No, Gas Prices Didn't Spike Because of 'Corporate Greed'
Corporations were just as greedy when prices fell in 2019 and early 2020.

The price of gas keeps rising.
"The reason for that is because of Putin's war," said President Joe Biden.
But that's impossible. Most of the price rise came before Russian President Vladimir Putin attacked Ukraine.
So some politicians simply blame "corporate greed."
Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D–R.I.) accuses the oil industry of collecting "excess profit."
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D–Mass.) even introduced a bill to ban "price gouging."
This is just economic ignorance, as my new video explains.
"If big oil could raise prices anytime they wanted and get away with it, then why were they so cheap in 2020, 2019, 2018?" asks the Competitive Enterprise Institute's Ben Lieberman.
Lieberman points out that companies are always greedy. Greed didn't just start now. They were just as greedy when gas prices fell in 2019 and early 2020.
"It all comes down to cutting back on supplies," says Lieberman.
It's not complicated. Prices change because of supply and demand.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, fewer people drove, and demand for gasoline dropped. So did its price. Oil drillers then did less drilling. Now demand is up because people are driving again.
But it takes time for producers to adjust.
"It takes months, not days, for a company to increase production," says Biden.
I'm relieved that the president understands that, but he ignores how his own policies reduce production and raise the price of gas. He didn't mention that when he canceled a long-planned sale of offshore oil rights this week.
Activists want Biden to also kill a pipeline that would bring oil from Canada to Wisconsin. They've already delayed it five years. They delayed the Keystone Pipeline for 16 years, until Biden killed it altogether.
This is so dumb. Stopping pipelines doesn't even help the environment. Oil still gets shipped, but by truck, train and barge. That leads to more oil spills.
At least one congressman is as foolish as the activists.
Last fall, at a congressional hearing titled "Exposing Big Oil's Disinformation Campaign to Prevent Climate Action," grandstanding Rep. Ro Khanna (D–Calif.) scolded oil executives for producing too much oil.
"Are you embarrassed as an American company that your production is going up?" Khanna said to Chevron CEO Michael Wirth.
"Demand for energy is going up in the world," Wirth responded, reasonably.
"Would you commit to reducing the production of oil?" Khanna asked ExxonMobil CEO Darren Woods.
"We're committed to lowering our emissions," Woods answered.
"I'll take that as a 'no,'" sneered Khanna.
Hilariously, now that gas prices are up, Khanna goes on TV to complain that oil companies don't produce more oil. "They're still not increasing the production!" he whines.
I tried to interview Khanna about his hypocrisy, but he won't talk to me.
"It's amazing what $4 a gallon gasoline in an election year will do to cause some people to change their minds!" says Lieberman.
Still, the environmental activists aren't totally crazy.
"We have to protect the Earth," I say to Lieberman. "Sometimes the market isn't the best director."
"There is pollution, and there is a reason to address it," Lieberman responds, "But we have to be realistic…these threats are repeatedly exaggerated."
They sure are.
"[But in] the public debate, you're losing. They're winning," I point out.
"At $4 a gallon gasoline, I think we're seeing a rethinking of the climate agenda," Lieberman replies.
Biden, at his State of the Union address, did say his top priority would be "getting prices under control."
But he can't get gas prices under control without more use of those hated fossil fuels.
"The Biden administration either has to choose between affordable energy or the climate agenda," says Lieberman. "It can't do both."
COPYRIGHT 2022 BY JFS PRODUCTIONS INC.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
We traded all of our manufacturing jobs to Mexico and China for cleaner water and air, why can't we trade all of our energy production away as well?
No. Wrong. The US (well, pre-pandemic) manufacturing sector was larger than ever before, but it was more efficient, which releases those excess workers for other industries. Thus it has always been, otherwise the population would still be 90% farmers. Creative destruction -- it even has a name.
Faith alone!
He's right, dude. I thought you were smarter than that.
What is your criticism of or counter argument to the evidence based assertion that American manufacturing output is at an all time high despite fewer workers as a result of automation?
USA manufactures a shitload, and we do it with fewer people.
Is that bad, and if so why?
