesture for 6 is the little finger extended. The pictures show this clearly.
The picture doesn't show
7: thumb and first two fingers touching at tips
8: thumb and index finger widely spread (like the ideograph)
9: a crooked index finger
10: a balled fist
Several of those are no doubt signs for "white supremacy", according to Democrats.
Some of them may be signs for white supremacy according to white supremacists. So what? Signs vary from country to country, just like languages, cuisine, dress, and other cultural norms.
The girl on the left definitely seems to be flashing the hang loose sign.
Everyone in the pic looked stoned, retarded, or both as far as I could tell. Certainly not sympathetic to the PRC but those illustrators deserved some disciplinary action AFAICT.
Jack grabbing Jill's hand is literally violence.
Jack should be blowing his teacher, John. Wholesome sex education for the under-12's.
"No one here will get offended."
If only. Best I can tell, at least half the comments lately are people being offended, either by the article, by other commenters, or because it's Tuesday.
Don't spare any tears for the PRCers. They are not people. They are toilets with arms and legs.
Eh.
It was just a business decision.
You know who else censored textbooks?
John Keating, of Weldon Academy?
The State of Texas?
Don't worry about china, Mike.
https://youtu.be/PBgbYQ5QAM0
We’re no better than they are. Notwithstanding their appalling human rights violations, they still appear to have a sense of self-preservation. Give them credit for that.
As for us: for the last few years, ideologues walked into our universities spouting neo-Marxist propaganda, without so much as a whisper from the rest of our society. Now they’ve moved on to our elementary schools and we are still silent, save a few vestiges of angry libertarians and Christians on the inter- web.
Our children are being offered up on the altar of political correctness right now. At least China has the courage to stand up for their own.
Thank you for sharing! Keep up the updates.
In only 5 weeks, I worked part-time from my loft and acquired $30,030. In the wake of losing my past business, I immediately became depleted. {res-02} Luckily, I found this occupations on the web, and subsequently, I had the option to begin bringing in cash from home immediately. Anybody can achieve this tip top profession and increment their web pay by:.
.
EXTRA DETAILS HERE:>>> https://extradollars3.blogspot.com/