Video Evidence Leads to $600,000 Settlement in NYPD Excessive Force Lawsuit
Taxpayers will foot the bill for the vicious beating of 19-year-old Jateik Reed, which started with an illegal stop-and-frisk.


Attorneys for Jateik Reed — a Bronx man who was severely beaten by police in 2012 — announced on Friday that they've come to a settlement with the City of New York, which will pay over $600,000 for the numerous unlawful actions of the police officers Reed encountered that day four years ago.
In addition to the excessive force charges, the settlement also covered the unlawful arrest of Reed's mother and brothers (who were at the time ages 16 and 4), who were taken into custody at the precinct when they tried to find out what happened to Jateik.
The incident in question started with the stop-and-frisk of Reed, then 19, which the police justified by claiming to have seen Reed holding bags of marijuana. But video surveillance footage contradicted the officers' contention, and drug possession charges against Reed were eventually dropped.
Once Reed was in custody, the officers claimed he punched and head-butted one of them, which was also contradicted by video evidence. Reed's friend, Trevor Nigel, videotaped what happened next as officers viciously attacked Reed with batons, elbows, and kicks. One officer then pepper-sprayed Nigel while he shot the video (watch below).
Capping off the disgusting display of police brutality, Sergeant Alfousina Delacruz was also caught on video kicking Reed after the initial beating as he lay prone and handcuffed on the ground. She will be required to pay $5,000 as part of the settlement, but like all the officers involved, is still employed by the NYPD and faced no criminal charges.
The department confirmed that all the officers had been disciplined internally for their actions, but would not disclose any details. This is because of a policy the NYPD quietly adopted earlier this year (reversing a more transparent policy which stood for 30 years) to keep officer discipline records secret, which the department justified by citing a privacy clause in New York State's 1976 civil rights law.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
the unlawful arrest of Reed's mother and brothers (who were at the time ages 16 and 4)
They arrested a 4 year old?
It's just a future criminal. It's absurd to ask a civilized society to wait.
You know who else said that?
Wait... never mind.
Hillary Clinton?
Oh. Look who's back.
Back? Did I ever leave? Do I not live in the soul of every member of the commentariat?
HEROES!
Science, bitch.
"Science" with no citations ain't science.
But video surveillance footage contradicted the officers' contention, and drug possession charges against Reed were eventually dropped.
THE SYSTEM WORKED!
Sergeant Alfousina Delacruz
The benefits of a minority-majority police force?
*ducks*
There is lucrative angle for dirty cop:
1) Cop shoots GoPro-equipped miscreant - but in the leg.
2) Cop gets off on criminal charges for shooting miscreant
3) Miscreant gets big payout from civil judgement
4) Cop and miscreant split proceeds
5) Cop and miscreant move to new jurisdiction
6) Cop knows guy in union who gets him hired
7) The cycle continues
Buddy movie maybe?
SugarFree presents Bad Cop! A Warty Hugeman Adventure
Is Warty still unconscious? The suspense is killing me.
Did you not see this morning's installment? Warty is in quite a pickle! Fortunately, he's into that. Sexually.
Which thread?
Scroll down to Chapter Two
Tango & Cash and Cash
7) Then they marry.
That's a narrative arc.
This is just disgraceful. Disgusting. Does the NYPD even have fitness standards for their officers?
No.
One man, one pass, one time.
This is because of a policy the NYPD quietly adopted earlier this year (reversing a more transparent policy which stood for 30 years) to keep officer discipline records secret, which the department justified by citing a privacy clause in New York State's 1976 civil rights law.
This is case in point where a nominally criminal matter becomes a matter of an employee/employer dispute, and therefore can be kept out of public scrutiny.
The video makes it appear as though some of those cops might not be in peak physical condition. Must be the thick jackets.
It was all a misunderstanding. They were repeatedly falling on Reed due to their unstable condition. This video merely proves the need for more training on a stairmaster.
All slipping on black ice and accidentally beating a man.
All Yakkity Sax playing.
All father not going home to his children.
A true comedy of errors.
She will be required to pay $5,000 as part of the settlement, but like all the officers involved, is still employed by the NYPD and faced no criminal charges.
