France Election Preview: Terrorism, Socialism, Nationalist Socialism, and the Prospects for Economic Liberalization

Voters go to the polls Sunday, where two candidates will advance to the final round.


Pool/Sipa USA/Newscom

The attack on a police bus on the Champs-Elysee in Paris yesterday, which killed two police officers and for which ISIS claimed responsibility, came while France's presidential candidates were participating in their last televised forum, and President Trump said today that he thought the attack would help the National Front's Marine Le Pen. "She's the strongest on borders and she's the strongest on what's been going on in France," Trump told the AP. "Whoever is the toughest on radical Islamic terrorism, and whoever is the toughest at the borders, will do well in the election."

After the police attack, Le Pen called for the expulsion of all foreigners on terror watch lists. The suspected gunman in yesterday's attack, Karim Cheufri, is a French national who was questioned in February for allegedly making threats to kill police officers. Meanwhile, the center-right François Fillon, once the frontrunner before a scandal over a no-show job for his wife yielded calls for him to drop out, said "Islamic totalitarianism" ought to be the next president's top priority.

François Hollande declared a war on terror after multiple coordinated ISIS-linked terrorist attacks in Paris in November 2015 killed 130 people. The French government followed up with warrantless raids, house arrests, limits on freedom of speech and assembly, and other security measures.

The 2015 attacks helped the National Front outperform its polling in the first round of regional elections, but by the second round, a month after the attacks, the bounce appeared to have faded. Voters go to the polls Sunday for the first round and in early May for the second round—four candidates are polling at about 20 percent; Emmanuel Macron, Le Pen, Fillon, and Jean-Luc Mélenchon.

And in fact, both Le Pen and Mélenchon, a former Socialist who created his own party and has been called the "French Bernie Sanders," support French withdrawal from the European Union and euro as well as more protectionism, and even closing the border to refugees and banning the veil.

"This is a very good example like Hayek used to say, where extremes actually join together," Emmanuel Martin, a French economist involved with libertarian MOOC Ecole de la Liberté, told Reason earlier this week. "Mélenchon-LePen, their program is 90 percent the same." Martin, who also describes himself as a libertarian rocker, even has a song about the tendency for such confluence in what we call the far right and the far left.

"Mélenchon is the new Robespierre," Martin explained, referring to the French revolutionary leader associated with the Reign of Terror, "and to some extent he's very much like Bernie Sanders, but I think he's more evil… They both share this total illusion of democratic socialism, which to me is a complete oxymoron, and to any libertarian obviously."

While terror attacks in France grab more headlines, the country has long-standing economic problems caused by too many labor regulations, too much centralization, and a lack of accountability in government. President Hollande's tough talk and concomitant actions on the war on terror failed to shore up support in the face of his failure to execute on economic reform.

The former economy minister, Emmanuel Macron, who was one of the architects of Hollande's belated turn away from socialism and attempt at some labor deregulation and other economic reforms, now has the highest polling average, at 23.6 percent.

"He's trying to gather so many different people, that it's very difficult to find something solid, something really, he's just a basic politician, he's trying to please everyone," Martin explained. "And his speeches are completely hollow, just hot air, really, and sometimes you even laugh when you listen to him, because it's so empty."

Nevertheless, there could be a bright side there. "Maybe that's the solution," Martin suggested, "to gather a lot of voters and then do some reforms, but I don't know if he'll do the reforms."

Fillon, the former frontrunner, came into the race, Martin said, "with a very Thatcher-like type of program, saying, yeah, we're going to suppress 500,000 jobs in the government, and the local governments, and people just hate that, because it's perceived as creating a cleavage, a division, but people on the right they like that, the conservatives on the right they like that."

In addition to the no-show job scandal, Martin noted, "the other problem with Fillon is that if he tries this very direct, straightforward program, people will go to the streets and this will be another revolution."

France, Martin pointed out, has 5.6 million government workers, out of a population of 66 million. "It's a crazy number," Martin noted. "And obviously these people don't have any interest in reducing public spending, and the more you hire them the more they'll lobby for public spending."

Additionally, according to Martin, more than half of the parliament is made up of public servants, "which means that you have public servants that control public service and they don't have any incentive to control public spending," which is currently 57 percent of GDP. "And Mr. Mélenchon wants to increase this."

