Kurt Loder Movie Reviews

Movie Review: Arrival

Amy Adams and Jeremy Renner on alien saving time.

|

Arrival
Paramount

Arrival is a thinking human's alien-invasion movie. The mood is austere, the story oblique (at first), and the invading aliens are somewhat obscured by a home-world mist they've brought down to Earth with them. Serious humans will be happy to know there's no cheap sci-fi action.

All of this is a little problematic, though. Director Denis Villeneuve (Sicario, Prisoners) is impressively committed to maintaining the picture's somber atmosphere, and he does as much as was probably possible to control the story's tricky structure. He also draws appropriately muted performances from his stars, Amy Adams and Jeremy Renner, who are allowed only flickers of humor as the knotty plot unloops. The result of all this restraint, unfortunately, is to lend the film an air of sterility that slightly diffuses our interest, especially in the middle sections.

The key to the story—although we can't know it yet—is conveyed by an opening voiceover, in which we hear Adams saying, "We are so bound by time…by its order." Her character, Dr. Louise Banks, is a professor of linguistics at an unnamed university. She lives alone in a semirural lake house. In a happier-days montage, we see her nuzzling a baby—her infant daughter, Hannah. We see Hannah growing into a little girl; then we see her in a hospital some years later, dying.

Banks's glum solitude is disrupted one night by the appearance of an army officer, Colonel Weber (Forest Whitaker), who needs her help in dealing with an international emergency. Towering alien space ships have suddenly appeared in a number of countries around the world. Their passengers don't appear to be hostile—yet, anyway—but since no one can speak their language, it's unclear what they want. One of the sites is in Montana, to which Weber and Banks soon chopper off, together with a theoretical physicist named Ian Donnelly (Renner).

Arriving at the Montana site, where one of the 1500-foot-tall vessels hovers about 20 feet off the ground, Banks and Donnelly are informed that there's an entryway into the ship that opens every 18 hours, for about 45 minutes. Floating up through the ship's very light gravity, the earthlings ultimately come to a transparent wall, behind which is a puffy cloud of mist, through which two tall, seven-legged shadows (quickly dubbed "heptapods") can be seen.

At this point, propelled by composer Jóhann Jóhannsson's bracingly strange score (all distant sirens and Brontosaurus-size moans), the story really gets underway. At issue is an interesting question: how would one go about communicating with an alien species whose language consists, not of words, but—as Banks and Donnelly soon discover—of subtly inflected symbols? (The heptapods trace them in the air with a sort of inky smoke.) Equipped with a whiteboard, a marker, and total determination, Banks eventually cracks this language barrier—although in a series of steps so compressed that it seemed to me insufficiently clear. Still, it was clear enough to slowly foreshadow the big—the huge—plot twist at the end, which is very much worth the wait.

The movie is beautifully made, but not entirely gratifying, and a reading of its source material—an award-winning short story called "Story of Your Life," by the brilliant sci-fi author Ted Chiang—suggests why. Chiang, a computer-science tech writer with what amounts to a sideline in fiction, lays out the intricacies of the heptapods' strange language in transporting detail—it carries you away. It's hard to imagine how Villeneuve and his screenwriter, Eric Heisserer, could have packed all of it into one movie, especially since the director also felt compelled to inject a 1950s' style subplot about military hostility to the alien invaders (Russia and China are planning a force-of-arms response). This is too bad, but box-office reality can't be completely ignored.

Still, Arrival is a picture that gives you something deep to think about—something that seems both wildly unlikely and yet fascinatingly plausible. It's a really new riff on a venerable movie genre.

NEXT: Against Shaming 'White Women' and 'Female Misogynists' for 2016 Election Results

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. At issue is an interesting question: how would one go about communicating with an alien species whose language consists, not of words, but?as Banks and Donnelly soon discover?of subtly inflected symbols?

    So they’re using emojis?

    1. A language based on symbols? Unpossible.

      1. My best friend’s sister makes $95 an hour on the internet.. She has been out of a job for six months but last month her check was $14750 just working on the internet for a few hours. Go this website and click tech tab to start your work… http://tinyurl.com/z9cxh6t

      2. If This Sound Good For You & Interested
        Watch Now….!!!Streaming Online HD Movie :
        ? ? ? http://bit.ly/2gkrFfx ? ? ?
        Happy & Enjoy to Watch For Free
        Or Visit first for check : https://www.facebook.com/movierolls/Available Now On HD Quality ! Arrival ? ? ? http://bit.ly/2gmlAQT
        Overview : Taking place after alien crafts land around the world, an expert linguist is recruited by the military to determine whether they come in peace or are a threat.
        Genre : Drama, Science Fiction
        Stars : Amy Adams, Jeremy Renner, Forest Whitaker, Michael Stuhlbarg, Tzi Ma, Mark O’Brien

      3. Calm Down Just Relaks – If This Sound Good For You – Popcorn First !!!
        Interested? Check – visit don’t forget to like & share
        Latest Update More HD Quality Movie Complete Available Here:
        ? ? ? http://theaterbox.club/ ? ? ?
        Happy & Enjoy to Watch For Free

    2. A language based on symbols? Unpossible.

    3. Clearly they are monsters. Or Millenials, same thing.

      1. They’re here to protest! #Trump

    4. Maybe they’re Italian?

    5. @Lee Genes : As I haven’t yet read the novella on which Arrival is based (ordered today), nor seen the film (tomorrow), this is pure speculation, but I am wondering if author Ted Chiang, didn’t base the character Dr. Louise Banks on Queens College (NYC) professor Alice Krober.