One of those three things I don't believe is actually true.
That Xe was a 'She'?
Right on- if cops had to pay for this shit instead of tax payers we might stand a chance.
Likely the union paid this.
Article says it's the City of New York.
I may have missed it, but it looked like the union was pushing to have the city pay that $5,000 but the city was pushing back that the action was outside the scope of employment.
Privatize security services. Speaking of which, I watched part of that anarchy debate. Only the David Friedman part. That man is awesome. I need to go back and watch the rest of it, I suppose.
The department confirmed that all the officers had been disciplined internally for their actions, but would not disclose any details.
"Disciplined internally" = "They felt really bad inside".
...that a camera was rolling.
I'm sure they were harshly disciplined. After all, they failed to notice the surveillance cameras, they failed to confiscate and destroy video evidence from the cameras, they failed to confiscate and destroy the evidence on the phone, and they didn't threaten witnesses with death if they dared to tell the truth.
They have a lot to be sorry for. I'm sure they have been sufficiently shamed in front of their more mindful brothers in arms.
Except that the "video evidence" showed nothing that the article claimed disproved the officers' claims.
Reason loves to get the street anarchy crowd all up in arms over purported video evidence of wrongdoing, when there is none.
Why don't all of you call one of these types, when you get mugged/assaulted, instead of calling a cop, that you will, later berate for protecting your sorry ass?
Jateik Reed
Hmm. Sounds Russian.
I've gotta say, white people have like zero innovation when naming their kids.
You settled, my man. It's done. But, hey, maybe the anti-Trump in the mayor's office will do something about it.
OT= Latest drug survey shows illicit drug use by teens at an all-time low.
"Clearly our public health prevention efforts, as well as policy changes to reduce availability, are working to reduce teen drug use, especially among eighth graders," Dr. Nora Volkow, director of the National Institute on Drug Abuse, said in a statement accompanying the study results.
No one is sure what's causing this overall decline in drug use among teens, but there are a few leading theories, Volkow said.
Maybe the two Volkows should talk to one another because the first one apparently knows something the second one doesn't. Although it is odd that the efforts so effective against most of the types of teen drug use don't seem to be quite so effective against marijuana and e-cigarette use. Maybe somebody should look into that.
And there's this: The survey found that only one in four 12th graders think e-cigarettes contain nicotine, with 63 percent claiming they contain "just flavoring." FYI, e-cigarettes contain whatever the hell you put in them. It could be that 63 percent of 12th graders vape with flavored glycol, or it could be that 63 percent of 12th graders aren't as ignorant about e-cigarettes as the dumb-ass researchers and reporters.
http://nypost.com/2013/07/01/b.....-ax-again/
Bad cop cheats the ax again
By Jamie Schram July 1, 2013 | 4:00am
She's the "Teflon Cop."
A Bronx police officer who falsely accused her boyfriend of abducting and raping her ? and a few years later pleaded guilty to using excessive force by pepper-spraying and kicking a suspect ? should still be allowed to keep her badge, an NYPD trial commissioner ruled last week.
In 2005, Alfonsina Delacruz lied to New Jersey investigators when she told them that her abusive boyfriend had kidnapped her, driven her to a Bergen County hotel and raped her.
Dunphy is en route to NYC to propose marriage right now.
He's surfing there.
Wait, you guys don't think that behavior makes her hotter?
The last thing they want is for the "diversity quotient" to be disrupted.
Isn't that what you "libertine-arians" - AKA cheapskate SJW's - want but don't want to pay for?
Golly, I sure am shocked that cops around the country are being ambushed and murdered.
Not that ambushing and murdering random cops is a good thing, just that it's not exactly a mystery to me why shit like that happens.
I must disagree. I believe murdering random cops is a good thing, as a lesson to the others.
Well, at least you admit, through your screen-name, to be multiples of what you are.
Look those brave heroes went home safely that night, and that's what's important.
What an absolute perfect job for a physopath bully where they get personal fulfillment for fucking people up while getting paid for and protected from their actions.
What an absolute perfect job for a physopath bully where they get personal fulfillment for fucking people up while getting paid for and protected from their actions.
Incentives. How do they work ?
Damn well, thanks for asking.