Mélenchon also wants to raise the minimum wage, which is more 60 percent of the median wage in France (by comparison, it is about 36 percent of the median in the U.S.) and is also tied to other wage tiers, and prohibiting companies from having more than 10 percent of their workforces on short-term contracts.

Similarly, LePen rails "against big companies, capitalism, and free trade," Martin noted. "She really is a socialist, but on the right."

It's a departure from her father, Jean-Marie Le Pen, the only National Front candidate to make it to a second round of presidential voting, back in 2002. Martin described the elder Le Penas a kind of "protectionist liberal, a small government protectionist, if you will… so he was a nationalist but he was also for small government, a small welfare state, more businesses, and all this."

The younger Le Pen is different. "She's a socialist," Martin explained, "I wouldn't call her a Nazi, but her type of socialism is a nationalist socialism, not in a Nazi sense but, if you look at Mélenchon's policies, it's exactly the same, he wants to close the borders, he's a protectionist, he wants to exit the E.U., the euro."

Le Pen was adept at "stealing a lot of voters from the former Communist Party," Martin said. "Just like in national socialism in Germany a century ago, she's very critical of capitalism, of free trade, of economic liberalism, of big businesses."

Martin himself said his original intentions were to not vote in this year's presidential risk. "But the risk of LePen-Mélenchon in the second round would be a nightmare."

Martin said he doesn't know whether he'll vote for Fillon or Macron, and was not particularly impressed by either candidate. He described Fillon as a Heritage Foundation type, calling him economically very libertarian but socially very conservative, linked to the Catholic right. Macron, while "less libertarian on the economy," Martin suggested, might be "at the same time more clever, smarter" politically.

"He could achieve the same results [as Fillon] without saying it, without having the whole population on the streets and all this," Martin said.

NEXT: Trump Looks to France, Gender Changes Daily at Harvard: P.M. Links

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. “Melanchon-LePen, their program is 90 percent the same.”

    It’s the other ten percent that will get you.

    1. How crony-capitalist is France? Does the average French citizen even understand the difference from real capitalism?

  2. Go Le Pen!

    Fuck Europe. Those continentals need to put country and culture first again.

    1. I just learned today from NPR that France’s far-left candidate wants out of the EU. I’m like, wow, even the far left is racist now.

    2. Yeah national socialism is totally the libertarian solution as long as you might leave the EU!

      1. It’s the (People’s) Republic of France, the choices are pretty much always going to be the open socialist , socialist lite, nationalist socialist, closeted socialist and stealth socialist.

        1. I know you’re not exactly going to get a libertarian in France, but Fillon and Macron, as imperfect as they are, are both much better options than Le Pen is.

          1. Not if you want to break up the EU, destroy the Euro, and have a continent full of independent sovereign nations.

            1. I suppose if ending the EU is your only concern and you care about literally zero other aspects of policy, and you have an unrealistic fantasy that electing Le Pen is going to usher in your dream of a free Europe, then maybe? It’s not even like she can unilaterally withdraw as president, so you’ll likely be disappointed again even if she does win.

          2. Nazism was a better option than obliteration. How did it play out for the Vichy government?

  3. he’s very much like Bernie Sanders, but I think he’s more evil

    Looks like they’re getting the dark cloud of fascism either way. Serves ’em right.

  4. “She really is a socialist, but on the right.”

    Socialist turtles frogs, all the way down.

    1. Ingrid Bergman. Would (have then), wood.

  5. Jean-Marie Le Pen, the only National Front candidate to make it to a second round of presidential voting, back in 2002. Martin described the elder Le Penas a kind of “protectionist liberal, a small government protectionist, if you will? so he was a nationalist but he was also for small government, a small welfare state, more businesses, and all this.

    The Frogs missed their National Front libertarian moment back in 2002?

    1. Just like they lost their libertarian moment when the Germans marched into the Saarland. French army rifle for sale. Never fired. dropped once.

  6. Marine has a career, 3 children and is divorced. She’s the typical modern French woman. See what happens when you let them vote and run for office?

  7. After the police attack, Le Pen called for the expulsion of all foreigners on terror watch lists.

    What’s the French translation for “due process”?

