Government Intervention

To Speed Economic Recovery, Release the Brakes

Government gets in the way of healthy economic activity.


By most accounts, the current economic recovery has been slower than a tortoise with a bad hangover. Experts disagree about why. One possible explanation could be found in the offices of Medarva Healthcare in Richmond.

Back in January of 2015, Medarva asked for the state's permission to move two operating rooms from their current location at the Stony Point Surgery Center to the West Creek Medical Park, about a half-hour's drive away. You might think that the decision about whether Medarva moves a couple of operating rooms ought to be up to Medarva, and you would be right about that—in theory.

In Virginia, however, such decisions require the state's approval, because the state maintains a Certificate of Public Need (COPN) law. Congress forced states to adopt such laws to address problems created by federal cost-plus reimbursement formulas; the idea was that government could prevent unnecessary duplication of services and thereby hold down health-care costs.

It didn't work. Eventually Washington wised up, changed the formulas and repealed the mandate. Several states ditched their COPN laws, but not Virginia.

It should have, for reasons that are overdetermined. Repeated analyses by the Justice Department and the Federal Trade Commission have found that COPN regulations hurt competition, "harm consumers," and not only fail to contain costs but "can actually lead to price increases." Yet efforts to repeal Virginia's COPN law have so far been blocked, thanks to large hospital chains that benefit from having the government stifle their competition.

And so this May, 16 months after Medarva asked permission to move two operating rooms, the commonwealth in its imperial majesty and wisdom said no.

In language that would have been familiar to a Soviet commissar, the state said the proposal was inconsistent with the State Medical Facilities Plan—and besides, "unused capacity exists and is accessible to the population of" Health Planning District 15, which is located in Health Planning Region IV. For this, Medarva has spent "north of $220,000" on legal assistance, says its CEO, Bruce Kupper—money that could have gone to "screening pre-K kids for vision problems," investments in new technology, or a host of other, better uses.

By itself, Medarva's proposal will not transform the American economy, or even Virginia's. But it is not an isolated case. In 36 states, medical providers have to waste many months and many tens—sometimes even hundreds—of thousands of dollars seeking… permission to spend their own money.

COPN laws are symptomatic of a much broader problem. "Permit Delays Choke Housing Supply," The Wall Street Journal reported the other day. According to a new study by real estate tracking company Trulia, home construction lags behind the 30-year average, and behind demand—"but the rate at which builders are bringing supply to the market as prices go up varies widely across the country. … The longer the average delay in getting building-permit approvals in a market, the less responsive the housing supply was during periods of increased demand."

The data back that up: In Jacksonville and San Antonio, permits take about four months; over the past decade the housing supply increased 43 percent and 46 percent, respectively, and housing prices increased 107 percent in each city. By contrast, permits in San Francisco and Oakland take more than 10 months, the supply has increased only 12 and 17 percent and housing prices increased by 278 percent and 220 percent.

Sixty-four percent of new jobs are created by small businesses (those with 500 or fewer employees), startups especially. But such businesses are increasingly incommoded by government rules that restrict what they can do or require government's permission to do it. And it is probably no coincidence that the rate of new-business creation has fallen behind the rate of business closures in recent years.

Half a century ago fewer than one worker out of 20 needed a government license to do his job. Now almost one in three does. The licensing regimes, frequently driven by industry incumbents, often make little sense: In Nevada, you need two years of training to become a travel guide, but only 26 days to become an emergency medical technician. If you want to shine shoes in the District of Columbia, you need four different licenses. Occupational licensing has grown so burdensome even the Obama White House has proposed reform.

If you want to drive for Uber in Austin, you can't—the companies pulled out after the city imposed punitive new regulations on ride-sharing companies. (Drunk driving arrests in Austin quickly jumped.) If, like Tesla, you want to sell cars directly to the public in Virginia, you can't do that either—it's against the law. The commonwealth is still undecided about the merits of Airbnb and other spot-rental activity. If you want to open a traditional bed-and-breakfast, be prepared for months' worth of costly permitting and renovations.

All of these regulations apply brakes to the economy—and all of them are imposed by state and local governments. We haven't even touched yet on the profound effects from federal regulations such as Sarbanes-Oxley (ask an accountant friend about that sometime) or Dodd-Frank. According to some reasearch, Dodd-Frank has made it much more difficult for startups and other small businesses to get the loans they need to invest and create new jobs.

Economic vitality requires economic action—but economic actors find themselves increasingly tied down by red tape at every turn. If we want to unleash economic growth, we're going to have to cut some of it. Virginia's COPN law would be a good place to start.

This column originally appeared in the Richmond Times-Dispatch.

NEXT: Sanders Delegates Looking to Nominate Alternative to Tim Kaine

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. Let’s start with the Federal Reserve.

    1. The “brake” that needs to be released there is on the rates. But who wants to be the President who takes “credit” for 15-20% APR home loans?

      1. Worked for Reagan.

        1. +1 Paul Volcker

  2. Speaking of the construction market: the other day some guy was on Bloomberg talking about a shortage of construction workers being the reason housing starts are slow.

    Nobody jumped in with, “Oh, they’re all coding and writing apps, now.”

    I was disappoint.

  3. “But without regulations, businesses will rape children and put razor blades in your food!”


    1. Especially those travel guides. They have to be watched closely.

  4. two days ago grey McLaren. P1 I bought afterearning 18,512 was my previous month’s payout..just a littleover.17k Dollars Last month..3-5 hours job a day…with weekly’s realy thesimplest. job I have ever Do.. I Joined This 7 months. ago. and now making overhourly.

    Here Going You Are………..

    1. Well written Jessica. I was skeptical at first, but you got me at “I Joined This 7 months. ago. and now making overhourly.”

      This is what our country needs. Make spam bots great again.

  5. And so this May, 16 months after Medarva asked permission to move two operating rooms, the commonwealth in its imperial majesty and wisdom said no.

    What’s incredibly frustrating is that the medical establishment begged, nay– demanded this oversight.

  6. Half a century ago fewer than one worker out of 20 needed a government license to do his job. Now almost one in three does.

    *insert snark about libertarian moment*

    This can’t be understated. While yes, we have far greater choices and consumer freedoms than in any time in history, so many of those choices are managed by the government. I guess we have to decide if that’s a net improvement.

  7. RE: To Speed Economic Recovery, Release the Brakes
    Government gets in the way of healthy economic activity.

    Nothing could be further from the truth.
    Adding more red tape, rules, regulations, laws, etc has proven to be a wise policy by those socialist slavers who rule over us in such a benign and benevolent way.
    Then look how much money they and their cronies have made at the expense of the lowly plebeian class.
    Who in their right mind wouldn’t want more intrusion by The State after knowing this?

  8. So when is Jonson going to talk about this and not about if he is high or not? Just asking.

  9. I quit my nine to five work and now I am making85 dollars hourly. …How? I am freelancing online from my home! My old workwas bad for me ,so I was forced to try something new? Two yrs have passed sinceAnd I say it was the wisest decision i ever made! Here is what i do?


Please to post comments

Comments are closed.