      Tablets were discovered at an archaeological investigation on Crete in 1900, written in an unknown language written in an unknown script: Linear B. A smaller set of tablets, written in a similar script, was called Linear A. Dr. Krober worked on the problem for nearly 20 years, and eventually realized that Linear B was an inflected language, difficult to write in a syllabic script.

      The parallels between Linear A and Linear B and Heptapod A and Heptapod B and a female linguist/cryptographer seem too obvious to be coincidence.

      More info in this article: https://goo.gl/CGVWPt

  2. Amy Adams,very much would.

    1. Does Amy Adams appear nude in Arrival?

      1. Its called Arrival, not Came.

  3. Ted Chiang is pretty awesome. That is all.

    1. If This Sound Good For You & Interested
      Watch Now….!!!Streaming Online HD Movie :
      ? ? ? http://bit.ly/2gkrFfx ? ? ?
      Happy & Enjoy to Watch For Free
      Or Visit first for check : https://www.facebook.com/movierolls/Available Now On HD Quality ! Arrival ? ? ? http://bit.ly/2gmlAQT
      Overview : Taking place after alien crafts land around the world, an expert linguist is recruited by the military to determine whether they come in peace or are a threat.
      Genre : Drama, Science Fiction
      Stars : Amy Adams, Jeremy Renner, Forest Whitaker, Michael Stuhlbarg, Tzi Ma, Mark O’Brien

    2. Calm Down Just Relaks – If This Sound Good For You – Popcorn First !!!
      Interested? Check – visit don’t forget to like & share
      Latest Update More HD Quality Movie Complete Available Here:
      ? ? ? http://theaterbox.club/ ? ? ?
      Happy & Enjoy to Watch For Free

  4. I’ve made $64,000 so far this year working online and I’m a full time student. Im using an online business opportunity I heard about and I’ve made such great money. It’s really user friendly and I’m just so happy that I found out about it. Heres what I do,

    ————– http://YoutubeJobs.Nypost55.com

  5. Really looking forward to this. It wouldn’t surprise me if my two favorite movies this year are from the writer and director of Sicario.

  6. This, and other reviews, point out what to me are really annoying but not-quite-unforgiveable problems.

    Why would the hextapods rely on earthlings to crack the language barrier? Presumably they have far more technological help at their command, and unless this is their first encounter with aliens, they will have already been thru this language problem quite a few times.

    Why would the hextapods maintain what is presumably their home planet 18 hour cycle when meeting earthlings? Again, they would almost certainly have far more experience in these matters, and matching the local planet’s day/night cycle seems far more promising than relying on the natives adapting in what must be an extraordinarily stressful moment.

    1. no matter how technologically advanced mankind grows in the future, no matter what great advances we make, no matter what incredible discovery(s) engender the dawn of a new, dazzling era: plucky, adorable movie kids will still die of cancer. tragic so tragic. the fault is in the stars, i suppose

    2. Perhaps they got their techniques from the British Empire? Or the Roman one? Or the frontier U.S? Or Colonial Spain? Or the Mongols? Or the current U.S. intervention into everywhere? Or…

  7. until I looked at the paycheck saying $4730 , I did not believe that…my… brother woz like actualy bringing in money part time from there computar. . there friend brother started doing this for less than 7 months and resently paid for the morgage on there home and bought a new Cadillac …….

    …….. http://www.jobprofit9.com

  8. How often is a linguist in the lead? Fail Safe (russkie aliens), Stargate… Any other instances?

    1. The Cana Mystery (novel)

  9. “knotty plot unloops”

    Don’t every type that again.

  10. Finally! There is a great way how you can work online from your home using your computer and earn in the same time… Only basic internet knowledge needed and fast internet connection… Earn as much as $3000 a week.

    >>>>> http://www.NetNote70.com

  11. Some years I see no movies, in a “good” year I might see two or three.

    I’m pleased that I saw this one.

    1. until I looked at the paycheck saying $4730 , I did not believe that…my… brother woz like actualy bringing in money part time from there computar. . there friend brother started doing this for less than 7 months and resently paid for the morgage on there home and bought a new Cadillac …….

      …….. http://www.jobmax6.com

  12. until I looked at the paycheck saying $4730 , I did not believe that…my… brother woz like actualy bringing in money part time from there computar. . there friend brother started doing this for less than 7 months and resently paid for the morgage on there home and bought a new Cadillac …….

    >>>>>>>>>http://www.centerpay70.com

  13. The ‘thinking humans’ alien-invasion movie’?? Im a thinking human, and was incredibly disappointed with this one. Nothing to think about. Dreary and weak, trying to be something thought provoking but sadly pathetic. My IQ is well beyond the so called ‘high’ range… and nope I didn’t get it.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.