    1. According to Eric Holder, that would be due process.

    2. In France, that is how they *do* process. 😉

  8. The collapse of the EU would be great. The obvious replacement would be a British-Nordic-Germanic-Baltic EFTA, to which the Latin states could apply if they were willing to do reasonable free trade.

  9. OT: Help a technotard brother out.

    So I’m looking to switch my default search engine, and I like the utility of DuckDuckGo.

    And then Chrome asks me “add this to Chrome to make it default search engine?” And I’m all… I see you there, Google, bunnyboiler that you are.

    Will Google still breathe heavily in my ear and smell my hair when I sleep if I’m on Chrome but using DuckDuckGo’s search engine?

    1. No, not in my experience. But I also just kind of assume every single internetted device in my vicinity is conspiring against me. Though duckduckgo is fantastic, it’s own search algorithm isn’t bad on it’s own, but if you’re not turning up what you’re looking for basically every other search engine worth knowing about is hotkeyed.

      1. Thanks, FS. You’re a peach.

          1. Typing must be difficult. Sex with bees doubtless has something to recommend, though.

  10. Macron and Fillon are miles ahead of the other contenders. Fillon would be a really intriguing option if not for his scandal that reflects very poorly on him. Macron is my preferred pick due to that. He’s not particularly great, but he’s pretty solid by the standards of France and certainly compared to Le Pen and Melenchon.

    The article kind of misrepresents Melenchon’s stance on the EU (in a way that makes him look better). He’s not against the EU per se, he just views its current incarnation as being a neoliberal institution that promotes capitalism. He wants to push for reforms that make it more leftist and socialist, and if that fails he’ll consider leaving.

    In the case that he or Le Pen wins, I’m not even sure how much power the president actually has to do that in France without the support of Parliament or a referendum.

    Also of note is that France uses a two round system if no one gets 50% the first time it goes to a runoff. Macron is favored heavily against anyone else if he makes it to the second round, and Le Pen is a heavy underdog against any of the other 3 as well (and I’m not talking a Trump against Clinton underdog where he was down 3-4 points nationally. She’s 15-30 points down against the other contenders and there’s no electoral college to consider).

    1. The enlightened Frogs won’t pass up the opportunity to make HERSTORY.

      1. If I had to bet, she will probably make the second round. To win the runoff, she has to make up a lot of ground or hope for a polling error that makes Brexit and Trump look minuscule in comparison. Her chances against Fillon and Melenchon look better than against Macron, so facing one of them would be a start for her.

    2. So then best is if Macron & LePen are top 2?

      1. That’s the most likely outcome according to the polls. It would be the best to maximize Macron’s chances, but at the same time I would much prefer Fillon to Le Pen so Macron-Fillon would probably be the safest and best outcome IMO. Macron leads Fillon by about the same as he leads Le Pen in any case. It’s a shame Fillon turned out to be a corrupt jackass, he looked a really good option by French standards before that.

        1. *looked like

    3. Is France really ready for a president who would *not* get his wife a no show job? Fillon is the only safe choice. He should be punished. But also elected.

    4. Indeed, when you look at where the votes will likely go in the second round, it becomes clear that Le Pen has very few fallback votes. Even if turnout is lower, there’s a huge cushion between Macron votes and Le Pen’s. But judging from the pretty high turnout (roughly 80%) in the first round, a similar 2nd round turnout will only make the cushion larger. Melenchon votes will not get behind Le Pens proposals such as immigration and increasing the number of prisons.

      Her policies are reactionary, not principled. Tribalism can only carry her so far.

  11. Goddamnit, another overtime game.

    1. Ok, that was quick.

  12. “the new Robespierre” – Be still my beating heart. Dare I hope? Visiones of tumbrels rolling toward Place de la R?volution.

  13. No matter how you cut the cheese, it sounds like France is all socialism.

    It’s doomed.

  14. I am creating $100 to $130 systematically by carrying down facebook. i used to be unemployed a pair of years earlier , but currently I actually have a very extraordinary occupation with that i build my very own specific pay .I am very appreciative to God and my director .If you wish to induce a good quantity of wage per month like ME , you’ll check my details by clicking the link


  15. France is pretty much already a third position economy, so I don’t think Le Pen really makes a big difference.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.