White House

John Kelly Was President Trump's Top Authoritarian Fearmonger. Good Riddance.

Trump's chief of staff was there to add a veneer of respectability to some of the president's worst positions.

|

John Kelly
KEVIN LAMARQUE/REUTERS/Newscom

President Donald Trump announced to reporters on Saturday that White House Chief of Staff John Kelly will step down by the end of the year, ending months of speculation about Kelly's potential exit date.

The popular narrative around Kelly, a retired Marine general, is that he brought military-minded discipline to a chaotic White House. It's not clear that Kelly's influence ever extended outside his own person. One likely candidate to replace him—Nick Ayers, chief of staff to Vice President Mike Pence—is instead leaving the administration.

As Kelly heads for the exits, let's take a moment to shove aside the content-free beltway obsession with who holds the cards in this feckless administration and deal with the realities of the man. Kelly was an authoritarian merchant of fear whose policy prescriptions revolved around using the government to monitor and control the behavior of the populace, citizens and immigrants alike. While their demeanors may differ, his exit is not a result of any genuine political disagreements with Trump. Much like former Attorney General Jeff Sessions, Kelly and Trump clashed over means, not ends. Anybody who loves liberty should be glad to see Kelly go, irrespective of who may replace him.

Before Kelly was elevated as chief of staff, he was installed as Trump's head of the Department of Homeland Security. In that role, he told Americans we should all thank our lucky stars for poorly trained Transportation Security Administration employees and their crotch-fondling ways. In an April 2017 speech, he told legislator critics of TSA behavior to either change the law or "shut up and support the men and women on the front lines." He was more than happy to scare Americans with fears of terrorists coming to kill us all to justify government intrusions into our privacy.

Perhaps it would be easier for Congress to support the TSA if it weren't a hotbed of corruption and scandal and lawmakers weren't being stymied by attempts to investigate retaliation against workers who blow the whistle on misconduct at the agency.

Kelly's a massive drug warrior, again using fear (this time, of opioid overdoses and drug lords) to try to sell us all on massive, expensive, and ultimately fruitless drug interdiction efforts. As a military man, he tended to see the drug war as something that just needed more troops. Reason's Jacob Sullum noted back in 2016 that "Kelly thinks a determined government can overcome economics." He simply believes that more money and more drug seizures would win the drug war, despite everything we've learned about that approach after four decades and a trillion dollars in spending.

He brought that attitude to DHS and then into the White House and turned it into a justification for the administration's cruel immigration enforcement tactics. Kelly, like Trump, is a big believer in the myth that illegal immigrants are crime magnets, going so far as to instruct staff of Immigration and Customs Enforcement to try to track down examples of egregious cases in order to sell a crackdown. And he was a full supporter of separating children of illegal immigrants from their families in order to deter people from coming to the U.S.

To the extent that Kelly brought "discipline" and "professionalism" to the White House, it was in support of policies that deprived people of liberty. His role was to find the correct levers of power to pull so that Trump could pursue his authoritarian agenda through the proper government channels instead of by diktat or angry tweet.

When Sessions was shown the door, Sullum noted that his replacement might not be any better than him (a prediction that is shaping up to be true), but could hardly be worse. We don't know who Kelly's replacement is going to be, but the cause of liberty is most certainly better off without him in the White House.

NEXT: The Amy, Vicky, and Andy Act Is Signed Into Law

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. “Kelly was an authoritarian merchant of fear whose policy prescriptions revolved around using the government to monitor and control the behavior of the populace, citizens and immigrants alike.”

    See a psychiatrist.

    “While their demeanors may differ, his exit is not a result of any genuine political disagreements with Trump. Much like former Attorney General Jeff Sessions, Kelly and Trump clashed over means, not ends.”

    Trump said during the campaign that the states should be respected on marijuana legalization. Jeff Sessions didn’t abide by that because he agreed with Trump.

    1. John Kelly, for all of his old man flaws, was also a patriot. I am sad to see him leave because at least I know he loved and respected this country. I am not sure I can say the same for many of the chattering class of journalists that like to bag on him.

  2. To the extent that Kelly brought “discipline” and “professionalism” to the White House, it was in support of policies that deprived people of liberty.

    HOW DO YOU KNOW HE WASN’T THE ONE WHO WROTE THAT ANONYMOUS LETTER TO THE NEW YORK TIMES.

  3. “John Kelly was President Trump’s Top Authoritarian Fearmonger….”

    Naah. That’s CNN.

    1. Megan Kelly?

  4. Reason still hates that despite what they say, Trump has accomplished one of the most Libertarian-ish administrations in 100 years.

    1. LOL

      Reason should absolutely hate it if a “libertarian-ish” President was this historically unpopular. What’s his approval rating again?

      Drumpf has been a complete disaster, but his lack of popularity is a good sign for libertarians since we’re firmly allied with #TheResistance.

      1. The real estate agent’s popularity right now is the same as the average for Bill Clinton. This is on Gallup.

    2. MAGA!

      1. There you go again with your virtue signaling, totalitarian tribal chanting, statist dog whistles.

        Wipe the state’s stain off your chin, collectivist.

    3. Trump has accomplished one of the most Libertarian-ish administrations in 100 years.

      Immigration crackdowns, gun accessory bans, raising tariffs, ramping up military spending, etc. are all right there in the Libertarian Party platform.

      1. Nothing you said proves him wrong, unfortunately. That’s how bad things have gotten – a president that does those things still is more libertarian than most of the others that have held the office since Coolidge.

    4. Tax and regulations cut and judicial nominees that are the most libertarian leaning in my lifetime. You can criticize tariffs although IP was an issue that needed to be addressed with China. Debt and deficit he can veto and shut down the govt but most of it is on autopilot with entitlements. Politically no one can touch those it will just be a matter of picking up the pieces when it finally becomes a financial crisis. The cold hard fact is government is reactive not proactive.

  5. If Kelly had anything to do with Drumpf’s draconian war on immigration, he’s clearly a terrible human being. But if he’s leaving that means he’s at least smart enough to know the walls are closing in on this illegitimate Kremlin puppet administration. Mueller’s investigation is reaching its final stages. In 2019 he will deliver a bombshell report with ironclad evidence of Russian collusion (or illegal payments to Playmates and pornstars; that works too) that will result in Orange Hitler being removed from office.

    Related: my favorite conservative columnist Jennifer Rubin explains how Drumpf might try to weasel his way out of trouble.

    1. When will Her Majesty take his place?

    2. Does it really take that long to manufacture evidence? Come on, you should be able to Photoshop faster than that.

  6. Relevant

    http://www.newyorker.com/carto…..employment

    1. Funny ’cause it’s true.

  7. Scratch Beauregard, scratch Kelly… improvement is improvement!

  8. “…again using fear (this time, of opioid overdoses and drug lords)?” accompanied by the drumbeats of the MSM with the Democrat party providing the chorus. Pretty sure the “opioid crisis” is the latest bandwagon the politicians and bleeding hearts have leapt upon to further enhance their power. Folks have been overdosing on various and sundry notions, potions & lotions since the first fool licked a frog.

  9. I essentially started three weeks past and that i makes $385 benefit $135 to $a hundred and fifty consistently simply by working at the internet from domestic. I made ina long term! “a great deal obliged to you for giving American explicit this remarkable opportunity to earn more money from domestic. This in addition coins has adjusted my lifestyles in such quite a few manners by which, supply you!”. go to this website online domestic media tech tab for extra element thank you .

    http://www.Mesalary.com

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.