Television

Stateless Dramatizes Cruelty of Immigrant Detention Bureaucracies

The Australian series shows it’s not all about Trump.

|

Stateless. Available now on Netflix.

There's something semi-surreal about watching Stateless, the new Netflix drama about immigration. There's not a facemask to be seen anywhere—the show was shot in the golden yesteryear before coronavirus—nor a single word about Donald Trump, for Stateless is set not in Texas or California but Australia.

Stateless is a good reminder that neither the politics nor the human tragedy of immigration has gone away, and that in the United States, the conflation of immigration with hatred for or love of Trump has almost completely obscured the real issue, the immigrants themselves.

They are up close and personal and center in Stateless, which takes place mostly in one of the desert detention camps into which Australia places all its UNCs, or unlawful non-citizens, as the country calls its illegal immigrants.

There's an Afghan family fleeing the Taliban so its little girls can go to school, Iraqis trying to get away from the chaos of post-Saddam life, and Chinese escaping an increasingly strident dictatorship.

The oddest refugee is actually trying to escape Australia, not enter it. Yvonne Strahovski of Chuck and Dexter plays Sofie Werner, a young Australian woman hiding from both her overbearing family and a vengeful cult.

Posing as a German tourist who has overstayed her visa, Sofie's hope is to be deported. But Australia's cumbersome and pitiless immigration bureaucracy is no more efficient at the exit door than it is at the entry. Learning her case can't move forward until she has an official immigration interview, Sofie asks one of the camp's other residents when that might take place. The matter-of-fact reply: "When frogs grow hair." Some of the UNCs have been waiting seven years.

(Sofie's story arc may seem like a contrived way to get a gorgeous white woman into the forefront of the show, even if Stateless's makeup department does a magnificent job of de-glamming Strahovski. In fact, Sofie's story closely resembles that of an Australian woman named Cornelia Rau who blundered into the country's official immigration maze in 2004 and was trapped there 10 months before her family managed to extricate her.)

Sofie is one of three characters whose tales begin separately but intersect in the detention camp. Another is Ameer (Australian TV regular Fayssal Bazzi), an Afghan who dreams of opening a tire shop in Australia where he can keep his wife and daughters out of the medieval clutches of the Taliban. After being bullied and robbed by smugglers, he finally arrives in Australia, only to find himself locked up in what's little more than a jail. "Why?" a friend answers his question. "Because we are terrorists!" The rest of the UNCs cheer in mock enthusiasm.

The third is Cam Sandford (Jai Courtney, Spartacus), a genial blue-collar worker who leaves his dead-end job in a junkyard for a better-paying gig as a detention-center guard. He immediately wonders what he's gotten into as he listens to other guards dismiss the refugees as illiterate seaborne trash. "Two words I reckon they learn on the boat—'motherfucker' and 'visa,'" says one.

Even so, there are few real villains in Stateless. Mostly they're driven by bureaucratic inertia and indifference—and an institutional fear of bad publicity—rather than purposeful cruelty.

When some agitated Sri Lankans climb onto the roof of a building and threaten to cut their own throats in view of orbiting TV news helicopters, the bosses find it's easier to get military jets to run the choppers off than to requisition a Sinhalese-speaking translator to find out what the protesters want. And when Ameer is too ill to go to the dining room, he goes hungry—some dusty health-department regulation forbids food in the cells.

The lack of a real Snidely Whiplash keeps Stateless from falling into the tarpit of melodrama that often makes the arguments of pro-immigration activists so tedious. The holding centers where Western governments stash immigrants—be they in Australia or the United States or Great Britain—are not Treblinkas or Devil's Islands. Their barbarity lies not in racks or iron maidens but in keeping people hopelessly locked up without trials or hearings for the crime of trying to better themselves. Buying everybody in America a week's subscription to Netflix to watch Stateless would do more for the cause than a million speeches by overheated ACLU lawyers.

Yet Stateless is not a work of propaganda. It's a drama, and a fine one. The characters' evolution as they're exposed to the immigration center and trapped in webs of secretive contradictions that ruin careers and families produces irresistible story lines.

None is better than that of Strahovski, a wildly underrated actress who was masterful as a slowly humanizing professional assassin in Chuck and an heiress walking a tightrope over a gaping chasm of sociopathy in her two seasons on Dexter. Her Sofie starts out as a genuinely aggrieved but also self-indulgent and lazy naif, then rises above her sense of victimhood as she lives among the imprisoned UNCs. When she smiles, she lights up a room; when's she ragged and begrimed, she's the manifestation of the un-personhood of the refugee.

A word is also due the omni-talented Cate Blanchett, who not only co-created and produced Stateless, but cast herself in a small but intensely memorable role as one of the cult leaders. She sings! She dances! And when she oozily assures Sofie not to worry about the $400-a-week tab for membership that "this has never been about the money," you instantly understand that it's always been about the money, except when it's about the sex.

NEXT: This Week in Policing Reform: Hawaii Lifts Police Secrecy, Civilian Oversight Boards Make Ballots in Miami and Philadelphia

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. It is for me. Well 98%. The other 2 percent is bearclaws.

      1. Yeah but there’s plenty of Jeff to go around!

        1. Stop making fun of Jeff. He’s on the right side of history when it comes to key libertarian issues like allowing serial killers to vote from behind bars.

