Police Abuse

A Lawsuit Details a Horrific Night of Beatings in a Pennsylvania Jail

"If it were my client who behaved as they had, he would be on his way to prison."


A Pennsylvania college student is suing Harrisburg police and Dauphin County correctional officers following a severe and unprovoked beating behind bars.

Leticia C. Chavez-Freed, who is representing Jarrett Leaman, 24, shared a copy of the lawsuit with Reason. According to the suit, Leaman and his friends were drinking at bars around town on June 29. Leaman was arrested at the end of the night for public drunkeness, as he was "visibly intoxicated and not communicative."

He was taken into custody without incident. Once he was inside the Dauphin County Judicial Center's booking facility, however, police and guards felt the impaired prisoner was moving too slowly. The suit says he was then "pummeled" on the cement ground. Further abuse reportedly followed, including a 250-pound officer putting his knees on Leaman's neck and back for more than two minutes, an officer punching Leaman's upper body, and officers punching him while his hands were handcuffed behind his back. One officer allegedly took a picture of Leaman's injuries "as if he were photographing a prized catch."

According to the lawsuit, Leaman stayed in a state of submission and did not resist at any point. After the beating, he was reportedly outfitted with a spit mask to hide his injuries from cameras.

The suit also says the medical attention administered to Leaman was less than satisfactory. At one point, a nurse allegedly entered Leaman's cell, looked at his face without removing the spit mask, and then exited. During another observation, a nurse placed the spit mask in his mouth while observing his swollen eye.

Leaman was released before 5:30 the next morning, and he then went to a hospital. Among his confirmed injuries was a fractured orbital bone.

Leaman filed his suit last week in the U.S. Middle Pennsylvania District Court. It accuses the city, the county, the police department, the facility, and several individual officers of violating Leaman's Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights. The suit seeks compensation for damages, plus attorney fees and other forms of relief.

"The unpunished violence at the hands of those who have an absolute duty to protect pretrial detainees is a serious crime. Federal law was broken, as was Pennsylvania state law," Chavez-Freed said in a statement. "If it were my client who behaved as they had, he would be on his way to prison."

Neither the Harrisburg Police Department nor the commissioner who oversees the Dauphin County Judicial Center Booking Facility Prison responded immediately to requests for comment.

This is the same center where 21-year-old Ty'rique Riley suffered fatal injuries earlier this month. Riley's family learned the prisoner was on life support in an intensive care unit when he missed a preliminary hearing. They had not been notified before then of his hospitalization, and they still don't know the nature of the incident that led to it. Riley died of his injuries on July 1.

NEXT: Presidential Candidate John Delaney Has a Plan for America’s Young Adults. It’s Called Forced Labor.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. “If it were my client who behaved as they had, he would be on his way to prison.”

    American qualified immunity. Don’t leave home without it.

    1. At least he didn’t have a dog with him.

  2. Can’t stop pigs from being pigs…I suppose there is another side to this story that only the jury will hear about and the officers will walk away, probably get promoted too…

    1. Look, procedures were followed….

  3. Further abuse reportedly followed, including a 250-pound officer putting his knees on Leaman’s neck and back for more than two minutes…

    No cause to body shame.

    1. Hey, that cop took a lot of steroids to get to that weight!

      1. I have no doubt that many cops take steroids and probably amphetamines too, which could explain a lot of their aggression, but the police unions get them an exemption from drug testing

  4. Modest proposal – when a prisoner is abused like this, the jail in question should be immediately closed and all inmates released.

    1. Releasing the prisoners is okay but you have to leave the jail open so you have a place to put the former police and guards.

      1. Why should we pay for their room and board?


        1. Don’t have to pay nuthin… just lock the door and be done with it.

  5. Riley’s family learned the prison was on life support in an intensive care unit

    It should be, but I think you left off the hard -er.

  6. Those bars of soap are always slippery – – – – – –

  7. Matches my experience – saw a cop throw a handcuffed prisoner into two walls and the ground because he lied and told him that he was a minor, and he ended up having to redo paperwork after calling his parents and finding out he was 19. Was lucky his head didn’t bounce.

    1. The worst part about that is the totally pervasive system that ignores such criminal assaults.

      That kind of behavior would get you a prison term in any other context, but put it in a prison and suddenly even extreme levels of violence are not only excused, but are actively defended and justified.

      And absolutely nobody is about to do anything about it.

  8. Where’s the Terminator when you need him. Just go in and wipe out the whole fucking station, LOL.

  9. Whom was the prisoner sllegedly hurting or endangering when he was arrested?

  10. The problem with police brutality matters is that there are guys like William J Lewinski, aka The Angel of Death, who acts as a consultant for cops in court, and he is one who never saw a case of police brutality he didn’t like. To suggest that cops are not above the law would be naive at best. Force and violence is the government way of doing things.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.