Congress Seems Happy to Let Obama Wage War on ISIS Without Its Say-So
Russell Berman at the Atlantic sums up the disgraceful punting of their constitutional responsibilities on the part of both Obama and Congress: he wages war against ISIS without their say-so, they don't care to be on record giving or withholding that say-so.
Excerpts:
The White House, after a long delay, sent Congress a proposed authorization for the use of military forcein February. (The AUMF has become the modern-day equivalent of a declaration of war.) Never mind that the U.S. military had already been bombing ISIS targets in Iraq and Syria for half a year, nor that those airstrikes have continued throughout the two months that Congress has spent reviewing the three-page proposal.
In the last week, the top two Republican leaders in the House have confirmedthat Obama's war proposal is going nowhere, and lawmakers are in no hurry to pass an alternative…
The whole exercise has bordered on the absurd. A quick recap: The administration has argued all along that it doesn't actually need new authorization for the war, because the 2001 and 2003 resolutions that Congress passed—and never repealed—allow for military action against ISIS as a terrorist group that branched off from Al Qaeda in Iraq. Speaker John Boehner demanded for months that Obama submit a formal proposal, but when the White House finally did, he left it for dead…..
I guess Congress' attitude is, it's nice to be asked. But it's not nice to be on record as either being for the attacks if/when they go sour, or being against them next time an atrocity video out of ISIS hits the world. But they continue to let 2001 define an endless war against whoever anywhere.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
I don't expect politicians to stand on principle despite their best interests come an election year.
I suppose that's one of the reasons why I'm a libertarian.
Politicians predictably not being able to stand on principle in the face of elections is one of the excellent reasons why they should be given as few decisions to make as is possible.
When we as a nation abandon all hope of our political class standing on principle, maybe we'll start to get serious about relegating their input to the few cases where it really is necessary--like whether to declare war.
Of course, the free citizens don't want to stand on any principles either. They'd rather defer the dirty work to central planners, just as long as all the bills go to their neighbors instead of themselves.
Congress is fucking useless. When does it ever fight for its prerogatives? It investigates massive scandals but takes no action, it allows the president to violate constitutional limits on his authority almost daily now, it illegally delegates power to administrative agencies, it doesn't exercise its power to ratify treaties consistently, and it's almost wholly ceded the war power.
Not much of a republic if the Constitution doesn't apply, and we let the executive do everything.
"The Imperial Senate will no longer be of any concern to us. I've just received word that the Emperor has dissolved the council permanently. The last remnants of the Old Republic have been swept away."
We're a nation of expert agencies run by unelected bureaucrats who do the law/regulation passing. It's hardly a surprise that congress doesn't act affirmatively in this capacity. The Secretary of state is probably seen as a kind of War Czar.
So we're Byzantium.
Why would Congresspersons stand on any principles when they can just defer the dirty work to central planners? The only principle most humans have is "fuck you, pay me." Unfortunately the welfare state breeds more of them; without the welfare state they would not survive.
Not much of a republic if the Constitution doesn't apply, and we let the executive do everything
On the bright side it was a good run. More than 200 years for a republic was a great achievement. Now it is time for reversion to the historical mean. At least we'll have some good stories to whisper in the dark to our grandchildren.
I wouldn't whisper those stories to your grandchildren. They'll likely turn you in to the precinct kom?ndant for counter revolutionary activities.
Or your grandchildren will have you committed.
Same thing.
It's amazing watching them let their own formidable power just slip away. I mean, since when do politicians do that?
Money? Comfort? Ego? Cushy jobs for the Kids? Can't stay in if you're making too many waves with the $$ people.
They still have power, they're just avoiding responsibility.
Those bureaucrats did it!
Courts defer to Congress. Congress defers to the Executive. Executive defers to no one.
So much for checks and balances.
I think it's been reinterpreted as cheques and balances.
We still have cheques, so we must therefore have balances!
Well, we're either going to a full-blown dictatorship, lightly clad in the barest negligee of a republic, or we're going to have a revolt. Or maybe both. Not now, but I'd say it's on the horizon.
Liberty doesn't protect itself.
I imagine that it would take some triggering event, like a major war, bio or nuclear terrorist attack, financial disaster (my bet) or pandemic, whatever to frighten Teh People into totally casting away their freedom in exchange for the illusion of security. Just a matter of time.
PATRIOT Act II, Electric Boogaloo?
PATRIOT Act II, Electric Surveillance.
Well, we're either going to a full-blown dictatorship, lightly clad in the barest negligee of a republic, or we're going to have a revolt.