          1. He should stop pestering them with marriage proposals.

            1. youre thinking of sarcasmic

              1. Great article, Mike. I appreciate your work, I am now making over $15k every month just by doing an easy j0b 0nline! I KNOW YOU NOW MAKIG MOR DOLLARS online from $28 k I,TS EASY ONLINE WORKING JOBS…

                go to this SITE for more INFO just copy and paste……Money90

    1. Great article, Mike. I appreciate your work, I am now making over $15k every month just by doing an easy j0b 0nline!OPt I KNOW YOU NOW MAKIG MOR DOLLARS online from $28 k I,TS EASY ONLINE WORKING JOBS…

      go to this SITE for more INFO just copy and paste…… Click For More Detail.

  2. Sounds like the second most important show currently on TV, behind only The Handmaid’s Tale.

    #OpenBordersForAustralia
    #AndEveryOtherDevelopedNation
    #(ExceptIsrael)

    1. I make up to $90 an hour on-line from my home. My story is that I give up operating at walmart to paintings on-line and with a bit strive I with out problem supply in spherical $40h to $86h…RDs someone turned into top to me by way of manner of sharing this hyperlink with me, so now i’m hoping i ought to help a person else accessible through sharing this hyperlink…

      strive it, you…………….Home Profit System

  3. “The Australian series shows it’s not all about Trump”
    Yes it is. Everything is.

  4. The Australian series shows it’s not all about Trump.

    Glenn, I hope you’ve enjoyed your time here at Reason, and best of luck in your future endeavors.

  5. You mean other countries don’t want random undocumented people just showing up? Say it ain’t so.

    1. “Posing as a German tourist who has overstayed her visa, Sofie’s hope is to be deported.”

      This makes no sense, why would she simply not get on a plane and fly out of Australia?

      That said, it hard not to notice that heartfelt acceptance and tolerance of all this “wonderful diversity, inclusion, and multi-culturism” increases exponentially the further our smug, self-righteous, sanctimonious elite live from the many negative affects of it. What despicable hypocrites they are!

      1. I don’t know how they deal with it in the Netflix show, but the real woman had severe psychological problems who discharged herself from a hospital to avoid medication and went on the run.

        When she encountered the police, in a different state almost a thousand miles away, she told them the story about being a German in Australia illegally. The cops who found her had no idea that she was missing from Sydney, and didn’t know about her mental health issues, so they had no reason to disbelieve her story. That’s how she ended up in the system.

        1. The woman in this show was raped by the leader of a cult and she was kicked out by the same man. The rest of the story is pretty much the same.

    2. “Australia is majority White. White supremacist xenophobia is in their blood.”

  6. If white people are so bad, why do all the black and brown people try to get in to white countries so desperately, yet none of them try to get into black or brown countries?

    1. Bingo, give that man a cigar…

    2. Because the White colonizers robbed all the wealth out of Brown and Black lands, leaving them no choice but to come to White lands.

    3. Nicaraguans filter across the border in tens of thousands to get in to Costa Rica and they are happy to be here. It is the better life that is the lure, not the skin color.

  7. It’s almost as if countries don’t want random non-citizens just showing up without requesting entry and receiving permission to enter first. Given that this is the case, what should be done about the people who knowingly ignore this fact and try to sneak in? Should countries just shrug their shoulders and put the wants and needs of people from outside of their polity ahead of the wants and needs of those actually in their polity? Reason seems to understand (I’ll have to double check for potential recent changes of heart – Reason seems to have had more than a few of those in the past 2 or 3 years) that groups of people within a polity have freedom of association, but don’t seem to want to extend that basic concept to an entire polity.

    1. Reason’s *core value* is denying the right of a polity that freedom to *not* associate with foreigners.

  8. I have been working from home for 4 years now and I love it. I don’t have a boss standing over my shoulder and I make my own hours. The tips below are very informative and anyone currently working from home or planning to in the future could use these.Make 5000 bucks every month… Start doing online computer-based work through our website……………………Click For Full Details.

  9. A customer satisfaction survey can help your business to improve customer loyalty. … The sales teams’ Christmas card lists may well be the best lists of all but they … This internally generated information may be biased, but it will raise most of …
    https://customerzsurvey.com/

  10. I have been working from home for 4 years now and I love it. I don’t have a boss standing over my shoulder and I make my own hours. The tips below are very informative and anyone currently working from home or planning to in the future could use these.Make 5000 bucks every month… Start doing online computer-based work through our website……………………CLICK HERE.

  11. Growing up an Army brat, I spent three years in Germany in the mid-1950s. One of my mother’s Officer’s Wives Club causes was taking comfort items to the local Displaced Persons camp.

    It too featured lots of barb wire confining people who had been uprooted during WW II and now had no country to return to. It was a grim, hopeless place.

    Even at 10, I wondered why it wasn’t easier to find them a real place to live than to keep them locked in a taxpayer-supported gulag.

  12. I loved the show. Had me in tears at some points. At the end of the show, it was revealed that now Australia has refugees on islands that are inaccessible to people; hence no protests. The system is so corrupt and the perfect job for misfits who have an ax to grind. They take their frustrations out on the poor people who only want to live free like anybody else.

  13. Look at what people will do to escape shithole countries.
    Don’t let your country become one.

    Import Not Americans, become Not America.

  14. I am still hoping for the movie theatre chains (AMC, Cinemark, Regal) to reopen in time for Unhinged, HERE►…ReadMore.

Please to post comments