I have actually collected $30,220 merely Four weeks by easily working part-time on my laptop.~ui85~When I have lost my office post, I was troubled & eventually I obtained this best career achieving this I was able to have thousand of dollars just staying at my home. Each individual can start this chance and obtain extra money online.
.
By visiting this web-page. https://brilliantfuture01.blogspot.com/
Besides all the blow-holing propaganda...
Why does it seem EVERY BLOODY manufactured item I buy is "Made in China"???? One would think not having to ship items across the globe would make USA made items far more appealing... Where are they?
Absolute nonsense. Manufacturing made up 11% of gross domestic product in the second quarter, the smallest share in data going back to 1947 and down from 11.1%.
Were you trying to rebut me by saying nonsense?
If so, you rebut yourself every link you post.
LOL!
You tried so hard, and that's all you could come up with?
Keep the faith, alphabeta.
"manufacturing sector was larger than ever before" -- Probably thank Trumps De-Regulation for that....
But it was still MILES away from a good point to be.. Heck it's not unreasonable at all to believe if the USA didn't hold the worlds oil trade currency the USA would be found out as the Poverty stricken communist nation the Nazi's have made it. Many economists have stated this exact thing. That the USA would collapse if foreign nations ditched the USD as their energy trading marker.
We traded manufacturing jobs for automation that allows American workers to be degrees of magnitude more productive than people overseas.
And somehow even with all that automation working away; it takes a full-time job (sometimes two) just to have a box of sticks(house) and a vehicle.
The whole 'automation' took the jobs doesn't hold water. Human progress has been growing since the cave man; that doesn't mean just ONE person works in today's world now does it...
So since the automation didn't ruin things in whatever yesteryear means it will not do it now....
Just because pigs can't fly yesteryear; doesn't mean they can't fly now.... lol....
Only the keen mind and quick thinking of SleepyJoe can save us.
hahaha well we're in big, big trouble then!
It's ridiculous how often this argument has to be made. Gasoline is a hugely competitive market. If one supplier could cut the price by 50 cents per gallon, they would own the market (if the competitors were stupid enough to think that artificially high prices are good business).
If the price goes up it's greed. If the price goes down then look away and forget about all that greed stuff oh look it went up! Greed!
If the price goes up it's greed. If the price goes down then look
away and forget about all that greed stuffat all the non-progressive stuff that goes on in oil producing countries that we have to prevent at any/all costs... oh look it went up! Greed!Admittedly, the smoke and mirrors, the man behind the curtain... it's all the same Great and Powerful Oz.
Dr. Oz?
It sort of is... but it also isn't.
We haven't built new refineries here in decades. Places like California and the Chicago region have specialty blends that aren't made elsewhere and in California's case there's no way to get other blends in short of shipping them from Korea of all places.
Lots of this is going on. It's one of the reasons Keystone was a deal, getting oil to refineries, but the refinieries are at full bore now and there's so much red tape that new refineries aren't coming on line.
Seems like a broken market to me, where existing players aren't going to see new competition, even though current refineries are at 100% and selling everything they can make at record prices.
That said, it's still a governmental problem, and decidedly NOT a matter of gouging. Energy production is a vast industry always boom and bust and the cycle changes at the whims of external forces.
the thing that irks me the most is the way those who push for aggressive action on climate change are too stupid to understand that gas prices have to be high to actually make it happen. as long as fossil fuels are cheap, there will never be sufficient incentive to change to other sources of energy.
there is some room for debate on where everyone, individually, thinks the line should be to maximize the transition to something else while minimizing the pain of that transition..... but if you have been hard to the extreme of ending the use of fossil fuels as fast as possible, you would think you would see high gas prices as a win. another example of politicians using an issue to get votes but not actually wanting to take any action on it.
Eat a bullet, fatass.
Not very cash money of you Nardz.
Wouldn’t want you to eat a bullet sugar bear.
Drink Drano instead.
there is some room for debate on where everyone, individually, thinks the line should be to maximize the transition to something else while minimizing the pain of that transition
The government shouldn't be engaged in social engineering.
the thing that irks me the most is the way those who push for aggressive action on climate change are too stupid to understand that gas prices have to be high to actually make it happen.