I think they said the same thing in Baghdad several decades ago. And they wound up getting one after the other.
We need to bring back the Fish Cheer:
"One, two, three
What're we fightin' forrrrrr?
Ho ho
I don't give a damn
we're all goin' to VIET NAM!"
Except, you know, with new countries inserted...
But all the people versed at singing that voted for Obama.
Why should congress do anything? Unilateral executive action accomplishes the same thing as a war without any of that messy accountability/culpability. Great taste and less filling.
It's the perfect scenario for congress critters: do nothing, vote for nothing, and win reelection!
They've seen how the Obamacare vote fucked so many of them in the ass. They'll want to avoid that kind of vote in the future. Better to leave things to the FCC, the DEA, etc. They can't get blamed for that.
Hillary Clinton's van parked in a handicap spot
Crikey, is she even trying to win????
And that girl that's acting like secret service -- if she's not a lesbian, my name is Oscar Wilde.
http://louderwithcrowder.com/h.....-laughing/
"Hillary Clinton's van parked in a handicap spot"
If the shoe fits...
Maybe she's preggers.
The fetus will probably self-abort.
She is officially the Cade McNown of politics.
OT:
I'm thawing out some ground venison but I'm out of ideas.
We have recently ate tacos, burgers, and spaghetti so I don't want any of those.
Suggestions?
Venison burger helper?
I'm not a snob by any means but do you seriously expect me to ruin good venison by making Hamburger Helper with it?
I did ask for suggestions though, so thank you but I respectfully decline.
Read my post and I came off as a dickhead so just to clarify, that was not a serious post, I was just fucking around.
No you're fine. I understand that you wouldn't want to ruin perfectly good Hamburger Helper by putting Venison in it. *shudder*
Dude venison is awesome.
Venison is the best animal flesh to consume. Period. No questions. No argument. It's empirical fact.
Venison Burritos.
Venison Chimigangas.
Venison halupkis?
It lost me at cabbage. I would purge the Earth of cabbage and its evil intentions if I were man enough to actually face it.
I hate cabbage in all forms except for halupkis, which are awesome.
Bacon-wrapped meatloaf "cupcakes".
Line the muffin tins with bacon, press in your seasoned ground, top with appropriate family sauce recipe, bake until you can't beat the family out of the kitchen any longer.
That's fucking genius. I'm going to try it.
It's why they pay me the big bucks. I have plenty more.
Stuffed peppers. Cook the venison thoroughly, drain and cool. Add cream cheese, an egg, mass quantities of chopped green onions, FRESH parsley, and a bit of bread crumbs. Just a bit. People overdo this.
Stuff your peppers only half full. Ten minutes before they're finished, crack an egg over the top and sprinkle with crumbled mozzarella.
OR...
Kraut buns. Cook and drain, add caraway seeds, sauerkraut, and fontina. Roll out dough, cut into circles, fill circles with your mixture and bake. Be sure to seal the edges well, it makes an unholy mess otherwise. Brush the tops with beaten egg and a bit of kosher salt. Lovely.
I can do this all day.
Oy, I'm a tard. I need to tell you, pre-cook the bacon a bit. Line the pans, then put in the oven at 300 for ten minutes. Cool and drain the grease. THEN fill with venison mix.
Crucial step, there.
So just to make sure, I line my pans with the bacon and cook it at 300 for 10 minutes. Take it out, drain the grease and add the venison mix.
Correct?
Ten minutes-ish. More to the point, you want the bacon to wind up underdone and yet with most of the fat rendered. There will be some carry-over cooking*, so keep an eye on it.
*Food doesn't stop cooking just because you've taken it out of the oven. Food stops cooking when it cools enough to stop the cooking process.
Let me know how it worked out.
Venison keftas?
Venison chili? I suppose venison tartare is out of the question.
We live in Texas and it's 80 some degrees out right now, so I don't think the family would eat chili. Venison chili is the food of the Gods however.
I also make shakshuka but I'll put meat in, usually crumbled sausage, but venison would work too. Shakshuka is GOOD. Try it.
Chili. Lumpia. Meatloaf.
Sausage
Cajun Sushi. Right out of Howard the Duck.
Venison chili on rice.
ISIS: Attracting the powerless and voiceless of the Muslim world
I hear he was shot while attempting to turn left.
The only movie where Will Ferrell didn't make me want to sponge his stain from humanity's blue dress.
"The whole exercise has bordered on the absurd."
No, no, no. The whole exercise rests at the very center of mass of the absurd.
Eh. It's not like we are fighting very hard. Seems to be the occasional bomb strike when we feel like it.