Milton Friedman

Flemming Rose Wins 2016 Milton Friedman Prize for Advancing Liberty

Danish journalist and author of The Tyranny of Silence published Muhammad cartoons in free speech fight against self-censorship

|

Flemming Rose OsloFreedomForum
olsofreedomforum

Flemming Rose, Danish journalist and author of The Tyranny of Silence, will receive the 2016 Milton Friedman Prize for Advancing Liberty, announced the Cato Institute today. Every two years, the libertarian think awards a $250,000 prize presented to an individual whom it deems has made a significant contribution to advance human freedom. Rose, editor at the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten, came to global prominence as a defender of free speech in 2005 when he commissioned and published 12 cartoons depicting the prophet Muhammad. As Cato's press release notes, "The illustrations, intended to draw attention to the issue of self-censorship and the threat that intimidation poses to free speech, provoked deadly chaos in the Islamic world and put Rose in the center of a global debate about the limits to free speech in the 21st century."

Despite numerous death threats, Rose has refused to stand down or apologize for his defense of free speech. In his superb book, The Tyranny of Silence, Rose not only calls out ongoing censorship in Muslim majority countries, but more importantly excoriates Western governments for using "hate speech" laws as excuses to stifle free speech in their own countries. In my review, "The Human Right to Offend," I argued:

As alarming as the actions of Muslim governments and individual believers have been, the reactions of many European governments and some supposed guardians of free speech have been even more dismaying. In Denmark, the public prosecutor considered bringing a case against the newspaper for blasphemy or racism. Out of fear of Islamist attacks, art exhibitions have been sanitized, movies suppressed, and people punished for "hate speech." The European Court of Human Rights has defined hate speech as "all form of expressions which spread, incite, promote, or justify hatred based on intolerance (including religious intolerance)." This completely turns the concept of tolerance on its head.

MuhammadCover
wikimedia

As Rose correctly argues, tolerance properly understood is the ability to accept speech one dislikes. "When we focus on non-discrimination and equality, and aim to empower the aggrieved, tolerance is no longer about the ability to tolerate things we don't like," he explains. "It becomes the ability to keep quiet and refrain from saying things that others may dislike." Calls to ban offensive speech sacrifices diversity of expression in the name of respecting diversity of culture. "If we accept the idea that people have a right not to be offended, we will end up with a tyranny of silence, for almost any speech may be deemed offensive," declares Rose.

Insult fundamentalists justify their efforts to restrict speech with the catchphrase, "Freedom of speech is not the same as the freedom to offend." In fact, there is no freedom of speech if people cannot offend those who would deny women equal rights, persecute homosexuals, and commit violence against people who do not share their faith. "The idea that if you say something that might be construed as offensive, you somehow restrict the liberty of others is nonsense," argues Rose. He is entirely right. …

Nothing undercuts the power and propaganda of tyrants and religious zealots more than the right of people to speak and write uncensored. In a free society, people can pursue and propound their own versions of the truth. In a fear society, everyone must submit to and live with lies. Societies in which citizens can speak freely flourish; societies muzzled by despots shrivel. 

"We know from history that if we submit to terror and threats; what we do not get is less terror and fewer threats," writes Rose. "What we get is more terror and more threats." Self-censorship in the face of intimidation has another name: cowardice.

Hearty congratulations to Rose!

For more background, see various articles by my Reason colleagues including, "Despite Constant Death Threats, Flemming Rose is Still a 'Free Speech Fundamentalist',", and our 2007 interview with Rose, "Revisiting the Danish Cartoon Crisis."

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

13 responses to “Flemming Rose Wins 2016 Milton Friedman Prize for Advancing Liberty

  1. It’s nice to see someone brave getting recognized for an actual achievement.

    Take notes, Nobel Prize Committee.

  2. Now Reason is supporting this radical Islamaphobia. I say it’s hate speech.

    1. Hyperion,

      I would like you to refute anything Dr. Bill Warner says or shows in this video

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t_Qpy0mXg8Y

      Islamaphobia is the muslim way of saying when they are the majority, you will have NO RIGHTS.

      1. I would like you to recognize sarcasm.

  3. Oh this guy is so brave for offending Muslims. He deserves an award. And the Danish need to give themselves a pat on the back for not prosecuting this guy – such good judgment they demonstrate on these tricky issues. Even if it means they have to assign a guard to protect this guy from them crazy radicals who wanna get him! Oh, they would never instigate an attack on him just to boost their profile – they are honorable! And Danish hate speech laws will never be used to silence the victims of hate speech themselves. That’s crazy talk! That never happens! They obviously have such good judgment!

    1. d: With respect, “tolerance properly understood is the ability to accept speech one dislikes.”

      1. Yes! Which is why this guy is a hero for not speaking out against his own government’s ‘hate speech’ Sharia – it provides the security without which he could not utter his award-winning speech in the first place.

  4. Commence your Home Business. Hang out with your Family and Earn. Start bringing $84/hr just over a computer. Very easy way to choose your Life Happy and Earning continuously….2O….

    ———— http://www.WorkProspects.com

  5. Thank you for this, Ron.

  6. my neighbor’s mother-in-law makes $75 hourly on the laptop . She has been out of a job for five months but last month her income was $21953 just working on the laptop for a few hours.

    try this website ????????? http://www.richi8.com

  7. Well done!

  8. This is an excellent choice. In these dark days for free expression, it’s nice to see that at least Cato, for one, has its head screwed on straight.

  9. Are you single tonight? A lot of beautiful girls waiting for you to http://goo.gl/pI9ucn
    The best adult dating site!

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.