^What you say when you're too stupid to conceive of, let alone understand, the paradox of diamonds and water.
Oil traded near $120 in 2012 and gas prices were averaging $3.30. Today oil trades near $109 and gas prices average $4.57. Why is gas so much more expensive now even though oil is cheaper?
Because multiple inputs go into the price. How much do you have to pay the people doing the refining? How much does it cost to transport the gasoline to where it's going?
Plus it's a futures market, and the future's fucked because the WEF has a plan to destroy the western middle/working class.
We are way beyond revolution being justified.
Have been for awhile now. Besides, the left cares nothing for our rights or lives. So why should I concern myself with theirs? They’ve had their chance to stop.
Then there’s that superfluous Ethan ol we’re forced to use. Which is problematic on many levels.
Inflation has done a number on the currency since then 2012. And the price, as said, is not solely based on the price of a barrel of oil.
Obviously after forgiving student loans the next step will be free gas, but only for the oppressed.
Everything is free for some of the oppressed already. They just smash and grab. Or just walk in the local Walgreens and take what they need.
It's amazing that all the dumbest takes have your face front and center John.
You are hopeless.
If things do collapse, it will be fun to hunt soulless Marxists like you.
Yet you have no refutation of John's arguments. Why do you deny inflation and claim it's price gouging? Warren was refuted, maybe you can help.
The Nazi's ---- "SHUT DOWN THE OIL!!!"
The Nazi's ---- "How can gas prices be so high!"
Yeah; They really are THAT STUPID....
Stossel does such a good job at pointing this out.
No, Gas Prices Didn't Spike Because of 'Corporate Greed'
Yes political greed, grabs for power, and stupid policy are what cause high gas prices.
Executives at 141 oil companies surveyed by the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas in mid-March offered several reasons why they weren’t pumping more oil. They said they were short of workers and sand, which is used to fracture shale fields to coax oil out of rock. But the most salient reason—the one offered by 60% of respondents—was that investors don’t want companies to produce a lot more oil, fearing that it will hasten the end of high oil prices.
https://www.businessreport.com/industry/why-us-oil-companies-arent-rushing-to-increase-production
Awesome. So,it shouldn’t be necessary for Biden to stop anyone from drilling, right? It’s self regulating.
Low information politicians like Sen. Warren and Rep. Khanna count on low information voters to elect and re-elect them to office. Members of the cult of the Climate Change religion should stop sinning by their use of any form of transportation requiring fossil fuels. That includes electric cars built and run on minerals requiring large fossil fuel powered vehicles to extract and ship them. They need to stop using all the other many, many everyday products that are made using petroleum products. "There are no solutions in life, only trade offs", Thomas Sowell.
My aunt is a huge Warren fan, she was a college academic in CA most of her adult life. She thinks she is an expert kn economics, but clearly knows nothing.
Just like Warren.
Even a generation x female would be a disastrously bad idea.
We're still engendered differently. Take a thing, teach it to be completely unacceptable by men's standards, then put it in charge.
Good idea?
Gas prices always drop durring election year. Its a fact. Is it natural? Nope. Its foreign policy. But dont worry, you make up tge difference later. Any price that can unnaturally drop can and does unnaturally inflate as well.
Cite examples? Sounds like you're denying inflation.
I don't know about you, but if I was a businessman, and if demand dropped suddenly and out of my control, I'd 1) have to cut back on production to address the drop in demand, and 2) do something to recoup my losses after demand began to return to relative normality.
The problem is, businesses like Exxon-Mobil and Shell, two gasoline producers that posted record profits in 2022's first quarter, are unwilling to make even one single sacrifice that might cut into profits.
What? A business doing some public duty? Ridiculous, say pro-business advocates. Public duty is never going to be pleasant because it sometimes means sacrificing one thing for a greater good. In terms of the well-being of the American people (these are also individuals), absolute self-interest by producers of goods and services is inimical.
But this is what happens in a political world that has been distorted by self-interest. Within what is known as "the political", self-interest must come secondarily to a larger good.
In a libertarian weirdness that denies the existence of "the public" or any "public interest", all that's left is self-interest.
That's how republics die, John Stossel.