Although Teenagers Are 80% Less Likely to Smoke Than They Were in 1999, the CDC Insists No Progress Has Been Made

The agency’s indifference between smoking and vaping is scientifically indefensible.


Brian King, deputy director of the Office on Smoking at Health at the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), claims the latest survey data on teen tobacco consumption "indicate that past progress in reducing youth use of these products has been erased." That is true only if you define tobacco-free e-cigarettes as "tobacco products," which the CDC does, and if you ignore the enormous difference between the hazards of smoking and the hazards of vaping, which the CDC also does.

An article about the 2019 National Youth Tobacco Survey (NYTS), published yesterday in the CDC's Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, highlights the rising popularity of e-cigarettes among teenagers. The share of high school students who reported using e-cigarettes in the previous month jumped from 11.7 percent in 2017 to 20.8 percent in 2018. It rose again this year, from 20.8 percent to 27.5 percent, although the CDC cautions that the difference may be partly or entirely due to changes in question wording and survey methods. (The NYTS, previously conducted on paper, went electronic this year.) "Direct attribution of this change to actual increases in product use is not possible because changes made to the 2019 survey could also lead to higher estimates of use," the article says. The Food and Drug Administration nevertheless cited that possibly illusory increase in adolescent vaping as a justification for its proposed ban on flavored e-cigarettes.

Despite alarmist warnings about "a whole generation of young people" who supposedly got hooked on nicotine through e-cigarettes, just 9 percent of high school students reported vaping on 20 or more days in the previous month this year, while less than 6 percent reported vaping every day. Furthermore, frequent vaping is concentrated among teenagers who also have smoked. In the 2018 NYTS, just 1 percent of teenagers with no history of tobacco use reported vaping frequently. That fact suggests that teenagers who might otherwise be smoking are vaping instead.

Buried deep in the NYTS report is the fact that "in 2019, the prevalence of cigarette smoking among youths was the lowest ever captured by the NYTS since 1999," the first year the survey was conducted. During that period, the prevalence of past-month cigarette smoking among high school students fell from 28.5 percent to 5.8 percent. That downward trend not only continued but accelerated as vaping took off, which again suggests that e-cigarettes are replacing the conventional, combustible kind.

Today high school students are about as likely to vape as they were to smoke in 1999, but they are 80 percent less likely to smoke. Since vaping is something like 95 percent less dangerous than smoking (according to an estimate endorsed by Public Health England), that shift represents a huge improvement in terms of health risks. But according to the CDC, the situation is no better today than it was in 1999! The rise of vaping, the CDC's Brian King says, has "erased" all "past progress." That position makes no sense if the CDC is actually trying to prevent disease, as the agency's name implies.

King also insists that e-cigarettes "have no redeeming aspects among youth." But that is obviously not true for teenagers who would otherwise be smoking.

The CDC worries that "misperceptions about the harm from tobacco product use…remained prevalent in 2019." It is referring to the percentages of teenagers who believe that occasional use of tobacco products causes "little harm." Since that happens to be true, describing this belief as a "misperception" is rather odd. The CDC wants teenagers to say that occasional use of tobacco products causes "a lot of harm" (as most of them did), even though that is not accurate, especially as applied to e-cigarettes.

If anyone is misperceiving (or misportraying) the harm from tobacco product use, it's the CDC, which insists there is no meaningful difference, from a public health perspective, between a society in which 28 percent of high school students smoke and a society in which 28 percent of them vape. That position is scientifically indefensible and inconsistent with the agency's ostensible mission.

NEXT: Lawsuit Alleges 'Rampant' Sexual Abuse at Federal Prison

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. If they admit a reduction, what happens to their cushy government jobs?

    1. Lateral promotion where they get the same pay and no responsibilities.

  2. King also insists that e-cigarettes “have no redeeming aspects among youth.”

    Quick, name *anything* that “has redeeming aspects among youth.”

    1. They vote for democrats

  3. Well now I don’t know if I should trust the CDC on climate change, either.

    1. I know. Don’t trust them.

    2. I don’t even trust the CDC on epidemiology. The fund and publish some great research, to be sure, but then their public announcements are little more than fearmongering.

  4. Wonder how much of the CDC budget is allocated for prevention of real diseases?

    1. Maybe your congresscreature can propose legislation to have the CDC study *that*.

      1. They’ll just report that criticizing the CDC is some form of mental disorder.

  5. totes not because they’re nine bucks a pack now

  6. How’s it going to be when it comes to vaping THC and CBD as opposed to smoking or even eating whole cannabis? Is vaping going to be “forever” (i.e. for the next 20-40 years) going to be condemned as a way of inputting anything to the body?

  7. There’re doing it to stay skinny the same reason some people smoked. Nicotine causes the release of fat into your blood. Eventually it’ll kill you from hardening of the arteries but hey you’ll leave a good lookin corpse.

    1. When “Eventually” comes within a year of any other causes of death – it’s hardly the alarm publications has made it.

  8. Alarmists and facts are mutually exclusive.

  9. This is just one more reason to buy ciggies for kids.

  10. The CDC worries

    They’re fuckin’ worrymongers. That’s their con.

  11. CDC spends $7.87 Billion in 2019 from US “Grant” money.
    2,626,418 TOTAL people died in 2014 in the USA

    Taking for granite people would live FOREVER w/o disease
    1,864,422 Died from Heart, Cancer, Respiratory, Mind, Diabetes, ALL disease related items.

    That’s $4221 PER-PERSON who died from any disease (ALMOST ALL CONSIDERED OLD-AGE symptoms) had anything to do with.

    Shoveling money into a fireplace at that rate is bound to create one monstrous fire.

  12. Hello, the process to buy weed online or to order medical marijuana online is very complicated.
    But we have guarantee our customers to get our products by mail ordering cannabis,CBD oil,
    strains,cannabis concentrates,marijuana edible, marijuana seeds from our shop online.
    Marijuana is sealed by using vacuum packaging. Packages have no smell and always bypass
    all Customs checks cause we offer discreet shipping of our package. Our Store is the most
    reliable online dispensary in the Cannabis Industry. We provide tracking details where u
    can track and see how your package is delivered online and also our customers have the
    chance to shop with us online without a medical marijuana card.Buy medical marijuana
    strains online. we got top grade space moneky meds,weed tins,zlittlez, Runtz weed tins,
    biscottis boyz, jungle boys and buy space monkey meds online http://www.weedtinsshop.com

  13. Buy the best MEDS online from gloriouspharmacy shop with or without
    description at very good price and discount given for bulk purchase.
    just click on any of our product link below… i had to order here and had v
    the best products at an affordable price so i vouch for them….c
    take Adderall? Buy Xanax online, Buy Adderall Online, discreetly shipped to
    your home ,
    Buy ativan in Canada(ADHD) and USA without prescription,where can I buy
    ADHD drugs,Buy Oxycodone securely ONLINE Order Ambient for sleep,
    how to buy ambien online, Buy Dilaudid securely online Purchase Morphine
    online,Buy viagra online,oxycodone, Order percocet online | Roxicodone for
    sale in canada and australia contact us at

  14. Yeah, it’s tough to smoke when you’re having all that porn-related sex.

    This comment not approved by Silicon Valley brain slugs.

  15. Prohibition enforcement personnel measure efficacy in terms of thousands of man-years in prison, billions of dollars confiscated, volume of product destroyed and hundreds of suspects killed. The Chicago Tribune didn’t call them “dry killers” for nothing.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.