North Miami Cop Who Shot Behavioral Specialist Arrested Ten Months After Incident
Faces felony attempted manslaughter and misdemeanor culpable negligence charges.

Ten months after shooting an unarmed behavioral specialist trying to defuse a situation involving police confronting one of the specialist's unarmed developmentally disabled residents, Officer Jonathan Aledda has been charged with attempted manslaughter, a third degree felony, and culpable negligence, a misdemeanor, the Miami-Dade County state's attorney announced as they issued a warrant for Aledda's arrest.
NPR reports Aledda was arrested but offers no details on the arrest.
According to the state attorney, Aledda was "not in a position to correctly assess the situation or in a position to accurately fire" when he shot Charles Kinsey, the behavioral specialist. The police union insisted in the aftermath of the shooting that Aledda was aiming not at Kinsey, who was on the ground with his hands up, but at the developmentally disabled patient, who was sitting on the ground with a toy truck.
Apologists for the cop also suggested Aledda thought the patient had a gun, not a toy truck, but the police chief told investigators Aledda was told there was no gun and to stand down before he shot Kinsey.
Aledda was suspended with pay. A commander on the scene who refused to lie in order to protect Aledda, meanwhile, had been initially been suspended without pay before an investigation found no evidence supporting accusations by police leaders that the commander had"misled shooting investigators.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
They wanted to be thorough and make sure they got the right guy, just like with every other violent felony case.
What took them so long? A lynching delayed is a lynching denied.
"Culpable negligence", huh? Kinda like people who are expected to know better are expected to know better, rather than that people who don't know no better are slammed for reckless endangerment?
I still think of the guy calling the cops over the attempted car-jacking and when the cop shows up he starts snooping around the car rather than announcing himself to the homeowner and when the homeowner comes out to confront this unknown person snooping around his car, the cop shoots him. An untrained homeowner asks questions first to assess the situation, the trained cop shoots first and asks questions later. He knows he's going home safe no matter how many innocent bystanders he has to blast. If the homeowner tried that shit, he'd be up for capital murder.
I've never been able to get a knee-jerk cop-defender to admit that cops should know better than the general public. Cops are perfect innocents; they are not professionals. Everyone else is filthy with original sin and can be accosted for any damn reason. Cops can get angry and can be mistaken, but no one else may be anything other than calm and polite.
Seriously, they don't need sensitivity training. They need to work shitty customer service jobs for a year before they can carry a weapon. That'll teach you how to deal with assholes and puncture your ego.
For those of you who've followed his work as I have, Will Grigg passed away today.
Holy shit. That sucks.
Going to check the Libertarian Institute website.
They don't have anything about it yet. Probably still shaken up about it.
He and I were Facebook friends, along with lots of mutual friends. So right now, it's all over my feed.
Damn. I mean he was writing articles just a few weeks ago, right?
What happened?
He'd been ill and hospitalized with cellulitis for the past couple weeks, but he apparently died of a heart attack earlier today.
Oh, I assumed one thing had to do with the other. So even if he didn't have an infection, he would have still had the heart attack.
Death just comes out of nowhere sometimes.
Shocker.
RIP.
https://mises.org/blog/rip-will-grigg
Wow, that is sad news. I loved Will Grigg. He was one of the good ones over at LRC. RIP, Mr. Grigg. Your writing will live on.
One of my favorite articles he wrote was For Your Own Protection.
The link didn't come through, so here it is:
http://freedominourtime.blogsp.....ction.html
That was indeed a great essay, I remember reading it at the time he published it. The man was a singularly gifted writer and a fierce advocate for liberty. He hated government even more than I hate government.
Agreed, and thanks for a working link.
Just today a guy had the crap beat out of him for jaywalking, and then not grovelling to the cop.
And so it goes.
That's the sort of story Will would've been all over.
Boom
Man, I hate to do this, but I'm going to do it anyway. He made a great case against handcuffs only to pull the rug out of his own argument with the anecdote about the cop being in grave danger because he didn't handcuff another cop. *shrug* o well
Good article, thanks.
Never heard of him.
Oh, OK, another cop-hating anarchist. This comment is illustrative:
I do hope everyone reading this realizes, it WILL CONTNUE until either WE kill THEM, or WE are dead.
Long past time to retaliate. Our Revolution started over less.
Don't want to be a thug, don't aim at a retard and shoot a normie.
but at the developmentally disabled patient, who was sitting on the ground with a toy truck.
So he shot the wrong person. Seems legit.
I think there's no use pretending you can "reform" this.
Well, anything can be reformed, it's just a question of methodology, which ranges anywhere between changes in paperwork to violent revolution.
I'm sure now that's all cleared up, the commanding officer will surely pass his newly scheduled psychological review.