Deadwood Returns for More Violence, Cussing, and Mayhem Amid a Changing World

Movie treads the familiar grounds of the beloved, abruptly canceled HBO show.


Deadwood: The Movie. HBO. Friday, May 31, 8 p.m.

Thirteen years after it last aired, HBO's revisionist Western Deadwood has returned for an encore. Any fears that creator-writer David Milch or his characters may have mellowed during the hiatus are assuaged in the first moments, when arch-villain mining magnate George Hearst rides into town to the heartfelt greetings of the local citizenry. "You murdering, thieving cocksucker!" calls out one, while another salutes him as "You bald-pated cunt."

And, yes, murder is still the leading strategic tool for mergers and acquisitions in Deadwood, and the town's pigs still the most popular recourse for the disposal of inconvenient corpses. The whores still outnumber the preachers, the language is still a mixture of the oddly baroque and the profoundly obscene, and most importantly, Deadwood: The Movie is as a provocative, intelligent, and funny place to visit as the series ever was.

That said, Deadwood: The Movie is not really a movie at all, at least in the sense of being a self-contained production. It will be practically incomprehensible to anyone who didn't watch the original series, which ran for 36 episodes from 2004 to 2006. HBO's abrupt and unexpected cancellation left a number of dangling threads, and this edition is best understood as an attempt to snip them.

The series was set during the late 1870s during the Black Hills gold rush, when Deadwood was a lawless boom town. The movie picks up 10 years later, as South Dakota is becoming a state, but in many ways, it might as well be the next day.

Hearst has just come riding back into town, to stir up trouble by acquiring land—by fair means or foul—for the telephone lines he wants to run into Deadwood. He succeeds effortlessly at the stirring-up-trouble part, not so much at getting the land. And, soon enough, those hungry pigs are back at work.

Virtually all the characters who were still alive at the end of Deadwood's final season season—and even some who were dead, via flashbacks—return for the movie. (Notable exception: cold-blooded casino owner Cy Tolliver, who was played by the late Powers Boothe.) Rage-prone Seth Bullock (Timothy Olyphant) is still sheriff, thoughtful prospector Charlie Utter (Dayton Callie) still his deputy. And though Bullock's former illicit lover, the twice-widowed businesswoman Alma Ellsworth (Molly Parker) has moved away, she's returned to tend to her bank.

Another recent returnee is the drunken frontierswoman Calamity Jane (Robin Weigert), back to mourn her murdered pal, Wild Bill Hickock, and seek reconciliation with her old girlfriend, moody madame Joanie Stubbs (Kim Dickerson).

Murderous but somehow lovable saloonkeeper Al Swearengen (Ian McShane), though he's nearly obliviated his liver, is still running whores in his upstairs rooms, though he leaves most of the details to his aide-de-coitus Trixie (Paula Malcomson).

The only significant newcomer on the scene is a mysterious woman named Caroline (Jade PettyJohn), who may or may not be the daughter of a hooker Al Swearengen murdered to pass her corpse off as that of Trixie, who George Hearst wanted badly to kill.

Though Swearengen was the one who actually cut the hooker's throat, practically all the main Deadwood characters knew of the murder and gave tacit approval by not giving it away to Hearst. The arrival of Caroline, the victim's maybe-daughter, sends a collective spasm of guilt through the town elders. "Make friends with her ghost," Swearengen urges Trixie. "It ain't fuckin' going anywhere."

His remark is just one element of the hazy streaks of nostalgia and regret that inhabit Deadwood: The Movie. The future is inexorably arriving in Deadwood—Hearst's telephones being the literal incarnation—and most of the characters are closer to the ends of their chapters than the beginnings. Says Swearengen, vowing that no phone will ever darken his place: "A saloon is a sanctuary. Any man worth the name knows the value of being unreachable." Increasingly, the world is too much with the citizens of Deadwood.

This engaging and melancholy farewell to them has long been rumored, and even longer denied. Milch supposedly had a deal for two films to wrap up Deadwood, but every time he was reported ready to begin production, he forged into some other project: the inscrutably weird theological ramblings of John from Cincinnati, or the ill-fated horse-racing drama Luck, canceled after three horses died during the shooting of its first nine episodes.

The report of a two-movie deal may have been true. The final moments of Deadwood: The Movie are ambiguous and indecisive and could easily lead to a second film. But if so, it won't be with Milch, who is drifting into the mists of Alzheimer's disease. Like Al Swearengen, he'll soon be unreachable. His last words to us were fine ones.

NEXT: Texas Police Union Kills Effort To Close State's 'Dead Suspect Loophole'

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. I guess I need to start rewatching the series. Forgot about Boothe being in it.

  2. Boys are back with a bang! Would you be interested in watching similar movies and series on New Live Gomax App

  3. First season was good but once the town was built I lost interest.

  4. “You bald-pated cunt.”

    See, this is great writing. I miss Game of Thrones already, because whenever a character on that medieval Alternate-Earth called another character a cunt, I laughed and laughed and wondered why other series could never match this level of cleverness.

  5. That’s Kim Dickens, not Kim Dickerson.

  6. The dialogue in that show was positively Shakespearean in quality.

  7. I suck hind teat to no fucking man in my love of Deadwood, but this movie wasn’t great. First off, the lack of continuity rankles, in that Doc Cochrane seems to have gotten over his nasty case of tuberculosis no worse for wear (though at least Swearengen’s finger didn’t grow back). Second, George Hearst again? The Homestake Mine started to be traded publicly in 1879, and Hearst was a US Senator in 1889, yet here is haggling over 800 acres and personally paying off assassins? (A Senator and millionaire, he’s unaccompanied by a single secretary, just a coterie of gunmen. Rankle, rankle.) Third, the killing of Charlie Utter is a retread of the killing of Whitney Ellsworth. I mean the show was fine, and I’m glad it was made and I watched it, but it wasn’t great.

    They would have been better off more fully exploring the stone-ass murder of Jen in which all the leading lights – Swearengen, Bullock, Starr, and Trixie – are complicit.

  8. I was PISSED when they cancelled Deadwood. It made no sense. As I understand it it was very popular, and critically acclaimed. Made no sense.

    I’m glad this finally got put together since they’ve been talking about it forever. I hope there is a 2nd movie. I’m sad to hear the creator is losing his mind… He was a truly amazing writer, and I remember thinking what a neurotic but brilliant bastard he was when watching the DVD special features years ago. At least we have his work!

    1. Just watched the movie… It was pretty alright. Just felt like 2 decent episodes of the show. I hope they do another. The cast on that show is amazing.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.